Nice one Alan! Tough call, but Port Charlotte just ticks the boxes for me. There's something totally unique about that Bruichladdich distillate that sets it apart from other peated drams. For me it's the best peated whisky Isla has to offer around that 10-12yr age, and even wins the day going up against the likes of Ledaig 10. Great video! Slaintè🥃

Great head to head Alan! I would pick the Port Charlotte 10. For me the PC10 is consistently a great pour while the Ledaig 10 sometime hits me as great and sometimes not….I think I need to spend more time with the Ledaig because the coastal and dirty machine shop notes are my favorite.

I’ve polished my bottle of Port Charlotte Islay Barley 2013 are watching your video. I enjoyed both. The 2013 bottle says it’s aged eight years, but I get nothing of the spearmint/toothpaste & banana/coconut notes of an immature Islay, like most of the Caol Ilas I’ve tried, as well as the young secret Lagavulin cask strength bottling, Finlaggan, or even some 10 year SFTC Ballechins. The 2013 Providence series entry from Bruichladdich is everything the 10 year is: smoked meats, gentle maritime, biscuity barley-sugar & Bordeaux bonding impossibly well to that sweetness, and the grassy flavors of the Classic Laddie & earlier unpeated Islay Barleys disappear/mature out of the flavor profile. The 2013 adds to that a bit more ‘farminess’- not bitter grass/hay, but ever so subtle funkiness, right in a Ballechin-lovers wheelhouse. The next version of this release, the 2014, has a maturation profile with a good bit higher percentage French red wine casks. I like the subtlety of this release. I’m not so sure that Sherry-bomb Alan would agree. Perhaps another head to head is warranted. Cheers, Alan!🥃

I love my Ledaig 10 (Rioja and the 18 are no slouch either!!)... but there's no besting Port Charlotte 10. It's simply too good.

Ledaig wins for me.. just, i think i enjoy the dirty industrial overalls a tiny bit more. The pc 10 takes a while to open up in the bottle, i preferred the last half of the bottle way more! Both excellent

nice choice, good the both of them

I did the same line up Alan, & with a few other smokey ones in with the mix, these two coming up as finalists. Did the line up with my son & what a memorable day ( definitely it's in the sharing Alan), my winner was the Ledaig & the PC running up & I reckon there was a single point score difference too. Two sensational cheapies, & honestly best value going if you love your peat. I came back afterward to Edit... I just lined same two up again & I still prefer the Ledaig. Great review Alan.

Strapped in Alan, as you suggested. Port Charlotte for me, but the definately will be people that prefer the Ledaig. Slàinte mhath

This was a perfect heads-up duel of 2 equally matched opponents. Nice description of the notes on these guys. I know it's hard to pick a winner, because these are such day-to-day mood drams. Congrats to today's winner. Cheers All! 🥃

Nice one. Port Charlotte for me

No loser’s here Alan both winners in my book., love em both, slàinte Alan.

Both are delicious, Alan ! In PC10 maturation is some Sauternes involved, a french sweet white wine.

A very very hard pick but yeah I think the PC10 takes it by a small margin. Cheers Alan!

These are my favorites. I pick both. 😊

I love it at 3:30

Both great and good value single malts.

If value is not a factor I'd give it to the Port Charlotte 10 as I find its taste profile a little more interesting. Still Ledaig 10 takes it for slightly better price/quality ratio. In Bulgaria 0.7 l bottle of Ledaig 10 can be had for the equivalent of roughly 38.50 pounds by current exchange rates whilst 0.7 l bottle of Port Charlotte 10 will set you back 49-50 pounds at least. On the other hand 1 l.bottle of Port Charlotte 10 from Travel Retail store costs ~ 54 pounds which is even better value than Ledaig 10. However I'm not a fan of the 1 l. bottles as my rate of consumption is too slow and I will be stuck with it for a good year and a half. All in all, both great whiskies! Cheers!

Both are really great in it's own way 😋

Interestingly Tobermory use Islay peat while Bruichladdich use Highland peat.

They are both favourites 😊thanks Alan. Take care ciao 👋 S.

Not sure what the difference is between 88 and 89. In voting it's too close to call.

Ive got both in my future stash, wouldnt be without either of them!

Depending on the mood I could go either way. Slightly leaning towards the PC10 because I had the that one during a memorable evening with my three sons a few months ago.

The way to compare them is to ignore the price of the Bruichladdich. If you can't get past the price then the Ledaig wins hands down.

I have a ledaig 10 in now and love it , it really does need and least 10 minutes in the glass and 2 teas spoons water for me its very hot stuff . The port Charlotte for some reason i don't get much flavour from but i will persist until I do .

Tough call this Alan. The Ledaig is currently about £10 cheaper, so if value is a factor then I'd lean towards the Ledaig. Purely on drinking, I think it depends on what mood I''m in at the time, as I find the PC quite a bit peatier (is that a word? 🙂) and has a bit more of a power hit. Having said that, I love them both. I have the 2 in my cupboard, both about half way down, so that says it all.... I seem to go back to them both in equal measures.

Great two whiskies for a comparison! Would be happy with either in my glass 😊

Thank you Alan, that was fun and informative as always!! These 2 are among the great peated whisky standard bearers as some of the other big-name Islay OB offerings fall down in terms of price/value and overall inconsistent quality.

Picture quality really good Alan have you a new camera

Nice collection you got there!

PC 10 is awesome stuff - I get a smoked bacon and huge mascherano cherries taste coming through on the palate and absolutely love it.

PC10 for me. It costs a bit more but i think it doesn’t just compete with its peers, you have to get into the £70+ to beat it. Good review though.

Both 😙

Good morning Alan

Can't beat peat !

Hi Alan how many drama you have per day?

Port charlotte by far over Ledaig. Laphroaig 10y 43% beats them both though