YES!

Well said

The only people that are sick or the zionists that pretend they are semites but yet they converted to Judaism

The lunatic is on the Grass

Me too for ever

He is a useless, stupid old fool ...nuff said.

Yh, just ruined it

@@jaycristoval6155 and me

And me. I only play a Momentary Lapse and the Division Bell now. What a pathetic old man....

It's humiliating especially when you claim your God will bring the righteous victory

L'chaim, my Hebrew name Jacova is the female form of Jacob. Muhammad thought he could subjugate God and every soul on earth to his perversions.

Right/wrong? Depends on what u think is right. If u think that u need others to join ur group in order to b considered human, then ur right/wrong is just as dangerous. It’s y entire Americas were taken over violently. Doesn’t matter what d excuses were. Extermination is not humane.

An Israeli historian and Zionist (name escapes me at the moment) quoted an Ottoman leader lambasting the Arabs for the shame of losing to loser Jews, who Muslims had become accustomed to abusing at will. Mohammed, I don't need to reiterate his views on Jews who rejected him as Prophet.

@@RojaJaneman Amigo. God nor Archangel Gabriel spoke to Muhammad. Are you seriously going to spit in the face of Jesus. Moses, Jacob and Abraham for the dick search of Muhammad. God is my Father and rabbi. Where do you live?

He can be a good singer but he doesn’t have any history books what so ever ! What do you expect from a dump singer !

Do you think the white Jews came from Israel / Palestine you are out of your mind... They converted to Judaism under Charlemagne so in reality they are the real anti-semites

You people are obviously delusional self-righteous hypocrites

It's fatal stupidity. really

He never had any plot.

been an antisemite a viscious one for at least 30 years...

@@extanegautham8950 He's very lucky Jews aren't like the violent barbarian IslamoNazis he supports, or he would be six feet under.

He did that a long time ago. Never had the plot really. His parents were anti western active communists

If speaking the truth makes you that then a large part of the world is just that then

You are the ones completely lost you don't even know your own identity... The white Jews are fake Jews

It's also well-documented that he was a narcissistic bully towards his fellow Pink Floyd band members. Even David Gilmour called out Roger Water's anti-Semitism.

🤣

I would’ve probably taken a lot of drugs, too. LOVE Syd. Loathe Waters.

Do you actually know what indigenous means? Zionism was an ideology born in Europe, and the first Zionist jews who settled in Palestine came from Europe. They even described themselves as colonisers, but you’re telling me they’re indigenous as well? Not the people who had already been living there for generations? A religious belief about your ancestors living there 2,000 years ago doesn’t make you indigenous, regardless of how true that story could be.

@ryokan9120 Like all of his ilk, he believes that Israelis deserved being masssacred, and like all of those who deny the truth, that no one was raped, tortured, and mutilated.

❤

The Dar. K side of the moon😅

Yes, the class room that he wanted all young people to reject.

​@@sharonreichter2537well said . That track was a terrible message to the young.

He doesn't care. That's the answer. I have a feeling that early in his career a Jew helped give Pink Floyd their first break and it pisses him off that the person took a good chunk of money for his services. Like everyone else in the business. That or as a child his family's landlord was Jewish. Haven't listened to Pink Floyd in a decade because of him and I won't ever again despite my fandom for David Gilmour.

@@gheller2261 This was painful to watch. I hope at the very least it exposes him for what he is.

@@gheller2261 I still listen to PF and will not let Waters ruin their great music for me. By the way, back in 2014 or a bit earlier, I remember reading an article about David Gilmour and he also was part of the Free Palestine movement. He was wearing a t-shirt with the slogan in the photo from the article. Not sure where he stands now but just so you know - Waters is not the only one.

I wonder what he would say if they all moved to England.

😮

Disgusting

😆

Which education? It’s not like ours is true

​@@RojaJanemanYou need an education in music history if you didn't get the joke.

@@extemporaneous4545 who’s music? Western? Not a fan 😒

@@RojaJaneman If you read a lot of the comments here, you will see that a lot of people are referencing this line. It is a cultural benchmark. Just give it a listen. Another Brick In The Wall Part 2 by Pink Floyd. Even if you don't get blown away, it will help you to understand this reference if it ever comes up again.

by the wall, the rest of the band couldnt stand him

@chatify68 that's putting it lightly, he is a vicious anti Semitic piece of garbage.

They are considered somehow purer than politicians, or even people in think tanks who receive money from vested interests, because supposedly they have no skin in the game. They might have no skin, but they themselves are the walking vested interests, because a lot of them are very much vested in their own egos and their own opinions at the expense of the facts.

@@extemporaneous4545 exactly. Rockstars eventually deteriorate into megalomaniacs.

Probably because he's making too much sense LOL

With lunático imposible to make any sense. Let them talk

Yeah netanyahu

Yes, Zionism

VILE, EVIL Zionists LIVE behind a VEIL of ignorance.

@@MrSigtrx You're just another brick in the wall

@@American-BadAss732 Hello, is there anybody in there?

Of course not, MsStack. Not unless your mindset leads you to feel that way. I've been solidly conservo since a tyke, as an early reader and growing up in the sixties and seventies, with lots of issues where conservo editorials made solid point after point as lefty policies piled up in both decades. When I finally heard classic rock, after only hearing top 10 stuff in my childhood, Floyd and others became faves. Most are like Waters, solidly on the left. I simply accepted that, along with accepting it with authors who feel that way. Mind, when I find writers who feel as I do and i also like their writing, it makes me feel good.

I learned about Roger Waters racism about twenty years ago, and it was a huge letdown. Just remember, he was kicked out of Pink Floyd and David Gilmore is a first class humanitarian and pro-Israel!

Waters showed ZERO emotion or empathy for the Nova Festival victims tortured, terrorized, brutally gang raped, wounded and slaughtered in cold blood and taken hostage. Nor for the peaceful Kibbutzim citizens

Waters is another DR. FRANKENSTEIN

HEY WATERS, Israeli lives matter

What does that do? You already bought them

Yeah and people that support Israel and Zionism in general have lost any common sense... You must be completely self-righteous and hypocritical

@@ca8944so what's your point exactly ? Lol

@@carmenismyname sorry auto correct. I fixed it. If you already bought the albums, throwing them away does nothing.

Don't chuck your albums away, his bandmates couldn't tolerate his BS either. He's just another Prick in the Wall. 😄

😂

I have been shocked by Water's commentary. I saw Pink Floyd twice & his anti-Semitism upsets me to no end. I'm so glad Gilmour isn't supporting Water's hatred!

@@donnawatson2443 Gilmour is fantastic. He's just a mellow old guy making beautiful music. The new song he released with his daughter is fantastic. She has an amazing voice 😍

the rest of the band got tired of singing about the things that only roger cared about they saw it as stifling their creativity look at the commercial success of the band post roger

@@lesweizman388 absolutely. He just became so toxic . He also downplayed the contributions of the other musicians, saying that they were nothing without him. I'd say without Gilmour and his brilliant guitar work Watters would be nothing.

@@user-tf3jl8dd7qnot to forget Richard Wright. Actually David Gilmour and Richard Wright were the real musical talents in the band and essentially the ones responsible for the Pink Floyd sound that was the base for their success - no surprise Roger fell out with both of them. Obviously out of envy which interestingly is also the main motivation of Antisemitism in general and most probably as well in his case.

Because the Palestinians are the people that were already living there (indigenous) and the Zionist Jews were overwhelmingly colonisers who came from elsewhere (not indigenous). Yes, 2,000 years ago Palestine was inhabited mostly by Jews and Samaritans, and that’s because the Palestinian people used to be Jews and Samaritans. Over time, they converted to Christianity, then Islam, and gradually adopted an Arab cultural identity. The people who call themselves Jews today are largely converts that are indigenous to the lands they migrated from (Europe, North Africa, Yemen, Ethiopia, etc). So your whole premise is based on a misunderstanding. The Palestinians are the direct descendants of the ancient Judeans. The Jews of today are at best, only partially descended if at all.

​​​@@elliotcactus4895try telling a Palestinian that they're just Jews that converted to Islam. Try saying it to their face. Fortunately we have genetic testing. The Palestinian people are more closely related, ethnically, to the people of Jordan and Egypt. Their last names are Arabic and Egyptian, not Hebrew. Why would that be? There's possible admixture there, but to say that Palestinians are the direct descendants of the ancient Israelites due to some admixture would be like saying Jews are white due to some admixture with Europeans. Oh, that was what you actually thought? DNA of both Ashkenazi and Mizrahi Jews can be traced to the Levant, which would not be possible if the Ashkenazi are just later converts. Then you run into the small issue that the modern population of Jews in Israel is majority Mizrahi anyway, so that argument that israelis are European colonizers is extremely weak.

@@ophelia.artaud that’s funny because the genetic studies I’ve seen find Palestinians to be much more closely related to the ancient populations of that region than todays Jews are. One study I recall found Palestinians to derive somewhere between 80-90% of their ancestry from Bronze Age Levantine people. No studies have ever found anything like that for Jews, and quite often it’s just partial “near eastern ancestry” which isn’t necessarily Levantine. Judaism spread throughout the world as result of proselytism, not by a mass expulsion by the Romans. The Romans only exiled enslaved prisoners, while the majority of the Jewish population continued to live in Palestine, converting to Christianity and Islam in later centuries and adopting an Arab cultural identity (hence the Arabic names). Meanwhile, in other parts of the world, there were numerous cases of jewish proselytism in places like North Africa, Yemen, Ethiopia, Kurdistan, the Roman Empire, and in Eastern Europe, which created large populations of Jewish converts. This is why Jews from Eastern Europe look Eastern European, and Jews from Ethiopia look Ethiopian. Ashkenazi Jews are indigenous to Eastern Europe and Ethiopian Jews are indigenous to Ethiopia. They might be of the same religion but they aren’t the same people. They certainty aren’t indigenous to Palestine.

@@elliotcactus4895 ok, so why does every single Google result refer to Palestinians as an ARAB ethnonational group? Forget the Arabic names. Why do they only speak Arabic? It's not like Arab conquest led to natives Persians or native Turks in their regions completely forgetting they speak Persian or Turkish, they also did not get new Arabic names. So why would that only happen to the converts of Palestine? Why do they themselves claim to be Arabs? Especially when Palestinian leaders are making appeals to other Arabic nations (see: Hamas to Egypt) also, Ashkenazi do all have unifying characteristics that have always served as antisemitic tropes, but now you wanna deny that and act like Jews in Europe look like any other European? They don't, and that's historically been a VERY BAD THING. You're a new age antisemite so of course the closer to European you can pretend Jews are, the better for your agenda. No. They've always been distinct from the populations they've lived amongst EVEN if there has been admixture with the local population. This is something that is common is diasporas, see: African Americans.

@@elliotcactus4895 my comment was deleted. I looked at a couple Google results and I did find some good studies that show Jews and Palestinians are each other's closest genetic relatives, which makes it even more f**ked up that you are trying to completely negate the Jews of Europe from having any ties to the middle east, they have European admixture but no they are not wholly indistinguishable from Europeans. If that were true it would have probably made the whole hiding Jewish families from the Nazis thing a lot easier. Palestinians aren't pure though either, they have DNA from the Arabian Peninsula from later migrations to the region. Also gonna say once again that your whole argument ignores the Mizrahi Jews that make up the majority of Jews in Israel.

Apparently yes, I've noticed a pattern among all these "liberals" from the U.K. the first one to demonstrate this was Miriam Margolys then Vanessa Redgrave in 1978.

It's the left, from many supposedly civilized countries, that spout this ignorant racism. There are many good people in the UK, most of whom are going to vote Reform.

Although the majority of people are not antisemitic in the UK, the Jew hatered comes from three places. The upper classes who regard Jews as vulgar, Unity Mitford married Mosley and Edward 8th had to abdicate because of affiliation with Hitler. The far Left wing who feel betrayed as they supported Jewish people and Israel after the Holocaust, but couldn't stand that Jews started to do well and become successful, because they like minorities to be victims. The third group of antisemites are sometimes from Irish or Scottish decent, as there's a strong Catholic tradition of Jew hatred.

Zionism in Judaism are like oil and water and if you watch the video with Rabbi Shapiro on trt world explaining it you'd see things a little differently

I'm sorry to say, as a British person, that Antisemitism has increased exponentially in the last few years. Much of this Antisemitism is propagated by far-left students, left-wing academics, and a rapidly increasing Muslim population. They also use the Palestine conflict and old-fashioned conspiracy theories to justify their Antisemitism. It really is thoroughly depressing!

Why are people asking for your DNA test?

because they believe Ashkenazi Jews are tall Slavic/Germanic fair skinned blonds with no ties to the ME and no amount of evidence to the contrary will convince them otherwise. it's a prominent race theory among "anti Zionist" Jew haters. It's basically 180 degrees from what the old 19-20 century European anti-Semites thought about Jews. Jew hatred always finds new ways.

@@ruslanotarov9727because they want to accuse her of being Jewish, because they think that’s a bad thing.

I’m sorry this happens to you :( these people are shameless and ignorant.

@@ruslanotarov9727 because many anti Zionists claim Ashkenazi Jews are white Europeans who have nothing to do with the Levant, and no amount of evidence can convince the otherwise. It's a kind of a weird racial obsession

Hamas has experts in shrinking his head...

It's still on Acid

😅😂😅😂

It was a a trance festival; I’m not sure if those even have live music.

😅😂😅😂

???

@eadams902 Water’s DNA originate from the dark side of the moon

Roman and German Hapsburg. Look at his nose and MASSIVE chin. Both antisemitic races.

@@user-pe5qy1zw6y 😂😂

😂

Today in a world of social media, that's impossible. They're lining up to show you every wart and sound you every fart.

The Devil Went Down to Georgia.

,.,.,.,.,.,.,