Matt getting his own list was a much needed upgrade

PSA for everyone: pumpkin spice is not pumpkin flavour, pumpkin spice means it's flavoured with the same spices as a pumpkin pie would be.

The fishy smell/"taste" you guys got from the Culver's concrete mixer is pyridine. Culver's uses actual pumpkin puree, which contains pyridine, hence why it's a note you can pick up on

did anyone else replay 14:31 just to see the sheer genuine terror they both had on their faces, as well as to see who had the fastest reaction time

It is Amazing that Wired was able to get the man who carried the entire Hunger Games franchise.

The fact that he was able to drink all of that without turning into a horrific pumpkin homunculus only proves that he is an immortal highlander.

Patch Notes: - Matt gets his own tierlist Huge improvement

As someone with food-safety related anxiety, it was cool to see Matt and the crew being chill (and then funny) when Charlie mentioned his gas station food concerns. It's nice to hear a response other than judgement.

35:43 i feel compelled to point out- any “cream” frappe from Starbucks does not contain coffee. that IS, in essence, a pumpkin spice milkshake 🗿

Charlie becoming a frapp fan is the greatest character development of 2023

I worked at Culver’s for 5 years. The pumpkin spice shake is vanilla, a scoop of pumpkin, and some cinnamon. And that jaunt is DELICIOUS. So y’all must’ve gotten a bad one idk 😭

seeing charlie’s smile sparked a gleam in my eye and a slight palpitation of the heart. my grandmother was watching as well and now she can walk again. my goodness, may charlie inspire millions once more

Can't believe they skipped over the Pumpkin Spice Cheerios. Thousands of years from now archaeologists will wonder what was wrong with our species.

Didn't expect this but I will accept this great surprise. Nothing beats Charlie and Matt testing something just after Charlie had an interview with Wired which was also completely unexpected

the pumpkin muffin with the creamcheese is actually a recipe we make at home. You make a pumpkin muffin and then stuff em with this creamcheese mix halfway through cooking. super good homemade at least !!

Not liking Oreos growing up is so relatable. I absolutely despised Oreos as a kid and now I can eat an entire package like Charlie

Finally , Matt has been deemed list worthy.

This is the second time that Charlie brings up his urethral swab story on a food video.

The split screen dual tier list was better presentation than one after the other

I love how you guys go through the trouble to avoid cross contamination with food items, but with beverages you swap spit freely. 😂😂

I love how whenever Charlie stands next to any of his friends he looks like a tiny dwarf and they all look like giants towering over him 🤣

The Starbucks Creme Frappucino has no coffee. The bases of the fraps, are coffee base syrup or creme base syrup. So its literally milk, pumpkin spice syrup, creme base syrup, ice, blended topped with whip cream. Its definitely their biggest seller, I personally like it with 1 shot of espresso.

I want matt and charlie to rate the products in seperate rooms and see if they still have same opinions.

I think the 2 best pumpkin things I've had this season are the chai tea lattes at starbucks and the pumpkin bread ice cream at cold stone. I've gotten SO much of that already.

Im enjoying the tier list 2.0 update where Matt gets his own tier list.

Charlie literally pulled a "You thought I was feeling you" on Ice Spice's drink 😂

I would looove to see you guys try the food and drink items right as you get them. Like driving around to the different locations and trying them in the parking lot 😂

I worked at Culvers for three years- as long as they're doing it right. Its literally the custard mix with milk, pumpkin pie mix from a can, and cinnamon 💀

Matt getting his own list brought me an unprecedented amount of dopamine

Matt: “and it’s organic” Charlie: *“So I got a urethral swab-“*

I work at wawa and I agree that the pumpkin stuff is pretty sweet. The pumpkin coffee from the thermoses is pumpkin spice, while the hot coffee with pumpkin in it you had in the white cup is actually pumpkin PIE squeeze, so there is a slight difference in flavor.

Watching Charles immediately drink from a straw that Matt just drank from, proves those two will be friends until the end of time.

I’m surprised they didn’t find the actual pumpkin spice Oreos. I have a pack of them, was surprised when I saw the spooky ones and not the pumpkin spice ones

This is life changing. As a pumpkin spice enthusiast, this means a lot to me.

if it’s a cream frappe from starbucks then there’s actually no coffee in it so that could be another reason why Charlie likes it more that he thought he would 💀 although the frappucinos from starbucks are usually always a safe bet whether they have coffee or not flavor wise, I’ve never been disappointed by a frappucino

i like the way you split the lists while also being able to clearly see both lists

14:30 the way matt and charlie both had instant reflexes was perfect 😭

Can't wait for Winter time when they unveil their peppermint menu so we can get another one of these bangers

best way to describe the munchkin drink is imagine someone chewed up doughnuts and then spit them out and froze it

This is the first time in years I have been able to fully concentrate on a video of this length without pausing or multitasking. This video was pure gold

Matt”it taste like a bath and bodywork’s spice candle “ Charlie”I remember chewing on those”

Pumpkin spice is that cousin that you never asked for but hang out with a little too much

Okay, the beginning of the ad where it focuses into Charlie’s deadpan face is hilarious

Gotta give this guy his props for naming city of heroes as his favorite game on his wired interview. That game was really something special when I was younger. Really wish it was still available to play.

It makes me giggle every time they do a wide shot of Mat and Charlie and Charlie looks tiny as hell compared to Mat

As a former pumpkin spice coffee, i can confirm this tier list is unbeatable.

I love how charlies new fear of listeria thanks to chat came up as well as the Urethral swab from almost 10 years ago, like Easter eggs for the moistiest fans

please keep doing these kinda vids, super entertaining, I love it

Can’t believe you’d have a pumpkin spice tier list video without a single tablespoon of pumpkin spice being eating.

Every time I see a tier list posted I hope for Matt to consume something and say “it’s like that scene in Ratatouille…”

Truly amazing he was just in a wired interview 3 hours ago, but still has time to review a selection of goods

I saw your wired autocomplete interview. Just gotta say props and I really love your humility. Been a sub for a tiny bit but been watching for years. You da man!!

charlie never fails to spread us wide open and pound his content into us

Nothing like Mr moist becoming the average spoiled teenage girl

I love these, I would recommend putting matt's rankings up beside charlie's rather than flipping pages, but these showdowns are awesome, please continue.

Charlie getting bukakke’d by that yogurt made me laugh harder than anything in the world oh my god that was unexpected 22:46

Pumpkin spice by itself is a tough powder to swallow, but in coffee and pie? A match made in heaven

Doing a pumpkin spice tier list just before October is next level tier listing in action.

I like this way of showing the list more than 2 small list cause they both feel more significant

im loving the tier list videos

Matt finally got the Ratatoullie reference right. He said strawberry instead of grape. Character development!

23:18 the rattling of plastic cutlery in the background made me think Charlie’s yogurt cup was just a bowl of nails without any milk.

The tier list we all needed!

danny calling out matt for "crumb structure" cracked me up way harder than it should've lmao

Charlie's face expressions are the best after he drinks the shakes

Charlie has revolutionalized tier lists

I love watching charlie rate things I have never and most likely will never experience or encounter

So, the reason the Culver’s pumpkin was so much more pumpkin forward is there’s actual pumpkin pie filling in it. Pumpkin is a very odd(?) Flavor If you’re not expecting it. So it’s the only(?) one that’s actual Pumpkin and Spices, not Pumpkin Pie Spices

I NEVER go to Starbucks but ngl a pumpkin spice frappe is something I religiously wait for every year. Pumpkin just hits different

Matt is the play-by-play guy and Charlie is the color commentator 😂

The video editing is improving even more!

I wanted to share that the reason that first pumpkin drink from dunkin was so strong because it’s the signature pumpkin spice latte, and that has a shot of espresso in it, and most of the time the employees don’t know what a shot of espresso is so they end up putting too much in there, coming from someone who enjoys coffee and works at dunkin

i think having both lists side by side is the best way to do the lists

You should do a celebrity microwave meal tier list

the information you all present about food and its nutritional aspects is so useful that I forgive you for hating coffee, we all make wrong decisions and some times we have to allow others too.

The tier list videos r my favorite forsure

The wired interview went hard.

Charlie and Ice Spice, what a dynamic duo

Matt having his own tier list is an excellent evolution of the videos. Also, during that cut did Charlie have a few Oreos instead of the one?

I like when the camera crew and the ppl behind scenes get involved

never stop doing these tier lists

I never thought I see the day that they would even have a pumpkin spice tier list

As a dunkins employee I cant confirm that there is bear minimal sugar in the latte, the pumpkin swirl has sugar in it but the vanilla is the sugar free version we do not add sugar unless you ask for it generally it consists of pumpkin swirl (sugar and dairy added to the flavor) vanilla shot (what I think is just vanilla extract a bit) milk (milk) and espresso (stronger then normal coffee beans)

Finally. The Matt List. Been waiting on this for ages.

The pumpkin shake from culvers is insanely good. i have no idea what they put in yours to make it taste like fish

charlie never fails to spice my pumpkins

Since your doing a pumpkin spice review I FULLY expect that eggnog review in December.

"It tastes like a pumpkin spice candle." "I remember chewing on those" *casually sips coffee with a 1,000 yard stare*

I see Charlie and Tier List I click immediately. Love listening to you two try this stuff and react to it. On the frosty it's not bad but it's not for me. It's insanely too sweet for me.

I hope one day I have friends that I feel close enough to that I can share my own stories about pissing blood with them

I worked at culver's and I can't say it ever tasted like fish to me as much as I find that hilarious lmao. It's made with pumpkin pie mix and salted caramel blended tohgether

I really love the tier list videos :)

Pumpkin spice is said to clear out your pores. It does remind you of the fact that Halloween could easily transport you to places you've never been before.

3:10 Matt wanted to get some more but Charlie was already pushing it away. 😂

Hands down my fav mukbang channel - keep up the good work. Really looking forward to Charlie’s nikacado arc

Charlie will look up at Matt like he's a mother bird when he has food

Watching 14:32 frame by frame was one of the best recorded moment in history

As far as Holiday shakes, Chick-fil-A has a bangin ass peppermint bark milkshake. Makes my mouth water like Niagara Falls. Fills my belly with the holiday spirit🙌🏼

how authentic they are is so underrated they are so down to earth 🐐

gotta give it to that slide at 25:05 so smooth it didn't even need a transition