I'm not gonna say if she's good or bad, but her voice fits her songs. You couldn't have Adele or Demi sing Hands To Myself. Selena's is great for her types of songs. Then again, she couldn't sing songs like Dangerous Woman or Hello like the artists do.

Her voice is nice but she doesn't know which style suits her best

Shes famous for more than her singing. People keep up with her because she selena gomez, and her songs are catchy. She's a personality, and people have seen her on TV and in the media sing she was really young. She might not be the best singer but you have to realize people like the music and selena gomez. Plus I thinks she sounds good in her music.

I don't why but I love her voice it's like slow and unique

Sometimes she is okay but whenever she tries to hit a high note or to sing a bit more it's sounds horrible. I'm sorry she should stick to acting

In my opinion, it doesn't sound like she's really singing. She was sort of off key, and just sounds like she's raising her voice and whispering at the same time???

not every ONE has to be Ariana grande they have different styles

Selena has a beautiful unique voice. Very seductive, soft & relaxing. She has a wide range of tones...just hypnotizing. No everyone likes high note singers or those that scream a loud. Nope, I prefer to chill to relaxing music. NO ONE LIKE SELENA, sorry. Idc what people thinks.

She should stay in acting, I mean she's a really good actress. I'm not saying that she's a horrible singer but she does need improvement. Acting would really be her best field.

If she auditioned for American Idol she would not make it. Simon would say "sing it don't moan it" 😂

I think the obsession of hitting high notes made us forget that music is not all about that and we just can't appreciate the different artists and their work. Sure Selena is not the best. But some of her songs are actually good. She has a very soothing style. And I think she really improved her vocals over the years.

Edit :" the best singer in the world is not the loudest , the best singer moves you ." Kelly Clarkson All i wanted to say is that i don't give a damn about her singing whether she is able to hit high notes or not . She has a unique voice . There are many songs which are just made for her. People are comparing her to Ariana Grande, Ari is a great singer but just imagine if she sings same old love. Selena's version would sound much better than Ari's. She makes good songs , have good personality , encourages women , treats her fans right . If you hate her so much then stop watching her videos . That's it.

4:54 she sounds a LOT better when she sings like that (falsetto)

no offense but she cant sing. she has a few good bops tho

A person going through the disease Lupus can't hold their breathe for soo much time so that's why she is breathing again and again.... But I still love her..... I love you Selena Gomez and you are my role model..... I love you..... Hope you all will understand her problem. { Edit :- Guys, it's not only about having Lupus disease, it's about the kidney transplant she had. She had many complications in that surgery, it also affected her. And if you don't like her it's okay, but there's no need to curse her or wish bad for her. Be kind. Learn to accept some things and if you don't then please you shut the f-ck up! Thank you 🥀 }

4:57 Selena sounds verry GOOD and beautiful. She is a verry wanderful,cool,funny and verry beautiful women!!!!!!!

I hate how everyone is being nice to Selena for not being able to sing very well. If Taylor sang like this, she would've gotten a lot of hate. Let's be real, some people just like her because of her looks.

In my opinion I don't think she sings that good without auto-tune

I love her ❤. She's such a strong , beautiful , nice and RARE woman ! Nobody's perfect so stop sending hate to her send love❤ not hate

In my opinion Selena's voice really suits her songs....keep going selena..... love u 😍😍😍 you determine who you are

She sounds really fine, I though she was gonna sound terrifying, but i'm really happy actually, she has a beautiful tone. Obviously she's not Ariana or Demi (I think she tried way too hard) but I like it

she's not a good singer BUT her singing is not annoying though..

She's my favorite one actually... her voice just gives off the vibe that I've been finding tho. I am not really into high notes, like fr. Her songs, I play it on repeat these days. This is my opinion, please do not attack me (or anyone else)

This is a proof that she doesn't lip sync🙃, Her voice is amazing! I love her and her amazing sweet voice!

I Really love her voice it's so soft , Hitting Hight Notes isn't Everything!

I'm sorry but the party all night part killed me 😂😂😂

atleast she's singing from her heart. and that's enough

singer NOT mean HIGHT NOTES !!!! ARE YOU OKAY? her voice is so SOFT come on she is a human too like us. She has a heart. Her voice is soft

She actually sounded decent at 1:47...seems like slow and soft is where she does well. Maybe it's a combination of being able to hear herself better and having time to catch her breath on longer notes?

i really hate it how when she sings live she sings the high notes softly. i would really like to hear her sing a year without rain with the same power as the recorded version, even though it wont sound good

Selena has a beautiful voice wow any one else thinks the same give a like

Every voice is an art of its own. I absolutely adore Selena's voice. 🖤

she can only sing low notes and even then its not really singing, its like talking/whispering... she really should work on her breathing. even if lupus is affecting her breathing she can still work on improving. nothing against selena, i like her acting, but her music career is only alive because of her looks and because her songs are catchy. the natural vocal talent just isn't there

HOW HAS SHE MADE THIS SINGING CAREER A THING?!? There are people out there who sound like whitney and can't get signed but this bih has several albums???? man life is unfair

Selena's voice sounds so beautiful and melodious. I really like her own voice and it matches to her beauty. That's so great for me! 🥰

I think that when she doesn’t do much of physical action she sounds great I mean in the videos that she was sitting or just standing still you can actually hear her voice sounding great.

selenas lower tone is beautiful she can achieve REALLY low notes

It's not fair...she gets so much attention when her voice is average there are singers out there with amazing voices and don't get noticed at all

She is still my 👑. Stop judging people. LOL

I wish she puts a rap part in her song cuz as you guys know she is so good at rapping.:^)

She don't sing she talks

Why all the comments comparing her to Ariana? You don’t need to be able to reach the highest notes to be a good singer. Ariana and Selena are two completely different types of singers. Ariana has a very strong, powerful voice which makes it easier for her to perform. Selena however, has a very soft voice and finds it difficult to sing powerfully. Even though the examples in this video aren’t the best, it doesn’t mean she can’t sing. If you go watch her acoustic version of ‘who says’ her voice sounds really beautiful. Also don’t forget that Selena has anxiety and lupus which can affect her singing on stage. Edit: I’d completely forgotten about this comment until today and I was reading thru the replies and some of y’all are so mean :( I never said selena was the best singer, but she has some really beautiful performances. Just because Ariana is the better singer it doesn’t mean you have to put selena down. Just leave her be man, she’s not hurting you in any way, let her fans enjoy her music ffs

I’m LOVING all the the positive and supportive comments. I agree with most of them. And the fact that she knows she doesn’t have the strongest voice and makes mistakes, but she still sings live instead of lip syncing.. that gains a lot of respect in my book

It's good to know how much she has improved since 2016 till today

I know that she's not the best singer or the best vocals but theres something in her voice touches my heart every time !! I love low notes actually and her voice can hit a very low note which's so precious to me ! U guys just don't buy her music and stop the hate !

There are some points where she sings really well, and some where she doesn't. Not everyone can sing perfectly every time, and honestly, most of today's pop singers can't sing to save their lives. At least she loves what she does.

haters: she can't sing. Selenators: kill em with kindness. 😽 . . . P.s : I'm a selenator :')

We finally got a cover of “Oceans” 4:53

She's just a decent singer. If she focused more on improving her vocals she'd be good!

She has a flat voice. It sounds good low. She isn't the worst out there but isn't the best either.

She has a beuatiful voice rather than high-pitched voice. Don't forget she has LUPUS so she can't hold her breath for a longer and thus, doesn't has high vocals. But her voice is low and beautiful and so peaceful that can calm any body, mind and soul. And also don't forget, music isn't all about high vocals but about entertaining people and make them move on your song which I don't think any other singers can do. See how she maintains her low voice which any other singer barely does. You can sing everyone's song like them but just try once to sing Selena's song, you won't be able to, cuz she has got a different and the best voice. I repeat, I'm talking about VOICE not VOCALS.

She slaaayyyyeeeedddd “same old love” She such a queen 😂 👑

She can't sing, her beauty saved her

She's good at the low notes but not the high

I love her Voice 😍Very Unique for me .... Sounds like a Latina accent ...

Selena is Selena, and her voice has got an essence being unique. and after all, that's an undeniable truth that the softness of her voice not its soprano power is the reason so many people are her fans, like me!

She has a boring and weak voice, and uses way too much vocal fry. Her songs are pretty catchy though.

to be an artist doesn't mean that you have to be Mariah Carey. she can sing.

fr, i really can't stand some of y'all. OF COURSE everyone has their own opinion but she CAN sing! she is a mf queen. you can say that she can't sing but then hate on her, saying things like “ugh my hears", etc...? it is ENOUGH! plus if you don't like her/her voice then leave.

She has such a beautiful voice. So underrated.

For all the people sayig that they can sing way better than her, well, don't forget that when you sing live onstage, your voice will sound alot different than when you sing alone in your own room because of the microphone and the echo. Only when you perform onstage will you know the struggles...so don't judge

Selena shouldn't be singing at concerts. She doesn't have a special voice, can't reach high or low notes, she has an average voice. I can understand that some people can like her voice because it's not awful or a complete disaster, and she has a lot of producers who make "good" music, but that doesn't mean she should be a singer. There's a lot of people who are more talented that her and no one pays attention to them because they are not as pretty as her, and they doesn't have a Disney career. I took singing lessons since I was 4, and for someone who has 15 years of singing lessons, like me, knows when someone is out of tune, when they don't know how to breathe and that if you had lupus, you shouldn't be jumping and singing (because she is not dancing, she is jumping). She doesn't breathe with her all her lungs, she sing with her chest and throat, and that's a huge mistake. Also, she has a range of an octave and a half, when a good singers has a range of three octaves or more. So to any Selenator who thinks she is a good singer, she isn't. She just can sing. Period. That doesn't mean she should be a singer. She should be an actress. That's what she have been studying for years. You can like her music but that doesn't mean she is a good singer. Miley, Ariana, Adele, lady Gaga, Beyonce, Shakira, etc, they are singers. Good singers.

She was on a list of singers that doesn't use autotune. She can freaking sing. An expert has a channel and he listens to different artist and he said she can sing and has gotten better then from when she first started.

ngl but it got pretty good from 5:08 to 5:33

Y'all she was never a good singer why is everyone surprised....

she can sing but not very good. as a singer she is very weak.there are sooo many talented singers out there who cant make it to the public.

All I needed her voice so grateful for that i never stop loving her

Selena has such a unique and soft voice, and people hate on her voice for no reason and say that she can’t sing as if they’re vocals coaches when actual vocal coaches love her voice. She’s not a strong vocalist like other people but just bc you can’t hit high notes doesn’t mean you can’t sing. Plus she has lupus which affects her respiratory system which is why she has to always take a breathe

Maybe she can't sing that well but she has a beautiful voice and no one can deny it

She can sing but nothing special with her voice...Try put her in The Voice, i think she s not gonna pass it......

Selena’s voice suits songs with slow pace. She’s a low pitched singer and she’s really good with ballads and acoustics. As far as ik she slays in acoustics and ballads. She has a gifted ability to put emotions her voice very well.

My baby,she's always perfect ❤

still her voice is like music to my ears

I honestly don't understand why people worship Selena. She cannot sing at all. She only sounds "good" when she's using autotune, but that's literally it. I swear if she wasn't pretty, no one would even look at her twice.

3:39 look like those men are in depression 😂😂

She doesn't need any autotune 😁

reading the comments actually made me happy....we are all true selena fans....its because she is a beautiful soul...no one can talk bad.....even tho her voice is okay.....

Selena isn't a bad singer, her voice is just not made to sing strong high powerful songs like Ariana or Demi her voice was meant for slow smooth songs

She doesn't have the strongest voice, but when people say she whispers, it's just plain wrong, she has a breathy falsetto, plan and simple

I dont know why people are giving hate comments... Its soo good... I don't understand whta bad... She sings beautiful with or withour autotune...

Lets be honest here... Selena has a voice of a girl singing in the shower

let's be real, she wouldnt make it in any singing contest like x factor or american idol.

Omgg AMAZINGG💛💛

Selena Gomez is d best singer, actor, & most important a beautiful person 💛 *I* 💛❤ *LOVE* ❤💚 *HER* 💚💙 *SO* 💙💜 *MUCH* 💜

this is every singer actually i think selena had been getting better through the years but for sure there are times when she can and can't sing but u guys need to calm down and stop acting like this is something

Its like 1:10 she doesn't sing well, but 6:09 she sings perfectly (my opinion) I love her and it's not because she can't sing some high notes that she can't sing, cause she can do it well.

I’m not even a fan, more into Ariana. But she can sing. 1:27 I love the little mid-belts. 1:44 So relaxing, love the acoustic mixing with her Smooth Vocals. 4:53 Sent me to Heaven… 5:07 Love the Falsetto, with the A4 Belt. 5:20 Love the Belts going up to B4. 5:46 If this doesn’t sound like Heaven to you, then you are delusional. She literally CAN sing. Just know, you don’t have to have a wide range to know how to sing. If she can sound good Acapella or Acoustic (which she does) she can sing. Her top note is G5!! And y’all still say she can’t sing…wtf.

Singing varies in so many ways and Selena's voice is so unique and has its own character that whenever you hear it you would definitely identify that it's Selena. Identity in singers are important and Selena has indeed a vocal identity that no one else can copy plus her beauty, what else can you complain about?

her live singing isn't good. this is why I don't pay her any mind.

FIRST!: Selena is not the best singer and she doesn't have the best voice like Ariana.. But she can sing her own way! I really like her voice! I don't care what haters say but Selena still slay! I love her and I'll always love her! She is my rolemodel and she make me so happy♡

ver voice is unique !!! love this

Am I the only one that loves Ariana AND Selena? Stop comparing them both. Selena’s voice is gentle and soothing whilst Ariana is a powerhouse of vocals. And Selena’s voice is calming and her music is so special to a lot of us. It’s sad that people need to bash her all the time.

She is a beautiful person in and out and if you listen to her voice that isn't auto tuned it is really good.......

I really think her new music suits her voice so much more!! It's so nice and she delivers them so much better live! :)

Her voice fits her and her songs

She has a really beautiful voice like a unique rare voice that i've never heard before...

let's just keep in mind before judging her : 1_she suffers lupus which a very danger disease where body cells attack the body's organs 2_sometimes she can't breathe well while singing 3_most songs in these videos are without music and I think she is an amazing singer that makes amazing music

We get it. Selena doesn't have the most amazing love. Not everyone has a voice like Demi Lovato and Selena is one of them. But she loves singing and honestly I like her songs and how catchy they are. If you've been watching her for long time you'll notice that she's made a lot of progress. She's never claimed to be one of the biggest singers of her generation so don't act like she did. Plus her new songs are suited for and not too vocally challenging. Her voice can be very soothing tbh.

I wish I had a voice like her .I love you Selena!!!

I think that her voice is good when she sings at a lower tone because the high notes can get a little weird, but she is still is really good with her songs