thats lovely! my mom didnt sing but played this on piano whole of my childhood :)))

Very good you come from a good home.

@@vonMohl she’s actually a Mezzo Soprano so it actually sounds more mellow than this 🤗

Ohh qué hermoso dormirse con esa música cantada por su madre cada noche. Qué afortunado!❤

Same

Won't you please add his name to the information for the video? She is not performing this by herself, is she?

@@mccarlson52 This! Although clearly the channel owner is not paying attention to posts.

lovely, sensitive accompaniment.

👏👏👏👏

Best 👏👏🌷

I donno how I feel about this performance, everybody seems to love it. But for me personally there is something missing here. I mean I really liked the conversation between the piano and the voice. You could really tell that they were playing with this aspect on an interesting and yes fresh level. However I feel like the woman didn't give this piece the emotional and vocal depth it deserves. This song is supposed to really touch you with strongly conveyed emotions. It is supposed to just express deep affection. And I feel like the woman lacked in this aspect and well ignored it to some point. In the high notes she is very good but her lower notes feel somewhat tense and not sounding and powerful enough to convey what they are supposed to convey. But then again this is just my personal opinion and reaction to this performance. However as I said before the sometimes playful conversation between the two voices in this performance was interestingly refreshing but still missing the point of this piece.

I totally agree

@@komperakompera2190 I think the composition is powerful enough to be best without more expression. I guess when you have heard more emphatic versions, then this might be thought flat. Same when someone plays Beethoven 5th faster, everyone else's then seems slow!

@@komperakompera2190 I like the way she is so natural, simple and does not exaggerate.

I sang this song in concerts often, especially for my beloved husband!

Thankyou very much 🙏🙏

Thanks!

Bravo to have your translation

When you study voice you have to spend lots of time to learn the correct pronunciation...❤❤

Yes, her pronunciation ist very good. She should perhaps train a bit more the difference between the pronunciation of 'sch' and 'ch' in words.

@David Steven Tabbat Unexpectedly, female voices work better than males'ones with this Lied

@@dlefil1364 Why unexpectedly? This was a song of dedication from Schumann to his new bride Clara and as such was an intimate lied which to my mind is sung better by the ladies.

@@suzannesadiiqa I agree with you!! I suppose that when I wrote this msg I had listened to males'voices the I didn't like compared to this one.

You're totally right: this Lied tends to be performed with too much solemnity. As a matter of fact, solemnity being already in the score, there's no need at all to stress it...

Elegantly stated, David. I am a performer as well. The world is big and lots of room for differences.

ironic-- I was just assigned this piece and this was the recording sent haha!

no need to send the same thing 2x

She has! Check out her web page.

indeed! fabulous.

Bin damit einverstanden.

Um. I'm working on this piece with my voice instructor right now and... Schumann wrote this for his wife... Yeah, the judge is sincerely incorrect.

Sad?! That's crazy! It's ebullient, ecstatic, and enthralling!

Undergrad -- senior recital!

Arts Laureate Incredible!

So far as I know, this is not a "short version." The song itself is very short, just as we hear it here.

David Steven Tabbat: You are right....the way to double the length in a program is to sing this in another language, such as my lyrics in English... done as a hymn.

Seems ????

Christopher Koelzer, piano

I agree, but I am happy to see it's been added since!

Christopher Koelzer, piano

@@James_Bowie Thank you!

Because it was written as a bravura piece for piano alone.