"It would fit on light island" Yooreek's shadow element: am I a joke to you?

When I first heard Pentumbra sing his second verse, I could barely even hear him over Yooreek. I was completely unaware that he was mimicking other Ethereal monsters.

At the start I didn't really like Piplash, but I gotta say, he's been growing on me. X'rt isn't that bad.....but not that good. That's the one thing I hate on ethereal workshop

My opinion .1 all .12 none

Tbh X’rt is bad when it’s alone, but with Pentumbra and Yooreek, He is godly.

Sorry but piplash LITERALLY is one of my favorite EW monsters, and how is piplash offbeat? Once you get used to Piplash, Piplash isn't offbeat anymore.

You'll probably mass report this comment but. Piplash is not off-beat, it's something known as Syncopation but you wouldn't know. Syncopation is filling out empty spaces between beats, which is what Piplash is doing. You are always viewing this Island as 4 Crotchet beats in a bar and Piplash plays between two crotchet beats in Auglur's verse. In reality, the island is 8 quaver beats in a bar with in term, Piplash isn't "off-beat" whether if it's not syncopation or not. Thank you.

I completely agree with you, X'rt is the worst monster, Pentumbra is the better Mimic, and Gadzooks is Workshop's Ziggurab. my ziggy boi :)

My Ranking 12. Nitebear 11. Blarret 10. Meebkin 9. Gadzooks 8. X'rt 7. Flasque 6. Piplash 5. Auglur 4. Yooreek 3. Whail 2. Vhenshun 1. Pentumbra

Imo 1-yooreek 2-gaddzooks 3-flasque 4-vhenshen impact 5-pentumbra 6-auglur 7-blarret 8-whaill 9-meebkin 10-piplash 11-nitebear 12-x'rt

someone literally made a whole discussion about 0:19 on the msm wiki explaining how this is stupid

Ty for putting my fav on top :) Also the crown at the end is alone

i mostly agree with your opinion on X'rt, to be honest i feel like i owe an apology to nitebear for labelling him the worst monster in MSM in my opinion.

Gaddzooks is the best monster! Also give my boy X'rt some respect he's trying his best (I wish he played more 😔)

Don't know why but I like X'rt because of its contribution to the song, it sounds more like a distorted saxophone than real burping

Piplash isn't off beat it just plays at unexpected 16th notes

Your opinions don’t change often but when they change they change drastically. Never thought I’d see the day Auglur is underrated 😂

Did anyone else got earth island vibes from X’rt’s sound?

seriously dude,wtf did they had in mind while making x'rt? design is kinda cool i guess but why that sound

How Is Piplash Off Beat?

PROO I HAVE AN VID IDEA!!! if you can, can you rank all magical monsters, on their respective home island(not including nexus or sanctum)

I think in Wave 5, Whaill's unused track will probably come because that might be the last wave of Ethereal Workshop

Lotta change from last time wow

You should do a rank on ghostopias if rare wublins had a sou d

Ay man don’t diss my man piplash like that😭

X'rt is such a miss, definitely gonna mute him when I get him. Nova's prediction for this triple element was so much better. Pentumbra is great, just needs to have his volume increased so you can actually hear him.

My Ranking: 🟥12. X’rt (It doesn’t sound good and doesn’t add much) 🟩11. Piplash (I’m kinda used to Piplash by now, it adds to Auglurs verse. How is Piplash even offbeat?) 🟩10. Nitebear (It’s good how this guy made the ending more sad) 🟩9. Whaill (Whaill is not bad by any means, it just kinda gets boring when the 2nd track is still not used) From here it’s gonna be so hard to rank for me 🟦8. Meebkin (It’s a good support monster) 🟦7. Blarret (Track 1 doesn’t just support, because no one sang in that part) 🟦6. Flasque (Sorry, you add a bunch but you are not the best one on here) 🟦5. Auglur (I don’t think Auglurs overrated anymore. I’d say well rated now. The sound and design is good) 🟨4. Gaddzooks (This guy carried the drums until Vhenshun came) 🟨3. Yooreek (This guy literally carried the vocals. The tongue is a unique feature which also added to that one part it only plays) 🟨2. Pentumbra (It’s a great shadow quad, I didn’t expect something like this. The first track compliments Vhenshun really well, the second track doesn’t overshadow Yooreek, and I like how the 3rd track didn’t mimic a workshop monster, but Jeeode from Ethereal Island) 🟨1. Vhenshun (You have no idea how glad I was to see that he’s added to not make Gaddzooks the only drum anymore. This was the best monster when I ranked it on wave 3, still the best for me. Its design and sound is just so good and creative. Might be overrated (idk) but I like it)

NEVER LETTING HIM RATING AGAIN 🗣️🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥

I like X'rt cus it adds like a nice little effect, it also looks like shrek

Everyone in 1st place guys!!!!!

My ranking: 👑1. Gaddzooks, bros back is breaking for carrying the song (10/10) 🟨2. Yooreek, this guy adds so much to the song and the green guy adds a good amount also (9.8/10) 🟨3. Pentumbra, he adds a lot and he sounds great (9.6/10) 🟨4. Venshun, we got a workshop on ethereal workshop lol (9.4/10) 🟨5. Auglur, overrated but you cant tell me that it sounds bad (9/10) 🟦6. Flasque, his design and sound fit the theme of the island (8.7/10) 🟦7. Meebkin, underrated, adds a lot and has a cute design (8.4/10) 🟦8. Whaill, their first track adds a good amount to their verse and they have an unreleased track (8/10) 🟩9. Blarret, A good background singer nothing else (7.3/10) 🟩10. Nitebear, same with him (7/10) 🟩11. Piplash, at first I did not like it but after listening it 100 times I got used to it. (7/10) 🟥12. Xr't, I think we all agree this is bad (2/10)

Did you already rank Candy Island

Piplash is not offbeat 💀

Your opinions are so controversial I LOVE IT

Well hey, atleast BBB got creative with X'rt and Pentumbra.

Yooreeks is probably my second favourite lol

BBB saw the Meebkin burb memes and though they sounded good, so they made X’ert (imo it’s a cools onus that needed to be louder and have more tracks)

I WAS GONNA DO THIS HWHAHAHA

bro i love flasque too its all abt the design

I think X'rt is kinda funny, maybe it's it sound, idk but frankly i wouldn't want to be 10ft by this thing. Pentumbra is a bit underwelming, probably because the last ethereal workshop update added literality my all time favorite monster in the game Vhenshun, who's #2 on this list let's go. But I mean, Pentumbra doesn't screan quad to me, if it weren't for it's sound, then I would dislike it a bit more. Overall, this update is definitely weaker that wave 3 but i still like it.

X'rt is honestly the closest thing to a throat bass we have. And I feel like I can do a far better X'rt lol

I agrée with your placement for piplash, but it isn’t offbeat.

I Agree at 12. All this Monster Does is Burp and Fart not Singing or doing anything Nothing.

While Z'rt isn't "bad", there are still 11 better monsters. Also, Piplash is really cool, though MSM didn't let them cook.

Everyone is treating x'rt as the new shLep

1:52 *Every other flasque left the chat*

Yeah Flasque is insane

I don't think X'rt is THAT bad, I think it is just a bit off beat. But opinions are opinions and I'm sure there will be kids in the replies saying "NO!!! X'RT IS BAD!!! YOU'RE WRONG", but I hope I'm wrong. I like how Pentumbra get scared by it's shadow in the start of the first track.

Youreek is not meant for lullabies if anything its legit wublin island

I like piplash

Piplash is fun for me! (sorry 😞!!!)

I have a great idea Mystcal mmeadows by msm quibble fan

Mid tier: 12. X'RT ( ITS MID ALONE BUT GOOD IN THE SONG ) 11. Piplash ( I Like it cool sound ) Good tier: 10. Nitebear ( makes the end better ) 9. Blarret (same thing but with another track) 8. Whail ( good vocalist ) 7. Meebkin ( Almost in the great tier but just tiny bit short from getting there) Great tier: 6: Flasque ( Good percussion ) 5.Yooreek, ( its amazing but I like other monsters better) 4. Gaddzooks ( carries percussion but tiny bit short from goat tier) GOAT TIER 3. Vhenshun ( do I have to explain? ) 2. Pentumbra ( Best vocalist ) 1. AUGLUR ( IDK WHY PEOPLE RANK AUGLUR LOW JUST BC SHE OVERRATED. DESIGN IS ethereal. SOUND IS ONE OF THE MAIN PARTS and sounds good

Whaill is my fav :also plz reply futer gamer pro

I hate that thing people have to call bad things underrated and good things overrated, theres no middle point anymore 💀

My opinion: 12 - x'rt 11 - nitebear 10 - piplash 9 - flasque 8 - meebkin 7 - vhenshun 6 - blarret 5 - yooreek 4 - whaill 3 - penturmbra 2 - auglur 1 - gaddzooks

Za king of za meebz

12:Xrt🟥 11:Piplash🟥 10:Nitebear🟩 9:Flasque🟩 8:Blarret🟩 7:Yoreek🟦 6:Meebkin🟦 5:Whaill🟦 4:Venshun🟨 3:Gaddzooks🟨 2:Auglur🟨 1:Pebtumbra🟨

My opinion: 1. vhenshun (he is still my fav) 2. Petumbra (he is cute when he jumps and i like his sound) 3.flasque (he sound good) 4. Meebkin (i ranked him 6 on wave 3 but now i like him with those bug eyes!!!) 5. Gadzooks (funny ahh moment lol) 6. Auglur (her sound is good) 7.yooreek( WAA WAA WAAAA WAA WAA WAAAA WAA WAA WAWAAWAAAA) 8.piplash ( door stopper loking ahh) 9.X'rt (burping ahh monster) 10. blarret (tired of his sound now but stills carries the song) 11. Whail (i dont wanna see the rare i hope its pretty but it's sound still good) 12. Nitebear(i dont want some baby ahh kids comment i love nitebear bro that freddy fazbear meme has turned into brain rot)

X'ts was very underwhelming lol

Everyone have favorite monsters if you like blarret that your favorite blarret not like mean to futureprogame90

Piplash carries Auglur's part.

I basically agree! Gaddzooks *is* the best monster ❤

Pentumbra Litterly like similar Vhenshun, Yooreek, And Jeeode Any Tracks And X'rt is burping and croak sound so awful but design is okay

If you want to know why they call meebkin the king of meebs add a G to the end of the name

At first I didn’t here priplash

HEYYYY

0:14 lol

1:augler 2:meebkin 3:piplash 4: pentumbra 5:yooreek 6;blarret 7:X'rt 8:whaill 9:vhenshun 10:gadzooks 11:flasque 12:nightbear These are my ratings 123 are gold 45678910 are silver 1112 are bronze

0:22 if someone says the "Piplash is my favorite monster" i will reply to them say cry me a river wont ya?

Pentumbra is number one

I was second to rate wave 4

I agree x'rt is worse than blabbit and smochile combined in dof

My ranking 1: vhenshun 2: pentumbra 3: meebkin 4: gadzooks 5: blarrit 6: gadzooks 7: flasque 8: auglur 9: piplash 10: yooreek 11: x’rt 12: nitebear (sorry Fnaf fans)

Piplash is a good montah

Mimic does not ruin cave island

Sorry Futureprogamer I can't join your tribe I'm in one

Do my musical cats They had the best music, even better than msm

Notification

0:25 That scream at the end lol

Children when this guy has an opinion 😡

In my opinion, this wave was kinda disappointing. I think ethereal workshop right now is fine but it definetly feels very unfinished and empty. I was hoping for the next few waves to add a lot more to ethereal workshop and wave 2 definetly promised that, but wave 3 and 4 didn't add that much to the song so ethereal workshop still sounds unfinished. Hopefully wave 5 will be a big step up.

Ggadzooks is god like gob

Yeah I do agree with x’rt. He’s literally just burps and like a bubbling mouth. Ugh! But I mean at least there trying there best… Quick edited. I’m planning to make a wave 5 prediction for ethereal workshop. I just need to know what elements are next

Well then gimme a dang bottle bc piplash is a chad and my fav

I am the best monster ☹️

#JusticeforXrt

W RANKING 🗣🗣🗣🗣🔥🔥🔥🔥💯💯💯💯🥶🥶🥶💯

Angler is bad👍

Xrt is ass

I Bet The Haters Are Going To Comment: "BrO x'Rt Is AmAzInG! 😡"

But piplash is my favourit... nah just kidding.Piplash is kinda trash anyways i feel like you mistreat meebkin and yooreek they carry the whole damn short song but i think you will put them a litter higher in wave 5

Unpopular opinion: gadzooks is the worst

My ranking: 12.X’rt: Why’d he get done so dirty 😢 11. Nitebear: not bad but the others are better 10. Blarret: same opinion as Nitebear 9. Whaill: it’s super hard to rank these 8. Yooreek: I don’t know AAAAA 7. Flasque: would be better if the others weren’t better 6. Meebkin: My personal favorite, but not the best by sound 5. Auglur: Very good and also basically carries the end 4. Pentumbra: Also very good but could’ve played in the end 3. Piplash: they’re growing on me 2. Vhenshun: I’ve done it dirty, it deserves number 2 1. Gaddzooks: yes

I like piplash

X’rt is the 2nd best monster on EW, everyone else is tied to 1st

X'rt is only my first least favorite cause of his sound.

I love xrt and I like his design but it’s just an opinion

I love crt though :(

55th liked