These people so called human rights protestors.. what about other people's rights on that train who wants to get to work and have other things to do? These protestors are jobless and small minded. You did raise and show your voice but harming other peoples isn't the way!!

No all people is like the student, no need to earn money, no need to feed the family, no need to send they kid for education. the student/protester is overact, cross beyond the protest line, and start hurting the common people daily life.

i feel pity for d elderly and d ones with disabilities, pregnant women and those who are carrying children..

Why are these kids doing this?

Protests like marches are fine but don't cause problems for your fellow citizens. It's the fastest way to turn your supporters away.

Now these protesters are getting out of hand...

What if someone's in emergency and stuck in the station because of it. This is not peaceful rallies anymore.

I remember the last time there was a report interviewing a passenger. She said that she would understand the demonstrators with sympathy, but she did not want them ocupy train in rush hour.

Those troublemakers should be banned from riding MTR for life.

Visiting HK now is a a suicidal act. When capital substitutes work, when market substitutes humanity, people found themselves lost.

These youngsters has gone way overboard. They should be punished

I was really annoyed by the protestors who blocked the mtr😠Won't support their protests anymore. 😠

self-destroyed in hk.

Crying for freedom by taking public to be hostage. How desperate means is!?.

Not a smart move to get public support...👎🏼

What if someone missed a trip to the airport? If they did this to me, i'd lose my mind.

HongKong such a stressful place these days. Everyday dog bites dog’s bone.The price to pay for democracy.

MTR needs to claim those protestors for damages or losses caused by such an action.

This is how u get ur fellow citizens to turn on u

these protestwrs should do their protest without disrupting other's life .. if they keep doing these they will just lose support from others

This is getting so out of hand. I hope Hong Kong people don’t support these type of protest. The more support they get they more they think what they doing is justifies. Violent and aggressiveness will never be the answer. Do they think Hong Kong government is that strong enough against China? The things that they’re doing it’s just pushing Hong Kong into China even more. When things starts escalate even more, China will take things into their own hands. I want democracy for hk but not in the way that they are trying to prove it. Harassing others and disrupting the public? You want to protest? Fine? Don’t lie, be aggressive and violent. I watched a video of a elderly man got angry at the protester and he hit the sign that one women was holding. He hit the sign. The women started screaming saying the guy was hitting her. a crowd of protester start harassing this man non stop and calling him names and trying to provoke him to hit them. I was going to cry. This old man so old and alone and the crowd just would not stop harassing him. It was a disgraced and disgusting to watch how hk people have turned out like that. They were also shouting that he’s communist supporter and from China. He was speaking English.

Only minority of idiots are ruining HK future, why the majority not speaking out against these rioters and lawless individuals manipulated by politicians and possibly foreign powers for their personal gains ? Please HK people rise to speak out.

Hong Kong reputation slumped by those behaviors. Someone said right, if you want to express your opinion, don't disrupt others, especially they are milking live.

Those masked youngsters used their lawless freedom to disrupt other people's freedom. What a shame! They don't deserve any support or empathy. They should be punished.

I think the Police can arrest them now cause now they are causing trouble.

Bunch of spoil kids...

"passengers weren't complaining and they were supporting us" said by protesters

When Protesters Applying a Job in the Future: Resume: Full Time Protesters -Singlehandedly stopped 5 MTR trains from running -Able to Convert Umbrella, Cardboard Box, and Bricks into weapon

They behave worst than wild Animal out of jungle! Round them up and lock them for making so much Trouble to public.

Please protest peacefully and do not disrupt the life of other. Protestors can afford to not work and protestor for days, but not for the people on the train. If they are late or can’t go to work, that’s a day of pay lost.

Tiu Keng Leng is where I live and I thought was far enough from central area that it will be freed of conflict, but I appreciate that I have this morning off to avoid this madness also sympathy for the innocent people having to suffer due to few protesters. EIDT: also have to appreciate not all protesters are this inconsiderate.

Hong Kong is invaded by zombies..pure madness!!

Arrest them. Their illegal actions will only further alienate HK residents.

I didn’t know hooligans is part of democracy. This is strange interpretation of democracy in Hk.

That proves what i say. They don't care people's freedom, only own freedom

such as madness will destroy HK

This is great advert for democracy 😂😂 so majority will want china to govern totally. ...this is a mess.😣

"If you don't buy me the candy I'll do all the damages as far as I can. All blame on you not giving me what I want!"

imagine all the students rushing to school "im sorry teacher, a bunch of idiots decided to block the freaking mtr station so yes, that's why im late for school by an hour" its really very inconsiderate of them to do so, and it affects wayy more people than it should be

Those nuisance idiots should be arrested and given deterrent jail term.

do these people not have jobs?

It's quite upset and made many HK ppl mad that MOST HK media could not report news fairly or accurately! The extradition bill is "dead" that announced by the HK Chief Executive. Those protestors had 5 request, one of those is “release those arrested rioters". That's ridiculous! If the arrested rioters were peacefully protested, they would not get arrested?

Tell you what, as a HKer, I still haven't gotten used to the lack of constant protesting and I have a neighbor who USED to protest. He has a protest sign and everything but he's a nice guy.

It's not even about the Bill anymore !!!! THAT'S THE FUNNY PART !!

0:19 nice camera angle right there 😂

They not protest because the bill,they protest bcause they do not have a job or things to do.

The restraint shown by authorities during this chaos is admired.

Disrupt others is despicable. Arrest them.

Now we can see whom the protesters are standing for, the Western.

What HK laws on public nuisance and causing public disorder? Does the train company has any rules and regulations on such behavior? If such laws rules and regulations are non existent then I can only say the city administrators should be replaced immediately. I also found some of the passengers reactions laughable. "HOPE THEY GET WHAT THEY WANT". I want to add they deserved what they got.

Just close the doors. Those injured, it's their fault

I feel like this is quickly getting out of control. I support the protesters (or let’s say the ideal of the protesters) but they shouldn’t be holding up the train during rush hour for an hour! HK was crowded enough when running well when I visited a few days ago. There were many other peaceful examples of protesting (Lennon walls, banners) but all this is doing is dividing the country. Unless of course not all these protests are actual protesters and rather mainland or government lackeys simply acting to divide the country and make it implode and eventually decide this isn’t worth it (either with or without force) and give in to central control. And I guess you could say ‘well shouldn’t they? Lol there’s no point in fighting, we all know what’s inevitable’ but just take a look at Vox’s video ‘How China is erasing its border with Hong Kong’. Within it a government official from LegCo (I know) says that ‘for the record, we will not go without a fight’. And personally for me, I wouldn’t feel like just ‘giving up’ and rolling over when I’m told that the ideals of free democracy, economies and *media* especially are slowly but surely being taken away from me. They’re not saying they want to return to the Uk either, (besides, the UK is too afraid to intervene as they try to better sino-uk relations anyways with all of brexit and this new gov chaos-I’m British, first generation Chinese) all they want is to maintain these ideals. They’ve been away from China for almost two centuries, and the centuries prior to that Hk was nothing more than some rocky islands inhabitated by few people. Hong Kong is more Western than it is Chinese, but then again, it’s a bit of both. It can’t just be put into the category of either Chinese or British. I only hope that the beautiful city I visited isn’t destroyed, by either side, when I return.

if local HKers do not react to rioters, they deserve what they are bearing.

These protesters are just too much. They should not disrupt the transportation schedule as a lot of ppl need to carry on with their daily lives unlike them being funded daily without having to earn their daily bread. The rest of the innocent ppl should not be supporting them anymore as their demand should have reached the Hkg Govt and Central Govt by now!

If according to the western media most citizens are showing their understanding and support for the protesters then just let them be. Hong Kong people will find their way out.

This time so difficult for Hong kong people, I understand very well because I have experience this kind of difficult before in Thailand. I hope you can through it soon.

Hong Kong Don't have Police??????

this is madness ACE ACE SPARTAA!!

Isn’t the extradition bill withdrawn already

While I’m stuck up in Canada for the rest of the year and all of my friends are back in HK for the summer I’m like “SOOOO HOW’S YOUR HOLIDAY BACK HOME?!” 😂😂

If the protesters did like this, they'll not get any sympathies from other hongkongers, sorry about my english 🙂

These protestors are losing my respect. They are becoming more and more of an annoyance than Bersih team in Malaysia.

Not watched the news or anything as we don't have TV. can anyone explain what happens in Hong Kong?

I wonder where the police officers were when such disturbing scene took place? Why did they not take any actions immediately? Protestors also need to undertake the responsibilities if they decide to violate rules and laws.

they have turned into hooligans. arrest them

THUGS

So sorry for the disorder in Hong Kong. Hope this city will survive.

Few months ago, my family booked ticket and hotel in HK for sightseeing in October for 8 days! This destination is quite popular for Thai people as it does not require VISA. I hope, both parties can settle very soon.

why use these time doing something meaningful, useful, how long can you live in the world? waste of time.

I hope that the 5 of Aug, PLA takes control of Hong Kong

Really heart break to see this. These young people claim this is their Hong Kong and then they are like: begin to violently destroy their own home, while other brothers/sisters are trying their best to work hard and contribute to the prosperity of the family. You feel wordless and feeble when dealing this with family members. You can beat all intruders, but you can do nothing to ease family members if they've have a wrong set mind.

These young HK protestors abruptly disrupted the normal operation of MTR service but still blamed the others the responsibility. They deserve no forgiveness nor trust on this matter. On the one side, they seeked what they called "universal suffrage" and "human rights" from the government but ironically, they were acting exactly what they detested the mainland Chinese are doing. These malicious and malevolent individuals were seditiously by Jimmy Lai, who enjoyed the best foods and highest~quality services. HK must restore the stability and prosperity. They should be kicked out from HK, this such a great and safe city.

Its a sacrifice. But people have places to go and things to do. Many are running against time. Some have emergencies to attend to. 🤦‍♂️

Protestors so free? Don’t need to work/go to schl?

They redefine the strike, the strike is to prevent others from working, i learned it

Sometimes violence is the answer, but don't do it to your people.

Hong-Kong soon will be such as California state(Garlic festival), 6 dead and 9 suffered serious injuries. In America it is normal but for Hong-Kong if it happens would be completely disastrous for the city and the entire country. Our love from Brazil.

Well done, Singapore support hong kong, the more messy it get the better for Singapore.

what if the operator just drove on without closing the doors? i bet these “freedom fighters” would be scared shitless

Dont stop! LOOK AT PUERTO RICO

“As long as all commuters support our idea of anti-extradition bill, everything will be as usual.” They might think like this.

Terima hakikat la org hk..buang masa kamu buat mcm ni..👎👎👎menyusahkan org..kamu tak mampu lawan kerajaan punya..kamu sendiri yg rugi

5-demands? Guys !! You're fooling yourselves Where are you now??

Keep doing this. Seems lots of support for these kind of disruptions. No loss to China or the HK government. Only the commoners suffer. Well done. Le'ts see how long before the public will be fed up.

If protestors want to brave this exercise, unveil their masks and be bold about it. There are no tear gas at MTR station. Perhaps MTR should have better clamming doors 🤣

it is sad to see the previously reasonable and mostly peaceful protests steep into daily disturbances, but what's more aggravating is the government response to all of these situations

Best summer internship performance, kids. I bet your bosses are very happy

I don't agree with what they said about the government not responding, it just they didn't get what they wanted.

Must kick them and jailed for life the better

红卫兵在香港? 🤭

The people of Hong Kong still hold rights granted to them in the : “ English Bill of Rights of 1689 ? “ English Bill of Rights 1689 that are still in effect are: (1) That the pretended power of suspending the laws or the execution of laws by regal authority without consent of Parliament is illegal; (2) That the pretended power of dispensing with laws or the execution of laws by regal authority, as it hath been assumed and exercised of late, is illegal; (3) That the commission for erecting the late Court of Commissioners for Ecclesiastical Causes, and all other commissions and courts of like nature, are illegal and pernicious; (4) That levying money for or to the use of the Crown by pretence of prerogative, without grant of Parliament, for longer time, or in other manner than the same is or shall be granted, is illegal; (5) That it is the right of the subjects to petition the king, and all commitments and prosecutions for such petitioning are illegal; (6) That the raising or keeping a standing army within the kingdom in time of peace, unless it be with consent of Parliament, is against law; (7) That the subjects which are Protestants may have arms for their defence suitable to their conditions and as allowed by law; (8) That election of members of Parliament ought to be free; (9) That the freedom of speech and debates or proceedings in Parliament ought not to be impeached or questioned in any court or place out of Parliament; (10) That excessive bail ought not to be required, nor excessive fines imposed, nor cruel and unusual punishments inflicted; (11) That jurors ought to be duly impanelled and returned, and jurors which pass upon men in trials for high treason ought to be freeholders; (12) That all grants and promises of fines and forfeitures of particular persons before conviction are illegal and void; (13) And that for redress of all grievances, and for the amending, strengthening and preserving of the laws, Parliaments ought to be held frequently. (14) And they do claim, demand and insist upon all and singular the premises as their undoubted rights and liberties, and that no declarations, judgments, doings or proceedings to the prejudice of the people in any of the said premises ought in any wise to be drawn hereafter into consequence or example; to which demand of their rights they are particularly encouraged by the declaration of his Highness the prince of Orange as being the only means for obtaining a full redress and remedy therein. ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- From Wikipedia English Bill of Rights 1689 Legal status The Bill of Rights remains in statute and continues to be cited in legal proceedings in the United Kingdom and other Commonwealth realms, particularly Article 9 on parliamentary freedom of speech.] Following the Perth Agreement in 2011, legislation amending the Bill of Rights and the Act of Settlement 1701 came into effect across the Commonwealth realms on 26 March 2015 which changed the laws of succession to the British throne. Part of the Bill of Rights remains in statute in the Republic of Ireland. Modern recognition Two special designs of commemorative two pound coins were issued in the United Kingdom in 1989 to celebrate the tercentenary of the Glorious Revolution. One referred to the Bill of Rights and the other to the Claim of Right. Both depict the Royal Cypher of William and Mary and the mace of the House of Commons, one also shows a representation of the St Edward's Crown and the other the Crown of Scotland. In May 2011, the Bill of Rights was inscribed in UNESCO's UK Memory of the World Register recognizing that: All the main principles of the Bill of Rights are still in force today, and the Bill of Rights continues to be cited in legal cases in the UK and in Commonwealth countries. It has a primary place in a wider national historical narrative of documents which established the rights of Parliament and set out universal civil liberties, starting with Magna Carta in 1215. It also has international significance, as it was a model for the US Bill of Rights 1789, and its influence can be seen in other documents which establish rights of human beings, such as the Declaration of the Rights of Man, the United Nations Declaration of Human Rights and the European Convention on Human Rights.[28] As part of the Parliament in the Making programme, the Bill of Rights was on display at the Houses of Parliament in February 2015 and at the British Library from March to September 2015

feel bad for the HK, the black shirt should be treated harshly......HK police needs to be trained in Singapore, Malaysia, Indonesia in handling the mobsters ......

They destroy themselves.

Sorry for you being a little late to work..... just protesting for your right not to be arrested without due process lol!

It's time for Hong Kong police to use all necessary force to stop all these nonsense

too crowded, RIP for the protesters in MTR station

These aren't Peaceful Protestors, sadly, Rioters/Terrorists seems fitting for this type of extremists!!!

Chinese army is the fastest solution to put these thugs behind bars and restore law and order .Ordinary citizens are terrorized by assaults , criminality and general lawlessness . Madness.

Why must Hong Kong people lives but upset by these rioters?

It also made me sad to see that HK has a GAP. Yuck.