my school band must be rare then cause my director is usually cracking jokes and we always have fun during marching band (band selfies, fun competing, ect) and we sound pretty good

PhionexFantom you could say that to jazz teachers (me) we're chill as fuk

Jazz teachers are either very chill or very harsh. Classical teachers like Taki tend to vary less in temperament but are often major perfectionists all the same. That said, any good teacher won't hold back from being honest. Taki was very realistically depicted. Reminded me a lot of my music teachers in both High School and University

i dont know what you are talking about mine is great.

My teacher was pretty laid back, even on the performances

Old man? I've never had a guy for a band director, actually.

Indiana Jones That’s new, most of the time people always have a man, either old or in between

That's your reality

Alternative: barely teaches anything

Breh my band director acts exactly like this guys except he's more awkward

I'm Unoriginal that had me raging, so you not expect to be practicing the same piece for a LONG time? What kind of band plays for a week and thinks that’s good enough?

HyperStar Gaming Especially when they find a way to be off beat WITH THE METRONOME They don’t even need to count, they just need to listen.

@@hyperstargaming6150 calm down. It's just an anime

Imagin saying that in muic school so childish

xiiao hao whether it’s an anime or not doesn’t matter, what matters is that the characters in the show are lazy and overconfident, when they clearly show they don’t have enough pure talent to get by all the way to ALL REGION. That’s quite prestigious, and extremely difficult.

semor 1539 we can never escape from the endless ling ling comments on different videos

No amount of Lingling insurance can compensate the burn from this teacher's roasts

i found a twosetter yay

“WeRe NOt a RoaStiNG ChAnNeL”

amazing

+Aneta Prosół Everyone said that, are they really so mad?

+Francesco A YES, THEY SERIOUSLY ARE. Unless they're conducting an elementary school, because yelling at tiny children doesn't go over well with the parents usually.

His calmness reminds me of the smile It gives

Yep...Taki-sensei is in the minority....this is why I'm in choir.

This is how an military officer chews people's asses. Says less, cuts more.

Exactly lol. And they really have the nerve to be mad when they were the ones who weren't practicing

Yeah we once practiced Bolero for 5 months. It was pain

Loaf cat Really? For my band, we had to practice for 7 months before we went to L.A. for an international music festival. If we played like the students here, we’d definitely get a 45 minute talk about how our effort isn’t enough and that we’re complacent. It was..rough.

They said that and I was like "amateurs, I breathe in the whole piece that I could still play my marching piece three years later with no practice in between. Y'all don't know the real struggle"

Considering they played so badly. A week isn't enough lol

lol

Everyone is fugly duckling 🐥

Lmao

had a teacher who straight up left the band for a month.I was the band leader(marching band) and had a pretty hard month keeping everything in place.

This is my orchestra

VanguardSupreme Id prefer this to what I’ve seen happen

Same here, I really got confused why people were saying he was nice and kind. when he was smiling through that whole roasting, I actually kinda got emotional and it kinda also hurt my feelings lmao

VanguardSupreme Gordon Ramsay would like to know your location

Soma Holiday They’re hard to compare in the first place. Here, there’s just a bunch of high schoolers, so this passive-aggressive approach is understandable. Let them feel like shit because they know they’re shit. In the case of Whiplash, the instructor conducting a prestigious jazz ensemble, and is going fuckin nuts to weed out the weak. Different circumstances lead to different approaches.

im glad my band teacher isnt like that

+Enigmatic Vertorso He even gave them the option of just having fun. The group insisted on their "aim for the nationals" goal for themselves.

alphamone Yeah...if you’re aiming for nationals and not practicing with a metronome, you should just focus on regionals instead. Or just giving performances without competing. I was like “wtf” watching this...how could these kids not practice with one of the most essential tools for musicians and think they could make nationals

My BD records us every once and a while and points out every bad part :))))

@@alphamone Well, most of them did anyway. Several others didn't.

Never saw this show, just only this clip. At first, I didn’t get why he was berating them since I assumed this was just a normal elective course/club. Not anything the students were seriously specializing in, or even wanting to make a career out of. Actually, I was a little annoyed at him, following that train of thought. The kids might just be doing it as a side thing, so they may not be serious. Moreover, maybe they have other things going on that would need their attention more. But then he mentioned how they aimed to go to Nationals, and his attitude made sense. Can’t be lax if the students themselves want to aim that high. And if they’re not actually serious about it, then there’s no need to keep dreaming about Nationals. You either get it together, practice and take it seriously so you can meet your goal. Or you can take it easy and not get serious about things like competitions and performances. But don’t waste anyone’s time if you’re all talk and have nothing to show for it.

一人二役、凄いですよね✨

声優さん同じなんですか？

あいなてゃん そーですよ！ 櫻井孝宏さんが演じています✨

やってるうちに入らんのだよなー でも、こんなレベルなら、パー練でどんなことしなきゃいけないかって、しっかり言っておくべきだったのでは？

くそっ、ハート💕押したいけど555なんで押せない(T . T)

Triggerhappypilot stop stealing my pic :^)

So you do know the difference !

No. Stop.

I'M UPSET!!!!

@@amyhua835 now I can only see Kumiko getting slapped up by Taki-sensei during her euphonium parts.

Same!

Me too

Sounds gay to me

He's adorable

Same lmao

み * 俺のとこは言えましたよ。 大分頭堅い先生だから よく喧嘩になりましたけどね。

うちは部内の仲は比較的良かったし、顧問も頼りないけど接しやすい感じで、わりと合奏中に先生の言うことに反対することは無かった（単に間違ったことを言ってないとわかってただけや）けど提案とかはかなり出来てた 普段、合奏とかじゃないときは先生と雑談で半分タメ口状態で話してたけど怒られへんかったし反論とかもしたけど1回相手のことを肯定する先生やったから普通に喧嘩になることもなかった… だから普通にガツガツ接せたぜ（長い）

中学の時(特に３年次)は先生と部員全員が仲良かったし信頼関係が強めだったからお互いに意見出し合いながら納得いくまで話し合ってたけど… 高校がこんなだったなって思う。先輩引退して1番上になった途端に他のみんな傲慢になって外部講師にめちゃくちゃ文句言ったり…(自慢じゃないけど私は講師に従うタイプだから何も言わない)

私はアメリカに住んでるので違うかもしれませんが、私の先生は凄く怒りますよ。メトロノームに合わせて弾けなかったら、授業を無しにしてしまいますよ！私のバンドは、トランペットが少しやばいので、一回うまく弾けないせいで、先生は怒ってスタンドを壊してしまいましたからwww

Even as a flutist/flute player I could tell something with off with the trombone section, it made me cringe in the inside.

Lol you can't tell what good trombone playing sounds like unless you're the conductor?

Diablito el Demonio have you not been at one of those music competition and you have “Von baron de la cremé”, a master bass flute player talk about how you don’t have the right flow to your rests? Cause I have and if you don’t think that conductors make some stuff up sometimes then you must have some great conductors. But I mean, yeah, I could tell something was off lol

It wasn’t a false scene because the conductor asked who thought it was good, not I think it’s not good

When a conductor asks this question, it almost always means that it sounded horrible. I would know. My band director asked us this question one time

外してるのはテンポだけですよねw 音がパオーンになってない。

これでも経験者がいるんだし、吹く分音色はよくなりそう。

りん それなぁ〜

@@reito-udon リードミスってたすごい

塚本が口を出すから・・・

伊佐野千夜 音は綺麗(((

伊佐野千夜 この酷さを演じられるプロさだよね

まあ滝先生がトロンボーンやってたからってのもあると思う

Hiroshi Naito やってました！って言ってたのは塚本やないよ！

元の顔も可愛すぎるよな ゴリラみたいな奴が3人くらいはいるはずなんだけど

ちょwww 私サックスやってて あんまり不細工にならないんやけど、部活のゴリラ思い出して吹いたww (・∀・)ﾔﾒﾚ!!!!

pet trum 顧問がごりらʬʬʬ

pet trum 慣れてくると(ずっと続けてると)不細工にならないよ！

だーくえんじぇる お！同じだ!!!!

Rain LOL if he said that.

xiCenitiix That's pretty much what he said, hahaha. Only with nicer words.

Rain Don't forget the smile!

臨時攻撃態勢 それなw

究極に矛盾

ほんまに上手い人にしかできんよな…

中武三紀 矛盾の意味わかってなくて草

下手な人だけじゃなくて、シンバルとか、所々うまい人がいるのもリアルだよね

倍音練習したらすぐにできるようになりますよー！倍音練習したら、リードミスも減るので、一石二鳥

@伊佐野千夜 え、いえいえ、謝らないでください( ˊᵕˋ ;)💦コツ書いただけなので(；´∀｀)

リードミスするまで吹きまくって､リードミスしたところをアニメ側が合わせた説微レ存

本当にうまい人とかはわざとリードミスできるらしいです。わざとリードミスするのも一つの練習法だと先生に聞きました。。！Byホルン吹き

oh yeah, i felt this too back when I played the violin. once we got a different teacher who was garbage at managing the class, and everyone played poorly or talked to each other and stuff like that WHILE THE MUSIC WAS PLAYING, i lost passion and my playing got bad too. unfortunately i never really got back into it because the whole band class removed the string instrument section after that year and the same teacher stayed :p

EmiOkimeOtaku I like how right from the first bad performance the show tackled how differently people react to poor performances between musicians and people who don't know anything about music. I've never been into band/ensemble stuff but those first performances had me cringing.

Stuntddude Agreed.

Im in orchestra but they were so damn off beat.Like seriously wtf.

HOW IN THE FUCK DO THEY EVEN SPEAK THE WORD "Nationals"? THEY WERE SO OFF BEAT THAT THEY'D HAVE TROUBLE EVEN PLAYING HOT CROSS BUNS

omg, ikr??! and the whole band has the guts to participate the suFes in this type of situation, such a horror!

non band people: I can’t tell that its wrong, sounds fine to me

The trombones being of beat literally hurt me 😂😂

@@mindlessreader1595 as someone who has grew up around 2 band siblings, hearing this was painful

Terence Fletcher: Not quite my tempo.

"No way he'll get that far" *the band makes it to finals in his first year of teaching* Suck it, band directors

普通に考えて無理

いや、でも名前出していいのか分からないけど活水中学・高校の吹部の例があるから絶対無理というわけじゃ…🤔 まぁ並大抵の努力じゃ成し遂げれないのは確かですけど( ‐ω‐)

トランペット吹き さん 「響け！！」は好きですが、何回見ても「これで・・・？？」と思ってしまう自分がいます。 いや、もちろん全てが描けるはずはないんですけど、ビックリするような常識を超えた画期的な練習方法があるわけでもなさそうだしなぁ 世の中、ものすごい創意工夫を重ねて地区大会上位常連の強豪にはなれたけど、まだ全国には1度も行けてない学校、先生がいっぱいいるし、学生さんの立場からすると、3年死ぬほど練習してもやっぱり無理ってことがほとんど。 まして「関西」は、毎年「全国常連校」が順繰り持ち回りで全国出場3枠を占めてしまい「初出場」ってほんと稀(去年の迎星はすごい)。でもたまに初出場があっても、やっぱり関西大会金賞を何度も取ってる強豪と言われた学校。京都の高校はどこも、もう十何年も全国行けてない。 さらに関西には吹奏楽連盟理事長がずっと指導してる「淀○」が居るので、他地域より確実に1枠損してる。審査に忖度はないと信じたいけど、所詮は主観のはずなのに、どんだけ審査員が変わって時代が変わっても、同じ自由曲(3、4曲)をグルグル回して「鉄板」じゃあ悲しい。あの理事長の吹奏楽への功績はよくわかるけど、「連盟の理事になるんなら、個別校の指導者やっちゃダメ」ってルールぐらいあるべきじゃないの？だいたい、連盟の理事に「任期」はないのか？不祥事の責任とって辞めへんのかい。 なんだかちょっと違う方向に行ってごめん。でも、こう思う関西人は少なくないはず。不祥事直後だけに今年こそ「淀○」落ちて他の学校に門戸が開かれると期待してただけにコロナで流れて残念。

ka mio 今年のあたらしい顧問 吹奏楽部未経験の新任音楽教師😭何にもわかってなさすぎて本当に部活嫌になりそう

吉岡仁美 本当にそれ。うちの顧問と全く一緒！

めちゃ分かります…。 コンクールのクラのソロオーディション(しかもマードック)を年功序列じゃなくて、実力で決めたいからやりたいと先輩が顧問に言いに言ったのにも関わらず、「貴方が吹きたいだけじゃないの？」と真顔で言われてました…。頭硬すぎな指導者は吹部に4人も要らないなと思いますね、ダメ金で喜んでるような吹部なんだと去年思いました、最悪です。

私の部活のとこなんか元顧問と副顧問どっちとも移動になって、音楽経験ゼロ、数学教師の人が顧問だよ😭 ほんとどーなっとる笑

@@user-yu2xm7ci1i 異動ですか？ 確かに音楽の知識が足らない顧問はちょっと困りますね😅

😂😂😂😂😂🔥🔥🔥

Tania Lmao

普通に無理だな。

瀧じゃなくて滝だよw w w w w w

。しらす それがまたいい

。しらす 君の名は

。しらす さん 流石「毒舌イケメン悪魔」

いわゆる「名物」の先生なら、もっと主張したり鼓舞したりしそうなところ。これで伝わるだろうか？と疑問に思うのは私だけだろうか？ しかも「部長」か誰かに裏でそっと手助けしてるわけでもなく・・・

LOL

+Raptor Jesus Like Terrace Fletcher from Whiplash?

Omg my teacher is the same.

LOL same but not with the cursing

Mine is the same but he's around 70 and he says witty stuff about how some parts suck, but with love you know

Underrated comment

しかも、この曲海兵隊と言って小学生のとき金管で４年生が吹いてたやつ（笑）

あるよ

H. A. めっさ入門だよね

海兵隊吹いたことないけど弱小のうちでもさすがにこれはないかな …この後登っていく覚悟も根性もないけどね！！！

ごめん、うちの高校これと同レベかこれ以下の気が…((

こんなの怖いうちに入らんだろう？？

むしろ優しい笑

高校って人数多いし、やっぱり下手なとこやと何となくで入ってる人おりそう。緩そうーとか。私中学やけど実際本気で音楽が好きで入った人、うちの学年半分くらいやったし。私も、やってるうちに好きになった人やから最初は部活めんどかったし練習も真面目にしてなかったし。

いや、これだけ揃う学校ならもう少しマシなはず。

nami kisaragi それな、こんな顧問いたら毎日通うわ

That's not it at all. If a director is speaking purely out of disgust, they'll speak out of disgust. The calm disappointment here is what you get from a director who has been frustrated thousands of times before and by now has realized that frustration doesn't do anything to troubleshoot an ensemble.

Archer: THERE ARE MANY REASONS.

そんなん言う前にパー練回ればええんや。

Its cause her clarinet squeeked

Erick GTRZ yes i know. i am in band.

@@adventmercy lul who asked

Gabriel Pelayo i was just saying im in band lol

Idk man pretty sure she should replace her reed

is that Toscanini who said that?

Raptor Jesus damn.

You mean slide whistle?

Okay Raptor Jesus

*yus*

and no kazoo

It's already been done by departed reflections in the intro to his review of the show. :D

ペットにれいながいるからかな？

鎖那 麗奈は上手いから合ってると思うけど…

鎖那 は？

Who wouldn’t? 😂

stick as in a metronome?

@@daten__ probably hitting a stick against a stand or cowbell, it's what my band director does.

The common instruments get called in to play their parts, us Bassoons don’t even play half of the time

Nah, my choir teacher is pretty much like this guy, making us feel bad in the calmest way possible.

Poot Potatoes my choir teacher is very nice and he even rewards everytime we did well. Whenever he gives us a difficult part to sing, he laughs and says "well damn this is going to be a ride for you" which gets even funnier when you see the troubled faces of the singers. And then if we sing bad, he'll have this really sad expression on his face when he would tell us that we're not good enough and it's in a pretty calm way. That makes us sing the song even better the next time.

Sad if you really think about it.

Steve Burstall that’s actually really sad