@@davidsantacarla I can’t wait to come back to this comment in a few days after the overwhelming guilty verdict. Not sure what trial you’re watching.

Exactly 💯

​@@MarmaladeSally fact

Exactly

@@davidsantacarla Welp...

I was thinking the same thing

@@paige2337 me too

They know the complete truth.

That would be Goofy. heh.

This monster would have shot the dogs too

What a bizarre way to describe getting sweaty - but didn’t he take a nap? - when you’re accused of about to kill your wife and son at that exact time.

Exactly very odd in fact I thought he was getting ready to say which is to kill my wife and son

It was definitely an odd statement.

He was talking about doing opioids. And working all night on trying to cover his financial mess.

@@1957es exactly ... on one hand he says he was ready to get to work and be sweaty and on another he says he wanted to nap....

Lol, that emoji, had me.. lol.. dope

😂

And he said that with certainty

If you keep people talking long enough, they will slip up and tell at least part of the truth. Even practiced lying lawyers are not exempt from it. He will give himself away. I hate hearing him wander around with his answers and go on and on about inconsequential things. Deflection.

Yeah how could he know for sure there wasn’t someone waiting and watching them from somewhere, just little things that if he really were clueless about what happened to them he would be questioning the same things but he doesn’t question things about the killers

Bingo!

14:48 DONE

Quietly reminding the jury Alex is a liar. “According to your new story”😂

I thought the same thing! 😂😂

Umm ... Buster did it.

In the not so distant future, everybody will be wearing bodycams.

The little detective. RIP Paul

110% indeed

Get ready to do what he didn't wanna do to take out your wife and son

I heard that too! I was expecting the prosecutor to ask: what was that?

He did ask, a/c. But it was a nano second Hail Mary save face answer.

Yesssss

Don't!!! I needed a drink when i heard that. True fact. True comes easy and doesn't have doubt... lying is about trying to recall something that never happened to you the way you are trying to relay it. Ffs.... He was nodding "yes" when he was saying "No" to the question about killing them. Ten mins on the stand.

Hearing people is more important than watching their body language

Bingo!!!

I'm glad the prosecutor kept asking that question about the dogs acting normal. I am surprised Murdaugh didn't catch onto that.

Perfect

He said it regarding dogs knowing “no body else around”

Yep. He said NOONE ELSE AROUND. So glad he just admitted to what I figured happened.

Yeah, what is it that he didn't want to do? He didn't want to "doze off on the couch"? Because that is what he claimed he did right after

@@liverecon769 he says the thing he didn’t want to do was “get all hot and sweaty”

@@eshometchel BS. He was subconsciously admitting to murder....just as admitting no one else was around that the dogs didn't know. His guilty conscience was getting to him, and he knew he deserved punishment. So instead of coming right out and saying he did it, he was going the long way around to admitting his guilt.

@@eshometchel Oh, I thought he meant switching from Oxycontin to Advil...

Spot on Jess, strange way to say..I didn't want to sweat...

I also remember her saying to someone in her courtroom, about their story, something like, “If it doesn’t make sense, that’s because it isn’t true.”

That’s absolutely the truth. yeah, repeating a question. Dead giveaway.

Exactly " no one else was around" that's right AM it was all you

That is what he said. “No one else was around”. So he just shot down the theory of others being around. He must have looked to make sure no one was around to see him.

Yeah - The Dogs Didn't Feel The Need 2 Protect Thier own - No Danger!? Were ALL The other Dogs Locked Backup B4 OR After The Killings?? Why Did Alex Finally Bother 2 G02 The Kennels ONLY 2 Hurry Away?? Did Alex Put Bubba Away?? Did Anyone check The Dogs (Bubba)4 Any Family Blood - Maybe 4 Instinty Checking out his Dead Family??

When I got up from laying down if I was laying down I would have got up yes Mr Waters. 😂❤ It’s looking like you might get 60 days optional ankle monitor after time served so sorry to bother you Alex is what he’s thinking. He like that Jussie Smollet guy guilty way way beyond any reasonable doubt 😮

@@lynnzielinski3186 good point

what a story,,, what a book.., and movie…! this is going to be…!

This is going to be a Netflix movie, staring Jesse Williams as Alex Murdaugh

​@@juanplazas4593Wow, excellent choice. Much better than mine, because I was thinking Denzel.

​@@juanplazas4593 Bill Burr as Alex. And just making a mockery of him. Would be great.

Not really

And he only did that when the prosecutors were asking him questions, almost never with his defense attorneys

Exactly!

Yep. Interrogation 101. Even Harpoo knew it & that's why he sat quietly staring. He told the court that he advised Alex not to take the stand. But Alex has to be in charge.

Typical technique used by liars.

Exactly

He doesn't even realize how he is incriminating himself. Those lawyers must be just disgusted.

That's how killers usually confess. Little by little and they box themselves into a corner. You're right. Another day on the stand and he would've admitted all.

if he isn’t found guilty there is something seriously very very wrong with our justice system

it’s simple.., he’s a hard core liner..,a person who doesn’t speak the truth…! ! period..!

​@@jetblack1211Cmon man. He spoke the truth when he stated his name. You gotta start SOMEWHERE. Cut the guy some slack....

I'm sorry

I’m so sorry! That’s awful!

So sorry for your loss I really am. Nothing close to your loss but I had to put my dog down last month and I remember exactly how many breaths and bites of steak I gave her right before the final shot was given. No way he doesn’t remember his wife and sons last words and moments before he left for his parents.

Of course you can! That's exactly what I thought. Your comment gave me chills. How tragic for you x

Oh 100%. He wouldn’t forget the last things he said to his wife and child. That’s ridiculous.

Same for me Guilty Guilty and Guilty. Why lie in the first place?

Busters turn to be prosecuted for the death of Stephen Smith 😊

His lawyers are as crazy as him.

​@@mayimoona4868 the mm

Just because he lied makes him a murderer...don't be silly.

…..and if there had been, why did he lie about being at kennels and ALL the many other details he gave??? Because he is the killer!

@@sloan_005 I think he lied bec. he is a crackhead.

@@sloan_005 Are you 100% certain ? No doubt ?

And he just assured us that there was no on in the woods that could have been waiting to kill them.

​​@@Bugsy0333 100% certain he did it. Maggie and Paul were killed right around the time there cell phone activity went dead forever. Alex was there at the kennels at this time even though he consistently lied and told everyone he was not.

Exactly...

People from the south aren’t that smart tbh

Yeah, AM even looked confused and perplexed as to why Creighton would ask such a question, like "what does that have to do with anything?" I wonder if stupidity runs in the Murdaugh family.

It's his good friend. He knew it from the beginning

He looks impressed.

They look like they know it's over

Bc he’s a narcissist. He thinks he can talk his way out of anything and his word should be trusted. Smh he’s pure evil.

Because he is cocky. He believes he can convince at least one juror better than what his lawyers can do.

He TRAUMATIZED us all over again too!😮

i wonder how he paid for the attorneys.

He said he chose to testify refusing to discuss it with his lawyers. Said it was his call alone.

Straight up

I don’t know about you but when I was using I knew EXACTLY how much I used…he was way too vague.

@@whiteguydre exactly!!! His rant was ridiculous. How hard would’ve it have been to say “I started years ago on hydrocodone but bc my tolerance got high I ended up on 30mg Oxy’s and I’d need one like every 6hrs or so, so maybe 4-5 a day.” That’s 1 sentence that summed up his 10 min rant when asked how many pills a day he was taking at the time of the murder. He makes my skin crawl so much.

Not all drug addicts are junkies who can't function in society. Most addicts in this country are exactly like this. Most addicts are people you'd never suspect of being an addict. Addicts work in literally every industry u can think of.

He's a narcissist and a pathological liar

Same 9 years 😥

my Mom died 39 years ago.., and still remember all the times we had together …,it’s etched into my memory with an iron.., never to be forgotten,she was 94 years at that time…

Me too ! My MOM , 20 years ago in May ! Not verbatim all of the conversation but I clearly telling her " I love you, Mom "!

If your high on pills you will or maybe he doesn't want to tell if

@@emilyheather328 I was on benzos while my mom was on hospice and remember every moment

Its because he changes his story - so after this he had to pretend he was just saying maybe I did this .. and that… after changing story this way was his only chance. Just still made him worse in the case, because it reminded jury over and over about changing story before.

add to that, “maggie asked me to leave"

​​@@brucerulz5297 "why don't you just Foff"? Or words to that effect would be technically asking a question,.....? Or "why don't you just go lie down on the couch so you don't sweat"?, Or words to that effect, While we both just bleed out here at the kennels, perhaps still a question ❓

😂😂😂yup

On top of the fact he lied and said he wasn’t there. Now he’s there.

And went down there and did what I did

​@psfulton414 Exactly. I came upon a bad car crash a few years back. I jumped out of my car and saw one man severely injured on the ground. I pressed emergency number and was saying, "Come on". I

Exactly what I was thinking ? He is so guilty !

This isn't really true at all and for everyone. Which is why someones emotional reaction can't be used as evidence. Everyone reacts differently to trauma.. Some people cry, some people get angry, some people shut down. You can't say "Well because I would be crying and a mess and he wasn't that means he did it". I'm not saying he's innocent, but to act like everyone reacts the same is redic and not realistic.

@@magnuskane246 completely agree- a person in shock might seem to be devoid of emotion to someone else. What they used to call shell shock in the military is how some react to a traumatic event and the person may be described as having a “thousand yard stare”, meanwhile the person next to them who witnessed the same thing is excitable, talking quickly and hyped up on adrenaline.

That's not true,most times you dont know the last time is the last time

It sounds like Paul had a lot of problems, but his momma Loved him and God allowed for him to identify his killer in an unquestionable way !

Paul was garbage too

He also said "I did what I did" when describing what he did there..

I wonder if he knew he was gonna die. Or if he knew what was gonna happen to him. He had drove with his dad earlier that day.

@@rosezamora9129 How horrible that his dad could be so casual and familiar, then shoot him in the chest and head

What time stamp did he say that?

@@daliborashadowheart2111 3:20

@@daliborashadowheart2111 don't know exact time.. but it is in this video when he talks about wanting to leave the kennels and return to the house.

Don't you listen he meant he didn't want to work or get hot and sweaty

@@emilyheather328 can't you read in between the lines!

Oh whoa, Big Foopah Alick 🫤

The Evil defendant said himself,nobody was there

The dogs and the guines!! He said they are super loud when there’s a disturbance.

The only way those dogs would not have warned them is if it was someone they knew. This man is so guilty!

@@kathleenoloughlin461 EXACTLY!!!!! Dogs would have definitely barked at a STRANGER....And who gave the code to the gate for a stranger to enter into the property???

Welp

This was good questioning Creighton !

That's what Judge Judy always says and it's true. And the truth no matter how crazy it is always makes sense and if it doesn't it's because it's a lie, that's what I've always said.

He is so detailed on everything, including how he used his thumb to push the dogs cheek into its tooth to make it drop the chicken yesterday. Like we need to know that crap. But he can’t tell them if or where he touched his wife and son to check for their pulse smh and if he says “well now that I’ve seen the records I know…” one more time I want to scream haha it is clear he is adjusting his story based on all the evidence he’s been sitting and watching. I’m glad the lawyer is calling him out on this new story that suddenly came up now after all this time when he’s had every chance to tell the truth.

Addicted to money too! I think he was addicted to the scam. I think he liked being “the smartest person in the room” that no one knew he was scamming all this cash & swindling these vulnerable sweet people.

@@Betsy-Rspot on except for sweet ppl, majority of ppl aren’t sweet. Ppl suck

Jodi Arias was the other way around. She remember every minute detail of her life and was happy to recount them on the stand for daaaaaaays. The only time her superior biographical memory failed her was when the day when she had to kill her ex-bf in self-defense.

Spot on, RIP Travis Alexander 🙏 😢

The other day I was like I’m done watching this lol , then I was like nope I need to see why they convicted lol

@@TheJawn_G Girl yes!!! i was the same way... My Boyfriend like didn't you watch the 1 year trial and sentencing already? 😂😂😂 I'm like yes but they got something wrong and I'm Gone Get to the bottom of it lol 😭😭🤣

@@TryMeMrsRabbit40 yes I need to know all details

I agree this case is very addictive. When I think I'm done watching, I find myself watching more.

@@Netchick41 Yessss ! i swear me too even though the trial over its still evidence being released that i never saw and I'm still intrigued 😣 i will not let up on this lol

He's trying to confuse the jury

Which should fry him

Narcissistic behavior, word salad

Speak for yourself. I can tell he’s nervous, refuses to answer the obvious and has a very selective memory. He is manipulating the jury in helping them find him guilty 😝

Absolutley he was backed up in a corner thank God for the Video Paul made

Yeah, I agree. He's trying to control the narrative he created and the prosecutor ain't having it.

Alex thought he had all his I dotted and t crossed but when he learned of the video paul hd made with the dog then it realy changed up his alaby but as he was on the stand he kept adding to things and at several times not answering a direct question

Exactly!!

True story!!

He doesn't have a mirror in the pen

Ikr. Including his brother or other son.

I don't think he did it but might know who did

Yes he does. Trust me. He does

What about justice for Mallory?

Truly chilling.

​@roscoerevenge I'm concerned about that too. Buster probably killed that kid Stephen Smith. This family is just shameful. Maggie sounds like an absolute Saint. I still think Paul killed Mallory, and I think Buster killed Stephen Smith.

​@@sarahelizabeth7705 same

at least say they were barking but they didn't find it strange or unusual.

Exactly

Unless there told as if it was planned with the time he arranged to be there to meet them

have you never heard of scoping out your target? for all we know they werent even planning on killing them that night but even if they were they dont have to know anything other then that area is where the kennel is and when the dog sitter isnt the one looking after them its alex maggie and paul who goes and feeds plays gets 1 or 2 to have around them... they coulda been gathering intel and decided now is good as ever... they coulda got spooked when alex wasnt around anymore... they coulda been going for paul cuz he killed that girl with boat and just had to get maggie cuz she was there... they coulda been getting maggie as a way to get back at alex or paul for all they did and didnt realize paul was even there or thought he left... i mean there are so many holes in this event and to me yall just take one little detail and say GUILTY as if you know exactly what wouldve happened in your own little world your created. for all we know he did do it but maybe he didnt do it... to even say the word "stranger" is hilarious to me cuz youre acting like some guy from kansas just got off the bus walked 15 miles to a random house and sat in the woods... ohhhh and to take it to your comment he somehow knew they would be there lmao... for all we know it was a random stranger who just escaped the mental hospital the next county over broke into a home grabbed some guns and randomly ended up in the back woods by mosselle and the kennel.

Stanger could know exactly where they are if he/she had an appropriate locate them

@@HIGH_noon ma’am. Lmao

@@felisha209 hahaha you think im a girl... lmao maam

He isn’t selling his story today he’s focused on keeping the story straight

Don’t forget yesterday he said those guineas make a lot of noise if something is around and we never heard about them making noise or anything. Smh.

He repeats the question, that gives him time to think an answer .

Yes! When you actually experience something, answering questions about the facts of that experience don't take that long to recall. But when you have to process and recall a story you made up, it takes long to come up with the answer. 100%.

I actually think tia is what a word class liar abounds like, I think he has been almost flawless in his answers whilst the prosecution have attempted some obfuscation of his narrative

Yes, he repeats the questions so he has a little extra time to think of an answer. Unbelievable

@@horsetowater I agree he did a pretty good job most of the time. Evading answering difficult questions. Stalling and confusing everything by talking around it and rambling about different things. As well as knowing when to admit to fault and when to "remember" things, and when to pretend he didn't remember. He also was careful to say answer in a non commital way by saying I "believe" and I "think" , so that it wouldn't really be considered lying if he got called out later. It wasn't until hours into his questioning by the prosecutor that I started noticing him make a few mistakes. Probably due to fatigue as well as the prosecutor upping the pressure. ( And it IS hard to keep up lies for that long of a period. Much more mentally exhausting than telling the truth.) And so the prosecutor did manage to land some punches at that time, and really nail him a few times. Yes hes a skilled and practiced liar (and lawyer) but I still can't believe he took the stand. I think it was a mistake.

4:10 bingo

Agreed… any loving family would hold onto every word spoken between you two. Or even if you the person didn’t say “I love you,” that would haunt after such tragedy. Or “she told me she loved me… that’s the last time I ever heard her tell me that.” It would be heart-wrenching!

If I was innocent, I'd be furious with the time wasted on me and not finding the actual killer or killers

@@ashleybreckheimer1387 right

Exactly. He doesn’t remember. The last convo he had with his family. NO WAY he would have replayed that moment in his head over and over and over. I wish the prosecutor would have mentioned both that fact and the loose hunting dogs not sensing any other human

i caught that too. she probably did say that and it made him mad enough to kill her.

Waters should have pounced on that freudian slip.

Yep! Probably found some more pills, Paul may have hid them, she said leave . Why his sudden change of heart to “going to kennels” very shortly after they went to kennels. Just long enough for him to grab some guns out of gun room. Why took golf cart. He knew may could have got the car data. Why he thought he could leave out about going to the kennels. He knew if took cart he could lie.

Exactly!

I also noticed that during her phone records review, she was texting Paul about dinner and also texting her friend about getting a pedicure, then Alex called her but she sent the call to voicemail. She also got home very close to dinner. Looks like she was avoiding him. He probably says he doesn't remember what he said before leaving because they were arguing.

I thought that too. Why not take the bait, unless you were completely unaware of Mr Waters intentions with those questions.

In saying nobody else was there that line of questioning stops. If he said maybe there was it would have been a whole new web of lies he needs to come up with, on the spot. Having split second to decide which way to go he shut that line down. Damned either way 👍

Maybe they wanted to see how far he would lie so the can smack him in the face with what they have against him.. they’d ask who would he out there and why? Did y’all doing something to someone for them to want to do this.. what did she do to someone what did he do? He was at the kennel.. Their property is gated.. idk if it was left open or closed.. they have tons of grassed area..

💯💯💯

Lies mixed in with truth!

Yeah, it's like some smug reference he was making

Exactly!!

Truth!!!

are we sure he didn't burn through $50K a week on clothing?!

Pills do that

​@@emilyheather328 Satan does too

Yea, he remembers things from years ago but when he was being interrogated about this murder he's vague and cant remember things

Cause, he’s lying 🤥

So sad he can't remember his wife's last words my Father passed in 1991 I can remember his last words and my Mothers in 1995 he is an abitchoul liar

@@debbieragsdale7776 absolutely! My dad took his own life 18 years ago, I remember our last conversation. All my grandparents died surrounded by family, I remember the last days, conversations.... vividly from 23 years ago. I can't remember a conversation from 2 days ago, but anything attached to trauma is etched in my soul.

He seems to remember a bunch of particular details but ironically doesn’t have any recollection of his conversation with them? Yeah, makes no sense.

I feel Alex admitted the murders but only in his own words and when he was pushed to admit about being at the kennels

@@momentofimpact6227Absolutely. That’s the key. Memories connected to trauma. That really hit me. And I’m so sorry about your father. Hugs.

And his slip that Maggie asked him to leave.

Both are jaw dropping admissions 😮

“I was getting ready to do what I didn’t want to do: SWEAT!” 😮 Alex Murdaugh

How about "I drove down there, I did what I did".

@@terr777 IKR!!?? If they (jury) pull a FL-Casey Anthony on this, I think I may give up on humanity!

Was it thigh or calf?

And shot in the back too?

He lost his rag ,

@@lisaphin21 leg

he drove over her with the atv then realized he'll have to ditch atv and ran back to the house. he wouldn't be able to explain how he drove over leg then ended up at the house with the atv

I remember

I know where I was. So true and princess Diana dying. So come on Man. Please for * Sake... just stop!!!

exactly. I remember exactly where i was standing in the room when i last talked to my dad before he died. same thing with my mom.

There is no way he took that many pills on daily bases the truth is I Beleive he ran out of money his chances of getting money was very slim I Beleive Maggie was going to leave him Thank God Paul had that video he solved his and his Mothers murder My Daddy was in law enforcement for over 25 years he said some people didn't have a Consciousness Alex fits this case I realy feel

Yep, pretty coherent in the cop car, too. No tears, no shock -- just talking, talking, talking.

😆😆😆😆😆😆😆

Short. Angry. Had a motive. But there were supposedly two shooter so maybe the chickens family?

No - the guinea hen did it!

🤣

Omg people coming up with funny comments in such circumstances.. 😅 I'm sorry I had to laugh 😂

Especially when at least one of them was out roaming the property at the time.

I can remember the exact words on 25July 1985, he fired suddenly 4 hrs later Underground on a mine in South Africa, can remember his clothes etc, this guy is lying period

Corey I wonder if he 'said goodbye Mags and PauPau" before he pulled the trigger.

Tbf i dont remember the last words my aunt spoke to me. But that was a month before her death.

@@keepitsimple4629" time for pew pew pau pau" - Alec Murdagh, probably

@@dominicwilliamson7912 Yeah, but if she had been savagely murdered maybe you would have?

I'd like to hear the chicken 🐔 but like other members of that family HES GAWN

😂😂

Bubba loves shrimp

Exactly

@@brucerulz5297 gave me chills !! Sheesh

Followed by..." I did what I did"