Shocked people haven’t seen this movie. It’s great. It’s deviated some already. I wonder if the killer will remain the same. I think they are going to change that. Good show so far

My theory: The kid. Her son.

6:00 - when Barbara is looking through the files on Rusty’s desk, she wasn’t horrified or anything about seeing those images. I really think that she’s seen things like that before. From what I remember, she didn’t even flip any of them over to “hide her eyes” from them or anything. Makes me believe it’s not the first time she’s looked through his stuff. She could have seen the Bunny case files.

I will have to stay out the comments as well guys…I saw the movie from the 80’s

Okay, I read the book and saw the film. Btw the film is phenomenal so I'm confused as to why this needs ro be a series. But maybe they'll change or expand the story. Either way i hope it's good.

Why was Rusty cleaning the shearing wheel in his own car ?

Dang. Going to have to stay out of this one. I read the book by Scott Turow when it came out in 1987. STILL remember it (how, I have no idea), so...Here's what happens...(KIDDING, but can't wait to see your reaction when you find out who the killer is). The Harrison Ford version was pretty true to the book.

Yes, you guys are are talking about all the good ones.

I don't think the wife did it. Why would she tell him " you have to stop loving her" . She also seemed genuinely of the opinion that the affair was over. Strangely I always have to think about the living corpse that she played in America gods with flies buzzing around her. That distracts me alot or maybe I mix her up with a a role she played in Preacher

First time watching your show. This was a great breakdown! Presumed innocent has drawn me in for sure. While I think Rusty has serious issues. My gut says it is th e wife! Why? I think she has looked through his files before, and she was way to calm as she looked at pictures of horrific murder scenes. To me, the way she says to Rusty, «You have to stop loving her » has the vibe of someone who took that into their own hands. I think she knew her husband was obsessed, so she decided to remove the obsession. However, I do not think she knew the affair came back and the baby is throwing an unknown element into her plan. That is my initial thought. However, it is too early to tell. I subscribed, I will be back for the next show. Thanks.

Hi Dan, Jules & Bag Face , I saw the Excellent 1990 Movie Presumed Innocent w/Harrison Ford as Rusty, Bonnie Bedelia as his wife, & more good actors, in a Theater in '90, & This mini-series Is a Remake of the film, & is also based on Scott Turlow's book. So If this follows the Movie's plot as it has so far, I Know Who killed Carolyn, so the Mystery of this series is Spoiled for me.😕 But I WON'T reveal & spoil it for you all, and I may keep watching it anyway as I like Jake Gyllenhaal & Ruth Nega.😊

I started to watch it, but realized I've seen the movie. I don't know if I can sit a through whole series knowing the outcome. And I agree with Jules about the guy not opening his mouth! He sounded so weird.

As soon as I saw the son I had a feeling it was him. He could have been very resentful and angry his mother was more passionate about work than her family or being a mother. He could have had access to her files and become obsessed with the images and memorized the hog tie. It would also explain why there was no sexual assault.

Why the people at the DA office don’t get along? Because they were running against each other ?

It's going to be Rusty's daughter, and the tool that was used in the murder is going to be in the shed... also, the prosecutor was in love with Carolyn and since he is jeaalous of Rusty, he is trying to do everything to finally stick it to Rusty - but he didnt kill her.

Do you have any theories yet? Let us know!

Had to delete my comment because I realize a lot of people did not read the novel or watch the 1990s movie if this is your first time watching it enjoy the killer is front and center though

I think the wife did it… she’s extremely to calm, understanding, & forgiving! She killed that woman for f’n her husband …taking him away from her!

I feel like it is either the wife or his son. I don't know why?

Bill Camp and Elizabeth Marvel (the actors who play Raymond and Lorraine Horgan) are married to each other in real life.

I think it’s her ex husband or the kid. Or both, they might be accomplices

I definitely think it is too early to tell who is guilty, but some characters definitely cast some suspicion right now. The first person that came to mind was the wife because of the same reasons you guys said. She just seemed too calm about the affair. I know her family is the most important thing to her and she is being strong for her family, but if she suspected the affair started again, I wouldn’t be surprised if she would get rid of the one person who is a threat to breaking up her family. We saw her snooping thru his files so do we really think she just took his word that the affair ended before and she didn’t check his phone records or anything from time to time to see if the affair started back up again? Especially since he admitted that he was basically stalking her. I just think that if she suspected that Carolyn was starting to become a threat to her family again, she may have done something about it. I’m also suspicious of Tommy, just a feeling because he just seems like he would go out of his way to crush Rusty. He just doesn’t seem like a person who seeks justice, he seems more like a person to create narratives to benefit himself. Rusty is also suspicious to me at this point. With all of his secrets coming out, even tho I think it is probably unlikely that he murdered Carolyn, he just hasn’t gotten a check mark in the innocent box from me yet. I’m very curious about this 2nd semen sample that Rusty just found out about from that previous case. I wonder if this is a clue to lead to Carolyn’s killer or just something that will be used to cast doubt on Rusty’s innocence. I’m curious to see what kind of clues we will get next episode!

I think Tommy is the killer. What an awesome show

It took me 2 episodes to realize Im familiar with this story because it was a excellent movie from the 90's with Harrison Ford . I dont know if I want to continue watching if they're gonna do it exactly like the movie because I already know who's the killer and almost spoiled it for you guys I had to catch myself and delete it. So i'm conflicted right now On if I should continue. I think I will continue to watch anyway Because I just like it so far. I'm just gonna hope they surprise me. In your reviews Maybe you should give the commentor's a heads up to not talk abouth the Movie or Books in the comments. I have the feeling someone inadvertently will if you guys dont let people know in advance.

I read the book and saw the movie. Here's a hint, the killer is in the lineage of Professor Moriarty. I was disappointed with the movie, as the book makes it clear that the relationship is based on explicit sexual obsession, which I found raw and interesting. Harrison Ford wasn't good in that setting....

My theory: his wife did it. She seems too calm for the situation, something is not quite right…

Nico or Medical Examiner

I know who did it