Yes she does … loved her on X Factor

Yes. She was runners up

Yes she was one of my favs too

Hard to forget all of that makeup lmfao

She compete twice in factor uk but ndidtn win hope she win here

Yes! That multi-colored hair guy had a story but his voice was no where near AI material.. we all kno why they sent him through! I'm not a mean person but c'mon now let's be realistic! This is American Idol not a Therapy session

I think she told her story with this song.

she has a massive sob story tho hahahahahah

Just cause someone has a sob story doesn’t mean there not trying to to reach there dreams

seriously?? because you don't "love" anything? and do you love anyone at all?, actually?? because it's CLEAR that from your posted reply: "No sob story just pure talent. I love this audition" & not even a period to designate the end of that cold-no-hearted wannabe sentence by you. and you're such a desperate & hateful INCEL male towards the lovely Scarlett?? as it's truly a wonder you even wanted to watch ANY of the videos from the current season of the A.I. USA show or the XFactor UK so many of us from around the globe have loved from the days & years past before - let alone this CURRENT A.I. USA presentations from this 2024 year..in OTHER WORDS: why are you EVEN HERE?? why do you even BOTHER posting here?? because Scarlett, she's a contestant from the XFactor UK show from seasons before [a normal, soulful person would *behave* as if they KNEW that fact] who MILLIONS of fans from AROUND THE WORLD love & remember! and who is ALSO someone who Simon DEFINITELY does remember & know! so, as far as your sociopathic need to criticize any person 'sob story' goes, doesn't mean a contestant like Scarlett, even with her history in Simon's professional life - that she automatically moves forward - doesn't mean she is a PART OF going THROUGH into the next or all other levels.🙄 so what is it you're so threated by that you have to criticize her for something she NEVER even presented in this video?? a "sob story??" why do you have such a huge need to suggest that was a part of her audition?? and because IF you were old enough and/or *intelligent* enough to know those facts about Simon's previously past ACTUAL shows - of which he's not only a host but ALSO a producer of + largely a significant OWNER of: you'd intelligently be AWARE of the FACT that he ONLY wanted to HELP Scarlett do well when she was on the XFactor UK all those years ago. and he could ALSO have easily - more easily than you could EVER understand - Simon could have easily BANNED her from ever appearing again in any of the shows he has had a financial interest in! but you and far too many other IDIOTS are clueless about her professional history regarding Simon Cowell & his professional history & multiple businesses..but of COURSE, you and your clones would not be aware of such facts.😐 also, btw, those of us who actually have a SOUL: we're NOT threatened by as you seem to be, other human being's PAIN - because WHY are you so threatened by this?? because you show that you're the WORST kind of only wannabe humans who give NO ffs for other people and what they've been through or are still going through...unless many countless of us have misunderstood your cruel posts & comments?? SERIOUSLY, if we're wrong?? please tell us..and be kind, please STOP your terrible posts & replies. meaning IF we're wrong about you please help those of us who actually CARE about other decent, good people understand you, too.📿☯🤲🕉🌷

When she sings, I don't "just" feel her-I BELIEVE her. 💜 That's a magickal superpower!

I'm so glad she didn't over sing that song. She took her time. Absolutely Beautiful

Get your hearing checked. She’s no idol.

I thought the song would never end. She oversang it!

@taroman7100 She always oversings that's her down fall

I also think she’s a smart singer from a technical standpoint, because, even though her voice was so heavy on the verses, she lightened up and brightened it up at the right time for the high notes, so that she can bring her voice up with ease.

I concur

Are you the one who comments on Regine Velasquez’ videos?

Me too! Loved her and her personality

same here! she made it so far

She has grown as well.

Yes, me also and now American idol...from Malaysia 😀😀

YAY Scarlett!!! Go girl! Rooting for you! X

because they didn't want people to get upset that she got eliminated for no reason

Yessir love your feedback on these vids. God bless

Thank you so much!! @@mckinleyhafen

Hi Robert, thanks for being here for yet another season of AI. I always look forward to your comments. Hope all is well 🙌🏻🌟

Picked it back up right when she stopped singing just beautiful 😂

She seems to have a good voice She completely over-sang this though. There's such a beautiful simplicity to the original. Sometimes less is a lot more

Approx 5 yrs 2 1/2 months. She came in 2nd in Dec 2018. Maybe her first time on X Factor was 7 yrs ago. I thought she had lost weight and cut down on most of the make up, and stopped dressing like that.

Having idols are evil and bad

was she still wide

Easily

No top 2 dude hope she is win

​@@Christekhno Is English your second language?

​@@Quantumtraveler707 yeah why sorry for my bad grammar

Lmao

Same I’m surprised she never mentioned it to the judges, unless she did and it was never aired. She sounds even better since then, she was great before but that performance was just wow!

Same, she was on in 2017 & then again in 2018 where she was the runner-up.

Me too❤ she is talented

Yes she is

EXACTLY! When she posted like a month ago that she was gonna be on I screamed! I commented saying I been a fan since I seen you on that show. I’m so glad she came to America to join American idol! I woulda never thought I’d get to see her on my tv!

Isn't that called coming in 2nd place?

isn't that called top 2? @@aspenrebel

@@cliffxen5418 NO! It's called 2nd place. Where are you from?

@@aspenrebel is it relevant? top 2/second place/1st runner-up - semantics.

@@kauze_ NO! Try speaking and writing proper English. Instead of being a mindless, brainwashed lemming!!

Same

Honestly, the whole time I was watching this all I could think was that American Idol doesn't deserve her.

I was so heartbroken when we didn't see her sing and then she's eliminated 💔 😢

The sob story will inevitably come as filler when the episodes progress... and she will break down and katie will console her and say look at the bullies now... bla bla bla... generic bs. Calling it now.

Amazing comment. I agree with you. She caught my attention since her 2018 audition and she left a huge impression. So glad to know I am not the only one who's been really taken by her. Thank you for your great message, you went out of your way to say that and I understand why because I feel so similarly to you and have been posting along the same sort of vibe :) Bless

Yooo! Doing great!

I was annoyed!!!

@arnoldcoquia1902yes she was and I stopped looking at it after the point in my eyes she was American Idol PERIOD

yup, I stopped caring for it the second I found she was eliminated. They just shot themselves in the foot - AI could have had a huge UK audience.

Just watched it again, and again she's brought tears to my eyes. Freaking amazing performance. Scarlett Lee is a magical human being. One of the best singers in the world.

Right? Seems like every year more and more get cut that they don't even show 😯