Asalaamu Alaykum brother, you have any Aqwaal of the Ulamah concerning the Athar attributed to Ibn Abbas(Ra) where he said" هو به كفر .

Ya Akh Ibrahim, InshaAllah when is the video of an Ashari lying on Ibn Abdul Barr will come out?

to know an Islamic gov, learn what's Islam or a Muslim. A man with exceeding white clothes and black hair came to the Prophet peace and blessings on him and said what is Islam? And the 5 pillars were mentioned - Shahadatain, 5 salat, Fasting in Ramadan, Zakat and Hajj! - This guides the Community! Then was asked what is Iman/faith? - 6 pillars were mentioned, Beleif in Allah, His Angels, His Books, His Prophet/Messengers, The Last Day and the Qadr or Divine Decree. - This guides the individual. Then was asked what is Ihsan? - It is to worship Allah knowing He sees you as though you see him. Then is goes into the signs of the last day, though not mentioned in this hadith its the kawarij being with dajjal - and the kawarij will be refuted here - In sha Allah. ~~~ An Islamic state is run by a Muslim, Who upholds 5 pillars of Islam and 6 pillars of Iman which is in a way linked to the first pillar of Islam. proof: Ibn Umar said to Qadriya your deeds won't be accepted. Taf. Ibn Kathir says Ibn Abbas on Qur'an 5 :44 - if you affirm the law and then error even on desire, it is fisq or minor disbelief. 2 sign of Second pillar is calling of the Athan, - If the Athan was heard the Sahabas Radiyallahu anhum would not invade. This matches the hadith don't fight your rulers as long as they pray. Narrated Humaid: Anas bin Malik said, "Whenever the Prophet (ﷺ peace and blessings on him) went out with us to fight (in Allah's cause) against any nation, he never allowed us to attack till morning and he would wait and see: *if he heard Adhan he would postpone the attack and if he did not hear Adhan he would attack them.* "Anas added, "We reached Khaibar at night and in the morning when he did not hear the Adhan for the prayer, he (the Prophet ) rode and I rode behind Abi Talha and my foot was touching that of the Prophet. The inhabitants of Khaibar came out with their baskets and spades and when they saw the Prophet (ﷺ peace and blessings on him) they shouted 'Muhammad! By Allah, Muhammad and his army.' When Allah's Messenger (ﷺ peace and blessings on him) saw them, he said, "Allahu-Akbar! Allahu-Akbar! Khaibar is ruined. Whenever we approach a (hostile) nation (to fight), then evil will be the morning of those who have been warned." Sahih al-Bukhari 610, Call to Prayers (Adhaan) ... So in this sense this is the Minimum outward Muslim state. The rest is Ihsan and corrected by Dawa! 3 Zakat was collected, Yes Abu Bakr fought the people who withheld Zakat however among some of them was Musailimah al Dajjal and was Zakat given personally during Uthman Radiyallahu anhu's time? 4 Fasting is a special act of worship with Allah that one does personally. 5 Hajj is only done in Saudiyah. On the authority of Tameem ibn Aus ad-Daree (ra): The Prophet (ﷺ peace and blessings be on him) said, “The deen (religion) is naseehah (advice, sincerity).” “To Allah, His Book, His Messenger, *and to the leaders of the Muslims and their common folk.”* - Sahih Muslim 55, Kitab Iman. The Leaders and common folk were separated due to mannerisms of dawa to them being separate! There are the 5 protected pillars in Shariah - Din, Life, Mind, Family and Wealth. ~~~ For a judge, if ijtihad is correct its 2 rewards, if he is wrong he gets one reward. - so after affirming the law, if they error they still get a reward, so its not an Aqida issue... Allah rewards those who strive. 3 common doubts they use. A1) Deals with non Muslims rulers B1) Using customs of people. C1) Sahabas Rebelled Answers A2) Prophet Muhammad peace and blessings on him did make deals with non Muslims like Hudaibiyah or in Medina, Qur'an 8 :72 etc. B2) Customs if they don't oppose other aspects of shari'a are ok and even apart of basic fiqh. Modern example, traffic lights! Ancient example in divorce customs is used for some of the payments... - so are the kawarij going to say marriage is not apart of Islamic law - when marriage is half our din? C2) By Ijma Muhajirun & Ansar didn't teach rebellion, this is ijma Sahaba Dalil in Quran 9 :100! Ibn Abbas said to kawarij there is no sahaba among you. - Al Hakim Mustadark 2/163 , also in : Islamic Aqidah & it's history , by Muhammad Aman al Jami. There would be two groups (bayas) in my Ummah, and there would emerge another group (Kawarij - seceding itself from both), and the party nearer to the truth (Ali) among the two would k*ll them (Khawarij). - Sahih Muslim 1065, Book of Zakat Husain & ibn Zubayr are note Muhajirun or Ansar & didn't revolt & excused! This shows how colosally ignorant the kawarij are! ~~~ Sum : Islam gov. is by a Muslim holding to 6 pillars of Iman, affirms sharia in whole as Iman in Qur'an, incl. deals of rulers (hudaibiya) & customs (nika), ruling errors don't negate Iman (Ibn Abbas Q 5 :44), & call to salat via Athan is minimum via salaf! Rest is "Ihsan" in a sense or perfection corrected by dawa and not kawarij bida sin fighting. There is ijma (Qur'an 9 :100 Muhajirun & Ansar) not to rebel against a Muslim ruler, even if they take over. Muhammad صلى الله عليه وسلم said: You should listen to and obey your ruler even if he was a Ethiopian (slave)....... and Hadith continues. - Bukhari 7142.

Asalam Alayk, to know an Islamic gov, learn what's Islam or a Muslim. A man with exceeding white clothes and black hair came to the Prophet peace and blessings on him and said what is Islam? And the 5 pillars were mentioned - Shahadatain, 5 salat, Fasting in Ramadan, Zakat and Hajj! - This guides the Community! Then was asked what is Iman/faith? - 6 pillars were mentioned, Beleif in Allah, His Angels, His Books, His Prophet/Messengers, The Last Day and the Qadr or Divine Decree. - This guides the individual. Then was asked what is Ihsan? - It is to worship Allah knowing He sees you as though you see him. Then is goes into the signs of the last day, though not mentioned in this hadith its the kawarij being with dajjal - and the kawarij will be refuted here - In sha Allah. ~~~ An Islamic state is run by a Muslim, Who upholds 5 pillars of Islam and 6 pillars of Iman which is in a way linked to the first pillar of Islam. proof: Ibn Umar said to Qadriya your deeds won't be accepted. Taf. Ibn Kathir says Ibn Abbas on Qur'an 5 :44 - if you affirm the law and then error even on desire, it is fisq or minor disbelief. 2 sign of Second pillar is calling of the Athan, - If the Athan was heard the Sahabas Radiyallahu anhum would not invade. This matches the hadith don't fight your rulers as long as they pray. Narrated Humaid: Anas bin Malik said, "Whenever the Prophet (ﷺ peace and blessings on him) went out with us to fight (in Allah's cause) against any nation, he never allowed us to attack till morning and he would wait and see: *if he heard Adhan he would postpone the att*ck and if he did not hear Adhan he would.* "Anas added, "We reached Khaibar at night and in the morning when he did not hear the Adhan... Sahih al-Bukhari 610, Call to Prayers (Adhaan) ... So in this sense this is the Minimum outward Muslim state. The rest is Ihsan and corrected by Dawa! 3 Zakat was collected, Yes Abu Bakr fought the people who withheld Zakat however among some of them was Musailimah al Dajjal and was Zakat given personally during Uthman Radiyallahu anhu's time? 4 Fasting is a special act of worship with Allah that one does personally. 5 Hajj is only done in Saudiyah. On the authority of Tameem ibn Aus ad-Daree (ra): The Prophet (ﷺ peace and blessings be on him) said, “The deen (religion) is naseehah (advice, sincerity).” “To Allah, His Book, His Messenger, *and to the leaders of the Muslims and their common folk.”* - Sahih Muslim 55, Kitab Iman. The Leaders and common folk were separated due to mannerisms of dawa to them being separate! Narrated Abu Wail: Someone said to Usama, "Will you not talk to this (Uthman)?" Usama said, "I talked to him (secretly) without being the first man to open an sharr door... - Bukhari 7098, Book of Afflictions/fitan, & Muslim, book of heart softening hadith Shaqiq! There are the 5 protected pillars in Shariah - Din, Life, Mind, Family and Wealth. ~~~ For a judge, if ijtihad is correct its 2 rewards, if he is wrong he gets one reward. - so after affirming the law, if they error they still get a reward, so its not an Aqida issue... Allah rewards those who strive. Common doubts they use. A1) Deals with non Muslims rulers B1) Using customs of people. C1) Working for non Muslim Ruler D1) Sahabas Rebelled Answers A2) Prophet Muhammad peace and blessings on him did make deals with non Muslims like Hudaibiyah or in Medina, Qur'an 8 :72 etc. B2) Customs if they don't oppose other aspects of shari'a are ok and even apart of basic fiqh. Modern example, traffic lights! Ancient example in divorce customs is used for some of the payments... - so are the kawarij going to say marriage is not apart of Islamic law - when marriage is half our din? C2) Surah 12 Yusef : 54 & 55, Yusef worked in Egypt as a councellor, etc. D2) By Ijma Muhajirun & Ansar didn't teach rebellion, this is ijma Sahaba Dalil in Quran 9 :100! Ibn Abbas said to kawarij there is no sahaba among you. - Al Hakim Mustadark 2/163 , also in : Islamic Aqidah & it's history , by Muhammad Aman al Jami. There would be two groups (bayas) in my Ummah, and there would emerge another group (Kawarij - seceding itself from both), and the party nearer to the truth (Ali) among the two would k*ll them (Khawarij). - Sahih Muslim 1065, Book of Zakat Husain & ibn Zubayr are note Muhajirun or Ansar & didn't revolt & excused! This shows how colosally ignorant the kawarij are! ~~~ Sum : Islam gov. is by a Muslim holding to 6 pillars of Iman, affirms sharia in whole as Iman in Qur'an, incl. deals of rulers (hudaibiya) & customs (nika), ruling errors don't negate Iman (Ibn Abbas Q 5 :44), & call to salat via Athan is minimum via salaf! Rest is "Ihsan" in a sense or perfection corrected by dawa and not kawarij bida sin fighting. There is ijma (Qur'an 9 :100 Muhajirun & Ansar) not to rebel against a Muslim ruler, even if they take over. Muhammad صلى الله عليه وسلم said: You should listen to and obey your ruler even if he was a Ethiopian (slave)....... and Hadith continues. - Bukhari 7142. ~~~

@@enigmaticalmystery4647 Have a look in this إن شاء الله kzfaq.info/get/bejne/g9OhgaiH0pyvl4U.html

‏جزاك الله خير

yes its called hotseat podcast, takfir

Bro the leaders or today don't just "not rule by shariah". Rather they have totally removed shariah and replaced it with a completely different law(un law, French law, english law, tribal law etc) ... Their situation is comparable to that of the mongols who claimed to be Muslims but ibn taymiyyah encouraged to wage j against them as they ruled by their own tribal laws😊

@@aarizshaikh9724 But didn't Najashi act even as a secret Muslim? Didn't Marwan do the khutbah in different order on Eid day? How much removing changes it from beyond a major sin. Quran 5.47 says who don't rule by sharia is a fasiq. Keep in mind prophet Muhammad peace and blessings be upon him waited for the athan being missed before going to kaibar, so isn't the athan along with a Muslim ruler who believes in hadith Jibril the minimum to recognize a Muslim state?

@@aarizshaikh9724 “they have totally removed the Shari’ah” this is a disgusting lie. In almost every if not every Muslim country, prayer is established in the masjid. So that is Shari’a then. Done. Argument crumbled already.

⁠@@Fulaan7So the UK by your logic has full sharia. Argument crumbled already.

@@IrjaRepeller no because prayer in the UK is not established by a governmental entity. Rather it is done by Muslims from their own accord.

Ofcourse tadlees and thareef.

wa alaykomus-salam wa rahmato Allahi wa barakatuh

every unjust takfir comes back to oneself. This is very scary. Imagine doing all this takfir but you pray, fast, give zakat. Then you stand before Allah, the most high, as a disbeliever because you couldn‘t hold your tongue. a3udhubillah

@@AbdurrahmanAlKurdi theres a hadith a man says a word and he ends up 0 years in depth, just falling into hell last I checked... another is that a man says a word small to him but great with Allah and is....

@@AbdurrahmanAlKurdi The Ulema regard this only for the one who doesn’t have any Ta’wil for the Takfir

Ibn abbas is the sahabi of prophet S

It is in Tafsir at-Tabari

@@vcdrrj Yes but which volume and which page?