How many ASTRO fans are here to support Rocky?

"Where Am I" and "We Still Love You"... These two songs are like the ONE for me, I'm very grateful to Rocky and Eunwoo for writing them... They didn't have to share their personal feelings and terrible pain with us, but they did it... Thank you, boys, whatever happens, whoever wants to separate you, stay together and support each other, like you've always done, and Bin will protect you from the heaven, he loved you so much.

The way Rocky sits still while the whole world keeps moving perfectly describes what grief feels like-being stuck in that emotion, questioning, and processing everything that happened and could have been, and figuring out how to move forward... We still love and continue to love you, our moon.

It's scary when time just stops for you while the whole world is moving and only you're stuck at same place it hurts

rocky's figure freezing all throughout the song but all the cars and everything still passing by like the lyric ‘time scarily passes by even though i'm still in the same place’

Look at the details dandelions😢 its for bin hyung❤

Who's crying? 😭 Thank you Rocky! We still love you Moon Bin-ah!

My dear Rocky, thank you for this beautiful song, it is a very deep and emotional lyric, when I heard it for the first time I couldn't stop crying and today I see this simple video and I cry, your lyrics say a lot and touch the heart , I also felt lost at a time after the departure of Bin, a very special being who touched many hearts, and remembering that hurts me a lot, it is difficult to recover but I have been achieving it little by little. This song "We Still love you" says it all, I look for it in the sky, in the flowers, in the butterflies, in every dandelion that I find on my way, my beautiful Star Angel, we still love you and you still hurt and I will always love you and carry you with me in my heart because you will live forever, until we meet again. You are incredible Rocky, I wish you much success, and I will also support you in everything you do and please take good care of yourself and be happy. an affectionate greeting from a Hamo from Chile

The video seems simple but its message is actually profound. In that moment, everything in the world goes on (the cars are moving) but Rocky's world stays still.

MOONBIN will always in our heart💜💜 Rocky thanks love you🥹🫶🏼

You are so precious Rocky. Thank you for always remembering Binnie. Love you Park Minhyuk 💜

Tu mundo se detuvo ese día Rocky? Aunque no lo creas, a mí también. Aún duele verdad? El por qué te golpea. Es fácil de deducir por el vídeo que aunque se ve simple es profundo para quienes te conocemos desde hace mucho. Siempre ahí para ti, Hamo y Aroha. I love you forever 리키❤❣️✨

And we will love you forever ♡☆ beautiful song for moonbin..

HAMO X AROHA X ASTRO FOREVER 💜❤️ thank you for sharing this wonderful melody! We will always support you ❤❤

Me siento agradecida con todas esas chicas que siguen aquí viendo los videos de Rocky, en serio gracias, gracias por tomar de su tiempo para ver los videos de Rocky, simplemente gracias por apoyarlo

라키야, 노래 진짜 좋다✨ 가사는 너가 직접 만들었지? 이노래 듣고 나에게도 와닿았어.. 나도 너무너무 그를 보고싶고 또 보고싶어 매일매일. 민혁아, 잊지마! 너 혼자가 아니야!! 우리 여기 있어, 널 사랑하는 사람은 항상 네 옆에 있었다고!!!! 많이 힘들땐 털어놔줘, 혼자 삼키지말고, 우리랑 같이 많이 대화하자, 이렇게 음악으로. 노래해줘서 고마워 라키야💜

라키오빠 정말 고마워요 민들레가 참 예쁘네요🌼 소중한 그 사람에게 닿기를...🌙

This song is perfect, We all miss him, and continue to love him. I love you Rocky, fighting!!!! Hamo loves you

문빈때문에 아스트로를 알게되었고 라키를 알게됐어요 진정 음악인 가수네요 노래가 심금을 울리네요 응원합니다

Binnie astro & Rocky forever in our heart arohamo fan base love you and ever Will support you

Astro六位小朋友的感情在煎熬奮鬥互相扶持中，所建立的兄弟情，是一輩子也忘不掉。心疼你們。人生無常，你們五個要好好的，祝褔你們astro。

Thank you Rocky❤ for sharing your feelings. I waited so long to hear them. I know you are hurting in private and in your heart and mind. I think of Moonbin all day everyday and at night, I don't think I'll ever shake the pain of loosing such an amazing person. I didn't even personally know him but my pain is so deep it amazes me me everyday how he's always on my mind. How can this be? I will forever keep Moonbin's memory alive and I hope you will too. Please write a new song for Binnie every single year for his birth date or passing date. We all need to hear your thoughts and care, because it helps us too. We need you to recognize Moonbin forever! I love the song, and I'm sure Moonbin is so touched. Rocky/Moonbin forever! Astro-6 forever!!💜💜😭😭💔💔😪😪⭐⭐ Moonbin is always shining down on you. Love him forever and ever never let it fade and it can happen through writing songs for him, don't stop writing Moonbin love songs, PLEASE! Moonbin FOREVER! We have to keep his memory alive.

It must be so difficult for Rocky, especially because he had just started down a different path. While I have no doubt that ASTRO support Rocky, there’s a layer of distance created by that path. AROHA still love you, too, Rocky.

no matter what, i will always stay by your side my six boys 💜💜💜💜💜💜

Rocky, thank you for making this song and video. We all share the same feeling… miss Bin😢

After listening to this song I just want to give a big hug 🫂

"We still love you" is a song written by Rocky to express his pain and personal feelings, honestly he went through a lot this year. But Rocky never gave up , instead he stayed positive and fought back for us and the past. What did we do to deserve someone so sweet and wonderful like Rocky?? I am so grateful to have someone like him in this world. With his music , I feel like I can see the world in a different way and have some hope towards the future. Rocky , I am sure Bin-ah is watching you from heaven with a great smile on his face and he is very proud of you. Thank you for always staying strong and confident, Hamo will always support you our dear Rocky ❤

I miss Binhyuk/Binky alot😢 thank you for sharing this beautiful song Rocky. It means a lot to me. And I can speak for fans, them too. Stay strong Rocky. Moonbin love you too.

Mi canción favorita del álbum. Gracias por siempre apoyar a ASTRO. Estamos muy agradecidos contigo ROCKY. Siempre estaremos contigo. Y sí, a él lo seguimos amando... y amaremos por siempre.

ten por seguro que también lo seguimos amando y lo extrañamos cada día 🌙🤍

라키ㅠㅠ 무슨 말이라 한들 위로가 되고, 어느누가 그 그리움을 채워줄 수 있을까....ㅠㅠ 항상 응원해ㅠㅠ 어떤 일이 있어도 팬으로 꼭 옆에서 버텨줄게ㅠㅠ 라키의 외침이 빈님에게도 꼭 닿았기를.....ㅠㅠ

None of the ROHA members who know the six members of ASTRO will ever forget Binnie. But you gave us the opportunity to think of him when we listen to the song "We still love you." Thank you. And I will continue to love you, Binnie, and ASTRO.

멜로디도 노래도 너무 좋다. 가사를 보니 딱 떠오르는 한사람..우리 모두 추억하고 기억하고 있는 한사람..너무 보고싶은 사람.. 노래로 느낄수 있게 해줘서 너무 고마워요. 라키 최고..👍

I couldn't prevent myself from crying😢. This is so heartbreaking 💔. We'll miss him and love him for the rest of our lives. We love you Rocky, you are such a great artist💙🫶🏼. Fighting!!!!🫂

Ever since there was an empty spot, I've been afraid to look up at the night sky How are you doing after you leave? What do you see? Are you comfortable there? There's no answer anyway Realization doesn't help much I desperately want to you who used to smile a lot

노래 너무 좋아요 빈이가 더 보고싶은 날이네요

Gracias Rocky por plasmar tan bonito, siempre Binnie con nosotros. Cada minuto del día esta en mi

Hermoso guapo exitoso Rocky. Gracias por éste homenaje al hermoso guapo exitoso de Moon Bin. Dios te bendiga 👏👏👏🤩🙏🫰💜💕😘🙏😇🤴🏻🇲🇽🌹

민혁아 가슴이 먹먹하다ㅠㅠ 오히려 이렇게 경쾌한 멜로디로 해줘서 더 고마워❤우리 모두 행복하자

민혁아, 고마워. 울고 싶지 않은데 아직은 잘 안되네.. 정말 보고싶다.. 우리 함께 기억하고 그리워하며 살아가보자. 민혁이가 다시 노래하고 무대에 서는 모습을 기뻐하며 가장 먼저 응원하고 있을 우리 달일거야. 그치? 우리 라키 사랑해. We still

We still love you rocky & moonbin

This is beautiful Rocky, absolutely beautiful. Thank you for sharing your feelings with us. I’m sure Bin can feel the love you’re sending to him. Bin has and always will hold a special place in many of our hearts. We will never forget him. 🥹

노래가 미치도록 마음아프고 내마음도 그래ㅜㅜ 라키님 빈님과의 좋은추억만 안고 더 빛나게 살아가시길 바래요♡

je vient de voir pour la première foi les paroles en Français et je pleur pleur et pleur encore tes sentiment sont si pur . merci de les avoir partager avec nous . je vous aime tout les deux si fort .

Thank you Rocky by sharing your feelings to the world, our Binnie is definitely smilingly from heaven. He is always by your side.💜

Rocky is Soo talented, BLANK is. Composer of 4 beautiful songs ❤️

Rocky saranghe!!!! BINA I LOVE YOU FOREVER 🌛 💕 ASTRO AROHA FOREVER

Rocky, seguimos amándote al igual que a Binnie, gracias por compartir con el mundo esos hermosos sentimientos, siempre te lo escribo, eres muy talentoso y virtuoso, logras plasmar hermosamente las emociones y sentimientos que compartimos por un ser maravilloso que es ( sí lo escribo así es en presente ) Moonbin, a quien amamos y amare por siempre, 💜💜💜💜💜💜

Rocky aww so beautiful song. I send you a big hug, I understand your pain, I had a similar situation. Time, love and beautiful memories are our best allies. Colombia supports you and loves you. Fighting CEO! You are doing very well. 🫂🫰🍀🇰🇷🇨🇴

함께 성장해왔던 네가 이렇게나 많이 커서 혼자 대견하게 이런 일들을 해내고있다는 걸 빈이가 옆에서 지켜봤다면 참 대견해했을텐데.. 그치.. 너도 잘 알지? 어디서든, 네가 뭘하든 빈이는 네 곁에서 널 지켜보고 뿌듯해하고 자랑스러워하며 활짝 웃고있을거야 많이 그립고 또 아프지만 같이 이겨나가보자 덕분에 또 새로운 노래로 추억할 수 있게됐네 너무 고마워 이렇게 예쁜 곡 내줘서 민혁아 지쳐도, 힘들어도. 언제든 네 곁에 있을게 항상 네편이야 사랑해💗

Такие трогательные, но тёплые слова! Роки, спасибо тебе за них! Мы всегда будем любить нашу Луну!

Hermosa melodía gracias Rocky por esta canción. Bini estaría orgulloso de ustedes. Es muy difícil, el mundo sigue girando y sólo el paso del tiempo ayudará a ir sobrellevando su pronta partida. Bello video. Cuidate mucho y sigue adelante. Te queremos y apoyamos.♥️🐺💜💜💜💜💜💜🙏🇺🇾

이 노래와 가사는 진정한 의미를 지니고 있어요. 정말 아름다운 헌사입니다. 저는 노래가 흐르는 동안 지나가는 민들레 꽃잎들을 좋아합니다. 경치는 정말 멋져요. 그가 당신 옆에 앉아 풍경을 바라볼 수 있었을 거라고 확신합니다. 하지만 걱정하지 마세요, 우리는 그를 쉽게 잊지 않을 겁니다. 사실, 잊는 건 불가능하다고 생각해요. 그는 너무 많은 사람들에게 큰 영향을 주었고, 여전히 영향을 주고 있어요. 지금도 그를 새롭게 발견하는 사람들이 있습니다. 어쨌든, 이 노래는 정말, 정말 아름다워요. 정말 고맙습니다. -------- This song and its lyrics have a true meaning. It's a very beautiful tribute, I love the dandelion petals that pass by during the song. The view is magnificent, I'm sure he could have sat next to you and watched the scenery. But don't worry, we won't forget him anytime soon, in fact, I think it's impossible. He has impacted too many people and continues to do so, there are still people discovering him now. In any case, this song is really, really beautiful, thank you so much.

Siempre será recordado con amor, se encuentra por siempre en nuestros corazones. Lo extrañamos cada día.

Dios mío lloré tanto escuchando este maravilloso tema mirando al cielo Rocky. .oh no soporte. Y es qué todos nuestros hermosos ASTRO. .llevaran x siempre a Moonbin 🤧en su corazón. Dios los bendiga sigan adelante mis chicos hermosos .. siempre seran unos TRIUNFADORES... MOONBIN ASTRO ROCKY... X SIEMPRE..🤧

Rocky🫶 🇰🇷🇲🇫🫰 congratulations 👏👏👏👏👏👏 superbe chanson 🥰🙏🫶

Of course, we'll always love him. Thanks for sharing this song with us, Rocky ♥

Really we still love you moon.....my heart feel a little bad. But I know you aré ok... gracias Rocky un abrazo fuerte a la distancia... bendiciones

Así como “Where Am I” y “We Still Love You” me siento tan identificada con esas canciones 😢por qué así como ellos perdieron a un ser amado yo también lo perdí y apenas cumplió un año de su partida. Le doy gracias a Astro por haberme dado ánimos con sus canciones, así como las canciones de Rocky también me darán ánimos❤️así Rocky aquí te estaremos apoyando 🫶🏻

이 노래를 들으면 내 시간이 멈춰서 눈물이 난다.그리고 라키 씨는 행복했으면 좋겠어요.

I'm so proud of you for taking all the pain caused by Bin's passing and transforming it into this masterpiece.

Rocky we’re all here for you always anytime. Aroha and hamos, we’re all here for each other also! When we feel like crying or missing, we can lean on to each other always. Love you guys all so much 💜🌕⭐️

I loved it, I loved it, it fascinated me, it impressed me, it surprised me, Rocky is the most complete in the industry ❤❤😭

Hermosa cancion para moon bin, gracias Rocky. Exito!!! Fighting

라키야 힘내구.. 항상 곁에서 지켜줄께.. 널 지켜보고 있을 빈이를 생각하며.. 영원히 함께하자..

Gracias ROCKY ❤‍🩹

thank you rocky. we all still love moonbin

Rocky Oppa is this song for uri Moonbin oppa "We still love you" thank you for making an amazing song . Hamo &Aroha love you so much.😊❤

Thank you, Rocky 💜 Aroha is next to you 💜

This song bring me back memories of Moonbin ⭐ Beautiful lyrics. You smile but you feel bad sometimes. Do not worry. Tears are puryfing us and can make us feel better. We are here with you Rocky to comfort you as much as we are able to.

Gracias por haberle dedicado ésta hermosa letra a nuestro amado y gran Moonbin ❤️

You're not alone Rocky. I just know him by the screen, but you spend a long time with him, it must be so hard for you. Even I still crying till now everytime I missed him. We still love him. He still lives in our heart.

Te seguimos amando Binnie.!! Hermosos sentimientos Rocky bellísima cancion💜 I LOVE YOU FOREVER

BEAUTYFUL aún el dolor esta aflor de piel pero la verdad no sesi es bueno o malo pr que no dejaran que el recuerdo de binnie muera si no al contrario SIEMPRE este presente en nuestras vidas Gracias ROCKY por expresar tus bonitos sentimientos eres muy dulce y cariñoso Dios te llene de mucha paz en tu ❤ FOVER MOOROC SARANGHAE 💫💫💜💜💜💜💜💜❤❤❤❤❤❤

No pudo quedar más claro, el sentimiento de la ausencia tan importante. Siento que habla también por Aroha quien también nos duele su ausencia. Rocky eres muy sensible al escribir. Tienes esa magia para transportar los 5 sentidos en cada canción. Música con algo melancólica, letra totalmente explícita el sentimiento es claro y te entiendo. Gracias por compartir tus sentimiento en este tema. Así como cada uno de nuestros Astro lo han hecho.🥹 Te amamos Rocky y te abrazo desde la distancia. Faithing!! Tienes que seguir tu camino al éxito... Aroha te apoya...🤗💜✡️💜🎙️🕺🎼🇲🇽

Gracias por recordarlo con amor

노래 가사가 너무 좋아요. 우리에게 있어 소중한 사람🌼많이 보고 싶네요.. 사랑하고 앞으로도 사랑해요💜

우리모두의 마음을 대신 노래 해 줘서 고마워요..

Wooow excelente canción para mi lunita preciosa ❤🌛

Rocky muchas gracias por compartir con nosotros esta canción… gracias por amar tanto a Bin…. Ojalá la promesa hubiera durado más tiempo…desde el primer momento no dejo de llorar …

Realmente quiero abrazarlo, no imagino como la pasó y como nos compartio el dolor que sigue, te apoyo siempre mi Rocky 🥺💜

Спасибо за этот трек🫶🏻🫰🏻🥺это действительно так "Мы все ещё любим его🌙✨"

이 노래 진짜 좋음… 너무 좋아서 오히려 슬퍼 ㅠㅠㅠ

노래가 우리 팬들에게 와닿았어.. 가사는 라키의 마음 이겠지..? 나도 너무너무 그를 보고싶고 또 보고싶어 매일매일. 너에게 힘내라고는 하지 않을게, 하지만 이건 잊지말아줘. 넌 혼자가 아니라는걸, 라키 옆엔 팬들이 있어....! 바로 여기 있어. 힘들때에는 혼자 참고 마음을 억누르지 말고 주변사람에 털어 놓아도 돼😊

라키❤항상 널 응원해 노래 너무 조타.. 빈이를 향한 마음은 모두들 다 제자리걸음인것 같아..

My sweet Moonlight 🌕💎 That day the light went away with you.. My heart and mind can't understand it 💔

Как же я люблю эту песню! Большое спасибо Роки за неё!

라키랑 똑같은 맘. 라키가 독립하고 혼자 해야 할 일도 많고 또 보여줘야 하는 삶도 살아내야 하니 얼마나 힘듦을 삭힐 시간도 없이 힘들까 생각했는데. 그럼에도 묵묵히 열심히 네 모습을 보여줘서 참 대견하다 싶다. 맘의 돌덩이와 그리움을 남기고 묵묵히 라키의 길을 걸어가는 모습에 맘이 짠하다. 그치만 항상 라키 뒤에는 이 많은 팬들이 있으니까. 같이 슬퍼하고 아파하고 기뻐해 줄 팬들이 있으니까 항상 힘내길 라키야~ 고맙고 사랑해 럭키라키~

We Arohas still love Rocky, Cha Eunwoo, Jinjin, Shana, MJ and Moonbin forever!

Rocky Hamo está contigo ... Te amo demasiado kisiera abrazarte fuerte y decirte n estás solo ❤❤

이 곡을 만드는 것도 표현하는 것도 분명 매우 힘들었지. 당신과 멤버의 생각은 반드시 천국에 도착했다고 생각합니다. 매우 힘든 중전을 향해 우리 앞에 모습을 보여 주셔서 감사합니다. 너와 뭄빈, 멤버 여러분의 행복을 진심으로 기원합니다 🍀

너무 고마워요 라키, 가슴속에 남을 추억이에요.❤❤❤❤❤

❤ Aqui escuchando esta hermosa ❤ canción a mi LUNITA MONBIN💜🐺🌙❤️✨🩵😭❤️

I'm crying, thanks Rocky for this song for our Moon, we all miss him and love him so much 😭💜 a big hug from Chile!

Catchy song with a sad, heartbreaking lyrics

라키 고마워요.가사를 보고 너무 울었어요.너무 힘들어.그런데 살아가야 돼.보고싶은 마음, 소중한 마음, 너무 좋아하는 마음 잊지 않고 계속 여기에 소중하게 안을게요.

Abrazo para el corazón 🫂🥹

Even though it's a bright day, it still feels sentimental, with the image of a moving car but you sitting quietly next to an empty chair, as well as the details of flying dandelions making it very beautiful. I thought this song didn't have an MV, but you gave it to us along with its very beautiful lyrics. Thank you Rocky. I hope you can find comfort and we will always love you no matter what…. Fighting Rocky-ya,,, I love U

I still cried when I heard the song. Always miss and love him 🌙✨❤ Thank you so much to make this song❤️

The song, the lyrics and the video broke my soul, so brave for sharing this with us Rocky 💜