Schaaf's New Whittling Knife Set- Should You Buy It?

Рет қаралды 6,368

Ай бұрын

#Carving #aleclacasse #whittle
Reviewing Schaaf's wood carving knife set!
Order my book, Carving Faces in Wood, here:
foxchapelpublishing.com/LACASSE
Check out my online carving school by clicking the link below:
www.aleclacasse.com/online-wo...
Subscribe to Woodcarving Illustrated at foxchapelpublishing.com/produ..., Use Promo Code CARVER to access free projects with your online subscription purchase. Add this free download to your cart: Sea Captain Pattern Download. foxchapelpublishing.com/produ...
Send mail to:
Alec LaCasse
P.O. Box 101
Lakeville, MI 48366
Affiliate Links:
Schaaf Whittling Knife Set:
amzn.to/3VNyZTr
Flexcut 6-piece set
amzn.to/49J95VE
Schaaf 12-piece set,
Use Code: ALEC15 to get 15% off:
amzn.to/49Hmei4
3M Face shield
amzn.to/3Hh8pto
Makita Chainsaw 5012b
amzn.to/3kPXwqV
Ryobi Rotary Tool 1.2amp:
amzn.to/3XKCtop
Manpa cutter head:
amzn.to/3HDEa1a
Makita angle grinder:
amzn.to/3HCEg9u
Purchase the Flexcut knife here:
amzn.to/3Cpv0Td
Carving Glove:
amzn.to/3Glebdm
2” x 2” x 5” Basswood Blocks:
amzn.to/3Xac7eL
Leather Strop for sharpening:
amzn.to/3Gq9cYP
Honing Compound for Strop:
amzn.to/3Qj9hlF
Spray Finish For Carving:
amzn.to/3GHSi9j
Artist Paint Brushes I use:
amzn.to/3GMSRi0
Artist Paint for Carvings:
amzn.to/3ZgFXjL
Super Glue Accelerant:
amzn.to/3Cy1ISj
Gorilla Glue Super Glue:
amzn.to/3GJoqJQ
Purchase the Flexcut Multi Jack here:
amzn.to/3VMR5lj
Crocs:
amzn.to/3inWdif
Check out my one day online workshops here:
www.aleclacasse.com/one-day-o...
Thanks for the support! Buy me a coffee here: www.buymeacoffee.com/aleclacasse

Пікірлер: 39

@AlecLaCasseArt Ай бұрын

Hey guys, if you have this set I'd love to hear what you think! I really appreciate ya'll watching!

@pinslayerx Ай бұрын

I’ve only been carving about two months now. And purchased this set(a bit less than you quoted). I’ve not used the scoops and have put them aside for now. The detail knife needed to be put on a stone and strapped before it gave me good cuts. The larger knife seemed to cut well from the start and I liked the way it made sweeping cuts. I did have a blemish about an inch from the hilt(about the same location you saw) which chipped abit needing some work to smooth out. I have only used the rough out blade just a little. It seems to cut okay. I quest I would rate them about a 6. But keep in mind I’m a novice at woodcarving. I’ve since, picked up on a flex cut detail knife which feel’s somewhat better and it came much sharper. I’m sure as I get more experience my opinions may change…

@tylerfinley8554 Ай бұрын

I enjoy this set mine need to be sharpened but I have cut deep into fingers with the general removal one

@VdubSPAZ Ай бұрын

As I said I purchased them they were on sale for 68 something with my Prime discount they just will not sharpen properly and I don't know if you noticed maybe you're set was cherry-picked but my blades were not set straight inside of the handles as for the spoon tools I don't remember if they were but the chip knife the rough cut and the detail were all different two of them were placed in the same direction offset to the handle and then the other one was offset the opposite direction I did like the little sheaths that was a nice touch and I thought the same about the Box they have so much going right for them but then they fail at the main part

@VdubSPAZ Ай бұрын

They are nowhere close to being on the same level as the steel used and the Beaver craft or the flex cut as I said I have purchased several different ones I'm not lucky enough to have a helvi knife and OCC is change manufacturers once again thought about buying a Drake I'm not sure I like the handles But after my personal experience with knives and none what they should be like I don't see how they can get to where they need to be but again I challenge you for your next video sharpen them the way that they should be but I don't think they'll do what you want and if not I believe they'll chip more than anything else I think that was the problem when I was sharpening them they were just randomly chipping kind of like the weird powdered blend knives that they currently have out for bushcrafting another things

@moondog5553 Ай бұрын

I just ordered your book, I can’t wait to get it. The faces you carve in wood have a aesthetic quality that I find hauntingly beautiful, There's something truly special and captivating about your work.

@AlecLaCasseArt Ай бұрын

That means a lot!!!! Thankyou!!

@ayobali992 Ай бұрын

Beavercraft have those hook knives in that design, just different handles. I just picked one up from Amazon UK last week and it's Wickedly Sharp. Thanks for the video 🤩 keep up with the great work 😍

@AlecLaCasseArt Ай бұрын

True that! I have one!

@paulnagtzaam914 Ай бұрын

like the video the name of this companie is also the dutch name for handplaner 👍🤟

@TheAstriapo Ай бұрын

I purchased a complete set of mallet chisels from them. my experience was the blades chipped easy and several of the handles split...

@AlecLaCasseArt Ай бұрын

That's unfortunate!

@OldMeanGeezer Ай бұрын

So, I were to start making carving tools and sent a set to Alec, I would make sure every knife was very sharp and the very best I could produce! If this is a example of the best, I wonder what the average carver would get?

@mattvergauwen5307 Ай бұрын

I don't have this knife set, but did get the first knife set they put out last year. The set I got is a 3 piece with a hook knife, a upswept whittling knife similar to the sloyd knives that often come in the cheap Amazon sets, and a detail knife. My set required a whole lot of stropping. I like the sloyd a lot for removing lots of stock. The detail is also very similar to the detail knives that come with the generic Amazon sets and is ground like the Beavercraft knives. I don't care for it to be honest. The handles are chunky and feel pretty good. Haven't used or sharpened the hook knife. This set also came with a strop/compound, a tool roll and 3 blanks of basswood. The straps on my tool roll are kinda cheap, stretchy material, and mine came with a tear in one of the straps out of the box. This set was $20 when it initially came out, which is why I got it. Was using up a gift card. It's now about $26. A pretty good set for a very low cost. Maybe a little better quality than those Amazon specials. I also have the $99 12 piece gouge gouge set which does well after a lot of initial sharpening. Sorry for the book length review! 😂

@AlecLaCasseArt Ай бұрын

I didn’t know that made a set like that! Thanks for the review!!

@wattsnex2725 Ай бұрын

I don’t have the set but I do actually like my Schaaf gouges. Although they came suuuper dull. But I find the steel to be good, just needs some maintenance.

@AlecLaCasseArt Ай бұрын

That's good to hear!

@donriley8246 Ай бұрын

They say on their info , that you have to sharpen them. I like my schaaf tools. Im not worried about beating them up.

@AlecLaCasseArt Ай бұрын

Yes! I’ll be curious how they take to sharpening !

@VdubSPAZ Ай бұрын

The sad thing is I really wanted to love it and first looks just quick glance without looking at everything over it looks really good unfortunately it fails on so many levels I would love to be able to share pictures and video that I took but unfortunately KZfaq will not allow you to post pictures or videos to the comment section

@AlecLaCasseArt Ай бұрын

That’s a bummer!

@DavidGodwinCalico Ай бұрын

Generaly you don't use a chip crving knife like you would use a carving knife. Badger State is great!

@lesliecrowther7004 Ай бұрын

I unfortunately do not have this set, do not think I've heard to much positivity about these tools. Alec, you mentioned ZAM compound ? What one would you be using 🤔 ?? I've had a look there is green and white, apparently billed as a jewellers roug ? Are you using it as a sharpening compound or just for polishing the blade 🤔. Hope you can help and advise. Many thanks, Les.

@AlecLaCasseArt Ай бұрын

I use the green for both sharpening and polishing in one fell swoop!

@lesliecrowther7004 Ай бұрын

Cheers Alec.

@VdubSPAZ Ай бұрын

I can tell you already they handpicked that particular set for you I'm telling you from a fact of my purchase from Amazon I almost wondered if it was like a reject or a send back that's how bad it was and you cannot get that micro bevel out because of the way the actual metal is it does not take an edge at all I went through and re-profile the blade and found lots of defects and how the blade was ground in the first place you don't see it at first but I took it down as far as I could possibly take it even down to 8000 and it would not hold an edge

@AlecLaCasseArt Ай бұрын

That’s a bummer!

@ozoneswiftak Ай бұрын

That small bevel is hard for me to get rid of. It will require hours of sharpening for the whole set to fix that.

@AlecLaCasseArt Ай бұрын

Sharpening is time consuming for sure!

@chrisorcutt7619 Ай бұрын

This set wouldn't be good for beginners cause they wouldn't know how to get them sharp. The quality looks ok though. I still like flexcut better.

@AlecLaCasseArt Ай бұрын

I would agree with that.

@VdubSPAZ Ай бұрын

I can honestly say I bought Beavercraft first Sharpen them the way they were supposed to be sharpened in the first place I hands down say that Beavercraft by far is better than that will ever be I bought them because of the name happens to be the same name as My friend And he was like Well that was a disappointment sorry man And I laughed I've bought Flex cut I bought Beavercraft And Beavercraft is just as good as flex cut Once you get it nice and polished I like the handles better than Beavercraft than I do flex cut because of that waxy Finish on the handles But other than that The schaaf tools socks.... if I was to purchase that said I would never ever been as far along as I am now with carving I literally would have quit but I did buy their $12 vtool gouge set and it's not great but it is very doable

@VdubSPAZ Ай бұрын

Better yet challenge of the day I challenge you to sharpen them to the proper profile profile and sharpen them the way that they should be I want to see if I'm an idiot and suck completely even though I have tons of knives and sharpened all of them to razor sharp and my wood carving tools are pretty much scalpel Sharp but I could not get them to sharpen up past their current sharpness it was like the metal wouldn't hold like you noticed the defect in the little blade when you start polishing them and sharpening them and reprofiling them you'll find more odd spots but I challenge you you have been officially challenged I double dog dare you you can't go past that LOL😂

@VdubSPAZ Ай бұрын

I can let you know from the very get-go before I even watch this the tool set I got nails to say none of the blades were straight to the handles the blades are supposed to be manganese what manganese is not magnetic so I don't know what metal it is it doesn't sharpen correctly and there was a weird Burr in the metal of one of my blades what otherwise the Polish on the metal look great and the handles looked phenomenal as well too bad they're finishing their product was not as such and the metal blades are not ground correctly

@bigdoc2985 Ай бұрын

I will never use or buy a Chinese knife.

@johnduffy6546 Ай бұрын

I have some issues with buying anything from China. They already own 3/4 of the USA...I will gladly pay more money for products NOT made in China

@mikegriffin2762 Ай бұрын

You are a good carver but you have no business promoting carving tools. You have botched the Schaaf carving tools. Quit trying to talk soon fast. I couldn't even make out some of the names of tools you were trying to pronounce. What do I know, I've only been carving for 68 years now? I wish you well but stick to carving your pretty good at that!! Blessings you you!!