It's strange. No matter how many times I watch any of Yahtzee's reviews, I can always watch all of them over and over.

I love the glitch wherein the horses and stagecoaches start bobbing up and down like somebody just pimped the Wild West with hydraulics.

I'm kinda hoping he just uses this same review for RDR2

Everyone has now forgotten that Red Dead Revolver ever existed

Red Dead Redemption Green Alive Atonement Yellow Undead Salvation Blue Sick Compenastion Purple Healthy Reparation

I love how on bigger, more popular titles like this more people seem to throw their shit at Yahtzee. Just because he pokes and nitpicks at games, doesn't mean he dislikes them. If you can't laugh at some of your favorite things, then you're too self-conscious or just blind about it. I think he's hilarious and a lot of times- spot on. He thrashes some of my favorite games, but I'm still giggling and waiting for the next one.

I love how Yahtzee describes handling, here's the merry-go-round example and in GTA V "the planes handle like the wings are stuck in a sumo wrestler's ass and when you level up your flight skill it's like the sumo wrestlers have put on slightly aerodynamic hats."

"Blue Poo Atonement" "Green Spleen Submarine" "Purple Monkey Dishwasher" i died when he said these

These videos are not only hilarious, they're informative. This convinced me to buy the game, which I enjoy playing to this day. Yahtzee almost always mentions not just whether a game is good or bad, but more importantly if you might like it based on what you're looking for. They are reviews, after all, and damn good ones too. Besides, RDR is patched pretty well at this point, so glitches don't really happen anymore

The ending of this game was phenomenally well written and executed. Still one of my favorite stories.

1:23 Give it time...

I actually enjoyed RDR's horse riding. Later I'd just mount a random horse (since, obviously, I lost the one I caught myself), find a field with a lot of horses, look for a black one and catch it.

Okay guys. This guy, fucking hilarious. I've watched several of them. He enjoys the games he plays, he just points out the flaws.

The horse riding in this game is still the best I've experienced. Even The Witcher 3 could learn from RDR. You can sprint, whistle for your horse, and hop on it all without the need to stop and look around for it.

"He's not dead"....until zombie marston.

Can't wait for the blue poo atonement 2 review!

"He's not dead." Not yet.

At my work we got a shipment of beer called "Purple Monkey Dishwasher" and I immediately took my break to come watch this video. I true Yahtzee fan knows when they're summoned.

Ever since I played rdr, I find myself sticking my thumbs in my pockets when standing or walking.

They fucked up multiplayer by not allowing you to lasso other players and troll the fuck out of them as you drag them for miles across the desert :(

I think horses from RDR and Roach from TW3 might be related.

Well then ignore the travel time and use the magical fast travelling camp fire in the menu

so many negative comments. he liked the game. this just his shlock to pretend to hate all games. it's a gimmick.

best free roam red dead redemption moment. I was watching my friend play and we were killing off people at a train station when he saw a guy running away. He entired deadeye mode while holding the evan's rifle which has twenty two shots and locked all of the shots on him. Neither of us noticed the transport cart with 4 horses starting to run by so when he did shoot only 1 bullet hit the guy he was aiming for before the horses ran into the way and he killed 3 of the four of them.

To all the people complaining that Yahztee only focuses on the negative points of a game; you may have mistaken the term "criticism" with the term "advertisement". One is trying to sell you a game whilst the other one is trying to protect you and your money.

I frickin' love this game. Out of all the games I own and out of all the years I've been gaming, this story was the only one to ever get any emotion out of me besides bloodlust. Hell, I'm still learning new things about this game. Just a few days back, I robbed a bank. Had no idea that was even possible.

Now that I watched most of Yahtzees Episodes I notice that he uses german words or exclamations quite often. I wonder if he have a secret love for our growly and harsh language. o_O

RDR was my fave game of 2010.I loved it so much I played it for like 6 months straight and then a few years later I re-played the game twice lol will always be one of my fave games

“He’s not dead” they took that as a challenge

the red dead part is from the red dead franchise which started with red dead revolver

Green Spleen Submarine FTW!

Yours are the only reviews I can watch for fun.

This is the first Zero Punctuation episode I ever saw. Nostalgia is a wonderful thing isn't it?

Of all the reviews this is by far the most hilarious

1:41 John's fricken face is amazing with those eyes! xD

I never had those problems with bugs and the controls didn't feel wonky at all to mee. I do think it's BS that it's not for the PC.

I figured that everyone waiting for RDR2 would be here, remembering RDR.

I wonder why this exact Zero Punctuation review surfaced in my Recomended vids...... hmmm...

Wanna know what I love? If you fall on a hitched horse from above, you immediately mount it! And no, medicine is NOT pointless, especially in hardcore mode (only in the game of the year edition). Medicine instantly restores your health. Your health will Regen over time, but it does take a while, and if you keep getting shot, it won't Regen. And medicine is pretty much necessary in hardcore mode, as health takes twice as long to Regen, and John has half the normal amount of health. Dead eye will make you invincible, but that's on a meter, which will Regen over time (and can be infinite for 10 seconds when you use moonshine) and with kills that aren't in dead eye mode, but in hardcore mode, you don't get the constant Regen. You have to kill (or use items) to refill it.

I never did quite figure out how the show downs or whatever they were called worked (the thing where you and your opponent try to shoot each other in slow mow like in every western movie ever). It seemed like what worked the first time had a 50-50 chance of working the second.

I have yet to try Purple Monkey Dishwasher in full. The beginning horse cart racing mission put me off so much I gave up with the game (after repeatedly falling down the side of the mountain with said horse and cart as if I had them firmly lodged up my anus!).

I wish I had watched this before buying Red Dead 2 without playing the first. Cause this is exactly my feels to the new one. Minus the flowers?

Anyone read one of his books? Are they as addictive as his reviews? I don’t even play computer games anymore, I still watch this guy constantly.

Love these videos so much.

this is one of the few games that i'm having trouble deciphering yahtzee's review for. he kind of implies that he kind of liked it at the end, but lists so many enormous failures before that. its hard to tell if he likes this one or not

7 year....7 YEARS!! Where is my lives!???

Whoo! Finally a video I haven't seen!

that... picture... is amazing...

Though it might not matter much now, there are settings on the game that allow you to take the "training wheels" off, and I'm not sure what system you played on but the PS3 version (or at least my copy of the game) has little to no bugs. In fact, if memory serves, I didn't have any bugs at all

Again this guy makes me laugh.

LOL at the calling Red Dead Redemption by other names! And LOLed at the funny parts too, especially with the imps! XD

Even back then he said there was too much pointless side guff. The depths we plum.

Odd, I bought RDR back in 2010 or 2011 (can't remember) for Xbox360 and not once did I get a glitch. Was he using PS3 or something?

Yahtzee's reviews are always different from other reviews. Even though other reviewers can be more or less cynical, Yahtzee barely spends any time sugarcoating or praising a game. even with games he likes it doesn't last for even a minute. I love it.

One small point concerning the auto aiming like your fussy mum was holding the barrel: you can turn that off in settings by changing it to expert. Apart from that an entertaining and largely accurate review. Especially the cougar revenge.

I always figured the Red Dead part refers to the way you die. The more damage you take, the redder the screen gets, and when it gets fully blood red you're, ya know, dead.

The drinking wasn't super realistic but with a Lil creativity easily becomes my favorite minigame. If you add in drinks of your own then getting john drunk and seeing how long you can hilariously steer him around without face planting becomes down right the best drinking game in video game history. Right up there with drinking every time you choose a dialogue option in a bioware game and it is the complete opposite result of what you thought it would be.

XD Went through the whole game and the only glitch I ever got was the gliding along the ground one, it felt virtually bug free when I played it... I feel lucky!

To my knowledge, the Red Dead part comes from a previous Rockstar title, Red Dead Revolver. The main character of that game was named Red, and his family was dead.

Did he just studder? 2:28 "but whe-but when you also have to tap..."

Red Dead Redemption was, by far, the best game on the Xbox 360 and Playstation 3.

I couldn't agree with this review more. I didn't dislike the game, but much of it seemed pointless. As Yahtzee said, beautiful game to look at, great story, but not much to do. It is also, hands down, the most depressing game I ever played. EVERY single side mission ends badly. Trying to help people just felt so futile.

This video is how many years old now, and somehow I never noticed that editing stutter at 2:29 before. Was that always there??

Overall, I love your videos. There is only one thing I don't like that comes to mind. Its the fact that you're so good at picking out the flaws in a game. Normally this isn't a problem. That is, until, you point out things I never knew existed and make me rethink certain games.

Still one of my favorite games of all time!

Who’s here waiting on the RedDead 2 ZeroPunk?

That bit with a zombie marsdon was a bit of accidental prediction 😂

3:04 Something about that animation cracks me up. XD

Blue Poo Atonement :D

someone has probably already said this but its called RED DEAD redemption because there was a game on the ps2 about the main charactor when he was younger called red dead revolver so its the sequel i think or at least i think it is

I love how yathzee prob likes this game more than i did but still goes harder on it than me.

I love how the chocobos in Final Fantasy 15 feel like the horses from RDR. They control very nicely and are very fun to explore on. Though in FFXV, you can only rent a Chocobo but not buy one permanently. At least at 65 hours in so I just gave up on hoping to keep one. Apparently the development team thought it would be a better idea to spend large amounts of money on snacks and cat food. >.>

Main story felt really stupid. Especially when in the end your character gets killed in an uncontrollable cutscene by roughly 20 soldiers while having tonns of explosives stuck up his every pocket. I could have killed them all in one shot, but the game forced me to die because reasons. The explanation for this is non existant aswell, this regular "i gotta die cuz zen dey wil leav my famls alone" bullshit, while there is no reason why would they unnecessarily try to hunt him anyway, no reason why he didn't consider actually getting away with his family, no reason why this would be impossible, no reason for anything at all. It felt random and illogical.

7 years later, a lot of this still applies to RDR2!

Four years after release it's still my favorite seventh gen game ever. Sorry but I'm an eternal cowboy, Yahtzee.

the gun auto aim can be turned off, and many of the hunting missions do serve a purpose, if you play enough you can hunt legendary animals, and some guns are only available to be bought after youve achieved a certain hunter rank (those guns also cant be aqquired in missions)

Maybe you can just repost this for the second

It's called 'Red Dead Redemption' because it is the second in a series. The first being 'Red Dead Revolver'.

When rockstar put him in the wild west before automobiles and asked "There are you Satisfied?" I expected him to say Yes!

The interesting thing is that I found that the horse controls a LOT like the one from Shadow of the Colossus, which was one of the few games yahtzee did like a lot

Best Game ever! (in my opinion)

Haha the butthurt in the comments still makes me laugh!

Fun fact: He actually was in an episode of Unskippable, which, ironically, introduced me to Unskippable.

And don't forget how slightly tapping someone sends them flying to the ground 😅

Call of Juarez was a more authentic western. This game was just GTA copy and pasted into the old west

Does he actually... like games?

It's he's 3rd favorite game of 2010 ! He doesn't dislike it , he's pointing out the mistakes he found , yet he thinks it was a good game .

I love this game. I picked it up randomly. I still play it actually lol Gorgeous atmosphere (even the bloody gory ones xD), some of the best horse animation I've ever seen. Apparently its very hard to make in game horses move correctly, never mind run and the like. At times between story missions I did find myself just standing there asking wtf I've been doing for the past 3 hours as I'm looking all over the country side for that last damn rabbit...Anyway, awesome story, I was definitely caught up in it all. Although the slight bug problems, I thought they were funny as I was bugged into the head of my horse..like a cowboy centaur. Though I didn't experience many of these bugs he mentions on the PS3 version besides centaur man when I was online. At the end of it all, I still have the want t play, and wish the story could continue. I'd definitely like to see what happens to Jack.

You can turn auto aim of so you can pretend to be a bad ass when your friends are around.

Yahtzee's reviews are most interesting after you've played the game because otherwise you won't really get what he's talking about

Red Dead Redemption was actually very storybook in how plots unraveled into the conclusion of John Marston's death, and to the extension towards his son's revenge. The whole point of the long horse rides was to show off the environment as well as the random events generation during exploration. If you hated it that much, just finish half of the Treasure Hunter challenges and use the free-travelling perk to teleport across the whole world.

3:35 For the longest time, I thought I was the only one on the internet that liked the sailing in Wind Waker.

The want to watch bestiality grew the more I stared at the back of that horse ;)

you do realize that you could turn off auto aim in the pause menu right? and they made updates to fix most of the bugs. and do you ever use the options menu?I ask because you always complain about things that can be easily fixed in there. Not to say that is all you complain about just some of it.

I only experienced one bug in my playthrough. Where Johns horse got sick of being a horse and decided to fly around for a bit.

I like how at the end he says he loves the taste of horse. He knew what tesco didn't............

I'm starting to think he just pics on tiny things just for the sake of being able to make a video on it now. I mean, he picked out many things that were not even flaws, with the flaws he did pick out being very minor. This is a masterpiece of a game just like TLoU, yet a video like his Titanfall portrays that to be a better game - going by the way he acts in his videos.

a game reviewer that hates every game? genius

i like how he unknlsojgly foreshadowed the zombie dlc

One of his favorites of 2010.