It would also negate the energy expended to make all the parts, as I am sure it will take a while to pay back all the energy used to make the parts.

@@MacksCurley yeah, these sort of low-energy or short-lifespan green energy sources are really a sort of awkward battery: Energy was expended in making the materials or device, you ship it off to some remote location that needs power, and the special catalyst (Sun, Wind, Vibration) slowly "unlocks" the finite amount of energy stored in that device until it's usable lifespan is depleted.

Or hanging in a tree

@@justtinkering6713 maybe a bridge rectifyer would solve that.

@@_g7085 At the same time, things like this could be made from parts that were destined for the landfill. Then the energy used to produce it for the original purpose was always paid off.

cheers mate

@Kevin Alexanderman - I hope that wasnt meant to be as negative and insulting as it came across ?

@@herenow2895 No , he did have the answer. Look at his tower then look at the pyramids . It was a global network..

This is great! I was thinking of a way to integrate power harvesting into sewage line exhaust vents in homes, I think this is it!!

Real heros like you make the world better.

people that get what they deserve go to Hell.

evanleebodies yeah , he reminds me of my teachers in Knaresborough , Yorks , where i grew up, he's old school , i wish more people were like him today .

@@arkangel8709 I had a go and it works!!

Plz share with us when you are done, interesting!

I was also thinking about this for use in the ocean.

Highways and train tracks vibrate quite a bit as well

@@denbecr49 nope he just added more methane gas in atmosphere.

When the south wind blows everybody knows.

Finally a good use for brussel sprouts.

I can relate with sprouts, cabbage and even kale.

🤣🤣🤣

L

I get your enthusiasm for human tossing, but I' dunno if that is such a great idea. He does not seem like the kind of guy that shows up uninvited. & have you not read the old testament? :0*

That's not how heaven works

@@leonkane8240 You're right. He might just be too polite.

@@james10739 I know. I was just illustrating how unfailingly helpful he is to everyone.

@@james10739 Allegedly :0)

Speakin gof trees I think that all trees w/in ounty limits be removed . ll they do is dump leves bust up concrete adn fall over during storms and what not killing peopel. It's actually an alarmign number of fatalities all of which coul dhve been prevented. Now unliek the deth of the paper grocery bg tht ws forced out of use by certin "progresive"political actvists who sweore theey hd the perfect eco friednly replcement nd gave us the Plastic Grocery bag..I do have a perfect replacement fo rallthos etrees that beloongin the forest ..fruit trees!. They don't dump aleaves, grow large enough to bust up concreete or grow large enough to kill peope plus if you've ever been hungry and broke let me add it's no joke. There's really no ojective that out weighs to prevent hunger. People especially mom's wil always buy theri fruit from a store. So pro growers have nothign to fer. A detail her e or there to sort out but ala folks don't want peopel grabbing fruit off a tree in their front yard or back yrd. You coul dcollect it dn put tubs on the crne makign it available . I'm sure there;'s enough kids who it wouldn't hurt to maintainthem . If we cn go to mars to live Sm i expected to beleive we can't take a big bit eou tof hunger by replacign danger ou stree w one's tht have fruit on them? Next tiem yo ustep ou tside stop look around dn count how many trees yo ucan see. Way wy befoe my tiem but johnny Appleseed was a thing ??? a century ago??? BTW I bought the worse keyboard I'm gopign smashiinto tiny pieces keys stick so my bd for the typos. Oh liek you r idea I shoul dhav eled w that. rrr I should have led w that.

Could be added to the ones already used on todays ships! the normal motion of the water, swaying, vibration, could possibly be piced up by muitible 'zoom tubes'? & passively transferred to a power bank, along with other combined solar or wind power systems.

I've seen vids of artificial trees that the branches are basically mounting poles for mini VAWTs. The VAWT blades are crafted to look like leaves or flowers

There are phallicly shaped vertical wind generators that work from being vibrated by the wind. Reverse vibrators.

E.T. basically did this in the 80s, using a line attached to branches when the wind blew, it transferred that mechanical energy and powered his "phone"

What if I just stick a whole lot of old speakers outside near the road and absorb the road noise ,,designed more along the lines of not a microphone per say but a loose cone that will capture sub vibrations as well.

Per se

@@chuckthebull speaker cone would not vibrate on it's own without input I would imagine plus if it would then the cone would absorb that energy.

Hmmm you are causing me to think of the "echo chamber" I bought in the 70's which when opened up by damaging the enclosure was just a very thin vibrating spring that was extremely flexible. Also when I "spoke into my turntable needle when recording a record onto tape as it finished AND turned the recording volume up very loud", I could hear my voice clearly on the tape (along with a lot of very loud scratching sound from the vinyl surface and motor hum). Simple vibrations are easily magnified and I'd guess these devices if made correctly could be ramped up to produce much more than seen here (and maybe charge batteries for constant use.)

I immediately subscribed to your chanell - Robert Murray-Smith " I think things like this Belongs to the Public Domain. You got me Right there because it speaks volumes of your standards, values and intergrity! As a design it is Robost. It is cheap and it works. Cheap is really important. It's got to be simple to make. It's got to be cheap to make or it never gets made." This is a listeners response, and i assure that it increases the conversation, it expands the discussion and thereby spark enquieries into further investigations. AlcoholIsActuallyBadSorry 1 year ago (edited) Came up with some improvements (about halfway through video): 1. The tube uses air entering through the orifice on the side to shake a diaphragm that generates electricity, and it can vibrate up and down along the length axis of the tube. Using air, it would be more effective and powerful to use a focusing horn to make the pressure vibrations larger. 2. Using different diameters, weights, and elasticity of diaphragms you can absorb a certain frequency of oscillation that is left out by the standard design, including using this to absorb bridge vibrations like a dampener or energy recovery from traffic. 3. This is not much different to how an unpowered microphone works. 4. Using materials that have a higher stiffness, or young's modulus, allows energy to transfer into the diaphragm more efficiencly without various substructures flexing, as well as reducing the overall weight. 5. There is not much benefit to using artificial plastic muscles versus a standard spring or pneumatic, unless the flexural energy lost to heat is lower than other materials and methods.* Warie Porbeni Founder and president of Radio Zeater Club radiozeaterclub@gmail.com*

You could even make it like an expanding telescope. And have it as a dual functioning unit. Attach the lenses and you have a telescope to see. Take the telescope caps off and install the other part for power. Whole thing would be collapsible and compact inside of carry case. It was brilliant that you came up with this idea for compact use for backpackers and such.

I was thinking something similar but built into the heels of hiking boots to generate power as you walk.

@@clintonrobinson8070 Or trekking poles.

@@clintonrobinson8070 theres some piezo generators worth checking out.

@@kke or in tent poles!

I was thinking along the guitar strings and spring idea when I watched it too.

You Just Described the Hidden Tech and Truth behind the Last Remaining Great Organs of the Grand Opera Houses...many of these are connected to Deep Natural Subterranean Airflows...👈🏼 another thing they hide from Us 😉🤫 Much Love and Peace 🤜🏼❤🤛🏿

How about putting a tiny solar panel on top connected to a little motor with some wires to strum the string?

Electrify a Victorian Aeolian Harp. That way, you'll get music and electricity

Hi boet.... Ja, let down by corrupt Nat. leaders.... My hearts grieves for all my brothers and sisters.... I have little but I'm blessed here... Stay safe boet🇬🇧

We are better off living off the grid. Eskom's and the country in general's power capabilities are not going to improve. simple hydro generation is also useful, provided you have a source closeby

@@danebecker Hey Dane, the cashless time is nearly upon us.... STOCK UP NOW BOET...

Hey that's my design idea 😡 how did you hack into my head..mine comes with an interactive tensioner for frequency optimization

You've just caused my brain to come up with an additional improvement. Add a series of vortex holes along the length of the pipe to induce vibration... vortex holes of different sizes...I must have a go at it..

@@albertcassler8763 Align the magnets, equally spaced in a Circle 👍🏼... Much Love and Peace 🤜🏼❤🤛🏿

Wind Doesn't just help to Produce Electric, it is Electric in itself, Scientists in the 1600/1700s knew this...Sadly its become part of the Occult Knowledge that is Kept from Us All...However Times are Changing...🤜🏼❤🤛🏿

@@albertcassler8763 wouldn't vortex holes of different sizes reduce vibration ?

Nice input! Thanks, you got me pondering!

Bravo!

Has anyone tried hanging an electric guitar up by the machine head in the wind and seeing if you get an output from the pickup? You'd have to bypass the switches & pots.

I immediately subscribed to your chanell - Robert Murray-Smith " I think things like this Belongs to the Public Domain. You got me Right there because it speaks volumes of your standards, values and intergrity! As a design it is Robost. It is cheap and it works. Cheap is really important. It's got to be simple to make. It's got to be cheap to make or it never gets made." This is a listeners response, and i assure that it increases the conversation, it expands the discussion and thereby spark enquieries into further investigations. AlcoholIsActuallyBadSorry 1 year ago (edited) Came up with some improvements (about halfway through video): 1. The tube uses air entering through the orifice on the side to shake a diaphragm that generates electricity, and it can vibrate up and down along the length axis of the tube. Using air, it would be more effective and powerful to use a focusing horn to make the pressure vibrations larger. 2. Using different diameters, weights, and elasticity of diaphragms you can absorb a certain frequency of oscillation that is left out by the standard design, including using this to absorb bridge vibrations like a dampener or energy recovery from traffic. 3. This is not much different to how an unpowered microphone works. 4. Using materials that have a higher stiffness, or young's modulus, allows energy to transfer into the diaphragm more efficiencly without various substructures flexing, as well as reducing the overall weight. 5. There is not much benefit to using artificial plastic muscles versus a standard spring or pneumatic, unless the flexural energy lost to heat is lower than other materials and methods.* Warie Porbeni Founder and president of Radio Zeater Club radiozeaterclub@gmail.com*

Catchy ! Energy Catcher !

Springy Thingie.

how?

Exactly what I thought when I saw the video! 😮

​@John Lillbourne The pulse motor has to be driven and if you wire it in a circle and think you can get "free energy" you are wrong. Physics doesn't work that way.

Maybe - it really depends on the voltages he is getting. Devices like this are often only good in groups and for long charge applications - if they are useful at all. To be useful, they will need to produce at least 1 watt. I don't think it is there yet - but at least these devices are true generators and not "free energy" schemes. To me, the point is working toward a solution, not getting one in the first try. I think this is a great example of that. Once he optimizes it, we shall see - for such a simple device, you would be amazed at all the things that could be optimized.

cheers mate

lol - always had that problem mate - and you should see the mess I make putting them on!

The trick is to never put them on. After all...this channel is all about alternative methods. 😊 But, like always, just be safe. BTW...i have only 3 "clones".

You must refer to the "3W" method!

​@@SI-GOD I have 4...two of which are currently for sale. cheap. (definitely not "over worked" in any meaningful sense of the word) ;-)

cool idea mate - go for it

did you have any link to understand better how it’s made ? Thank you

In line with what Tesla discovered, written in his "research logbook"?... If the natural occurence was proven true, why was the technology not dessiminated for public consumption- most specially a schematic drawing/ sketch- on step by step " do it yourself" procedure?.. Again, was the power monopolist behind the subtle "suppression" operation?... Just asking...

Put it on top of car and harness the wind blowing by

Too bad you cant read the multimeter, its 277 microamps

I think Robert mistakenly said 277 milliamps. I read it a .277 milliamps, or 0.000277 Amps.

cheers mate - much appreciated

how about the white barrier tube along every curve bridge crossing etc along most highways in North America or the world they're plastic tubes ... they literally build themselves almost

As Robert said there are many ways and combinations that might give significant results.

@@mjohnhayes If the generators get a reflective surface it would also add a security feature to the posts...

Good catch! Ad a diaphragm and, sing away!

Yep, reminds me of a flute

pls see my momment

please see my comment above

Or Vawts.

cheers mate - thanks for that

@@scrapwomblecreatives6944 from your rant, I might assume you have only begun such ventures into physics. I have about years of study. Some of what you said is correct, just not very accurate. The problem with making any claim right now about quantum mechanics is simple. The people who work on it (most not all) including schrodinger himself, said the equations are obviously missing something. Never forget the wild imprecision of language. Never forget the vast gap of knowledge versus truth. The labels you currently use might one day not hold much water at all.

@@scrapwomblecreatives6944 Madam or Sir, inventors who believe they have created a new thing of value and want to maintain ownership / control of their invention, *ALWAYS* research the previous patents of similar items, and especially building-blocks thereto, at the US and EU patent offices. I appreciate your enthusiasm very much, but it is not fair to others to merely assume your invention(s) are new or unique. Humbly intended: there are certainly a lot of other people smarter than you or I. The problem here specifically is that resonance and vibratory physics is older than you or I - and older too than Quantum Mechanics, which you vaguely reference. (See Hertz, Helmholz, Maxwell, just to name a few.) Also, the video mentions that there might be previously existing, patented devices. Well there are - and it's not dozens, it's hundreds in just the US PTO alone, including resonant tension-release devices of *many* sorts, from nano-scale vibratory EMF generators, to massive commercial-level tidal generators for producing electricity. And, yes (to answer Mr. Murry-Smith's question), this particular device does have related patents. (I don't have more time to list them, but they are easy to find using appropriate key words.) Also I have to say, echoing other posters this thread, we were experimenting with vibratory wire-strings, coils, and magnets to produce micro amperages already in the 1970s. It was a high school electronics teacher who showed us how to do this - and he was 60 years old in 1972. In other words, you, Madam or Sir, are certainly not the first one to come up (or patent) such ideas or devices. Please do us all - and especially yourself - a favor before you post: do your homework first. Thanks -H (P.S. I have been employed previously as a patent researcher.)

I make loudspeakers in my goofing off time. My first thought was to use a speaker motor, which will almost certainly be more efficient. But I’ll have a think about what will improve vibration harvesting. I’m usually trying to get rid of weird resonances, but in this application those are what we want, right?

bless your heart mate - your kind words are much appreciated - and thanks for taking the time to write

Update ? Where are you Located ? Best Wishes ..Build Dreams..

for sure mate

That is just a fun idea. Imagine them twinkling like firefly's as you sit outside in the dusk

This would be a fun project for the grandkids

@@ericf.wolcott4716 No wind at dusk

That was pretty damn good, thanks

I was thinking put a spring in it.

Built into the rocker panels?

@@glennkelley6096 - Nah, custom dual purpose shock absorbers.

Using the actual struts would make the most sense. I am pretty sure this has been on paper in this regard for years.

@@gul7809 never say never!!! People said the mechanical carriages would never be better than a horse and converting sun light into electrical energy would never be possible as well!

@@gul7809 efficiency is measured in more ways than power output!!!!!! You would know that if you did some research!

@@gul7809 oh...so you claim to be an expert in a field with comments like you have been posting? I would be ashamed to call you an employee!!! You would have been fired 20 years ago!

possibly mate - give it a go

It will create some movement for sure 👍

Maybe extensions outside of tube fixed to “muscle”? Rain gutters? Rains a lot where I live but also would work with wind.

The sound vibrations from the chimes should also vibrate the muscle.

I know a bit about thermal couple devices like Peltier devices. They generate electricity not just from heat, but cold as well as it does this via temperature differences. When you get the hot side hot, you must find a way to make the cold side cold with a very large heat sink to draw the heat away.

For sure. Especially if you combine it with another part. For example this + a Water Wheel. Using the natural force of water to push a wheel to feed the vibrations into the tension element. Flute Mechanics would provide differing volts/amps. I wonder the effectiveness of a compressed air versus this.

@@icarusunited I think the answer is contained in your post. The energy transfer is via the change in potential energy of the water as it moves from a higher elevation to a lower one via the water wheel. Resonant frequency is not a part of the energy collected from the system. Think of resonant energy like that in a bell. The bell will cease ringing a soon as you put your hand on it. Energy in the ringing bell is contained in the moving momentum of the mass in the bell. as soon as you touch it the energy of the momentum is transferred to your hand. There is no reason to try to put energy back in the bell in order to harvest energy to do useful work. Hang in there, critical thinking and asking questions one of the most valuable skills you can cultivate. Chase the facts, question everything, especially yourself.

@@kwatt-engineer796 but maybe near the boiler?! or by the beach collecting garbage?!

Have you tried out your idea yet? If so does it improve energy output? Have you been able to measure what it's electrical output actually is? Just watched the video and I'm curious about some of the improvements people suggested. Thanks

Great points mate - cheers

@@ThinkingandTinkering It just seems to me that the real problem would be regulating the power. As the vibrations increase and decrease wouldn't the amps and volts produced would be all over the place?

Dick Sargent Hey friend. It’s fairly simple to keep the voltage regulated, there are whole devices just for that, but even the simple capacitor will do it.

If it is lightweight enough and cheap enough to make, it'd be great for recharging a car battery while you're driving.