This is so great .... Thank you for this

I haven't noticed the change in ratio, but yeah, goes well with the theme of the video!

Actually! *nerd voice activated* It's not 16:9 in the end but 21:9 or probably 2.39:1.

​@@DJHEADPHONENINJAyeah it is

I love that!!

Asking bc I legit dont know but arent they effectively disbanded after lsoing their Chinese members?

⁠​⁠@@MinteeMusic the group social media is still somewhat active, remaining 8 members under sse did a seasons greetings promo. it has been silent otherwise. fwiw i don't think they will release music together again, unless it is an anniversary release, à la snsd/kara/rainbow.

@@MinteeMusicno

No, they continue for many amazing songs after many years @@MinteeMusic

@@MinteeMusic - No, WJSN continued as 10 members even after the C-line did not return to the group. Their contracts were renewed last year except for Luda and Dawon, who did not sign new contracts with Starship. However, Starship management made it clear that even though they did not sign contracts, they are STILL considered members of WJSN. Whether this means they will participate in future releases or promotions is unknown.

I was thinking if this was an ive song people would be eating this up. Shame people sleep on ive's older sister group...

Yeah, more vocal-based songs tend not to be popular which is a shame. /: Also, sorry, it’s just a pet peeve of mine, but it’s “losing” not “loosing.”

Don't worry. We are enough for seola. She doesn't need that fake trends. Our queen is real so is her song. Chill n just enjoy her work.

Oh for reaal, it's obvious that songs nowadays are only for the trend but this one reminds to when the times were good lol really good song

yes! i felt like this entire song is full. no empty parts, the chorus is also so well written compared to empty repetitive songs. ❤

💯 I really like there's a good amount of KOREAN lyrics. Nowadays most K-pop songs have too many English words

Yes!! Finally someone thinks like me.

I agree

Is that just your assessment of things? Because unless you have the artists or songwriters making official public statements to back up this ridiculous idea, I'm going to call it BS. In fact, the songwriters would probably be insulted to think they're being accused of just writing music to satisfy some kind of TikTok challenge trend. ANY song can be made into a challenge, even old ones that existed before TikTok. And for the record, TikTok is social poison and should be banned.

I thought the same

I loveee the songgg

FACTS

starship sucks fr

as you wish is probably one of my favorites as well

@@hungphamviet3543It is a great song! I love it! :D

🤧🤧🤧🤧

could you explain?

Stopppp i’m going to cry 🥲😭

@LenaKolchuk sure sure! - The 10 chairs and candles can represent the current 10 members of WJSN. - The blue butterfly, was used previously to represent the 3 chinese members in their song Save Me Save You & La La Love. WJSN's song butterfly was allegedly going to be the song where they would return to the group but instead became an unofficial goodbye as YueHua Entertainment quietly pulled out of the project. Blue butterflies have a lot of meaning and symbolism as well. ( you can see in releases after butterfly would not mention YueHua Entertainment ) - The clock and time imagery is related to their lore when they were participating on the show queendom 2 and somewhat in their MVs there have been time imagery too. (Not really related, but it's a fun fact. In the As You Wish MV, there were 9 clocks on the wall, which coincidentally aligns with As You Wish being their 9th album release)

they didn't put ad for mv😢

@@susuhlaing3492 yep, it's also kinda sad how so many kpop mv nowadays has its views artificially inflated, especially when you compare their mv views to the group's regular content views

@@wjsnsd it was necessary tho like not many people will know seola comeback unless they promoted it on yt ads but now mv views r organic and kinda growing each day so that's not enough but still doing ok but i wish sse put ads that way youtube will also suggest it to new viewers

@@susuhlaing3492 Yep I agree wholeheartedly and sadly sse will never change their ways towards wjsn

There’s a lot of things wrong with Starship. Not promoting Seola is one of them.

well seola was the one organizing all this but yeah sse approved this work so we can support it..

starship ain’t done shit this is all full bloom x seola they made the music together. but i will give them a silent applause for giving her a decent mv and having all her ideas incorporated successfully. it’s the LEAST they could do after fucking up wjsn.