[Ránki Dezső] Schubert: Piano Sonata/Fantasie No.18 in G, D.894, Op.78

Рет қаралды 12,487

Күн бұрын

Franz Schubert (1797-1828)
Piano Sonata/Fantasie No.18 in G, D.894, Op.78
Ránki Dezső (1951-), piano
00:00 1st movement-Fantasie
11:05 2nd movement-Andante
18:23 3rd movement-Menuetto with Trio
21:59 4rd movement-Allegretto
IMHO, the best performance. Ever.
Unfortunatelly very poor sound quality with pops and clicks
My performance order:
1.Ránki Dezső: 99+ %
• [Ránki Dezső] Schubert...
2.Radu Lupu: 99%
• [Radu Lupu] Schubert: ...
3.Wilhelm Kempff: 91%
• [Wilhelm Kempff] Schub...
4.Walter Gieseking: 90%
• [Walter Gieseking] Sch...
5.Sviatoslav Richter: 1.mvmt:10%, 2-3-4.mvmt:98%: 76%
• [Sviatoslav Richter] S...
6.Michel Dalberto: 1-2-3.mvmt:75%, 4.mvmt:20%: 66%
• [Michel Dalberto] Schu...
7.Alfred Brendel: 60%
• [Alfred Brendel] Schub...

Пікірлер: 13

@EugeneKirpichov 3 жыл бұрын

I'm obsessed with sonata, I think this is one of the most incredible pieces of music ever composed, and I've listened to many performances, and to this one countless times. This is my favorite one by far. Don't mind the moderate tempo at all; this sonata places me in another world that, despite being entirely unlike ours, runs at its own pace and doesn't care about waiting for me to contemplate it, a slower tempo is not necessary for me to enjoy it.

@shaldana Жыл бұрын

How on earth I've never heard this piece before, I'll never know. It's just lovely.

@cluster976 11 жыл бұрын

I think Richter can hold very well such a slow tempo and it's not a matter of "What on Earth could Richter have been thinking?!" as he was not a naife artist. Perhaps, instead, he is one of the few who interpreted correctly the "heavenly length" of which Schumann spoke, regarding Schubert's works :-)

@antoinezygfryd 12 жыл бұрын

Magnifique !

@tunabilgin4331 8 жыл бұрын

I prefer Lupu

@gkollias14 12 жыл бұрын

no i just disagree that this performance is the best ever, it is far from it. But Richter ir Richter he is clearly one of the greatest if not the greatest performer of Schubert. It is not just a matter of taste, I believe that the slower tempo at the beggining suites it very much. Lets just agree to disagree...

@IanGoncalves 8 жыл бұрын

Dear +tsnamesoralong , can you tell us why you like more that bersion than the others composer? :)

@tnsnamesoralong 8 жыл бұрын

It is difficult question, especially in English. I think, in point of view of (a) interpretation strength, (b) tempo, (c) dramatic power (mainly in 4.movement), (d) melodic guidance, etc. Ránki's performance is the best. It doesn't matter in point of view of technical sound's poorness (for me).

@lilly763 12 жыл бұрын

Just because this version is faster than Richter's doesn't mean that it is superficial and Richter's is profound. They are merely different, and preference is entirely a matter of taste. I love much of Richter's Schubert, but I am not a fan of his ultra-slow tempos in the first movements of this sonata and D. 960. Of course those interpretations aren't bad, but they aren't at all to my taste.

@tnsnamesoralong 12 жыл бұрын

@gkollias14 IMHO=In my honest opinion. ;)

@gkollias14 12 жыл бұрын

I am sorry but I will have to disagree with that : "the best performace. Ever". Although a good performace, a very interesting, it is the 2nd 'worst' if you want, together with michel dalberto. None of them is a bad performace but this one seems hurried and quite light and over the surface. Just compare the first 5 seconds with Richter's to all of them and you will see the difference. Richter is simply the master in Schubert and his performance proves this exactly.