No video

Reducing Chuck Runout & Overhang

  Рет қаралды 9,974

Winky's Workshop

Winky's Workshop

2 ай бұрын

/ @thepottingshedworkshop
"The Potting Shed Workshop" suggested that I reduced the overhang by modifying the backing plate and scroll cover. It was a great idea, Thanks!
Also many viewers suggested grinding the chuck jaws. I took a slightly different approach but it worked well.
/ @thepottingshedworkshop

Пікірлер: 147
@christiantrab6160
@christiantrab6160 2 ай бұрын
Thanks for the video. I am not an experienced machinist, I am a mechanic with a lathe, but I have used this Chinese type equipment for 25 years, and I have a couple of these cheap 4 jaw chucks in different sizes. In my experience these Chinese 4 jaw chucks have a "master key hole" and a key hole that is really not usable. So when you get it, first thing is to test runout using each key holes, find the best one, mark it up, and always use that one. I have no logical explanation for it, but it makes a major difference in repeatability and precision, I have a runout of less than 0.01mm on these. And sorry for my English, your videos have reached as far as Denmark :-)
@WinkysWorkshop
@WinkysWorkshop 2 ай бұрын
Interesting, I'll check out the the difference of the keys. You English is fine, thanks for the comment.
@AmateurRedneckWorkshop
@AmateurRedneckWorkshop 2 ай бұрын
I think you have just about wrung that chuck out. Thanks for the video keep on keeping on.
@WinkysWorkshop
@WinkysWorkshop 2 ай бұрын
Yes i did! Ha
@johnspathonis1078
@johnspathonis1078 2 ай бұрын
Great video. You could have gone deeper in the backing plate by drilling three new mounting holes. Replace the standard socket head cap screws with low head height socket cap screws. These are a standard fastener from Unbrako. There is another way of restraining your chuck jaws prior to remachining a three jaw chuck. Drill a hole in the front flat face of the jaws. As the jaws are reasonably tough and hard you will have to use a carbide drill. Since your chuck is small a 6mm hole (or 1/4") should be sufficient. Fit a Grade 8.8 pin into each of the three holes. Make a restraining ring from flat 6mm plate. Drill three 10mm holes in the plate at the radius to suit the grind ID. The chuck can be preloaded before maching. The ring is self centering. I saw on a video from either TL or RR that for best accuracy always use the same tightening point. The chuck's centering accuracy changes if a different hole is use. Same hole for grinding and normal use. Hope this helps. Cheers.
@WinkysWorkshop
@WinkysWorkshop 2 ай бұрын
I was going to do something similar to what you describe when I cut the ring but the aluminum was easy and probably just as effective. I also considered drilling new holes on the back plate and using low profile of even county sink screw. The later is not the best option however as small position errors try to control the back plate position. Thanks
@johnspathonis1078
@johnspathonis1078 2 ай бұрын
@@WinkysWorkshop Thanks for taking the time to reply. The major benefit of the drilled holes is that it can be used for any diameter regrind. If you need to regrind at a much larger diameter there is no issue. Also If the hole is tapped. I have seen people use this tapped hole to hold copper soft jaws. Cheers.
@angelramos-2005
@angelramos-2005 2 ай бұрын
Great video,Mark.Lots of surgery.It got better but I will not expect lots of precision from a 4 jaw chuck.Thank you.
@WinkysWorkshop
@WinkysWorkshop 2 ай бұрын
I agree and thanks!
@mikepoore1653
@mikepoore1653 2 ай бұрын
The thing about scroll chucks, 3 or 4 jaws, is that the thread of the scroll is what really determines its ability to center work. You can grind/bore the jaws and make it better, if there is an issue with the jaws. However, there will always be runout and it will vary by work diameter. There might be diameters that have zero runout and diameters with .015" runout because the scroll thread is not precise. Given your intended use, I am sure it will work fine.
@WinkysWorkshop
@WinkysWorkshop 2 ай бұрын
Yep, you are right. Hopefully the error stays bellow .015"
@ThePottingShedWorkshop
@ThePottingShedWorkshop 2 ай бұрын
Thanks for the shout out. I guess that's what we get for buying budget tools, they always need a bit of finish machining. Can't be sure of this, but I think clamping round stock in a 4 jaw relies on the stock being perfectly round, if not one jaw will not be loaded as much and the runout will get worse. A 3 jaw has to load all three jaws the same by comparison. That should be a nice useable chuck now. Good job!
@WinkysWorkshop
@WinkysWorkshop 2 ай бұрын
Good to hear from you and you're welcome. I agree about the self centering 4 jaws. In general the 3 jaw is a better choice.
@magicbytes3835
@magicbytes3835 2 ай бұрын
Hello Winky, thanks for another interesting video and for sharing your skills with us, much appreciated, cheers from me. 😃👍👍👍👍👍
@WinkysWorkshop
@WinkysWorkshop 2 ай бұрын
My pleasure 😊 Thanks for watching.
@johnrussell6620
@johnrussell6620 Ай бұрын
At 4:10, You could install 3 more screws/bolts with thinner heads in between the current-original bolts if you really want to push that back plate deeper into the chuck, basically stop using the original holes, or, put some short studs in the original holes as alignment pins. If you truly get deeper, you could make your chuck a "Set-True" style of mounting/alignment possible. It appears that by the end of the video, you had come to my same conclusions. Thanks for making this video.
@WinkysWorkshop
@WinkysWorkshop Ай бұрын
Yeah... I ended up putting the dust cover back in so its good that I didn't re-drill and go deeper with the back plate.
@RustyInventions-wz6ir
@RustyInventions-wz6ir 2 ай бұрын
Very interesting. Nice work. Never thought of removing the dust guard.
@WinkysWorkshop
@WinkysWorkshop 2 ай бұрын
Yeah, I thought that was a great idea (although not mine (viewer suggested). Thanks
@jubiletabustamanteserrano2446
@jubiletabustamanteserrano2446 Ай бұрын
WHAT A GOOD JOB OF ELIMINATING CLEARANCES IN THE GRINDERS EVEN THOUGH THE HEAD ALSO HAS A LOT OF FAULT. THESE CHINESE FORGET THE PRECISION
@WinkysWorkshop
@WinkysWorkshop Ай бұрын
Yeah this chuck was not very good. I'll be using it mostly on my wood lathe where its not so critical. Thanks
@kentuckytrapper780
@kentuckytrapper780 2 ай бұрын
Great video winky, keep'um coming..
@WinkysWorkshop
@WinkysWorkshop 2 ай бұрын
Thank you! Will do!
@robertwalker7457
@robertwalker7457 2 ай бұрын
Very interesting thanks.
@WinkysWorkshop
@WinkysWorkshop 2 ай бұрын
Very welcome
@CreaseysWorkshop
@CreaseysWorkshop 2 ай бұрын
I did exactly this when I mounted my 4 jaw chuck. I have a video of the whole process on my channel. I have used the chuck quite a bit over the years. It comes in handy for square stuff. You could get around your bolt hole problem by just drilling 3 new holes in the backplate.
@WinkysWorkshop
@WinkysWorkshop 2 ай бұрын
I considered the new holes and might end up doing this. Bob Kelly commented that the dust cover needs to be there. He said the tabs on the cover hold the scroll in place. I need to look at this closer.
@CreaseysWorkshop
@CreaseysWorkshop 2 ай бұрын
@@WinkysWorkshop I made a spacer ring to do that.
@WinkysWorkshop
@WinkysWorkshop 2 ай бұрын
@@CreaseysWorkshop A spacer? To hold the scroll or to seal the area?
@CreaseysWorkshop
@CreaseysWorkshop 2 ай бұрын
@@WinkysWorkshop To hold the scroll. The back plate seals it.
@jrehtil1494
@jrehtil1494 2 ай бұрын
Good job Winky
@WinkysWorkshop
@WinkysWorkshop 2 ай бұрын
Thanks
@bheckel1
@bheckel1 2 ай бұрын
I mount my router on my lathe tool post and grind my 3 jaws with a vitrified stone. usually get to a couple tenths. I have used the same stone for many chucks for many years. The mount took a couple days to make. It has proven useful for grinding internal bores too.
@WinkysWorkshop
@WinkysWorkshop 2 ай бұрын
I think the lathe tool works nearly as well, at least in the hardness range if my chucks. Also, even if cutting is not a perfect method, there is no way this chuck is repeatable within .005"
@654rebel
@654rebel 2 ай бұрын
Nice work, I've only ever seen chucks ground with a tool post grinder. Interesting method I would of never thought of that due to the interrupted cut. I was waiting for the insert to break. Nice job
@WinkysWorkshop
@WinkysWorkshop 2 ай бұрын
Thanks! I've done this several times. I think the lathe tool works better than the grinder as long as you take small cuts.
@rjay1674
@rjay1674 2 ай бұрын
I, like you, have several Vevor products. I have learned to disassemble everything from them, degrease and clean them in my Vevor ultra sonic cleaner to remove all of the machining and casting grit, then debur and reassemble using a good quality grease. Some of the inaccuracy you are seeing maybe caused by a bunch of crud inside. Another great video. Thanks.
@WinkysWorkshop
@WinkysWorkshop 2 ай бұрын
Thanks, sounds like a good idea.
@desertdweller9548
@desertdweller9548 2 ай бұрын
You might have learned to stop buying garbage and not have to waste your time on brand new stuff. 🤔
@WinkysWorkshop
@WinkysWorkshop 2 ай бұрын
@@desertdweller9548 The garbage usually works out well, admittedly this time was worse but given the price tag for a good quality chuck (5x more) I think my time is not wasted.
@mervynprice7009
@mervynprice7009 2 ай бұрын
I have only purchased a couple of Vevor items & they do look to be very well-made. I did by a 3 jaw Vevor chuck only to find that one of its jaws was not a match with the other two. Got it because I had purchased another Chinese 3 jaw & left it in its box too long & the warrantee had run out, then when I went to use it the body was terrible & it was all over the place. So I had another set of jaws & with these fitted, the Vevor chuck is very good. You certainly can not machine that bad jaw & get it to fit.
@WinkysWorkshop
@WinkysWorkshop 2 ай бұрын
I've had good luck with Chinese 3-jaws but this 4 -jaw is not very good. Vevor seems to be hit and miss. I have a TIG that works great and also a drill sharpener but the mill table for my drill press took a lot of work to make it right. Vevor is kind of like Amazon, they just sell buy and sell.
@junkmannoparts9696
@junkmannoparts9696 2 ай бұрын
Looks good . JM
@WinkysWorkshop
@WinkysWorkshop 2 ай бұрын
Thanks
@TheAyrCaveShop
@TheAyrCaveShop 2 ай бұрын
Good one Mark, I just did some regrinding on an independent 4 jaw.. That's another deep rabbit hole Dust cover elimination is good idea. ATB.....
@WinkysWorkshop
@WinkysWorkshop 2 ай бұрын
I thought so too... although I had one comment that said the flanges on the dust cover push against the scroll and stabilize it. He might be right but after reinstalling I saw no improvement. I turned the thickness down and the back plate holds it in place now.
@ypaulbrown
@ypaulbrown 2 ай бұрын
wonderful Mr Winky, Paul in Orlando
@WinkysWorkshop
@WinkysWorkshop 2 ай бұрын
Thanks!
@daveticehurst4191
@daveticehurst4191 2 ай бұрын
Winky, generally with quality chucks, the key hole that was used to finally tighten the jaws when the factory ground them is market with a x or number. If you always use that hole to tighten the chuck will be at its truest, due to any scrol sideways movement. When you do /did yours adopt the same procedure. Sharpie mark the last hole that you tightened the jaws to grind. Then put a permanament mark and always tighten the chuck using that hole. Good luck. Regards from Australia.
@WinkysWorkshop
@WinkysWorkshop 2 ай бұрын
Several others have said the same. This is new to me but it makes sense. I'll have to test and see what pinion is the most accurate. I'm positive I made the chuck better but I doubt anything will make it a great chuck. Still I'll take any improvement. I'm mostly concerned with the primary internal jaws. Thanks!
@breb77
@breb77 2 ай бұрын
Most of the chucks I used at work had master jaws which were hardened and ground for precision work. The change out would be for soft or harden jaws depending on the job requirements. They were keyed at their bottom. Even those jaw would require grinding, to re true the jaw. I know what you're going through, because I have a 13" South Bend lathe, which I bought a 4-jaw chuck for and I to, tooled out the jaws to achieve less runout. I often see .003 " TIR. and am satisfied with that on the lathe. Unlike the precision grinding equipment which I definitely was working in .0001 - .0002 " TIR. when setting up a job.
@WinkysWorkshop
@WinkysWorkshop 2 ай бұрын
Yep, I could not justify the expense of the precision stuff. My south bend 11 is worn quite a bit anyway. I have collets and a 4 jaw independent if needed.
@Pushyhog
@Pushyhog 2 ай бұрын
wow, great vid! thanks
@WinkysWorkshop
@WinkysWorkshop 2 ай бұрын
Thanks!
@brucemansfield2501
@brucemansfield2501 2 ай бұрын
You could put new bolt holes in the back plate and use flat head Allen head screws and locktite brass plugs in the old holes. That would look good.
@WinkysWorkshop
@WinkysWorkshop 2 ай бұрын
I considered that (the new holes part). I would have gained 3/16" less in overhang.
@randyshoquist7726
@randyshoquist7726 2 ай бұрын
I've seen Mark Presling use a vernier caliper designed specifically for scribing. They're inexpensive and readily available from Amazon or AliExpress. I'd like to get one, but the inch vernier scale is in 128ths, which to me is just silly. I'm mulling over ideas for modifying an inexpensive digital caliper to have a similar configuration.
@WinkysWorkshop
@WinkysWorkshop 2 ай бұрын
Interesting... yeah, 128ths are hard to deal with. I had bluing on the back plate so it was fairly gentile. I didn't know about the calipers made for scribing.
@johnbraun6552
@johnbraun6552 2 ай бұрын
Just a thought. Before you make another chuck backing plate, first make a copy of the spindle. that way you can check the fit without taking the chuck off and trying to start the threads of the new backing plate onto the spindle. I just made one out of plastic. works well.
@WinkysWorkshop
@WinkysWorkshop 2 ай бұрын
Probably a worthwhile effort but getting the threads exactly the same would be critical. Doable I suppose.
@desertdweller9548
@desertdweller9548 Ай бұрын
I would never put this much time and energy into a new product. Send the junk back. Life is too short.
@WinkysWorkshop
@WinkysWorkshop Ай бұрын
Haha... you might have a point there. It was am interesting challenge however and I am retired. If I was running a business there is no way I have this chuck. Actually I'd have to do a lot of upgrading. About the only machine in my shop that is really nice is my wells index mill and its on the small side. My south bend is worn out. The 1917 drill press is okay i guess.... Love the old machines!
@desertdweller9548
@desertdweller9548 Ай бұрын
@@WinkysWorkshop So true. Old machines have style and repairability and were not built to become obsolete every few years. I'm partial to older Craftsman shop equipment myself. Great stuff.
@WinkysWorkshop
@WinkysWorkshop Ай бұрын
@@desertdweller9548 I think Craftsman started going down hill in the late 70s but before that I think they were good. The 1932 Craftsman band saw I have is built like a tank. But yeah... a lot of the old stuff is very well made. There were a few that were not so good however. The Canedy-Otto drill press I restored was poor quality... lots of cracked cast iron. The last drill press I restored was incredibly good quality. It was made by Avey 1917. Oh and the Hardinge Cataracts is darn good quality but not very user friendly.... super precision for sure. It always amazes me how accurate they were without an computers involved.
@johnwolf5288
@johnwolf5288 2 ай бұрын
We all hope for tool room precision from bargain priced chucks. A bit of time can turn that bargain priced lump into a serviceable chuck. Nicely done.
@WinkysWorkshop
@WinkysWorkshop 2 ай бұрын
I've had good luck with the 3-jaws but this 4-jaw was fairly bad. My 3 jaw is maybe .004 to .006 off. Most often I can work around that amount but if not I have collets and an independent 4-jaw
@richb419
@richb419 2 ай бұрын
Hi, would it be a good idea to put registration marks on the chuck to backing plate? Rich
@WinkysWorkshop
@WinkysWorkshop 2 ай бұрын
Yes, absolutely. I numbered them. Thanks
@Wachuko-1
@Wachuko-1 2 ай бұрын
Interesting. Not an independent four jaw chuck. I don't think that I have any like that in my machines. All the four-jaws that I have are independent. Well, you made it better. That was good. 👍
@WinkysWorkshop
@WinkysWorkshop 2 ай бұрын
Thanks, it's handy for drilling square stock but the primary reason I got it is to use on my cnc wood lathe. Lots of spindles are square on the ends.
@chriscox6598
@chriscox6598 2 ай бұрын
Just an idea, could you have faced the existing dust cover down to fit the smaller gap and then glue it to the backing plate?
@WinkysWorkshop
@WinkysWorkshop 2 ай бұрын
A good idea! Stay tune for my next video. I just did what you suggested. 😜
@Rustinox
@Rustinox 2 ай бұрын
Using the little plates between the jaws was hod did my chuck too. It works perfectly fine.
@WinkysWorkshop
@WinkysWorkshop 2 ай бұрын
Great minds think alike :o)
@TERRYB0688
@TERRYB0688 2 ай бұрын
Mr Winky, not sure how a self centering 4 jaw Chuck is desirable, would have preferred a standard 4 jaw especially as it is a low cost item, also surprised that those jaws are not hardened
@WinkysWorkshop
@WinkysWorkshop 2 ай бұрын
The jaws are a step harder than mild steel but carbide does well. I already have a standard 4 jaw and I agree, it's a better choice if you have one 4-jaw chuck. I wanted it for drilling square stock on the metal lathe but the primary reason I wanted it was to use it on my CNC wood lathe. A lot of spindles have a square end and makes ir easy.
@lv_woodturner3899
@lv_woodturner3899 2 ай бұрын
Big improvement, well done. I am just curious, did the hardened jaws blunt the carbide insert? Dave.
@WinkysWorkshop
@WinkysWorkshop 2 ай бұрын
Thanks. The insert was fine. The jaws are harder than mind steel but not much.
@rexmyers991
@rexmyers991 2 ай бұрын
At 20:44 you conclude the scroll is the problem,. I agree - it’s a cheap chuck and that’s the best it’s going to get.
@WinkysWorkshop
@WinkysWorkshop 2 ай бұрын
Yep, I was hoping for a little better quality but after fixing the jaws It will be close enough for some stuff. One reason I bought it was to use on my wood lathe (most spindles have square ends) and the accuracy there is not an issue. I think the scroll is a problem for repeatability but I think the jaws were made wrong also. When changing diameters its fairly consistent.
@jasons5178
@jasons5178 Ай бұрын
i tru my jaws the same way but i machined the face of the jaws in the closed position so i can use a steel bushing took me from .004 original runout to .0005 after. best of all no grinding only slow and carefull machining
@WinkysWorkshop
@WinkysWorkshop Ай бұрын
How do you use a steel bushing?
@taranson3057
@taranson3057 2 ай бұрын
I have both a Vevor 3 and 4 jaw chucks and both are way out. They advertise as to how accurate they are when they really are not very accurate at all. My collet chucks are really accurate, well at least a lot better than the 3 and 4 jaw paper weight chucks that I have. Perhaps I should try this process on my chucks, I don't use them that often but when I do they only cause problems. Any improvements that I can make would definitely be a plus.
@WinkysWorkshop
@WinkysWorkshop 2 ай бұрын
Just speculation but... My other 3 jaw chucks are exactly the same casting and jaws but with a different name. Sanou. It seems to be a much better chuck than this 4-jaw. I only paid $68 for it. However, I noticed lately that the Sanou chucks are twice the cost of Vevor chucks. Probably worth the extra cost... or maybe I just got lucky? Hard to say.
@repairman2be250
@repairman2be250 2 ай бұрын
Thanks for the video and happy for your success to make it a better product. Many people have given their opinion on how to do things to make it more accurate. Vevor is a company for cheap products and therefore just average quality in my opinion.
@WinkysWorkshop
@WinkysWorkshop 2 ай бұрын
Thanks, Vevor is hit and miss. On some products cheap is not an issue. For instance the TIG welder I use will weld just as well as a Miller on steel. Its not the same quality machine but it functions well. I also have a drill sharpener from vevor that is amazing (although not cheap). The normal 3-jaws are okay but not great but this 4 jaw was terrible. So I sort of agree...
@dans_Learning_Curve
@dans_Learning_Curve 2 ай бұрын
Excellent 👍
@WinkysWorkshop
@WinkysWorkshop 2 ай бұрын
Thank you! Cheers!
@ypaulbrown
@ypaulbrown 2 ай бұрын
have you tried lightly snugging chuck, then rotating bar until you feel resistance, then do your final tightening? I find it helps on my 13" SB...hope this helps, Paul
@WinkysWorkshop
@WinkysWorkshop 2 ай бұрын
Yes i do the same, thanks
@ypaulbrown
@ypaulbrown 2 ай бұрын
Robert Shaw [Quint] would love how you are taming those Jaws........you may need a bigger Lathe
@WinkysWorkshop
@WinkysWorkshop 2 ай бұрын
Haha... you might be right.
@ypaulbrown
@ypaulbrown 2 ай бұрын
one question, have you put an indicator on your spindle ??? is your lathe a 9 or 10 SB ?
@WinkysWorkshop
@WinkysWorkshop 2 ай бұрын
Yes, the spindle is dead on but even if it was warped, the back plate would run true because it was turned while mounted to the spindle.
@bobkelly2447
@bobkelly2447 2 ай бұрын
Hay buddy I think you missed something ! when removing the dust cover you left the end of the scroll gears able to twist a bit... this will cause them to bind and the chuck will not be as tight as you think it is... yes it's a cheap chuck but you made it worse by removing the dust cover.... the dust cover has protrusions under it that support the end of the scroll gears so they can't twist out of alignment and bind.... you removed that so now they can twist and bind and worse move UP and allow the tightening gears to slip. so you NEED to weld in a metal piece to the chuck to do that now something to support the end of those scroll gears if you use it like that very long it will eventually ware out the scroll gears because they are forcing themselves out of the teeth when you tighten them down. maybe a drilled out nut welded onto the center column of the chuck would do it, I don't know but then you would not be able to get the spryl gear out to clean it good.... I think you worked yourself into a pickle this time.... putting the dust cover back in means making a new back plate.... but I think that is your best option in this case. sorry for the bad news but you have 3 options put it back the way it was, weld on some gear supports to the chuck, or use it like it is and hope it will last ! perhaps you can figure out another way to support those gears eh ? but they need to be supported on the far end !
@WinkysWorkshop
@WinkysWorkshop 2 ай бұрын
Interesting and you might be correct. I need to look at this closer. However, I've had a few 3-jaw chucks that had no scroll support aside from the pinion gears. The best fix would be to attach a tube to the back plate with cutouts for the pinions. Doable but not easy. Seeing as how the dust cover was plastic, I suspect it was probably only to stabilize the backlash between the pinion gears and scroll gear while tightening. I doubt there is any danger of slippage but it would likely make the chuck more repeatable. Thanks!
@bobkelly2447
@bobkelly2447 2 ай бұрын
@@WinkysWorkshop Well depending on how sloppy those pinions fit determines if it will slip ! yah Plastic is ridiculous in a chuck !!!!! my big concern is the binding it gets tight and won't turn anymore and you think it's a tight chuck but it's because the pinions are tilting up and binding in their holes and not wanting yo turn ! just thought you might think about that is all.... not every FIX is real easy ! LOL I have a scroll 4 jaw chuck and never use it. I use the 3 jaw or the independent 4 jaw only on my Logan 911 good way to true the chuck.... and I agree they must be trued in tension !
@WinkysWorkshop
@WinkysWorkshop 2 ай бұрын
@@bobkelly2447 I removed the outer plastic on the plastic piece and then turned the flat surface of the plastic down to the thickness of the space between the backing plate and the center tube the plate was screwed to. The backing plate now holds the original plastic in place. I agree that was the intent of the plastic piece although I'm not positive it will have any effect. Still a good idea to leave it there. Thanks... Oh, and I also made a short video and gave you credit.
@bobkelly2447
@bobkelly2447 2 ай бұрын
@@WinkysWorkshop LOL I am Honored Thank you. I like your idea of making a bigger hole for the stock to go in..... ! I've needed that several times I might do that ! LOL..... I think the plastic is plenty strong to hold the far ends of the chuck tightening screws thingies .... it doesn't take much but it is nessarry to prevent binding .... I THINK lol .....keep up the good work.... now if I could get my cut-off tools to work like yours I'ed be happy ! i brake a insert every time I try to use the cut off tool !
@WinkysWorkshop
@WinkysWorkshop 2 ай бұрын
@@bobkelly2447 I gave up on insets and use this blade on a spring cutoff. amzn.to/3z2ROsZ
@oh8wingman
@oh8wingman 2 ай бұрын
Taking the dust cover out might make things a little worse. You are now going to have a gap between the mounting plate and the chuck inside the bore. As a result, you could easily end up with small chips getting into the pinions and scroll gear surfaces.
@WinkysWorkshop
@WinkysWorkshop 2 ай бұрын
The rubber ring (although crude) seals this area.
@PorkBarrel.
@PorkBarrel. 2 ай бұрын
Why not drill new holes with countersink screws?
@WinkysWorkshop
@WinkysWorkshop 2 ай бұрын
Laziness. It did cross my mine :o)
@leslieaustin151
@leslieaustin151 2 ай бұрын
Good work Mark. But you have a habit that bothers me… you slow down the chuck using your hand as the brake. When you did that with the hose clamp flying round I could see the possibility of a badly torn hand - and that might slow your video production! Bad news for all of us.. Take care my friend, safety third, and all that👍 Les in UK 🇬🇧
@WinkysWorkshop
@WinkysWorkshop 2 ай бұрын
Thanks for the concern. my fingers were resting on the back plate so for me there was no concern but you make a valid point. I could get careless.
@mattym8
@mattym8 2 ай бұрын
You’re right. I do it too. Not a good idea.
@Ozzi5k
@Ozzi5k 2 ай бұрын
Why not put 3 new boltholes in the backplate. Seems enough space to me ;-)
@WinkysWorkshop
@WinkysWorkshop 2 ай бұрын
Yes I considered that too... I weighed the extra time and effort and the benefits and decided against it. I would have gained 1/8" in overhang. Probably should have.
@ellieprice363
@ellieprice363 2 ай бұрын
Excellent job. You made an accurate chuck out of a so-so chuck. Jaws are probably about 45 Rockwell C.
@WinkysWorkshop
@WinkysWorkshop 2 ай бұрын
Thanks, Yeah... I have no way to measure them. They are not super hard but more than mild steel.
@alfredrichter6236
@alfredrichter6236 2 ай бұрын
Or you take off as much as you would need for the plate to sit down all the way and drill three more holes to fasten the plate to the chuck.
@WinkysWorkshop
@WinkysWorkshop 2 ай бұрын
Probably what I should have done, thanks
@cyclebuster
@cyclebuster 2 ай бұрын
Man I almost bought one of those crummy chucks.
@WinkysWorkshop
@WinkysWorkshop 2 ай бұрын
I've had good luck with the Sauno (sp?) 3-jaw but this one was terrible. It will be okay on my CNC wood lathe which is where it will be most the time.
@cyclebuster
@cyclebuster 2 ай бұрын
@@WinkysWorkshop wasn’t this sold with a TIR certificate?? They are advertised with one
@WinkysWorkshop
@WinkysWorkshop 2 ай бұрын
@@cyclebuster Good question. I've seen these cheap chuck with them but i dont remember seeing one. I usually ignore them. I doubt they are real.
@machinists-shortcuts
@machinists-shortcuts Ай бұрын
The innermost faces of the external jaws are not designed to be used. This is why they were not finished machined and had so much runout. Self centering 4 jaw chucks are not meant for round parts. Round parts will only clamp properly on two opposing jaws. The jaw faces on the external jaws should be flat, not machined on an arc. Otherwise now they will leave marks on any flat faced parts that the chuck was designed for.
@WinkysWorkshop
@WinkysWorkshop Ай бұрын
Interesting about the inner most jaws. I've used them on my 3-jaw a few times just out of laziness but they are not ideal. The arch on the jaws is minimal so not too worried. It will mark but for most stuff it will be tolerable. Clamping the round stock was only for the purpose of checking the chuck. I will use it to clamp square stock. Honestly only two jaws will touch round of square most the time. I've already used it a few times to drill square stock and it worked great but the primary reason I bought it was to use on my CNC wood lathe.
@Hoaxer51
@Hoaxer51 2 ай бұрын
Have you ever put your test bars (at least the smaller one) in a collet and checked for runout in your bar? That way you know where you stand with the bar when you use it.
@WinkysWorkshop
@WinkysWorkshop 2 ай бұрын
Not this time. If the chuck was repeatable I would have. In fact I think I have a linear rail about 3/4" somewhere.
@alanswanson1952
@alanswanson1952 2 ай бұрын
Why just do a new bolt circle and no counter bore this time?
@WinkysWorkshop
@WinkysWorkshop 2 ай бұрын
I considered that too, good idea.
@nightraidone9768
@nightraidone9768 2 ай бұрын
As you said a self centering 4 jaw hast the same Problem like a chair, they are prett good when you want to machine square stock
@WinkysWorkshop
@WinkysWorkshop 2 ай бұрын
I totally agree. Plus I'll be using it on my wood lathe for turning square stock.
@terrycannon570
@terrycannon570 2 ай бұрын
Mark I am trying to understand what the advantage of having a 4 jaw scroll chuck is? I understand the advantage of a 4 jaw adjustable but not a scroll.
@WinkysWorkshop
@WinkysWorkshop 2 ай бұрын
Primarily chucking square stock. I've had several occasions where I need to drill the ends or make them round so it just speeds things up. One big reason I wanted one was to use on my wood lathe. Most spindles have square ends.
@terrycannon570
@terrycannon570 2 ай бұрын
@@WinkysWorkshop Thanks Mark. I didn't think about using it on the wood lathe. Now it makes sense. If you have a lot of square stock to turn or bore, then it will certainly speed things up.
@philreynolds7216
@philreynolds7216 2 ай бұрын
I am not a machinist, but I have a question: Wouldn’t the runout change based on where on the internal screws the jaw is engaged? Meaning that if you chuck a 1” bar, you get one runout reading, but if you open the jaws a little, engage a different area of the internal screws, and chuck a 1 1/4” bar, would you get a different runout?
@WinkysWorkshop
@WinkysWorkshop 2 ай бұрын
Yes, absolutely and a very good point. I checked the internal jaws with two size bars and they were not the same but close. No self centering chuck is perfect. Most often it will be close enough but if I need perfect I'll use a independent jaw 4-jaw or collets
@alejandrolabarca4366
@alejandrolabarca4366 2 ай бұрын
Hi, can do you show de concentricity of this plates and put a bar to see it too?
@WinkysWorkshop
@WinkysWorkshop 2 ай бұрын
Testing the plate isn't at all necessary. It was turned while mounted on the spindle so it will always be perfect. I did test with a bar. It was not as good as I would like but much better than it was. Mostly it changes every time i lock it down.
@alejandrolabarca4366
@alejandrolabarca4366 2 ай бұрын
Escuseme, my question was about your former video. Because I have the same problem, making 2 times rectifier.
@alejandrolabarca4366
@alejandrolabarca4366 2 ай бұрын
@@WinkysWorkshop Thank you Winky!
@EitriBrokkr
@EitriBrokkr 2 ай бұрын
Now unless you're clamping precision square stock, the exact dimension of when you bored it... It's completely useless.
@WinkysWorkshop
@WinkysWorkshop 2 ай бұрын
The jaws all need to have a load on them in the direction clamping. If you clamp precision round or square stock the low jaw will be flopping around. The trick is to clamp something that is springy so that all jaws have a significant load before cutting or grinding. I admit that the aluminum between the jaws is not perfect but it does work. It would be better if load was directly under the jaws or a ring on the outside of the jaws but thats also a bit more complicated. Something under the jaws restricts grinding or cutting and the external ring requires drilling the jaws.
@EitriBrokkr
@EitriBrokkr 2 ай бұрын
@@WinkysWorkshop yeah thanks, we know how to grind chuck jaws... That wasn't the point
@WinkysWorkshop
@WinkysWorkshop 2 ай бұрын
@@EitriBrokkr I need precision round stock to test the chuck not to grind it. Apparently you (or "we"?) have different laws of physics or perhaps we are not understanding each other.
@EitriBrokkr
@EitriBrokkr 2 ай бұрын
@@WinkysWorkshop the point is a 4 jaw scroll chuck is all but worthless... Unless you're running production on precision square stock 100 years ago. Especially with one piece jaws
@WinkysWorkshop
@WinkysWorkshop 2 ай бұрын
@@EitriBrokkr Certainly not as useful as a 3-jaw but still useful. I understand your point, technically unless both the chuck and stock are exactly perfect you are only holding with 2 jaws. So here's the deal. 1) No self centering chuck is perfect and the assumption is that some runout will be acceptable, 2) two-jaws are totally adequate to hold square stock while drilling and 3) most cold rolled stock is within .002". With some flex in the jaws and scroll along with some slight compressibility of the stock being held, all 4 of the jaws will contact the stock. Even before I ground the jaws a very firm tightening would make all four jaws contact. Now that the jaws are somewhat in the ballpark the tightness needed to achieve this is much less. Of course there is also the fact that I will also use this chuck on my CNC wood lathe. The compressibility of wood is tremendous and holding stock will never be an issue. I may actually make another back plate at some time. My wood lathe has a 1.5" spindle and my South Bend has a 1.625 spindle. I made an adapter but the stockout from the spindle is a bit over 2 inches further. On a metal lathe this would create a issue with chatter but with wood it works well. The bad part is, it limit the length of stock I can turn.
@fredflintstone8048
@fredflintstone8048 2 ай бұрын
With all due respect it's a silly chuck. A 4 jaw with a scroll? No! A four jaw that's worth having has individually adjustable jaws. The idea is for clamping on odd shape work and or being able to dial in greater precision than you can get on your 3 jaw. 6 thou runout to me would be worthless. More than 1 thou is not useful to me. 3 jaw chucks with scroll tension and even better if you can get one that allows you to adjust to fine tune the center. My 3 jaw has three possible mounting positions, the best giving me half a thou runout which is acceptable. I used a punch to mark that best position. Same with mounting my ER collect chuck to the lathe. No offense but I would scrap that chuck, or find some other poor soul to give or worse sell it to. It's really hard to believe that the manufacturer thought it was something worth building.
@WinkysWorkshop
@WinkysWorkshop 2 ай бұрын
While I do agree that a self centering 4 jaws are problematic, it works great for drilling the ends of square stock or turning the end round. Not perfect but it also depends on what you are making. Also, most the time I'll be using on my CNC wood lathe. A lot of what I turn is spindles with a square ends. Wood compresses so slight discrepancies between jaw sets or wood size are not an issue.
@jameshicks6753
@jameshicks6753 2 ай бұрын
Why would you buy a 4 jay chuck that doesn’t have 4 jaws that are not Independently adjustable. That’s what there four😮
@WinkysWorkshop
@WinkysWorkshop 2 ай бұрын
For turning or drilling the ends of square stock. Yes a independent jaw chuck will do the same but what if you want to drill 30 pieces of square stock it's a lot less effort with the self centering chuck and most often accurate enough. Oh... also I want to use the same chuck on my CNC wood lathe and quite often I turn spindles with square ends.
Building a Small Footprint Welding Cart - Part 1
15:55
Winky's Workshop
Рет қаралды 3,6 М.
A teacher captured the cutest moment at the nursery #shorts
00:33
Fabiosa Stories
Рет қаралды 63 МЛН
Simple Indexing on a Metal Lathe
15:49
Winky's Workshop
Рет қаралды 118 М.
I Bought A Minimill to see if they are Worth It
8:03
Someone Should Make That
Рет қаралды 1,1 МЛН
Fixing Cross Slide Backlash on my South Bend 11
26:02
Winky's Workshop
Рет қаралды 79 М.
Restoring a Vintage Watchmaker's Lathe
15:02
Chronova Engineering
Рет қаралды 92 М.
Quiet replacement gears for my South Bend lathe
10:16
Winky's Workshop
Рет қаралды 11 М.
Lufkin Jack Shaft Replacement on 100 Year Old Oil Well
42:22
TheZachLife
Рет қаралды 166 М.
Trash Day Rescue! - Thomas Johnson Antique Furniture Restoration
30:27
Thomas Johnson Antique Furniture Restoration
Рет қаралды 91 М.
Pushing GIGANTIC Tools in MASSIVE 1200 lb Part
11:53
TITANS of CNC MACHINING
Рет қаралды 197 М.