I just want to clear one thing as it came up in the reaction. The bombs bhagat singh used weren't actual bombs, they just produced sound and smoke no one was injured during these bombs. Thus the quote "make the deaf hear"

So many indian movies are oscar worthy but this was beyond oscar .. a true painful historical story 💔 😢 it penitrates your heart ...glad you guys reacted to it.

Indians LOVED this movie!! Its rated really high in IMDB.. I can assure most Indians cried watching this masterpiece 😔🙏

No Suraj indian people love this movie i dont know where did you read that but suraj you're wrong We love this movie

To the white shirt guy on the right: I am an Indian and I freaking love the movie! Dont be so judgemental or generalise things. It's a country of billion population for f sake.

You know what's the worst part? The Indian oscar committee rejected it to represent a movie from India at the oscars because it would "apparently induce hatred and biasness towards the British"!🤦

Thank you for reacting to this, it’s important to share movies and real life events that occurred with others.

I understand that u never lived in India and that your impression of India is probably that of your parents, but a lot of films of today's Bollywood are just like Hollywood and a lot of Indians like them. Not all movies are like bahubali

Suraj: I hope they go back to 1919. Movie: Don't worry, Suraj. Suraj: I almost don't wanna see it. Movie: No backsies.

Suraj what year do you think we Indians live in? Edit not all Indians like movies with music, and Bollywood isn't the only cinema. If you guys want to know more react to Shashi Taroor speech.

21:37 buddy i expect you to know this, this is our history, Legend Sir Bhagat singh, didn't want anybody to get hurt so he threw the bomb in diff direction, he gave the naara(voice) "Ki agar ye sarkar behri ho gayi hai, use uthane or jagane ke liye ye awaj(explosion sound) kiya hai hmne" these are not exact words, but something almost like this. So, he was a revolutionary as he said in the movie.

indians didn't like this movie because it has no music , wtf didn't expect this kind of stereotype from content creators. What era do you think we indians are living in??Really disppointed from you all for this bias.

"Indian ppl didn't like the film coz no singing dancing" What is more IRRITATING is that there's a whole market of foreigners interested in understanding India on youtube, while these 2nd gen or 3rd gen NRI desi people will display a full fledged event of how they dislike their desi identity. Their desi heritage probably embarrasses them, the means/media they use to inform themselves about India are not of help either. I'm pretty sure the little idea they have about India is through those biased sources like vox/the guardian/NY times/VICE. These sources gonna say India is actually on pluto, and they're gonna believe it. I have liked suraj in so many other videos, he's smart, but god he is ignorant about India. This hasn't been the first time Suraj has randomly said some dumb stuff about India. I don't really care about mickey, since he's a lost cause, never liked him & I wouldn't expect him to know anything about the Indian subcontinent. But Suraj was the one I liked, I expected better from him. I'm not interested in watching this channel anymore. It's ironic that these 2 desis were spreading misinformation, while the other two non-desis knew MORE THAN them _(when they mentioned Don & 3 idiots, both movies being around 15yrs old)._ I don't know why SO MANY 2nd/3rd gen NRIs behave like that, it must be related to the image they have of India & the self hate that comes with that. If you guys are reading this, it's absolutely fine if you don't care about your desi heritage( you probably hate it), it's fine if it's not attractive to you. BUT PLEASE, FOR THE LOVE OF GOD, STOP trying to speak for India with your random inaccurate information. Just say that you don't know much about your desi heritage, DON'T go on word vomitting just because you can do that since your parents were from the subcontinent. If you're a foreigner, then act like one. DON'T misuse the name sake desi qualification to claim the right to speak for India, you don't have that right.

The soldiers were from Baluch and ghurka regiments who didn’t really have much connection with the Indians I heard that British were very specific in using soldiers from different regions to attack on different places literally divide and rule

If you planning on watching another bollywood movie i am sure you would definitely enjoy "andhadhun" it fits the bill for you guys, it has 2 or 3 songs but trust it, it's a good film and people in India loved sardar udam i don't think there was even a single negative review from critics as well as from audience that was a wrong info given to you

"WE MAY FORGIVE BUT WE WILL NEVER FORGET!!" British needs to give the details of 40 trillion dollars of property looted from India and the 35 millions+ people they killed for 200 years in India.

A very important movie loved by all Indians ! I am really shocked at your ignorance Suraj and Mickey - I rarely comment but I had to - a lot of Indian movies now centered around important topics don’t have any songs and dances but people love and adore them regardless .. Pink, Village Rockstars etc and many more are such amazing and important movies - much before those topics were even picked in Hollywood … and some of them have the same production value as Sardar Udham too … you seriously don’t believe it’s IMDB rating is 8.8 because of the foreign viewers. Please brush up your facts because you are spreading wrong information. Your presumptuousness is what spreads stereotypes. Imagine people watching this and assuming the same.

Facts Indians love this movie , suraj . You might be confused with international ratings and reviews caused it showed real side of British East india company. But in fact it's still one of the higher imbd rated movie . Not over emotional or not national proud cringy type just straight facts I see people get hurt it didn't get Oscar , folks it's doesnt need an Oscar or a cringy European award to make it worthwhile . We love it 😍 Loved your guys reaction . I hope all those NRIs and other who have spread thier roots away from india realise what we /past generations went through and take pride in rep india in foreign lands .

21:39 There are many things you won't agree or think is right in this now carefree world. But I bet no one in the current world would be able to endure 10 percent of what these people went through at that time. And they did what was needed to be done. Be it wrong or not. There's a saying in Mahabharat the epic, "Sometimes you have to do something wrong for the greater good." And still the bombs they threw were thrown in a place where no one was present. It only produced sound and smoke and no real damage. When throwing a real one at their faces might've shown them much earlier, that we don't fear them. But Bhagat Singh still thought about their lives and instead chose to do something symbolic without harming people.

Never heard anyone say they didn't like this because it has no musical numbers lol. Only seen a few people say they didn't like the non linear narration, but it's a rare opinion. I'm a French fan of Indian cinema, here are a few suggestions for you guys: *Super Deluxe* (Tamil, hyperlink movie that will blow your mind 😊) *Kumbalangi Nights* (Malayalam, a unique drama) *Sarpatta Parambarai* (Tamil, boxing movie based on real events) *Udta Punjab* (Hindi, drama/dark comedy about drugs in Punjab) *Minnal Murali* (1st super hero movie of Malayalam cinema, released last December) *My Name Is Khan* (Hindi, social drama) *Zindagi Na Milegi Dobara* (Hindi, comedy drama/road trip) *Andhadhun* (Hindi, thriller/dark comedy) *KGF* (Kannada, action/masala) *Baahubali 1&2* (Telugu, medieval epic/fantasy)

Fantastic choice for movie night ! The friend that Shaheed Udham Singh was referring to at the end was not God but Shaheed Bhagat Singh. Shaheed Udham Singh had more faith in love than religion, that's why during the court proceedings he asked for a book titled 'Heer', which is a poetic love story by Waris Shah, instead of any religious book. This film was released directly on Amazon Prime, it did not have a theatrical release so we can't really assume that it wasn't loved by Indians. This movie had a lot of good foreign actors, most of it is in English, but that was just to give it a very authentic look. This film may have a Hollywood feel, but it is very much an Indian film. The writer, director, producer, editor, cinematographer, music composer of this film are Indians. Thank you very much for watching this film. I really hope you watch more Indian films, and in future, please make sure to have Chris and Rana as well. There was another film released last year, apart from this, which could have been sent to the Oscars as India's Official Entry, but wasn't unfortunately, it's called 'The Great Indian Kitchen'. It's a Malayalam language film (from Kerala), but it's theme is universal. The story told by the movie holds true for almost every woman around the world, i would really hope that you guys try out that film as well.

This was a great reaction! Hope to see you guys explore more Bollywood movies sometimes in future.

Shashi Tharoor's speech at the oxford debate is very eye-opening also. You guys can also react to that if you want to.

Shows how far away are the expat-indian generation raised abroad is from their roots. It is because of what they are taught or to be more specific of what they are not taught.

This movie portrayed only a fraction of how evil British colonialism was. They would strap soldiers/officers to cannons and blow them up for not following orders. They would force women and children into their army's prostitution camps. They would send people to Cellular jail in Andaman and Nicobar islands without trail and torture them. There British soldiers went on raping sprees and wiped out an island of 15000 people by spreading syphilis. Most insidious part of it all was dividing places like Bengal, Punjab in Muslim and Hindu majority parts and then amplifying hatred among them. Also, at 9:20 when Dawyer talks about White Mans Burden, hes referencing the poem written by Rudyard Kipling, the guy who wrote The Jungle Book stories and someone who was born and raised in India. Kipling hailed Dyer as the "savior of India" and donated money towards a fund he allegedly started for his benefit.

Soliders were not Indians. They were Gurkhas (a community of Nepal known for their brutal and fierce soldiers). British used them for such acts because they didn't have any connection (and hence sympathy) towards India. No one would commit such a naked brutality against their own people - no matter how selfish they are.

Nice choice, and that's incorrect information that Indians didn't liked it , they loved it...

56:36, the only reason they pulled it from Oscars, and the reason why RRR was was not well received in England, is that same reason why Reporters were not allowed to cover the real story of Udham singh vs The Crown. Just think about it, nothing has changed. Britishers of this generation still have the looted relics from their colonies and they so proudly showcase them at their museums. Queen's cepter still has the largest diamond from Africa and her crown still has the Kooh-e-noor diamond (And yes its called Kooh-e-noor not Kohinoor). I mean forget accepting their crimes, which were much more inhumane if not equal than hitler, instead many of the new generation of England thinks Imperialism is good. But the irony is, their forefathers were shit scared of Hitler taking over their land. They even shook hands with Red army and later they let him get slaughtered and raced towards Berlin to collect the "Victory over Evil". The same evil Hitler who used "Hooked cross " as his symbol(yes, its not Swastika, grow a brain plz) and was a religious Christian. But no the west is like, Hitler was bad, Hooked cross is a Swastika, we don't know the meaning of "Gammadian"

SURAJ...NO INDIAN EVER SAID HE/SHE DIIDN'T LIKE THIS MOVIE COZ IT'S NOT A TYPICAL MOVIE WITH SONG AND DANCE...WHAT U'VE HEARD IS WRONG BRO!

Literally, EVERY single indian loved this movie. They were PISSED when this movie wasn't sent to Oscar cause it "showed British in bad light". Idk where u get that false info from. I'm glad this is getting watched tho. U should watch "The Kashmir files" released this month. It's about the genocide of Kashmir Pandits in india. It's intense & a very great movie. It deserves to be watched by the whole world. And yes, Gandhi is a horrible human

Bro a lot of Inidans dont really prefer the song and dance type of movies. I live in the US for majority part of my life and even I know this. Also a movie that show cases the heritage and history of India is more loved than the average song and dance movie.

Indians loved this movie. It's some people in the Indian censor board who believed that this showed Indian hatred towards British (I don't know what to say to that) and they had the final say if this will be the official Oscar nomination from India. Other then that most Indian who watch d this movie raved about and it, just check the reviews buddy 👍🏻.

I now feel bad man, Suraj doesn't deserve this much hate, I know I've criticized him a lot but it was mostly because I felt misrepresented by him but I don't think now that it was his job. Suraj is clearly a well intentioned guy and is trying his best. We shouldn't pile on him this much, I hope you read this Suraj.

That was so rude and ignorant of suraj at 1:41. Do you really think that all people in India are some jokers and only watch movies which have silly singing and dancing? This movie is a masterpiece and it shook the core of everyone who watched it. Different people like movies from different genre and people here are mature enough to understand which is a masala film and which is movie is grounded! Grow up man! Don't try to woke all the time!

Suraj is so impressionable. You can put anything in front of him and he'll believe it.

An Oscar worthy film...

Well, apparently another movie The Kashmir Files destroyed the typical Bollywood formula and broke many box office records. The movie has no superstars, singing and dancing etc. Please don't generalize us Suraj, we love masala movies as well as movies like Sardhar Udham, Kashmir files and many non traditional Bollywood movies. It's just that the film makers are lazy and less creative that they spend more money on PR and less attention on the craft. Please don't blame us viewers for shitty Bollywood movies.

Good choice guys... expecting more good Indian movie reactions from you guys..not just high budget Bollywood..Indian cinema has some rare gems..go for it

Indian film industry is very vast and beyond bollywood.There are many world-class movies you must watch.✌

i am yet to find 1 NRI who has a contemporary and real understanding of india and its cinema. you guys are coconuts for a reason my friends, you guys are completely oblivious to reality

I really do appreciate the normies reacting to this. Its a truly tragic tale and the sad part is that even as Indians many of us forgot about him until this movie showed it with the context. looking forward to watching more stuff from your channel

Finally someone reacting to this masterpiece.

This movie is God's gift to us so that western people know what happened in 1919...too bad we indian don't appreciate it as much as it deserves.

The massacre was also depicted in the 1982 movie GHANDI

Thank you for showing this, british colonialism was one of the most evil things from 17-20 century. I never new about this but I will watch the movie. I usually only watch reactions to things I see but I was very curious about this movie.

In Asian countries you call every unknown brother ,sister or uncle

1:41 Man, suraj is a sensible guy, but he's so ignorant about his Indian heritage. _"Indian people don't like this movie coz no singing dancing"_ WTF. WHAT IS HE EVEN SAYING? What do these people think bOLLyWoOd mOvieS are? Do they think all bollywood movies are those typical 30yr old siNgiNg dAnciNG stuff?? Does he not know ANYTHING about his indian side? Like he's so wrong and his info is always outdated. I've noticed this with him in various other reactions too. In AOT reactions, when Jean is mourning Marco while cremating him, suraj didn't know wHaT wAs hAppEniNg. Lmao this dude didn't know what cremation was! That's not even a concept about which you can only about if you're Indian, cremation a pretty basic concept. But he didn't know that. Then in some other reaction, he randomly mentioned that *iN iNdiA, gUyS hOLd eAch oTherS hAndS wHiLe wAlkiNg tOgetHer.* This further confirmed my guess about him that he's one of those typical indian americans who don't know F about India, and usually have vague inaccurate assumptions about it. Because there's a video of some ignorant foreigner online who went to some random beach in southern region of the country or may be mumbai, where he recorded a lot of guys holding hands. No context, nothing.... he just made a video about hOw iNdiAn mEn lOVe tO hOLD hAnds. That's something which is definitely not true for a lot of other regions of the country. And this suraj probably saw that video. No idea where tf does he get his fActS from, sardaar udham not liked by indian audience coz no singing dancing, such a silly statement to make.

A life worth lived Sardar Udham Singh ji we owe u everything for ur courage sacrifice and valour …..

Just a break from watching your Clone Wars reaction (afterall you guys are watching my favourite show😁) This movie is phenomenal, it takes guts to watch it. And about how many Indians actually watched it, the no.s are slim. Yes, the many have actually appreciated this film, but common masses mostly go back to the usual Bollywood bangers. that's a sad reality. Therefore this movie needs all the credit for being what it is and doing such a daring job!

Why does Suraj look down so much on Indians? This is a mainstream Bollywood movie that was one of the bigger successes of the last few years. Diaspora Indians like him just annoy the f out of me. And India makes as good (if not better) movies than the rest of the world. Try and look beyond your prejudice. @ Suraj

Wtf..i was thinking today that it would be nice if normies react to this film after watching majeliv reaction... what a surprise.. looking forward to ur reaction

Not all our brothers had the privilege to voice their protest in peace and a non-violent way. Gandhi wasn't the only person fighting for our independence, Bhagat Singh's revolution raised many to stand in unity and fight back the opressors. And their sacrifice have given our generation the opportunity to practice peace and dharma. Every Indian remembers the privilege handed to us because of our ancestors. Long live their memory and legacy. We pale in comparison to them. JAI HIND - Karthik

this movie is so emotional,,, had me sobbing especially watching the jallianwala bagh massacre 💔

they didn't bomb the whole building, they went into a court-room where a law was been passed for Indians without Indians consent, they threw a low-intensity bomb in the middle where there was nobody because they said their goal is not to kill someone but to make the DEAF British Empire hear. They didn't run-away after that, instead they kept saying slogans & threw leaflets until Police came & then surrendered. U have to understand, these were students

Perfect time to watch Shashi Tharoor Oxford speech “British does owe reparations” You will get the correct idea of British rule in India. Must watch!!

Who told you that some Indians didn't like the movie because there were no singing and dancing? Where did you get that information from ? It's because of you guys who are not staying in India are actually feeding stereotypes about Indian films to the Foreigners.

Contrary to the cliched remark Beg to differ... We Indians have loved this movie...

The soldiers under the general's command were not indians. Instead they were gorkhas or from nepal. That is how the soldiers were deported across regions so they would not have any attachments or sense of belonging to the commoners.

This was rejected from Oscars due to hatred towards a country and this has been issued by the critics on public platform

since you lot are tapping into bollywood movies you should try Udta Punjab. A movie about drug trafficing in Punjab

as we start to hear and learn history from other voices than just the ones selected for us, distinguishing good guys from bad guys is complicated, however it is easy to identify acts of evil like this, another figure the group may want to look into is John Rabe and the Rape of Nanking, there are a few films to choose from

You have picked a great movie, this would be an experience for you guys.

Hitler used to admire what British did in India... so in a way the British did inspire him...

Those 15 mins in movie when he sees the aftermath of the carnage. I was in tears for the next hour

*I am an Indian & i thought this movie was/is a timeless masterpiece. *it wasn't Udham Singh woh became an atheist at some point,, it was Bhagat Singh. *ref in the movie,, when Udham Singh asks the scotland yard officer what was he doing when he was 23…Bhagat Singh was hung when he was 23,, hence he asks the officer not to speak of him(Bhagat Singh). *I'll only speak for myself,, i enjoy both kinds of Indian films…good plain old musical & dance numbers are just fun & easiest way to get entertained & detached from reality for a while,, infact sometimes i miss my old Bollywood dance music & stupidly fun movies. I don't know why we are hell bent on comparing our work with that of Hollywood standards,, i like my Indian movies as is…& i also do enjoy realistic cinema paired with grounded acting as well. *loved the reaction. 🙃 ʚϊɞ ツ

The west would never let this movie win Oscar

Forget about acknowledging the Brutal Incident The Brits Didn't even Acknowledged and Accepted The Movie for Oscar Nominations Citing the movie shows Hatred towards British! I wonder why 😅

Thank you guys for reacting to this! Please do more Bollywood.

Your whole group of the normies should watch 3 idiots movie together , you would love it definitely 😎

indians loved the movie , the love for melodrama is fast becoming a thing of the past . indias contemporary senescence is fast taking place year by year . one must keep up .

The JB scene made me cried every fking time...😭😭😭😭😭😭😭

the one in the middle is making me so nuts .... like everyone is crying n into the movie n he is yawning n soon as the movie ends he stood up n went away like he is so dumb ....

Next Recommend movie 1.Newton 2.Gumnami 3.Khudiram Basu 4.Faluda Trilogy 5.Balasesha 6.Trapped 7.Badhai Ho 8.Scam 1992 series 9.Majhi the mountain man 10.Tumbbad

The last scene where he take bath in pond of golden temple, you can see the blood on his body didn't get off, I think that mean he never get off to his trauma, the feeling what he got at that day, it's a beautifully made movie.

It's because of the sacrifice of these indian freedom fighters that india got independence in 1947, we built our own education system, created world class institutes like the IITs which leads to the educated and skilled talent pool of human resources and many of them migrated to USA and Most importantly - the INDIANS origin people in this channel are the children of those successful migrant Indians to USA. I hope this generation of indian immigrants to USA realises to this and appreciates this sacrifice

Where did suraj hear we don’t like this movie?..bro have some credible source..

_Sardar udham Singh_ 🔥💟 _Last 45 minutes jaliyanwalabag massacre painful scene_ 😔

That last sequence was really hard to watch.

And No the soldiers weren't indians but Gorkhas and also from Afganistan so they were distant. Also Jews were never persecuted in India - infact they took refuge in India and Isreal acknowledges it.

As far my knowledge, the soldiers were not indians, they were gorkha regiment, technically nepalis and were very strict and kinda emotionless when it came to their job.

This white shirt guy is literal definition of coconut...Indians did like the movie..In fact this movie helped many(Including me)to know/remind about Sardar Udham Singh's legacy... It was not a theater release though which is fine otherwise Censor board would have chopped off half of the movies important parts...😏 Edit: The main reason for pulling it out of Oscar official entry was This movie was exposing the brutality of the Britsh raj & not what the coconut duos are stating here...God!!! Such ignorant people🤦‍♀️ At least do some research before giving opinion but I do like the lady in the red though she seems like an empath...But those coconuts are bit disappointing in some parts..Anyways hope you coconuts do little bit research before coming up with any opinion...No hate but its quite hard to ignore 😖😏

This movie deserved an Oscar. It deserved to be seen by everyone. The issue is, the west wants to point and laugh at where India is today, make snide remarks and pass judgements without burdening themselves with the knowledge of how it got here and how much of it was actually out of our hands. It's the same with China, but China made it a mission to make sure that the west can never ignore or mess with them again,

That scene when he collects injured from dead bodies is heart wrenching.

This Movie is a Masterpiece. Great reaction Guys.

They were majority Nepalese gurkha soldiers they did not wanted any soldier to defy the order so they called the Nepalese

The ignorant comment about Indians disliking this movie because it had no dance numbers almost made me wanna stop watching. It's become a norm for NRIs and PIOs to stay embarrassed and ignorant of Indian history and contemporary India. Please educate yourself beyond Western stereotypes. Edit: it was cool that you replied to some of the comments, apologised and are willing to learn

this is a masterpiece which didnt even make it to the academy awards nominations as our indian jury neglected it

The movie got pulled out as British felt it would tarnish their image on the world stage, it was a diplomatic measure.

This is related to ww1 British promised to give dominion status on par with Australia and Canada to gain support from India mainland, some 80 k Indian soldiers died in war but after it over in 1919 , British became British again and started brutal repression. The same reason became reason for Indian Independence but this time Indian leaders asked for Total Independence in lieu of support which was hesitatingly given but they caused the division before they leave like they did in most of their colonies a never healing scar .Another thing Bhagat Singh bombed the court but no one dies because he used less explosive and threw it in empty space then gave willfull arrest. It’s ok I know you guys don’t know much so it’s ok but don’t reach conclusions.

They were not indian soldiers who shot at jalianwala bagh masscare they were nepalis gurkha

Iam from south India but as far as I have read and known personally, Indian Sikhs are the bravest, coolest and innosent souls on earth until u rage them or do something bad.. this story of Udham Singh n Bhagat Singh is testimony of time n again how they sacrificed themselves for their belief, humanity n motherland.. British specifically targeted them in this masscare so that it wil instill fear of British across nation.. Sadly youth r brainwashed on history claiming only Gandhi's non violence got is freedom.. Till today Sikh regiment, Nagas n Gorkhas are most feared n respected across air,naval n land army in India..

thats also how they force fed the suffragettes who went on hunger strike

The only thing remotely Indian about Suraj is his name. But then his ignorance can be forgiven as he is American after all.

And this is reality 😠.....Our grandfathers and great grandfathers have sacrificed their lives for freedom. We will never forget this 🇮🇳

It's really rare of me seeing a brown guy in that accent makes me feel proud of him 😂😂

those other poeple he shot were also governors of different region of India !

Since you guys watched Sardar Udham, would love to see you guys watch Kashmir files

Indians didn't like the movie because it has no singing or dancing? Yeah, nobody watches Hollywood movies in our country. If there was to be a reason it would be that Indians are not aware of this movie.

It's funny how The Academy denied this movie an entry for Oscars saying this movie spreads hatred against the British! Like there were no American movies ever that were based on racism or racist events of history... America be like: if we do something wrong its an experiment and if another country does it, its crime...!!! Till date The British owes an official apology for all they did in India! And its sad to see British history is tailored in a way it makes them feel they were right! Same is the case with Pakistan and those poor citizens are facing the consequences today 😂 (laughing emoji is because of so many lies i read in Pakistan's history textbooks).

You guys should go for tumbbad next it's just next level masterpiecs