Minitoon said that Mr. Stitchy will be returning on halloween, but the thing is if he adds Mr. Stitchy and not poley then that is just going to cause another drama to happen because Mr. Stitchy is also rare and limited and he is apart of the lore just like poley is so, people who have Mr. Stitchy and not poley are going to be annoyed about it because that would also ruin mr. Stitchy being a rare and limited skin. And knowing how the people are it's not going to go well, and at that point it would basically be like this whole Poley drama is happening once again but instead with Mr. Stitchy.

The Piggy mob vote

I think the main reason people want poley to come back is because minitoon stopped making event skins and new players havent gotten a chance to get a skin thats going to be rare

i feel like everyone's being dumb. why can't be both? there is exactly no reason to choose between two options

There are og players that don’t have it. I made my account purely to play Piggy and joined on the 17 of May. I had 10 days to do it, but I just didn’t. I don’t know why.

MiniToon has considered bringing back Mr. Stitchy and Bess, it would be unfair for OGs that got that skins if Poley don’t comes back but their skins do, so maybe since he got almost a Tie in the Poll, will still consider adding Poley back.

As much as I want Poley (Especially since I was an OG but lost it), I think it's best to bring back a new skin because there is also still book 3 coming out and the new skin could be canon. Also, since the votes are pretty much tied, Minitoon could just do both, and people would be happy with it.

adding back poley would ruin the point of limited skins,because then what's the point of having limited skins, if they're just gonna be added back in circulation.

Here is my solution: Make a police season, where you can get a poley redesign with teaser and remixed music, the lion cop/swat skin and some buildmode skins, decoration and events. I think that would be the best of worlds. Not perfect but close enough.

What's the point of a rare skin? It's not like Poley was hard to get anyway. Some people just didn't play back then. Just let people have a complete collection. Unfortunately, I will never have a complete collection unless seasons 2-4 come back, and there's no way that's happening :/

I used to have poley but I got data loss during the adopt me peak of 1M players or other adopt me peak, it was rlly sad because I couldn’t get the skin back cause it’s limited

The point of "100%ing the collection" is just stupid, is like i missed the metallica collab and i want it to be back because i didnt get it

If you think about it, this is piggys news fault. They’re the ones that said “poley is most likely coming back” when minitoon and Asimo never said anything about bringing poley back. Blame it on whoever sent the tweet from piggy news.

A possible solution could be that minitoon just brings back Poley and those who already have poley could get an alternative design for Poley by doing quests. So those who have Poley will be happy and those who don’t would also be happy

this is my argument. I was seven and really wanted piggy cuz I saw my favorite KZfaqrs playing it. When I finally got it, I really wanted to get that Poley skin everyone talked about. I even named my avatar Poley7864! But sadly, I never got it😢

If had the choice, I would personally do both in 2 maps that way we can give the new players a chance, and also the og players a new skin to play with. (This may cause some more drama tho)

I think in the minitoon he should put the poley skin back on because if these players get angry, It could be that the game is hated and falls and the future of this game is very worrying for many who are waiting for intercity

Next thing you know there’s gonna be more drama. We’re many tunes says he’s going to either put back the Mr. sty skin or have a new one.

Ngl, what the other comment said about a "cop season" would've been cool, a full on season about just cop skins, new build mode items, etc.

one of my roblox was hacked back then and now I cant get my poley skin back which is why I believe they should make Poley for sale (in my opinion) that way people can get it and then the new cop skin can be added as the collab.

I had poley and for some reason my data got wiped when I got a new tablet, I do have alot of other event skins

Another reason for Poley to come back is that Even if you were around back then, there was a possibility that you couldn’t get it since you were not aware of the skin and

4:41 also are you sure that's it's not being serapate quest and not again laser obby?.. +This can actually fix a bit problem,where new skin will be with special quest while Poley in place where Prototype is.

4:56 yeah,he done Braun Billy (or how him,I don't remember the part of name),and also Silzous with Kraxicorde...

I think that bringing back Poley would ruin the point of “limited” skins. I have Poley and it would be better if we get new skins, and new skins means new opportunities and options

I got really mad when I lost my old account. I had every single Piggy skin including these event ones and the ones during the seasons.

my friend got so mad at me because I had it’s better it stays limited

another good point some people who already had poley could've lost their acc so they're gonna be upset

I was unfortunate to not get Poley because Roblox was banned in UAE at the time the event started and ended. And once Roblox was unbanned I couldn't get it but I was there watching through the OG days right from chapter 1.

Man I had an acc with every og skin,including poley which I lost and I feel mad for not having a chance to have him back :(

i think that giving him a taser and maybe a model without the cap is the best thing to give the new players so the og stays more og

Why don't og players who have him get a special golden version of him so that way they can show their og 🤷‍♂️

Here's a thing i see a lot : give OGs a new cop skin ( on top that they already have Poley ) and give new players just Poley. That is literally gonna start another drama in a few years semi-OG players saying that they dont have the new cop skin and the cycle will just go on and on.

Honestly, Piggy News started it by tweeting like it was confirmed.

for me when roblox made the classic event piggy should have made a event that brings back all old skins with same quests for a week so this should be right and all people could have a chance by getting these skins.

What they could do is add poley but if you finish the quest you would get the new skin or get a alternate version of the skin like the b2 chapter 3 or bundle the new skin and poley and give the alt instead of og poley to the people who had him

This is becoming a Drama simulator

I have a really really good point so i had an account where i got poley but i forgot the password and now i cannot get it anymore i mained poley too! but now i just main the extra skins at the end bc they look "cool" (i think...)

imo, OG players should get a redesign of Poley as a seperate skin (for example: make the snout bigger and make the nose more of a triangular rectangle, add freckles, add the eyebags that pandy has, fur on the sides.) and new players and people who already got poley will get 2 new cop skin's (The lion one and another one which could be a robber or a criminal)

Thing that sucks is I was an OG but I didn't even know Poley existed until it was too late :(

For being such a small KZfaqr, your video was actually enjoyable.

I had been a OG, but due to a hacker I was banned and now I can no longer log in because he changed my password, I had the. that Mr.Stitchy and Poley account, that's why I want them to come back

How we can stop this is that there could be three types of poley The first one is the OG unobtainable one with the baton The second one is the one with the taser and is uninfected and the third one is the Canon one that has those red eyes with one of them having a blue pupil in it from chapter 3 refinery and you have to get it by accessing distorted memory on a private server and you can see a knocked out poley on the ground And then you have to jump on him 100 times and then beat the map. edit why can't MiniTune just add trading

Honestly i think that there should be a trigger in the mall map that turns the short and pretty easy laser section into a much longer and harder laser section and if you beat the way harder version you get Poley (you can get it but you're also punished for being late)

The piggy community needs to understand that not everything should always be obtainable. Some things in thus world you can’t get and some you could. Calling other peoples amazing arts trash just for a very old skin that they will probably never use is just sad. People are just so greedy 💀

I think that if Poley comes back Minitoon should bring canon version of infected Poley, the one that appears in the Refinery end cutscene without hat and different eyes that has no weapon.

If minitoon releases the poley skin again. People who got the poley skin when it first came out should get like a kinda redesign of poley or the lion skin

nothing hurts more than losing an accont with mr stitchy, owell, primrose, gold piggy, poley, that one skin i dont remember the name of but u could get it in chapter 6 book 2 for easter and pretty much every other purchaseable skin

I agree they wouldn't even care if they got poley, people would treat it like a collection of piggy skins i like main any skin every day except for piggy, brother, mother and father cus the dress looks weird on them

Well, maybe they can do a revamp of poly and make a separate skin to the old version so art new people can get poly and then the OG players won’t be mad at a rare skin that they have loses its value

TBH, i miss the Poley skin. i lost my account that had the Poley skin due to it being hacked a while ago. I do wish for him back because he was my favorite skin, BUT i do wish for a new one. So why doesn't he just do both???

ok hear me out Jailbreak return will give a new Poley skin, one that looks cooler or whatever. And there will be an alternate version for the classic Poley. Personally I don’t have Poley but his music is great and I really want a polar bear skin, so I think it would be great

4 years ago i was 9 I just started Roblox and I didn't know what I was doing and I tried to get the skin but I couldn't

If people want a new cop skin than it should be poley in phase 2 (what we see in the refinery ending) and his different eye pupils and no hat and weapon

I had poley in another account called "nadiesabe" and some numbers. Sadly, it got hacked when roblox was down for 3 days. I honestly want poley back, although I would love for both of them to be in piggy, I had like every rare skin by those times.

Personally I couldn’t get that skin since I am so bad at the bank obby thing, but personally I would be honest about this. The internet has way to many pointless people, that it’s very disfigured in every way they want. But personally I would agree it’s stupid for them, because they literally act like an anti-movement system. But if you guys see this comment, the internet has way too many brainless people, and twitter is like a hellhole of Wednesday’s Infidelity. Although I don’t really play piggy this much, I still want the OGs to keep ‘em.

Why does no one mension event traps? Like serously its unfair also considering they give a gameplay advantage it makes it unfair for people who didnt do it. Also the snowpiggy trap is so good to a point where if you dont have it and are okaying someone who does have it toy just lose automatically

If they bring back poley, they should create a new poley with more detail only available to the ones who has poley

Wasn’t there LIDERALLY a skin in the mall like 2 weeks ago?

Bringing back Old events would be cool, but bringing back old events skins would Ruin the value of it and For the people who got it I got all the events skins. It would be nice for the people who all Got it to get a special Skin type.

I want minitoon to release the poley from heist (infected and in ending) and the new cop skin. and the heist poley as an extra skin would be sick and I'd love that to happen.

This game still popping 😭 i haven't played since covid

1:52, 6:40 Hey thats me lmao Also another point I'd say is reasonable for Poley to come back, is that MiniToon said that he will probably bring Mr. Stitchy and Bess back, which at that point, why bring them back but not Poley? I also believe Bess is way rarer than Poley because well, Piggy was in its peak when Poley was released, unlike when Bess was. The other problem is for how many arguments the community may make, I am 90% sure that most of the people who voted for the New Skin just want to keep Poley while most people that voted Poley just want it to complete their collection, so kind of dumb by both parties imo.

They should add maybe a choice to pick some quests to get poley, and some quests to get a new skin

They're is also the point that most people in the opposite side ''Against Poley coming back'' saying that Poley was meant to be exclusive and limited... But it was in my opinions never hinted at... I'm pretty sure most of the advertissement at the time for the skin didn't mention any exclusivity... Poley was never meant to be a one time thing... It was limited for the collab sure. But they never said that we will ''Never'' come back... So why bringing Blatt back... another event Skin but not Poley for another collaboration ?

Bro,the whole thing can been fixed simple (expect the fact that's Minitoon don't like Poley):just add Poley where he appeared while for new skin make a special quest lol. Again, it's probably not gonna happen,but imagine if this happen actually...

I am a of of piggy started playing in 2020 I just didn’t play piggy whenever the collaboration with jailbreak was released so I don’t have poley

At this point minitoon should being back all event/limited skins

I’m an og player because I’ve been playing since station came out but I still missed out on the poley skin because every time I tried to get it everyone would pick carnival instead of mall even if I asked them and I was a dumb dumb and had no idea how to make a private server soooo yeah.

minitoon should just add a alt poley skin for OG skins that just has OG text printed on it

Why don’t they just use the pokey design from book 2 as the skin😊

I mean, if Poley comes back, wouldn't that interfiere with the keymaster badge? You know, because you need to go there for both the first part of keymaster and for Poley?

"Nobody can have something that only ME deserve!" ahh person💀(seriously are you gonna die if people have a skin that was limited and you have it? No so stop being litte jealous kids man pls🙏)

Why don’t they add a different skin for poley the one where he drops the white key and willow escapes and if you have the OG poley then you can wear the skin kinda like skulltrooper in Fortnite when the re released it and the OGs get the purple skin

Idea: MiniToon Releases Poley again for a week so the players who didn’t get him before can now. Then he releases the new skin for everyone to get sounds fair enough right?

BRO I FELLED SO BAD NOW, I LOST A ACC WITH ALOT OF OG SKINS 😢😢😢😢

There should be a new skin cause both people get a new skin if you were there

I stand with the pepole who want poley back i have poley already and the worst part that most of the limited skins will be returning (like mr stichy and bess) so i feel like its really unfair if you bring 1 skin back the bring all of them back.

Last time yall played poley fr bro😭😭

i had poly on my old account, but pour roblox moderation, has been frustrating me for ever sinds, so yea, i'd really REALLY want him to return

i think the poley skin should be back and for the ones that had gotten it they would have to do the same quest for an alternative skin for police doggy or poley

At first, I thought poley, but now, I believe a new cop skin is better, cause the new skin's design is very cool, and the OGs would get mad, and I respect the OGs. A Poley redesign would be cool for the OGs, tho

Honesty as much as people want it, and saying it now I was there when it was there but because I had a low end device and I sucked I couldn't get it so I feel people wanting it but criticizing a concept skin if a collab happens again just because you want poley back is just absurd. Like I know you want it back but at least don't be rude to a concept design

minitoon is probably gonna add back mr STICHY in halloween but I hope that happens I never got any of the rare secret OG piggy skins

I think for the new players minitoon could bring back poley, and for the ogs they get a new skin..

I had poley on my old account but so many peoples piggy accounts got banned😢

I don’t play piggy but I think they should bring Poley back and add a new skin. Games with trading have limited items and it makes sense because there is a economy but a game like piggy doesn’t really need limited skins because its kind of unfair to new players who will never be able to get it because they didn’t know piggy existed. New players should get an opportunity at things they weren’t able to get due to being new.

If minitoon brought back Poley, I'd like it if it was a different version of poley like the one in refinery

poley and mr stitchy are like the only rare skins i have

i was 3 days late to getting poley and have wanted him ever since, so that’s the only reason i want him back

I have 5 skins out of my collection, one of them being poley but I’m still voting for a new cop skin because no matter what in the future like 4 years later theres gonna be another collab with jailbreak and piggy Minitoon gonna put “poley” “cop skin from 2024 poll” and “new cop skin” and the beef will just start again

So basically Minitoon should put it there for a day since it’s rare but make it a little harder

I think that piggy should have an option after the start when you join the game they will put out both skins for one week and whoever picks poley can’t get the other skin. Whoever picks the skin can’t pick the poley skin.

0:08 yay, bro killed hacker

I never seen someone using poley now

I own the poley skin on my old main account but I lost it because one of my classmates stole my password because they saw it when I as logging in on my phone and I want the poley skin to come back no matter what. I will start playing piggy if it returns

As an owner of Poley but lost the acccount, it should stay limited, who even uses him anyways? It’s a mid ass skin anyways. If they added him back but remastered it I would think that’s fine.

Heres my opinion on this! 🤍🖤💙 Personally, as an OG with the Poley skin, I really don't want Poley coming back. I am unsure if Poley is the rarest secret skin (I've seen multiple yt vids stating so, and he's even the FIRST ever, so it is most likely). But anyway, it would ruin the fun of having pretty rare skin. Some skins that are rare, I don't have, but I dont complain either. Personally, it would be unfair and annoying for a rare skin to become available again. At that point, is it really that "rare" anymore? And besides that, I would love to get a second police skin! I've seen how much MiniToons piggy skins have developed, and I think a new police skin would look AWESOME! So yea! I think getting a new skin would be nice for new players too anyway, I mean sure the new players/any player whether is new or not who hasn't gotten poley, would be atleast pleased to get a better designed police skin even if its not as rare. Lastly, i dont think getting a choice would be all that fun because it would just make Poley still not as rare. Some players who are desperate for Poley (most likely thousands) would immediately take Poley. Anyways, that's all! And if you're still reading this, what's your opinion? Bye, bye! ❤

I have an idea which i think would be a much better idea, a criminal skin. Think about it, in the lore doggy, the player, and poley are cops which means there would be FOUR cops in the lore, but no criminal skins to compliment them. Please tell me if you agree.

One day. Make it available for one day. But then again, People are gonna complain that they didn’t get it.💀 Maybe two? Dunno, drama.