Heads up! There are spoilers in the comments, so if you're curious about the film and don't want to know too much about plot points, proceed with caution. :)

I'm a 64 year old grandpa male, and this is one of my favorite movies of all time. I love the old time and great acted movies. This still gets a tear a going to this day and must have seen it 15 times.

One thing that has always struck me at the end of the film is the moment when his memory is restored. In that moment his joy at finding his past and his wife is so tender and beautifully done. However, as my imagination continues the story to its logical conclusion, Smithy will experience the painful realization of the loss of his baby son in the same moment this tearfully joyful reunion occurs. The emotional rollercoaster he would be experiencing is something apart from the audience observation, but it must be an eventuality to be realized as the story plays out to its conclusion in our imaginations.

Thank you, my dear.. you are a refreshment and a delight. No pretense no professional posturing, merely the passion of a human being for the work of other human beings and a willingness to plunge into the details with loving thoroughness in order to elicit your deepest responses and share them with us. random harvest is indeed a profound film in so many ways.. not the least of which is the inscrutable mystery of the human mind and the power of

Ronald Coleman is terrific. This gem was my introduction to his art. Greer Garson became my first cinema crush. Mom urged me on to watch this film, when I channel-surfed into it as a young teenager (ca "1984"). Knowing little about romance at that age, I was still drawn to the romance and later tension in this drama. At times, I wanted to shout at the screen. The side-romance was so well framed, even I thought it was wrong. The marriage of convenience pushed me to the breaking point. I would love to have been among the live viewers long ago, to hear the groans ripple across the audience, as the ironies drop like bombs. Popcorn sales must have plummeted, with eager viewers waiting for a breakthrough. Thanks for the rewind. Among we, who love the movie, an extended review from you is a special treat.

This is my favourite movie of all time, with my favourite actress Greer Garson. I first watched this movie as a child , with my mum, and we wept tears of joy at the end. It is a beautiful story, all the loose ends tied up perfectly , great writing!! Thank you Jerome for your sinopsis, if I didn't know the film, you certainly brought it to life, explaining in just enough detail to make the viewer want more. Like you I don't watch it too often, but when I do, it's an occasion, and i love it. Mum isn't here now, but i know when I put this film on, she s right beside me, sharing all the emotions, just like we used to. I'm so glad a young girl like you has found this old black and white to be an enjoyable watch. Isn't it incredible, no swearing, no violence or sex just a great story, with great actors, pity we don't have movies like this nowadays!! By the way, Greer was in pride and prejudice as Elizabeth, her leading man was Laurence Olivier, another delightful movie, xx

One of my favorites. Greer Garson’s singing bit always stands out to me.

for me - Susan Peters contributed as much as Coleman and Garson did - i was so astonished when i first watched this film - here was an amazing young actress who has to take over when Greer Garson disappears for a while - and was as captivating as Greer - - i'm a huge movie buff - so i was surprised that i didn't know anything about her - so i immediately looked her up - and learned her sad story - - with her strong and appealing presence - she seems to me - more than countless other ingenues - to have been destined for stardom - her tragedy was our loss too

Love your passion for the great Ronald Colman. He's one of my heroes. This alongside, A Double Life are probably my favorite Colman films. I also loved his Bulldog Drummond films. Great actor.

I really like the long-form reviews you've been doing lately! And your best videos are the ones like this, where you get so obviously excited about the material you're reviewing.

I just found your channel and this is the first video of yours I've watched. Wow! One of my favorite films, with two of my favorite actors, and you hit every high note of my feelings about the film. Brava, a wonderful job. I so agree with every point you've made. The way he froze for a second when she called "Smithy" and then when he turned and the last piece of the puzzle fell into place, and his shoulders relaxed - that's when I go from silent sniffling to full-out sobbing, tears, nose running, the whole thing! And you caught it all. I just want to mention the amazing cameos by Henry Travers as the doctor, and his sweet, sweet laugh when he gave them the champagne after the wedding and said save it for the christening. And the incredible Ian Wolfe, whose face we don't even really see, as the clerk who registers the birth of the baby, and the charming way he deals with Smithy's excitement as a brand-new father. The score by Herbert Stothart is perfection as well, never intrusive yet always there when we need it. I really think this was his best work. And finally, the scene on the terrace of Parliament when Charles proposes marriage to Miss Hansen? Did you notice her suit? That three-layered organdy collar of her jacket. OMG! I sometimes re-watch that scene (as well as the ending, of course) just to drool over that suit of hers. If I could sew, I'd make myself that jacket/blouse, whatever it is and wear it every day!! OK, maybe I'm exaggerating, but you know it's so gorgeous. The costumer was "Kalloch" and he just blew me away. So thanks for this terrific review, I'm subscribing and look forward to checking out all your videos. Cheers!

A 'lovely' review of a favourite film of mine. In fact, my Mother's favourite film and like so many films from the 40s, she introduced it to me. This film always reduces me to a blubbering mess when the last 'Smithy!' is spoken. I am glad you didn't worry about spoilers and reviewed across the whole film. You did a great job working through the twists and emotional tensions. I particularly liked your inclusion of the body language from the two leads, something that I will note when I watch it again. I have read the book, but the film for me remains preeminent. I understand how you feel about Ronald Coleman, I can't watch Greer Garson without being enchanted by her luminosity. Great review and fantastic to see such an intelligent appreciation of the film's of Hollywood's greatest years.

Excellent review 👍 Look at the lighting in films from this era,it’s on another level.Also the camera work,in fact everything is of the highest level.Truly a golden age of film.

This is a quite good and sentimental film. Greer Garson is amazing. This is probably Ronald Colman’s most sympathetic role. Thank you for the review.

Random Harvest was among of the 3 biggest box-office hits of 1942 - a massive success. Also, Carol Burnett drolly parodied it as 'Rancid Harvest' on her 70's sketch show.

I agree with everything said about this beautiful film, especially the great Ronald Colman. Just wanted to mention the stunning score by Herbert Stothart. For me, he was quintessential "sound" of MGM in the golden years with fabulous scores for such classic films as, The Good Earth, Dragon Seed, Mrs Miniver, They Were Expendable and many others. Thanks again for you inciteful analysis and passion for Random Harvest.

One word "Smithy". It still brings an emotional surge.... Ultimate romance....

I watched this film on a late-night channel whilst on business in Detroit from my native north-west England. I was completely and utterly enchanted with it. Once I got home to good old Blighty, you can believe that I set about securing myself a copy of this amazing film. I don’t think I’ve ever seen any other film like it, nor could I imagine anyone else playing the parts that Colman and Grier play so wonderfully. Colman was blessed with a wonderfully mellifluous voice the likes of which have only been conveyed by people like James Mason or Richard Burton. I feel very blessed to have been in the right place at the right time, otherwise I would never have experienced this wonderful film.

Random Harvest is quite possibly my earliest memory. In a story about memory lost and memory found, it is ironic. At 62, I still remember watching this movie with my mom and dad when I was around 3 or 4. It kept my attention then, and now that I actually understand what is going on, I have the added nostalgia to my childhood. Ronald Colman and Greer Garson have always been my absolute favorite performers. Who doesn't love the variety of performances of Ronald Colman in Lost Horizon and Champagne for Caesar? Can you not fall in love with Greer Garson in Mrs Miniver or Madame Curie? I lost my DVD collection years ago when life took a difficult turn. It should be no surprise that even though my life hasn't returned to normal, I have already recovered many of my Ronald Colman (and Greer Garson) movies. I'm just pleased to be able to share my delight concerning an all time great classic that has dropped into obscurity.

Your soliloquoy about posture is soooo perfect. Worth a teary eye all by itself. I myself has seen this dozens of times over 50 years and sometimes it's a few years in between, or sometimes local film festivals stack it up for 3-4 seasons in a row with packed houses. It's also a great supporting cast and, while a lesser role, I love any role that Una O'Connor delivers. I am not unbiased - any time she appears, I always smile and give higher marks to the film makers.

one of my favs - best movie ending

You spoke very well-. I saw the movie a few months ago and was pleasantly surprised. And I'm already middle age. This 'will be one of those old movies that I will be returning to again and again, like Farmer's Daughter, Love Letters, Enchantment, Best Years Of Our Lives. They also surprised me on first viewing how great, well acted , entertaining and touching they were.

Two great roles! Luminous is a perfect word for Greer. Her musical number is an impersonation of Harry Lauder, a Scottish vaudevillian.

In the novel, Rainier states that he is 26 in 1920, which puts him around 24 when he meets Paula. But Rainier is also described as an old young man, so I'm not perturbed by the choice of Colman in the role. He brings a much needed gravitas to the part of Smithy/Rainier. That is what also makes Colman such a good casting choice in another movie based on a Hilton novel, _Lost Horizon._ Both characters are dealing with loss that they have experienced after fighting in WWI.

Why'd you make me re-watch that ending 😭😭 The way he inflates and turns. Deflates, and his eyes say it all. Reminds me of when I saw my wife slowly walking toward me with one hand holding a bouquet and the other in her fathers hand. Thank you for this video!

Crikey, I almost teared-up hearing you talking about it and I’ve never seen the movie. 👏

Thank you for a wonderful recap of the movie. Your own delivery is a remarkable performance. I plan to post a link to your video in my biography of Ronald Colman.

I have stopped counting the number of times I have watched this unique movie from years past, which touches upon issues still with us today. Medical, business, and political moments in time woven around a heartwarming love that endures unbelievable hurdles. .

Well, thank you for this recommendation. I watched it last night, really enjoyed. Brought to mind a favorite of mine, Goodbye, Mr. Chips (which I now have to see again). One thing I don't thing anyone has brought up: Paula as a secretary has to take the long way around her boss's desk every time he asks for paperwork and it takes her forever to get there. Wonder if that was intentional. Like, 'Take a good long look at me, you numbskull. Ring any bells?' Nice job on this, thanks again.

I also love this movie. Something I find moving in the last scene is when the violin solo plays as he's opening the door. It's the same violin melody from earlier in the movie when they entered the house together. Herbert Stothart wrote the score, which received an Academy Award nomination. He's not remembered nowadays as one of the great Hollywood composers, but he got 10 nominations, won for the Wizard of Oz, and penned the music to a lot of the best movies of the 30s and 40s. Another movie I like, from 1940, has a very similar plot - "I Love You Again". But, instead of a romantic tearjerker, it's a slapstick comedy, starring William Powell and Myrna Loy.

I really enjoyed your review of Random Harvest. It's always nice to find people on KZfaq who appreciate films from this golden era. Have you seen Ronald Colman in Raffles (1930)? It's a lot of fun and well worth a look.

I really appreciated your sensitive review of this deeply lovely film. You clearly know its value and this comes across in your assessment. One minor error is in saying Margaret was going to stay in ‘the north’ for a few days before sailing for South America. Their idyllic cottage was in Devon, which is in the south-west of England. However, thank you again for your kind review of a wonderfully heartwarming film.

My mum, who passed away last year, used to watch this film a lot when I was a child. So nice that someone as young as you, so pure and wholesome reviewing this kind of film is like a breath of fresh air. Keep up the good work.

... the power of living memory, without which, as in this Alzheimer's riddled world, we would be virtually nothing and nobody. Here's to true love and to a sound mind!

Well, that makes number 2 after Green Dolphin Street of my mother's favorites that you've reviewed. Have you already done Coleman's "A Tale of Two Cities" (another of her favorites)? I remember my mother sitting me down and insisting I watch Random Harvest on video one night years ago and being quite moved by its dreamy, emotional, fairytale quality. Incredible movie in every aspect - direction, acting. cinematography... even the editing had some brilliant unconscious cuts which I could only catch with the greatest attention. I must see this AGAIN! Your superb, passionate review has now made it impossible to watch anything else next.

Love this movie and Greer Garson just shines so much. This movie made me a huge fan of hers. Also like Ronald Coleman, of course. He was always such a handsome man. The book is great, as well.

Hey J.W. I wanted to share my thoughts on Random harvest with a bit of a twist... with music themes. Let me explain, one of my favorite past times is to take in an experience say a book, movie, video game, etc. and reflect on events/scenarios or character motivation by creating a custom playlist for myself to revisit the story without necessarily re-reading/re-watching. Now this is not a music recommendation per say, it's more of what I think of whenever I start listening to certain pieces of music and I thought it be fun to share. I will also be mentioning what version of of a song/music piece I'm referring too in case anyone does want to have a listen. *spoilers ahead folks* Let's talk character themes starting off with the theme I've chosen for Smithy "It's a Long Road" composed by Jerry Goldsmith (First Blood). Every time I start listening to this orchestral piece I am always reminded of the entire ark Smithy goes through the movie; From a man shrouded in apathy imprisoned at an asylum, to his escape, meeting Paula, gaining mental fortitude and all the struggles in-between to the end of the movie. The composition has some military elements and an epic crescendo that to me reminds me of the powerful scene at the end of the movie. For Paula, I see her as a ray of hope and love so "Dearly Beloved" (Kingdom Hearts) emotional cinematic orchestral crescendo and slowed + reverb are the themes that come to mind. Paula is introduced as a caring human being asking a complete stranger if he is alright and inviting set stranger to spend time with her, getting to know him and making quick judgment that this troubled soul needs help. And when push comes to shove she drops everything for Smithy's sake and eventually their friendship blossoms into romance with a promising future ahead. And when tragedy strikes I hear the second version slowed + reverb, She is faithful and determined to regain what she has lost. The pain the she endures until finally at the end the emotional cinematic plays once again when true love triumphs. Now I want to discuss music describing certain situations or scenarios throughout the story. In no particular order I want to start off with Smithy's and Paula's initial meeting and interactions with "Central Park" (King Kong 2005). Every time I listen to this piece I get goosebumps, not because the scene is full of emotion or cinematic but how meaning full it is to both character's stories and what life changing events they go through together. It also calls to mind an Easter egg observation I made between King Kong and Random Harvest; When King Kong is loose in the city causing chaos in his wake it's not because he is a hateful or malevolent being, no, he's alone, afraid and overwhelmed by his environment until Ann shows up and puts Kong at ease for a brief and meaningful moment peace. Like Kong, Smithy is out and about not necessarily causing chaos but he is definitely overwhelmed by the people around him and he does inflict fear to anyone he comes across in conversation. Paula like Ann not fearing the exterior can see a gentle and kind all be it tormented soul and wants to help by leading Smithy away form danger. Next up is a piece that sums up the time that was spent in Clevedon "Lake Hylia" Twilight Symphony (The Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess). Well to be honest I don't think I need to say much except for both characters it was absolute nirvana. Smithy is able to heal and becomes a suitable prospect for romance for Paula. And Paula becomes the happiest woman on earth for she has gained a home, a faithful and loving husband and soon a family of their own. Calm, soothing and romantic... enough said. Bare with me for this next one, "Snow's Station" (5 Centimeters per Second) is what I associate the short train ride scene. I think of the piece as a prelude to the romance Smithy and Paula will share together. Now you're probably wondering what on earth is he talking about, the scene is way too short and what is on screen is full of worry and doubt. Well... let me add context, what we see in the movie (and in any work of fiction) are only glimpses of a character's life that fits a bigger narrative, so the piece signifies what we didn't see. Train rides take time so I wouldn't be surprised if both characters formed a stronger connection by talking the entire way. Paula dropped everything for Smithy, a loose cannon in most people's eye's so what is she going to do? Ignore Smithy? Of course not, the gesture of helping Smithy to this extent is a beautiful sentiment towards smithy and so after another long heartfelt conversation I wouldn't be all surprised if Paula asked Smithy to cuddle for the rest of the train ride. Up Next is the when Paula now Margret catches up with Smithy now Charles and the emotional turmoil the leading lady endures throughout this painful scenario. "Love Deterrence" Orchestral or acoustic guitar cover (Metal Gear Solid: Peace walker/ Metal Gear Solid V: Ground Zeros/ Phantom Pain), To me this piece speaks of someone who wants love and has a lot love to give but can't for one reason or another. Imagine a depressed caged bird with it's only desire to spread it's wings and fly but all it can do is sing in sorrow. And for Paula, all she can do is remember happier times while being tortured by the turn out of events. Even though she is a fictional character I respect her decisions on not telling Charles the situation and staying faithful to Smithy. Paula's mental fortitude is completely off the charts, a lot of people would've given up or worse, I can see how she brought back Smithy Twice, her unrelenting will and undying love. Now if you're looking to listen to this composition you have to be careful because you could end up listening to an entirely different song. You see, the piece I'm referring too "Love Deterrence" is an orchestral reprise of a J-Pop song titled "Koi no Yokushiryoku". The Best way to find it is t look up ground zeros love deterrence or love deterrence acoustic cover. There used to be an extended version of the same composition with a prelude and an instrumental outro but I haven't been able to find it in years. This next theme describes two similar situations in the movie, when Smithy is wondering around town after his escape and Charles retracing his steps. "Another Time" composed by Jerry Goldsmith (Rambo III) exhibits someone lost in thought, not really knowing the answer's they seek are out there, but more reflecting and understanding the question being asked. When both characters are walking around puzzled and troubled, Smithy really wants to know who he is and claims he's alright and Charles just can't seem to figure out why his surroundings are so familiar. It's another piece you have to imagine some parts we didn't see, we only got a brief montage of smithy walking around sticking out like a sore thumb and we only got to see Charles starting to retrace his steps not the full journey. Despite that, I can imagine both saying to themselves "Why can't I remember?" or "Who am I?" If I can go off topic for a sec, this theme also makes me think of Marty from Marty 1955 where he is explaining himself to Clara what he was up to after the War, walking around the streets to the early hours of the morning and having thoughts... we'll leave it at that. For the final music theme to describe a situation will be covering the final scene of the movie. A powerful scene of emotion, broken-hearts mended, promises kept and true love rekindled "Through the Eyes of Love" orchestra instrumental to be a perfect fit. It just makes me reflect on the beauty of keeping a promise and staying faithful to someone after going through pain, adversity, temptation, doubt, loneliness and heartache. It's easy for the heart to be consumed by apathy or depression after going through all of that but if one can still hold on to faith, kindness, selflessness and hope than love has a chance of surviving. Life is too short , Paula could've spent the rest of her days in utter misery and in the end after all that adversity in her life she regains what was once thought lost. Bonus Tracks: "The Best is Yet to Come" Aoife Ni Fhearraigh and "Open Arms Lex DeAzevedo I really have no place to put these, I can only say it makes me think of Random Harvest. Now for "The Best is Yet to Come" I've read the wrong lyric translation but after reading both the correct and incorrect I say they both ca fit. Thank you for taking the time and reading my thoughts! Next comment won't be a long winded as this one... unless you make another 2 hour video...

This is such a nicely done video. Random Harvest is my favorite movie and you gave it a great review. Thank you for remembering Ronald Colman, his charm is stellar. I enjoyed this so much.

That final minute was beautiful! 🥲

I loved your video on Random Harvest. One of my favourite movies, It’s been a while since I’ve seen it. You did a fantastic job describing the movie. The feelings you showed were my feelings exactly. I am 80 years old and I still cry every time I see it. Another move I cry at is Now Voyager with Bette Davis. Very romantic indeed! Keep up the good work, I enjoy your work , and look forward to hearing your thoughts in the future. Mel

,, Seriously great review,, this is from the calibre of films I grew up watching, even before I started school and always knew that this cinematic era would forever be where real movies lived,, even the clothes they wore are greatly tailored,, no modern return to the golden era can ever have a proper costume budget or flair for replicating such quality, nor the period set pieces and knick knacks or window closers or gas mantels ,, or normal daily tousle of hair mixed with smog and lineament,, and your reviews are filled with all the heart felt emotions that only such wondrously exciting epics can evoke,, I'm so glad you're here to do such good work,, may you always endeavour so proudly 😏💐🏆 x

I agree with you 1000% I am avet 1970 vintage and this movie means a lot to me. It never goes away but it's easy er to deal with once you know about it.

Final scene...he stares wistfully at the cottage...his face lights up as he hears her voice... "Smithy?" His face beams. "Paula!" Susan Peters' role is cute, then heartrending.

One of my favorite movies. The cast and story were outstanding. Colman and Garson were two of my favorites. I really enjoyed your review. You did a great job of telling the story and analyzing the movie. I liked that your love for the movie came through so clearly. Like you I have watched the last scene many times. You do this so well. Thank you.

Your review was very good. I appreciated the background information on the actors. Thank you.

DUDE. I just found your channel, and you have since earned a spot on the list of people I aspire to be like! I Adore this movie with a capital A. Ronald and Greer are the perfect duo, and you've so thoroughly covered this film with your review. Like you, I also share an unending love for Ronald. Such a tender, complex, beautiful soul. UGh I don't have enough words. You are wonderful. Ronald is wonderful. This movie is wonderful. I have subscribed. Please continue to do the good you are currently doing, Cheers!

This was a most professional review. Very skilled. Confident, honest, understanding of the medium. It was magic, and partly due to your tie with Mom and Pop. Likely you are their pride and joy, haha. Hey, please find time to review; "Kings Row", and "Holiday Affair" with Robert Mitchum and Janet Leigh. Thank you. You really are gifted.

Very intelligent review on Random Harvest. I found it on KZfaq, and your review has encouraged me to watch it. If it made you cry, I'm sure it'll have the same affect on me. My wife passed away 3 years ago from Covid and I still miss her.

I just found this channel and I love your videos! You have great taste!

Wow... I was wandering thru favorite-film reactions and figuring I'd never find an ADULT review - and lo & behold, this RANDOM HARVEST pops up. Just amazing. For me, the opening scenes where he's part of "lost interviewings" - where amnesiac survivors were visiting by possible parents, wives, friends to discover identities - lordy - how sad. How crushing. I am screaming in my head, "Can I ever imagine such a sad experience?" No. Only in this film. I've never seen this re-created in any other film.

SHEER BLISS!!! Thank you, JW, for such a brilliant review of one of my favourite films. I can't begin to count how many times I've seen it - and I sob every single time! I agree with all of your points. Colman was absolutely gorgeous. Far too old, of course, but I can't imagine anyone else in the role. Your description of Garson as "luminous" and "radiant" is spot on. What a beautiful woman she was (and my favourite Elizabeth Bennet). I would urge you to read the story - you can read it online. SPOILERS: The Paula/Margaret reveal is at the end of the book. For obvious reasons that can't be done on film, but the shock of seeing Paula walk through that office door as "Miss Hanson" is so huge that it's truly inspired. It's one of my favourite scenes in the film. Others include when Paula goes through the contents of Smithy's suitcase in the hotel after Charles has dismissed them. That kills me every time! But the most poignant moment (apart from the ending) is the after-the-ball scene with the beads. I'm sobbing throughout! If I have one teensy issue with the film, it's Hollywood's portrayal of England. As an Englishwoman myself, I have that eye-rolling moment at the tweeness of it all. But I can forgive that. Thank you, again, and take care.

Great in depth review . Looking at the pictures in your video , it struck me that Greer Garson reminded me of someone else . Then it came to me , Meryl Streep .

Excellent review , Greer Garson is one of my favs . Thanks ! 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼

Thank you for your wonderful review of this film. This is my very favorite love story/mystery and I watch it often.

I’m a blokey bloke,I laugh in face of horror movies,I would claw my way to safety in the Himalayas with four broken limbs (you don’t want to know how) - but these sort of films tear me up,I can’t handle it 😭

It's one of my all time favourite movies, which I've seen many times, and I always cry at the end. Did you notice he doesn't stop to think that some people would be living in the cottage before he opened the door? I can imagine the man of the house coming to the door and shouting "what do you think you are doing? Go away or I'll call the Police."

I echo the delightful comments you made on this movie....it's one of my favorites. The beginning premise is completely believable: many soldiers in WW1 were shell-shocked or received wounds that made them lose their memory. WW1 was a horrific war, many combatants were MIA, and there were a great many "unknown soldiers" who were buried, and known only unto God. Another thing, people looked much older than their actual age in that time era. And techniques of making actors older or younger were still being developed.

Did you know Ronald Colman and Greer Garson were thought to have the best voices in Hollywood at that time? Even Robert Osbourne of Turner Classic Movies acknowledged this. I'd like to see you review BRIEF ENCOUNTER (1945).

Thanks for the review. I first saw this as a teenager watching Bill Collins spotlight on the golden years of hollywood and British cinema. It's probably my third favourite movie of all time.

Is the meeting still on?.Sorry for being late.Just managed to get my hands on a copy of Random Harvest.First time view.What a movie.The ending.The MGM lion would have been roaring with tears.This movie was not on my radar but I am now so glad to have seen it.I welcome your benevolent influence.

Loved your review . So well done ! Great movie that for some reason I haven't seen for quite some time . I also looked it up on Imdb and found out that this movie was Gene Wilder's favorite movie & and he also considers this to be the most romantic movie that he has ever seen ! I love old movies and cannot remember seeing one that gave me goosebumps likes one did tonight. The first time was when the organist at the chapel starting playing and it must have jogged his memory. They both were such superb actors just in body language alone without saying a word ! I've seen this movie a couple times , but it just blew me away when I watched it again tonight. The ending is one of the best in all film. Casablanca is a close second !

Thank you so much for this precise and sensitive review. I discovered two actors and an incredible movie. I had to watch it, and I did, and I cried... I'm not sure the last scene would produce the same effect with a younger couple ... Their aging are perfect for long lost souls eventually finding real happiness... (I'm thinking about the last scene of Lalaland, and for me, it doesn't work as they are too young tant shining to play mature lives, lost love, and regrets.- here it not only works but it is stellar ...)

Really wonderful, compelling review - it made me want to seek out this movie. I had no idea the story was such a complex, wrenching examination of identity. Stories like this really make me wonder how deeply - or shallowly - rooted our identities are and if they can be wiped clean as easily as erasing a computer hard drive. It's frightening to realize that our identities may be more fragile than we think. Really great review!

This is my second favorite Ronald Colman film after Prisoner of Zenda.

One of my favourite films of all time and don't tell anyone but the last scene always makes me cry ☺️

Hi Jerome , Love this content and old school black and white movies especially Godzilla 1954! Theses movies are greatly missed! Unlike the junk we have nowadays

I first saw this movie as a child and I am working ever cents, thank you so much for your wonderful review.

Just found your channel. Looks great. Will find this film. Then come back for the review after I have watched too. Will be checking out your book reviews too. As I've become a big reader of books recently.

This is the best film of all time as you rightly said it’s lovely

Hello and thank you for this review. I just picked up "Random Harvest" at the library...the film AND the book. I've never seen a Ronald Coleman film and actually only heard about him from the movie "A River Runs Through It" (he's mentioned a few times by some of the characters) so I am very much looking forward to watching this one.

Thank you I enjoyed your review of this wonderful film too.

Greer Garson- What a woman!!

THANKS !! JERROME WEISLBERRY . GREAT PREVIEW . R.I.P. RONALD COLEMAN THE VERY BEST OF BRITISH STARS. FROM U.K. (2021).

Wonderful review of a movie I first saw decades ago and didn’t have a strong reaction to, but recently rewatched it and saw it in a completely different light. I now love it and love both lead actors as well. There is something warm and comforting in Coleman’s face that even stars like James Stewart don’t quite possess. Here’s a movie that I’d love to see a sequel to even if it were only 20 minutes so I could see how happy their lives had resumed. But as it is, it’s a wonderful ending. The only other film with as heart warming an ending as this is perhaps Chaplin’s City Lights.

It's also Robert Redford's favorite film.

7:16 nice shot of Garson in her highlander costume. I LOVE woman in kilts; almost as cute as ladies in lederhosen!

It as taken me nearly 30 years to find this film I watched it 1 day in my 20.s i.oved it then but never new the title ,I've just seen it again , unbelievable I never give up seeing it again definitely in my top 5 films ever

Hi Jerome! I've been meaning to watch "Random Harvest" for a while now since it has a great reputation, but I haven't gotten around to it yet. I'll have to revisit this video after I do. I did recently see your delightful one-on-one interview with Daisuke Beppu and I was reminded of your love for Capra's wonderful "Arsenic and Old Lace". It made me think. Have you ever reviewed "Bell, Book and Candle" with Jimmy Stewart, Kim Novak and Jack Lemmon? The two movies are very different but I feel like "B, B & C" shares just a little of that macabre, dark sensibility and humor that "Arsenic and Old Lace" has (in greater quantities for the latter). Have you ever covered that one in one of your "What Else I Saw In..." videos? I'd love to hear your thoughts on that one. Thanks!

loved the review. as i if watched the movie. thank you for sharing.

Have you seen any of the "Blondie" movies from 1939-1950? The 28 films were based on the comic strip, with nerd husband, architect Dagwood Bumstead and his knowing wife Blondie, their eventual two children, Alexander {Baby Dumpling}, and Cookie, and their dog Daisy. There was even a radio series which came out during the run of the films. Much like the Sherlock Holmes radio series, and film series starring Basil Rathbone and Nigel Bruce. Dagwood was always my hero, the guy that would fall over anything, all his projects would backfire, and when he needed real help, he'd call for his wife. "Blooonndiiieee!!!!" Basically the dad in 'Back to the Future' but more likeable. I think it influenced the later "I Love Lucy" show a lot, but with the roles reversed, but Blondie was meant to be super silly while Lucy, tried to keep it a bit more straight.

The stars have the two most beautiful voices! I would only compare it with "Pride and Prejudice" with Greer Garson and Laurence Olivier.

Very cool movie review 🙆‍♀️

One of my faves. Colman + Garson.

You have got to read Random Harvest! It's better if you read the book first, for reasons that will be clear when you do read it, but read it anyway. It's actually a good adaptation, but it has to change a lot, and I prefer the book, though I watch the movie every so often.

Unrelated question though I'm referencing the same period.What would you say are the essential Intra War and Post War military Movies?

One of my favorite films. Great cast: Ronald Colman who has no equal, Greer Garson and Susan Peters... LOVE 🧡🧡 them both (I have a ton of their stuff). Greer Garson is in fact luminous in everything she does. I have always felt bad that Susan Peters came so close to marrying Ronald Colman, but ultimately loses him. She does a great job with that role. Greer Garson of course goes through a roller coaster ride, but at least gets "Smithy" back at the end. The toughest part to watch is actually when he proposes a marriage of convenience to her and she has to endure being so close and yet so far (as you pointed out). Yes... emotionally draining which is why I need to mentally prep before watching it. Three of my favorite movies (this one, Lost Horizon, and Goodbye, Mr. Chips) are all based on James Hilton books. That is interesting. Of course 2 of the 3 have Greer Garson and 2 of the 3 have Ronald Colman. The ending of this movie completely undoes me every time haha. "Smithy, oh Smithy". Thanks Jerome. Great analysis. Someone put together this wonderful little "best scenes" of Random Harvest. It's good. At the ending when they are back at the cottage you will hear them speak: kzfaq.info/get/bejne/l9J9dJyIu9jZips.html

Is the little village up north? I thought it was supposed to be Devon they headed for on the train, which is the West country. Purely an academic point Jerome. (I’m binge watching today.)

Looking forward to your review of Godzilla vs Kong when you go see it. I'm seeing it tomorrow!

I enjoyed your review and also loved the movie. But believe me, the book is even better. I consider this James Hilton's masterpiece. And being a book, the twists could be much better disguised and you feel overwhelmed when the reveal happens, gloriously. Whilst i loved the lead couple, I also had a soft corner for Kitty!!

Love it.

I loved Random Harvest. Have you seen Letter From An Unknown Woman from 1948?

This movie could've been too frustrating if it weren't for how the characters were introduced to us. Luckily, I straight up adored them right from the start. I'm already a huge Ronald Colman fan, and he is exceptional in this, particularly at the beginning, so that helps. And that makes twice that I've really loved Greer Garson: This and Mr Chips (one hell of a debut). It's necessary to love these characters, these versions of the characters, right from the start, and to be heavily invested in what happens to them, or there's a real danger of being put off by the ensuing events, and the highly unlikely plot. But they are that good, that lovable, so it's not difficult to enjoy the movie as a whole. I have to say, Susan Peters is kind of a beacon of light in the second half too, which was definitely necessary. You don't really want her and Charles to end up together, but you definitely want her to be happy. And I hereby echo essentially all of your opinions on Random Harvest. It is an incredible film.

If you haven't read the book yet, do so. One of the great "suspense" novels of all time. And happily, the movie is just as wonderful in it's own way. Both are first-rate. And yes, the ending scenes from Melbridge on, have a sort of hypnotic appeal that demands rewatching every so often...

Bramwell Fletcher (Harrison) was also with Colman in RAFFLES (1930). Obscure trivia.

One of my favorite films.The tenderness and magical chemistry overcomes Colman's age .The ending is beautiful.It is a lovely film. E njoyed your review.💙💙

The book is vastly more intricate than the movie. This isn't a criticism. No way could you give all the intricacies proper attention in any film. And I love the movie. But the book is structured in a very interesting way, worth looking into for its own sake.

I love how you say that the one criticism you have is the age of Colman. Then you justify it. You're reaching, but well done.

Brilliant film , brilliant review .

*RED ALERT, READERS ALERT, This mini comment review contains spoilers and personal thoughts of panchovilla7769!* Buenas Noches, once again this comment will be quite lengthy (and Ungrammatical) sorry not sorry. So I just finished the film and... well... that was an experience. I wasn't aware I would have so many emotions throughout the first half of the film. I grow up in toxic environments and having experienced hate, racism, self loathing and loss through circumstance I can really relate to Smith in the opening act. Seeing Smith in an asylum experiencing memory loss, giving off an intimidating presence to those who do not know him, not being able to speak for himself and just being an outcast amongst the crowd really hit home fore me. Not knowing what to do with himself and questionings his purpose in life was aggravating to watch. But when Smith meets Paula is such a wholesome moment, it was a fresh breath of air. Sometimes in life all you need is someone to support and believe in one's self and it take one's will to want and accept help. As a result our man Smith through A LOT of help from Paula becomes a man to be respected and endeared by those around around him. As for Paula's character, she was kind enough to help more than any other human being would extend themselves for a stranger, let alone an asylum patient (which at this point everyone has label Smith as dangerous looney). As they go through their journey they both realize they can't go on with out each other in their lives and this was very touching. needless to say, there where tears throughout the first half of the film. As for the second half... well... the situation and circumstance in which Smith becomes Charles was asinine to watch. In contrast to Smith who is kind, gentle, genuine and self spoken... Charles is... a bit of a donkeys rear end, if you know that I mean. Being cold, calculating and sometimes straight up cynical. And the situation he finds himself in when Kitty was introduce... well lets just say I got gold digger vibes from her. I absolutely hated when Charles gets engaged with Kitty, especially when Charles knows to well he won't be happy but goes along with it anyway... and in a twist Kitty puts off the marriage for both of their sakes, which was interesting to watch. Kitty realizes that the infatuation between them had no ever lasting passion nor balance between both parties. As of this point Paula is now Margret in the story and as Jerome Weisleberry pointed out, It must be devastating for a spouse/partner to find their beloved as a completely different person, not evening remembering who their former spouse and being in such proximity can cause unnecessary amounts of pain. But Margaret keeps her composer and our oblivious friend Charles is non the wiser. Massive respect to Paula's character for enduring so much self-inflicting pain for that sake of some Charles/Smithy and for keeping the promises they made together and later obtain back which she had lost so long ago. And finding out their son died a few years back, and the feeling of abandonment Paula must've felt, defiantly boils my blood to no end. But the ending... the ending was so beautiful that I won't discuss it because it's meant to be seen in full. Well those are some of my thoughts. *Dislaimer: This is a repost because I was putting a spoiler warning on the top of my original comment and accidentally deleted it.*

This is such a beautiful movie. have you seen "The Enchanted Cottage"?