I would do this but I don’t have the energy to wrap them and then unwrap them lmao

Seems like you've picked the right books for your TBR. Keep up the good work, Haley. We will support you no matter what.

I've been doing this ever since I watched Sara's video and it makes it so much fun, being able to pick a book at random and not know what it is! I've got friends to pick the number that links to the book I unwrap to make it even more fun! I love that you're doing this

i love how nervous she was to read once apon a broken heart only to absolutely love it

I understand how Carrie Soto is back may seem uninteresting, but I just finished reading it and I think it’s a really well written book (especially if you like to see character growth in the books you read). I also think she did an amazing job with writing Carrie Soto’s emotions and feelings. I would love to see you reading it soon

watching this while I crochet 🧶 can’t think of a more cozy day 😂❤️ can’t wait to see your thoughts on the ones you picked!!

Once upon a broken heart and the ballad of never after are my favorite books of the year ❤️

I adore the Once Upon A Broken Heart series, but I also really enjoyed Stephanie’s writing in all of the Caraval books as well, it might just not be for you!

I always love these types of TBR's! I did something similar a few years ago for Valentine's Day and it was super exciting to get a little surprise each day. Instead of opening them up in my TBR video, I opened up a new book each time I finished the one before it. Good luck with your picks!

Once upon a broken heart is on my tbr list too! I’m excited to see what you think about it. It seems like you picked a lot of great books ❤

Hope you enjoy Once Upon a Broken Heart! It’s my FAVORITE series! I liked it more than Caraval! The second book to the Broken Heart series is better though!😊

Haley thank you for making my weekend so much better with a new video !!!

Girl! I love your vlogs soooo much. I don't know what makes it so compelling. Atmosphere, books or your energy, but anytime I start your video I have this energy boost and am willing to enjoy my reading more. So thank you!

a curse so dark and lonely is amazing!! one of my biggest surprises this year, especially as someone who isn’t a huge fantasy reader. I absolutely loved it!!

I love unwrapping books. It is so fun. I am doing a 24 days of Bookmas this year with a bunch of holiday/wintery books off my shelves. Just wrapped them tonight. Hope you enjoy the books you chose.

you motivated me in to reading and now I have a whole tbr of like 6 books I lysmm hayleyyyy

Love this video idea!! Next time I think it would be a good idea to keep them wrapped until it’s time to read the book to keep the excitement :)

Swear on This Life is one of my absolute favorites!! It deals with overcoming childhood trauma in addition to the romance story and has some nice quotes. The story within a story is cool. I read it years ago before similar books cropped up, none of them totally measured up to SOTL for me. And I have Tweet Cute on my kindle and keep telling myself I need to read soon!

I am so obsessed with all of your book videos- they are my comfort videos I'll telling u

YESS TWO VIDEOS BACK TO BACK INVOLVING READING!!

I read stalking Jack the Ripper when it came out, and it’s one of my favourite books!! Love the mystery & the romance

I liked this video soooo much, expecially when you were waiting to get the book you wanted. Im really looking forward to the vlog abt it. Love u, Haley!!!

Stalking Jack the Ripper is one of my all time favorite series!! It is soooo good. I love the plot and storyline, the setting and the characters. Such a unique twist on classically known stories both fiction and real.

i loved the assassin’s blade! i read it after heir of fire and it was my favorite in the series out of those first 4. they’re not really “short stories” since they all continue off each other in chronological order. it was the first time i really felt connected to celaena and kind of wish i read it first in the series. don’t sleep on it!!!

Ohhh I love this idea of blindly picking your TBR so fun!! 😍 I also really loved The Cheerleaders, hope you enjoy it!

Aaa I love how your reading the second book in The shadow and bone series! I’m currently about 30 pages from the end of the first one, then im so excited to see the end!

Waking up to a video upload from Haley is the best way to start a day :)

Yayyyy you’re finally gonna read Once Upon A Broken Heart! I hope you will love it it’s different from Caraval and it’s so sweet and whimsical ❤ can’t wait to see what you think. This is literally my fav book!

This video was so fun, I can't wait to see the reading vlog for them!

You should read “ you’ve reached Sam “ it’s one of my favorite books totally recommend!! 😊

i hope u enjoy each book! :,))

Her videos are so comforting, whenever I'm anxious, I always come here and watch her vlogs and it just makes me happy

YES THE wrapping is beautiful

Omggg I'm in heaven two videos in a row 🫶🫶🫶 I'm dying for your videos❤

The author of A Curse So Dark and Lonely is one of my favorite authors. Brigid wrote the Defy the Night series (one of my favorites), and Letters to the Lost, another favorite. Highly recommend her work!

Best book reading vlog by Haley! 😍💖💖💖💖💖

It's been a while since I first read Tweet Cute, but I remember it being a lighthearted and enjoyable book. I hope you have a fun time with it, too!

I saw Sara do this and I’ve been waiting for you to do it for so long 😭😭😭. I’m literally so excited 🥹

i myself have generally only heard good reviews of the assassin’s blade, but i can see how it being a prequel short story collection may not float some people’s boats. i gave it 4.5 stars when i read it, and i thought it was a really wonderful collection of short stories that were genuinely very enjoyable and only added depth to the experience! i wouldn’t let the negative reviews hinder me :)

The girl of fire and thorns is such a classic fantasy novel! Was very very hyped back on 2015 Booktube. Read this book back at that time and it has still heavily stuck with me to this day and is still very close to my heart. Highly highly recommend

Love this idea! It would be fun to watch every month!

you are going to LOVE tweet cute!!! it definitely reminds me of your other fav books

i LOVED carrie soto is back! i read it the day it came out and omg i recommend it so so much!

I saw sarah do this and was WAITING for you to do this

I love Naomi Novick’s writing. ❤ The Schoolmance Trilogy is great and so is Uprooted. Spinning Silver is next on my list.

OMG DEFINITELY DOING THIS I was thinking that I wanted to wrap books just for the aestheticI can't believe I never thought of this wow thanks for another video haleyy I love your reading era I've been watching you since you moved to you first apartment alone!! ❤❤

I love how you have books everywhere in your den!

I read assassins blade after I read the full series and really enjoyed it! It was a fun easy read that just gives a bit more info about the main characters backstory, highly recommend not skipping!

HI i felt the same way abt the caraval series! but once upon a broken heart & ballad of never after are one of my favorite series! it is so much easier to get into in my opinion🖤

omg omg omg girl of fire and thorns is my favorite series ever !!! it made me love reading as a little girl

This seems like such a fun challenge. Thank you Haley for the amazing video once again!

Meg with books has a series where she picks her tbr like this ☺️ always fun to watch!!

I buy books for all my friends on birthdays or holidays and it's honestly because I love wrapping them too lol! So satisfying

Currently obsessed with rory gilmore challange and blind date w/books videos and you literally upload both of them in a week soo I've started to think you're my fairy godmother or something 💛

I LOVE THIS! I wanna do this with all my unread books!!! But it's about 170 books sooo wish me luck with wrapping all of those. I work at a bookstore though, so I'm pretty good at wrapping books now hehe.

i read once upon a broken heart and thought it wasn’t very good however the second book ballad of never after is my new all time favorite book it’s sooo good definitely recommend

yay new book video 🎉🎉 you should join the “books i want to read before the end of the year” trend!!!

I HAVE BEEN WAITING FOR YOU TO DO THIS 🫶🏼

I bought a darker shades of magic in hardcover and oh my gosh it's so pretty

Yaaaaayy Hayley I saw this video from Sarah do it and I’m so glad you did it 😂😂 you should totally do more🎉❤

Tweet cute is so good I really enjoyed it

i love the cheerleaders so much! I've read it more than 3 times lol

Can we all just appreciate the amount of effect puts into these videos.

I hope this becomes a new trend, seems like sm fun and I wanna do it so bad!!

This is a good idea! I just started reading Twilight a few weeks ago, because I found a brand new book set in a thrift store and wanted to read something I didn't own. I'm on the second book and never have seen the movies, so it's exciting!

i think you’ll like tweet cute! i don't usually like ya contemporary romance but i really enjoyed it. also, it's completely no spice

i just recently read tweet cute and LOVED it :’)

Once upon a broken heart is my new favorite book. Easily five stars. I’m obsessed with Jacks from caraval and he’s the main love interest in the spinoff duology. The plot is amazing, I couldn’t put the book down.

Girl I just love your videos💕

Can't express all but your content makes my day haha! ❤

Love this !

Tweet Cute has been sitting on my shelf for so long! The cover of Once Upon a Broken Heart 😍

Hey love ur vids Haley! ❤

I love this idea! I need to read more of my physical tbr too

I wasn’t feeling great but when you upload you make my day❤️

Next year you should totally try getting one of those Book Advent Calendars where you get books wrapped in paper and open one everyday! :)

I remember LOVING Tweet Cute when I read it in 2020! I also want to read Once Upon a Broken Heart so I'm curious to hear your thoughts 👀

The Cursebreakers series was so surprising to me, because I thought it'd be like a rushed written YA fantasy, but it was so good (I only got annoyed with one character in the second and third books) but after I had to read Forging Silver into Stars (which might be my favorite book of the year). Then I read Defy the Night and Defend the Dawn and loved them. Basically Kemmerer is becoming one of my favorite authors. Afterwards, I was in a reading slump because I couldn't find anything that held my attention and made me excited the way they did so I switched genres for a month and half and now I'm currently rereading favorite books to get over that slump 🙃 (Bad books don't put me in slumps but rather really good books do)

You should cover a bunch of books but only the front, back and spine of the book. Number them and pick a random one and read it but because it's covered you don't know what book your reading and once you've finished the book you can try and guess what book it is, the genre, the title and then unwrap the book revealing what it actually was to see how close you were.

You will love the cheerleader it makes you feel so much different emotions it's incredible

The assassins blade is so so good but so heartbreaking! I think you’ll love it honestly

this is such a good idea! i’m currently reading The Deal on my phone i’m almost done but i have to read The Love Hypothesis , The Spanish Deception and Mr.Wrong i bought them in october i haven’t had time to read them and i have to finish the Divergent series they are on my bookshelf for so long 😭

Haley, I love you! ❤️

Wow, I really love how Haley is doing a random TBR. Wow, Haley your video is so cool.

I love twilight so much

Stalking Jack the Ripper is so good I read it and loved it. This book does have a bit of romance not a lot but it’s so good!!

Hi Haley! I love your videos so much, I really think you’d enjoy Carrie Soto is back! Happy Reading! ❤

I listened to Tweet Cute last month + really loved it! I had it on my physical tbr for like a year tho bc I wasn’t sure but it ended up good haha :)

Twilight has my heart

Tweet Cute and The Cheerleaders are great!

YAYAYAYAYYY HALEYYYY I LOVE YOU.

i got an arc of carrie soto is back a couple months ago and was absolutely amazed by it! one of my favourite tjr books so far! i literally read the whole thing in one night! highly recommend

Haley, I would love it if you would read one of my all time favorite books. It’s really unheard of but it’s called The Grace Year by Kim Liggett. It’s a fantasy/mystery with a little romance. (I literally never hear anyone talk about this book and I would love if more people did)

Hi Haley happy Sunday afternoon and I hope you having amazing day today and I loved your vlogs and you are amazing Supporter and I'm proud of you

Haley!!! Been loving your videos -- especially as I've gotten more and more into reading this year!

OMG I just binged Once Upon a Broken Heart and The Ballad of Never After and I think you’ll enjoy them!! I gave Caraval 4 stars, Legendary 3 stars, and Finale 5 stars, which I think is similar to how you rated them in a previous video, so I think you’ll really enjoy Once Upon a Broken Heart! The first one is a little bit slow in the beginning because it’s setting up the new story with the new character, but omg once you get to The Ballad of Never After it’s so fast paced and crazy stuff will happen!! Can’t wait to see your review!!

Loved this video and such a good concept! I might have to implement for my December tbr

missed you omg!!! also love ur jumper

The assassins blade is soooo good!!! The five short stories are in chronological order and it honestly reads more like a full book instead of five stories

I loved Caraval, didn't love the second two books. But I loved Once Upon a Broken Heart and The Ballad of Never After even more! I've also wrapped up a few books on my TBR, I'm opened one a week until Christmas and they are all holiday themed, mostly romance! :)