Polski wielki tenor dramatyczny !! Mamy powód do dumy !!

What a tenor! He is a Hummer at 300km/h. As he starts you feel a baritone, not a tenor. You never expect such a powerful voice reaching those highs. He sounds to me pretty drammatic tenor or at list spinto. He just manages his voice as he wants. Chapeau!

Bravo, maestro!! ❤

Voix chaude et intensité dramatique qui servent un aria difficile. C est un excellent ténor. Quelque soit le pays, l important c est que le chanteur apporte son interprétation avec sa sensibilité.

I stand with Ton Marina below. A fine rendition, both emotionally and technically, of one of my favourite arias. Piotr Beczala is easily high among today's top operatic tenors. A superb performance.

GRANDE HO TROVATO UN NUOVO TENORE❤

Top ten of lucevan le stelle

Przepiękna ciepła głęboka barwa głosu. Piotr Beczała - emocjonalne, dostojne wykonanie, ciepłe spojrzenie. Wysłuchałam tej arii znanej opery w innych wykonaniach m.in. Luciano Pavarotti ... Kocham głos Piotra Beczały. Tworzy własną świetlaną legendę. Dziękuję. Monika

Soul-stirring performance, magnificent voice!

Beautiful voice.

You can't get bored of this! This music, the voice, the harmony of the instruments touches you so deeply! For those who love opera, this is soul-healing therapy!

Prachtige stem Ik kan daar iedere dag naar luisteren naar zoiets moois bedankt

Dzięki za taką pieśń i WSPANIAŁE WYKONANIE dla ŚWIATA danke w interesie Polski i Europy spas iba

Soo nice of this opera singer to sing this beautiful song.😊

Cudowny glos❤❤❤

Piotr Beczała nasze dobro narodowe. Kolejny raz udowodnił swój kunszt. Bravooooo!!!!

a very great performance Maestro Beczała

He is amazing!

Pięknie, brawo !!!!!🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹

Wonderful performance and voice!!! Великолепно!!! ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️😍😍😍😍👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼меня покорил этот голос!!!

Desde mi pais Chile aplausos para este hombre y su maravillosa voz que el que sabe de musica comprende lo dificil cantar esta pieza de la musica Dios guarde a ud .

Plus grand Cavaradossi !! Magnifique !!!🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏

All these negative comments. I would like to hear them sing this aria. I am an aficionado and he ranks up there with many of the best tenors. We all have our favorites. Does that mean we tear down everybody else. Snobbishness does not equate to forwarding this wonderful art form to future generations. Grow up all you-would-be tenors. If you can do it better, step on to the stage and prove it to us.

PIOTR PUCZALA .OZDOBA POLSKIEJ SCENY OPEROWEJ . KOLEJNY RAZ POKAZAL ZE TO JEST WLASNIE SPIEW TENORA .. CHLUBA DLA POSKI .. BRAVO .BRAVO👋👋👋💐💐💐💐💐💐🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹

Complimenti! Che magnifico Mario Cavaradossi!

Bravo piotr.! !

Uwirlbiam Tosce!!!,,,dziekuje Ci za cudowne przezycie... sluchajac Cie 👍🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹❤

the best of the best of the best!

Bravo!

Excelente interpretación. Todo un escenario propiciando la belleza y el encanto de tan sublime canción.

Weltklasse!

marvelous

The perfect aria

Emotiva presentación 👍

Wow!! BRRRRRRAVOOOOO!! ♥️

Nice voice

Brawo !

BRAVOOOOO!

amazing

The best Lohengrin ❤❤❤

Csodálatos 🎉

Bellissimo!!!

exceptional!

dziękuję za Ukrainę, mistrzu / thank you for your support of Ukraine, Master

Non sono un intenditore ma per me é un bravo tenore

Была в Большом театре на концерте Доминго. Бечала принимал участие. Полный восторг!!!

Singing policeman from Finland sings Cavaradossi remarkebly. It is here at youtube when Petrus Schroderus was singing at Finnish national opera.

Great voice

❤

Talent i piękne wykonanie..a ile ciężkiej pracy jeszcze trzeba wykonać aby taaaak śpiewać...

Does it get any better? This is simply wonderful. Wunderbar!!

Rewelacja !!

Preciosa, de mis preferidas, muy bien interpretada.

Bravo!!!! Y las estrellas brillabanE lucevan le stelle Y la tierra olíaEd olezzava la terra La puerta del jardín chirríaStridea l'uscio dell'orto Y un paso tocó la arenaE un passo sfiorava la rena Ella entró, fraganteEntrava ella, fragrante Cayó en mis brazosMi cadea fra le braccia ¡Vaya!Oh! dulces besos, o lánguidas cariciasdolci baci, o languide carezze Mientras yo tiemblo las bellas formas discogliea de los velosMentr'io fremente le belle forme discogliea dai veli Mi sueño de amor se desvaneció para siempreSvanì per sempre il sogno mio d'amore Ha pasado la hora y me muero desesperadoL'ora è fuggita e muoio disperato Y muero desesperadoE muoio disperato Y nunca he amado tanto la vidaE non ho amato mai tanto la vita vida amadaAmato la vita Fuente: Musixmatch Compositores: Giacomo Puccini

Wow. So many negative comments. Why. I think he is good. How well do all these naysayers sing. Probably like fog horns

After listening to Corelli sing this aria . . . it's very hard to listen to anyone else.

Job well done on a difficult aria. Thought hid phrasing was very good as well as he having a beautiful voice. As some other comments were made that Corelli sang this better. True, but you can’t compare Corelli to anyone. Franco Corelli had a beast of an instrument.

Miguel Fleta único!!!

Nothing wrong with this performance whatsoever. This is a very solid lyrical performance.

Con quei microfoni gli fanno apparire una vocalità eroica...ma la realtà è molto diversa...

E lucevan le stelle ... ed olezzava la terra stridea l'uscio dell'orto ... e un passo sfiorava la rena ... Entrava ella fragrante, mi cadea fra le braccia. O! dolci baci, o languide carezze, mentr'io fremente le belle forme disciogliea dai veli! Svanì per sempre il sogno mio d'amore. L'ora è fuggita, e muoio disperato! E muoio disperato! E non ho amato mai tanto la vita, tanto la vita! ❤💋 💋💋💋💋💋💋💋💋💋💋💋💋💋💋💋💋💋💋💋💋💋💋💋💋💋💋💋💋💋💋💋💋💋💋💋💋💋💋💋💋💋💋💋💋💋💋❣❣❣❣❣❣❣❣❣❣❣💔💔💔💔💔💔🙊🙊🙊 ..............

For me one of the best is Marcelo Alvarez , just amazing !!

Wonder full tenor

Where do you see negative comments???

Franko Korelli und Mario Del Monaco , danach hört alles auf

Achtung ! La voix bouge maintenant. Ce somptueux et certainement un des plus grands ténors actuels, abuserait-il de son talent?

E LUCEVAN LE STELLE E Lucevan Le Stelle, da ópera Tosca, de Puccini, perfumada A Terra onde se via estrelas brilhantes. O portão no jardim Se abriu. Com doces beijos e carícias lânguidas, a amada Deixou cair os véus, e se entregou aos beijos sem fim Que o tempo depois colocou nos apetrechos de viagem. Aproveitar a oportunidade de ter deleites é dádiva única Nos momentos em que é bem difícil haver a mensagem Idêntica a outra história de amor escrita em bela crônica. A ária "E Lucevan le Stelle", da ópera Tosca, de Puccini, brilha No céu, na terra e no mar, onde tudo passa a ser o melhor, Se ligando, em plenitude, aos eflúvios que é uma maravilha, Levando a luz na atmosfera psíquica do planeta que agoniza Em sua parte mais sofrida e renasce com encantos e sem dor Num belo momento que, hoje em dia e amanhã, se eterniza. (*) (*) FERNANDO PINHEIRO, presidente da Academia de Letras dos Funcionários do Banco do Brasil. - E LUCEVAN LE STELLE (poesia), de Fernando Pinheiro. - in O mundo de Morfeu, de Fernando Pinheiro.

¿Por qué micrófono dentro de un teatro cerrado? No es lógico. Y es micrófono para amplificar voz porque es de diadema. No es micrófono de toma de sonido para grabar.

from 1 to 10: 8,5

JonasKaufmann Plter Greims Wie Na

Heureusement qu'il a un micro...

The extended long phrasings made the rendition flat and boring, there’s a shot where the conductor seemed to be second guessing his tempo

I saw him in dublin,found his voice a bit under powered and nasal sounding,hit a couple flat nots too,not overly impressed

Oh my gosh, I'm going to get crucified but I thought this was awful. I know it was a lavish TV production being filmed here but why does Beczala have to go on walkabout? And even through a microphone he struggles to compete with the orchestra. I am so thankful that I am old enough to have heard the great Gigli sing live when I was very young and proud to have been a friend of the wonderful English tenor John McHugh in his later years, both of whom filled the Royal Albert Hall with their voices without the need of microphones. Perhaps people are now so used to listening to amplified sound and intense volume courtesy of the sound engineer that they don't really know what pure sound actually sounds like. Sorry.

Early DI Stefano is most beautiful in my opinion He is no Jan Kiepura that’s for sure but then again who was .

Beczala simply doesn't have the vocal chops for this music - listen how the vibrato loosens into a wobble at the top of the voice. Is this really what we've come to?

nothing sublime! looks like he cannot control his voice, but at least he went trough the entire piece

no, I think he was singing a lot better at the beginning of his career. You guys probably like his voice like I do, but his technique is quite bad. His talent is very rare, so it can hide the vocal technique problems, but the wobble is quite obvious. There are tenors at 60-70 years old who don't have this wobble in their voice Whoever taught him technique needs to stay away from teaching singers how to sing

Над техникой пения ещё работать и работать. Иначе без голоса останется

Non mi piace affatto. By the standards of the old school operatic singing, this is not good.

He sings in italian but he still got that russian sting

Like passing out a hedgehog, what a torture.

Vibrato sounds like a dying car trying to start.

Przy Pavarottim wysiada.

Poor dynamics and that mouth wide opened on EVERY SINGLE NOTE ewww

Bravo!