I was at that game so happy we won

if the keeper just knew not to step off his line

this has been the rule for ages in football . watch another sport like rugby or baseball if u dont like it . + GK looks retarded . Never seen it happen more than once in European football . Sportcasters also sound retarded . Mls and american people are a joke . Stop watching + playing football . Please .

@@jfxesports9754 he literally has one job

Law 14 was specifically rewritten last year to address stutter steps by allowing keepers to have one foot come off the line. I doubt it's going to be revised again soon (but I've been mistaken before).

I doubt it's a matter of being mad at the ref (though I'm sure many people are who don't know the rules as spelled out), but it is legitimate to be mad about the hard and fast rules as they are spelled out. The GK's "encroachment" in this case obviously didn't afford any advantage to him or his team, and if 'advantage' can be considered on one side of an offense, it should have equal weighting on the other side.

@@jdgower1 Frankly, the Law is harder on the kicker. If the GK infringes, it's a re-kick. If the kicker infringes by feinting at the end of the run-up, it's a mandatory caution and an an indirect free kick for the opponent. That's even if the kick is saved or missed. There have been quite a number amazing PK saves in the top leagues and competitions under the revised Law. Some GKs have obviously figured it out.

@@johnmcgimpsey1825 one foot is alright, both not because where are you gonna draw the line. Dudek won Liverpool a ucl final by saving penalties and he was miles out of his line

@@jdgower1 why tho? A penalty is supposed to give an advantage to the player taking it not the keeper. Faking a shot isn’t legal because the keeper can’t do nothing about but staying on your line until the player hits the ball, does not put the keeper at disadvantage. How many keepers are able to stay on their line and save the penalties? This keeper was not focused and that’s that

These are not stutter penalties, it's called: the game is rigged. Call it with the right name please.

LMAO but we won 😏

Should you really give man of the match to somebody who broke the rules twice? Part of the reason why he was able to make those saves is because he jumped off of his line. That's why they don't allow it.

I don’t agree because when he did that stutter step the keeper was still on his line if you watch closely but it’s when he hit the ball, keeper was off it. Loads of keepers saves penalties with players taking stutter step. It’s not supposed to give the goalkeeper an advantage, it’s a penalty for a reason. If we allow keepers to go off their lines, where will we put the limit. Faking a shot in a penalty kick is not allowed and I understand why but a stutter is definitely alright

​@@daneorigene6913That's a bs call if you know amything about the human body of a GK. You already have your movement in your mind and in your body. He wanted to wait, but the Taker simply hesitated making the move in the GK's body simply to early. I'm a former GK, trust me.

Blame VAR

If the player hadn't stopped his run to stutter on the 2nd PK attempt, he wouldn't have been off his line. It's ridiculous to penalize the goalie for his forward momentum when a penalty taker is trying to be cheeky.

@@Lakeland_IV No blame whoever wrote the rules. No ref would call something that minuscule before VAR came into the pro games. But now they're forced to follow the letter of the law because its a league for entertainment, clubs would sue if there was an issue with the PK and it wasn't re taken. The ref's hands are often tied and it becomes more about money than what is best for the game.

​@@its_milli8403 "No ref would call something that minuscule before VAR came" ie; "Blame VAR"

That stutter step should be illegal imo, it’s pretty wack

Bro for real I was at the game and I my brother told me the 2 first ones were gonna miss cuz they didn’t look confident

So would I. My thinking is that his arm wasn't supporting his body. The recent law changes get rid of the part that says "when a player falls and the hand/arm is between the body and the ground to support the body, but not extended laterally or vertically away from the body." So that is now punishable by a handling call in my understanding. Either way I would argue his arm isn't supporting him there anyway since its laterally away from his body not under him for support. As a referee myself those calls are always some of the most difficult because there are such good arguments for whatever decision you make.

I am a referee and I absolutely hate when this sort of PKs are given. The defender is sliding, he can't put his arm anywhere else, and he's too close to the ball in order to be able to avoid it. Anyway I actually hate how the handball rule is dealt with in general, because it's so inconsistent and often goes against the spirit of the game.

@@vincenzodanello4085 Nice to read some common sense when it comes to handball.

MLS clearly haven't learned their lesson yet

I call him the var encroachment legend

@@davidparkes1917 What did he do wrong here?

IFAB revised Law 14 to counter the stutter step by allowing keepers to have one foot come off the line. None of those saves were aided by the infraction - if the keeper had figured out how to keep one foot on the line he'd be being celebrated.

John is right. The goalies can bring one foot off the line, they used to not be allowed to leave the line at all until the ball was kicked. Also, stutter steps have always existed, you just couldn't halt your forward momentum. The long, exaggerated plan step into the shot has been around longer than the law change.

I counted 2 out of 3

Agreed. I say all blame on IFAB

@@surfhappens202 True that he only stopped the shot two out of three times, but I stand by what I said, he guessed it right every time - that last time he just didn't deflect it enough to keep it out of the goal. But he did go in the right direction and get a good chance by getting a significant touch on it. I've seen three PK saves in a row before, but it's hella rare.

Normal ! Le gardien bouge avant le tir. Rien de choquant, à retirer

yup, make the GK stand perfectly still while the guy running up does 10 stutter steps. Lame

@@mikedavis9144 😂

I think common sense would have meant it shouldn't have been a penalty to start with.

why for the kicker?

It is though, and I hate that it is

1. I agree, terrible call 2. Then the goalie should practice his diving accordingly instead of doing all those little steps forward 3. If the penalty was scored there wouldn't be a retake, since the striker didn't do anything wrong 4. Well I can only agree on that

IFAB recently did update the laws, which went in to effect I believe the first of last month, and was mainly focused on wording revisions. One of the biggest focus was the hand ball wording, since every referee kept calling handballs that didn’t need to be called. This particular case was a good call. Yes, the player didn’t make themselves bigger nor did they attempt to play the ball with their hand, but it was in an unnatural position and they where not using their hand to support their body. His left arm is stretched out, it touches the ball and with the new IFAB changes, it’s a handball. As for the retakes, I think what made it look bad was the fact that Chapman had to go to the monitor twice. The first time was close so I’m fine with the VAR. The second call should have been easy for the AR to spot and signal to the center ref that the keeper was off his line. I think if a player goes for a stutter step and the keeper is of his line, he shouldn’t be penalized. It ruins the flow the the game and the stutter step just destroys the flow of PK.

Montreal impacts won the game.

He doesn't claim to be objective, it's the new york broadcast

take away the stutter step

It's not as good as a league, but it's better than a lot of leagues out there.

Also, there wasn't a single bad call made

I know

Stinks for us😒

No he did not stopped his motion. If it helps, watch it in 0.25 speed. You can clearly see he's not full stop. He is always moving.

The rules still haven’t changed!

This had nothing to do with MLS. It's IFAB that writes the rules for all of world football. Lots of keepers have figured out how to keep one foot on or over the line - a change that was made by IFAB to benefit keepers, since the previous rule required them to keep both feet on the line.

IFAB BOARDROOM: How can we make the game better and less confusing? Executives busily writing solid responses. HEAD: Great! Let’s do the exact opposite.

He did