Frank is definitely underrated in the all time QB talks I’m a Georgia and Giants fan so I might be a little bias too

But he only has 1 SB appearance and win

@@johnhardy7764 takes more than a qb to win a superbowl. hell eli has 2 so by your logic hes better than dan marino, brett favre, and equal to payton. superbowls are a team statistic not a singular players. there are only 15 5000 yard passing seasons in history. drew has had 5 out of those 15. next 2 closest guys are brady and mahomes with both having only 2

Brees shouldn’t even be on the list honestly…

@@AkhDawud thats biased as all hell man. you sound like a falcons fan truthfully. (before you get into your feels i said you "sound" like one. not that you are one

Very surprising. The OG goat of stats and the eye test!!!

I don’t understand why people put young so high. He is one of the biggest what ifs in nfl history. However he was only a starter for 8 years and was hurt one of those seasons… I don’t care who you are but you are not a top 10 quarterback if you only know played 7 seasons. Otto Graham played 10 seasons and made it to the championship every year and yet few people have him in their top 10… young is probably around 12 or 13

1) Tommy Brady 2) Joe Montana 3) Peyton Manning 4) Drew Brees 5) Dan Marino 6) John Elway 7) Aaron Rodgers 8) Brett Favre 9) Troy Aikman 10) Steve Young

brady won with bad teams, good players get it done. stop making excuses for a bad qb

@@Huntswick Brady had a bad team?

@@Huntswick Brady always had a great team around him, in particular he’s been blessed with outstanding defenses throughout his entire career. Nobody on this list ever won shit without a great team. You’re also acting like I’m making excuses for why Elway never won a ring, when he literally won twice and got a Super Bowl mvp with a dominant performance in the last game of his career. Two rings is more than Rodgers, Brees, Young, Marino, AND Farve, and it’s tied with Mahomes (for now) and Manning. Manning was also dragged to a ring in his last year.

@@Huntswick So you're just lying

I don’t think mahomes will over take him in super bowls but I’d take mahomes any day if I was making a super team

I don’t care what people say, I have done research and this is the list I have come up with. Mahomes can be put anywhere on this list I admit that 4 is probably too high but he will get there trust me

Overall facts. Although I have brees at 6.

I have Bree’s at 8

I guess getting 4 SB rings in an era that was anything but QB-friendly doesn't make you a top 10 QB. I have a massive problem with Brady being called the GOAT. Is he the best in the current era? Absolutely, but he wouldn't make it a season if he played in the 70s or 80s. In those eras, Bountygate was basically the defensive playbook. The defense's job was to take out the quarterback, and if he walked away at the end of the game, you weren't playing hard enough. The idea of roughing the passer being called on the defense because they looked cross-eyed at the QB would have been crazy in the '70s and '80s. Comparing QBs since the changes in the RTP rules with those before the change is like comparing apples and oranges.

No

nope

Aikman is the most overrated player ever

@@BigPackersGuy whatevs

Super bowl or bust, huh?

Aikman was good and often downplayed by his haters, but he also wasn't even close to one of the greatest QBs ever. He was on loaded Cowboys teams that was akin to today's 49ers, except even better. Steve Young put up all time great level stats in the regular season and at least had one unbelievable playoff run with one of the best Super Bowl performances ever. Aikman's career isn't close to him individually, even if he did win more rings.

I have no idea where this guy got the Steve Young won three super bowls as a starter stat. Big error

@@wolfwiles he did win three superbowls, but he was Montana’s backup for two

@@stephenwu1524 I meant to put “as a starter” in my comment. I’m aware that he was on the team when they won before. But no one is getting bonus points on a top QB list for winning rings as a backup lol

Who would you replace on my list with those two

@@nextmanupsports Tom Brady and Joe Montana

Dak and Kirk?! Not even top 100.

Bro is definitely a packers fan. Aaron Rodgers is great but he always came up short in the postseason. Losing to the 49ers in 2021 was the nail in the coffin for him ever being considered top 3 all time.

​@@ashtonmillis4951 Nope. I'm a giants fan. The facts just speak for themselves. At a certain point you're just arguing with what factually happened. I watched the supposed GOAT get trashed by my team twice when it 'mattered most' so I've got no reason to cope like some of you to feel better. Aaron didn't choke or 'always come up short' nor did brady step up. His team choked while brady's regularly bailed him out. Stop listening to people like skip bayless. They factually lie to convince you of bs. Rodgers vs Brady per game playoff stats. (I'll even go based off 2008-2022 just so there's no era argument) 21 games vs 31 games. 100.1 vs 90.6 passer rating. 64.7 vs 62.4 completion %. 5.8 vs 4.7 TD % 1.7 vs 2.1 INT % 0 vs 2 pick sixes 3.46 vs 2.21 TD:INT ratio 7.6 vs 7.1 passing Y/A 11.8 vs 11.4 Y/C 3.8 vs 2.6 TDs per game. 443 vs 323 yards per game. See who wins in basically every playoff stat there is? Rodgers. In other words just say you didn't watch the games and only listened to skip bayless. Considering he's number 2 in MVPs. At minimum top 2 in talent. And staistically still the greatest QB of all time before adjusting for era when you look at both the playoffs and the regular season. It feels pretty safe to say he's at minimum top 3. I'm not even a packers fan it's just obvious when you just watch the games much less check the stats. The dude is at minimum top 3 if not the GOAT. Saying he shouldn't be considered up that high because of 1 bad playoff game is just delusion. Brady had multiple just as bad if not worse while rodgers has had so many great ones. Nail in the coffin? More like cherrypicking.

@@lightning10053 well those are some nice stats, now let’s look at the most important one, winning. The excuses for Rodgers ended in 2021 like I already said. At the end of the day 1 ring isn’t enough to be the goat it’s really that simple

@@lightning10053 I’m not sure I would call it trashed when they were both one score games if I remember correctly. And also I’m not sure why that somehow means Brady can’t be the goat.

@@ashtonmillis4951 It's a team sport buddy. Claiming winning is the most important way to judge an individual is stupid. Terry bradshaw has 4 rings. Does that mean he belongs in the GOAT convo over Peyton? Eli has 2 rings. Does that mean he belongs in the GOAT convo over dan marino and brett favre? Otto Graham won 7 championships in 10 years. Where's his GOAT status at? Context matters. It's why bill russel ain't better than jordan, rocky marciano ain't better than muhammad ali, and robert horry ain't better than lebron. Context matters, whether it be a different era or a better team. So with all due respect you can take your winning argument and toss it cause it amounts of all of 2 cents in this discussion an that's me being generous. The fact your argument has to focus on a team accomplishment rather than how brady actually played speaks volumes. On any given year the best quarterback in the league will win league MVP. Yet before Mahomes last year no MVP had won it since 1999, and out of the 38 times a QB has won mvp, only 6 of those ended in a SB victory. Think back on the greatest QB seasons in NFL history. 1984 marino, 2007 brady, 2011 rodgers, 2013 Peyton, 2018 mahomes. What do they all have in common? No rings. At a certain point it just become obvious, the best QB rarely wins wht sb, so why does winning it the most make brady the best of all time? It doesn't. Brady ain't the GOAT. Like I said. Brady's had a ton of games just like rodgers did in 2021. So that stance doesn't even help you. We're talking about thee ultimate team sport here. Using team accomplishments to judge 1 player is just outright absurd. We're here to talk about how they played. Not how many championships their team won. It's just that simple.

bradshaw was awful, this has to be satire.

You think bradshaw is top 10? Pfffft.

4 superbowls@@lightning10053