I’m trying to watch as much as I can I do enjoy your reactions.. I would like to see you react to a woman in Thrash .. Agnostics Business Suits and Combat Boots

One of my favorite albums ever! Should have picked a different song though, like Desperate Cry. Do another Between the Buried and Me!!! Please!!! The one y’all did was NOT a good starting point for them...

@@clashcor_4685 White Walls or Selkies are good starting points for sure

One main thing about Sepultura that George was spot on about when he says it's very street-raw is that Sepultura came from a large city in Brazil and played heavy music as a reaction to the outright corruption they lived through that ranged from everything to crooked cops to government officials to church clergy. They were a protest band, and their early music is almost too raw for that exact reason. Kudos to George for recognizing that!

Igor Cavalera (brother of the former vocalist/rhythm guitarist Max Cavalera) the Drummer, was a bit more technical (before "Roots"), and the violent riffage is what put Sepultura on the map, especially for me on this album. Again, imagine thousands of longhairs headbanging and starting a tornado in the slam-pit! They were from a pretty rough city in Brazil, so it reflects in the sound and lyrics. There is a LOT of "polished" Thrash too Ryan, they usually have a more Progressive take on Thrash too (like early Annihilator), a bit more complex, and are more underground or very obscure. George was sure gettin' into it though! "No Mercy" . . . If you thought Inner Self is chaotic, listen to the title track of "Arise" (my fave track), that is one dangerous slam-pit! Also, it took me a few months to get into Sepultura, when my younger brother introduced this album to me after its release. It was yet another step into Extreme Metal that I got used to, and wanted to explore further. There are MUCH more "chaotic"/complex bands out there - this song is actually pretty tame. But we Metalheads had to start somewhere to get used to the brutality, abrupt changes and complexities. . . . But I HOPE both you guys keep going, keep discovering and just taking it all in and coming to your own conclusions. But let's scare Ryan even further ;D: From Germany; *Kreator* - "Betrayer", ""Extreme Aggression", "As the Sun Burns Red", for a reaction? For the more Progressive (including polished), and complex Thrash, Death Metal and more . . . kzfaq.info/sun/PL2DU3TBNutEdtiYql5HxhzIxzuFIPcXS9 \m/

4sure

Except for the fact that it's a Scott Burns production so it sounds like everything else he ever produced.

@@BlasphemousVerses exactly! Scott Burns was pretty much, the "Pro Tools" before computer software etc etc was even thought of..

@Pleasure To Kill we welcome you even though you like the worst teutonic thrash band

@@BlasphemousVerses scott burns used a computer.

I AGREE" WELL SAID !,.

This was the band and album that turned me !

Arise is one of the few perfect albums. Not a second of it can be improved from start to finish.

Schizophrenia beats both

@@Idontwantahandle6669 Everyone forgets Schizophrenia, its easily the best thrash they put out. That being said Morbid Visions > all Sepultura discography.

I'll take Altars of Madness over this, but Beneath the Remains is very close. Neck & neck.

YES

​@@dreggymonaltar it's death metal

Yes

They play this song with a up speed tempo which I think sounds better

I still have the MTV Headbangers Ball VHS video. Its unmixed and so pure and raw. The official release didn't have that crushing tone. Its still unbelievable.

I remember getting this on VHS for Christmas way back in 93! Watched it so much - pure gold!

Saw them in Manchester UK on that tour in a pretty small venue. Utter insanity and still one of the best gigs of my life.

@@hairychris444old academy broke my nose stage diving hurt like hell but the best pit I’ve ever been in

That freaking nailed it.

No early 80s Metallica no Sepultura though, Metallica invented this shit damn near 40 years ago.Younger people just don't realize how underground and heavy Metallica were in the early 80s.

Does that make Slayer the Ultimate Warrior?

@@MrToband nope! they would exist even without Metallica! They just had the same influences, like Motorhead and Venom.

@@Rightio slayer are more like nailz

mike stoker I’m always amazed how they juxtapose heaviness and beauty in that song, it has my second favorite solo by them too after Mass Hypnosis

Absolutely, my favorite sepultura song.

I think the same thing for Alterted State

This is song is F I R E

Hands down the best of Sepultura to me!! “Desperate Cry” is such an awesome song!

the guy is a genius! played very simple but with a ton of musicality. every beat he did was well calculated. his tones were unique too.

@@alfredoduarte1516 Agreed!

@@alfredoduarte1516 very simple ? I guess you never played stronger than hate ...

Never underrated by me that's for sure.. Igor is a ledge...

and he was only 18 when this was recorded.

I feel like they dont get as much credit for their influence on death/black metal.

I think that was part of the appeal. It made the lyrics and Max’s phrasing so unique and visceral.

What about groove metal??

@@MaddDogg316 Absolutely agree.

@@WilliamSchneir I don’t really hear it you could say roots maybe was groove but I would consider that almost nu metal kinda like slipknot

Excellent explanation!

dub! 👍👍👍

Make no mistake about it... Metallica is the father and Godfather of thrash metal. Their "Kill 'em All" album was the album that ushered in and introduced "thrash" metal to the world as we know it.

This may be one of the most succinct and intelligent explanations of the genre I've ever read. Tip of the hat to you sir!

cavman250 No mistakes have been made. His explanation is perfect.

Sepultura even have an album called Chaos AD. lol

I don't agree actually. There are many fantastic Thrash songs that get somewhat ruined by weird chaotic subsections or solos (looking at you, Kerry King).

@@JHorsti I'm totally with you. I hear one guy say that is to encourage a mosh session. I don't know, just listening it's seems unnecessary a lot of times. But to each their own.

@@JHorsti But there are times it's totally called for. Check out a song called Terminator by a thrash band called Magnus. That solo is chaos, but it's awesome.

I don't think it's chaos, it's just heavy and brutal. It's actually very well structured

😎🤝

You sir took the words out of my mouth.

Just one minor point. While this album was still recorded in Brazil, which means equipment wasn't cutting edge, they did have the mad genius Scott Burns producing it.

nada haver o que vc falou eu sou brasileiro e vive na cidade do sepultura não tem nada de desespero aqui no brasil seu imbecil

@@eduardocesar9210 Calma tio, nao foi isso que ele quis dizer.

@@rorz999 when their dad was alive they were set but when tragically passed when they were at a young age they were left with nothing

I agree Desperate Cry is a fantastic tune.

Infected Voice too!!!!!

Every song from Arise is just a masterpiece. But I agree, Desperate Cry is my personal fav.

@@TWANDTWthat solo in desperate cry is by far epic. the live music video where the crowd was chanting during the solo section made the song more epic

Big agree here. Desperate cry!!!!

YEEEESSSSS

Death?? To Forgive Is To Suffer.

They ain't ready for that

Yeah, that's a better choice.

100% I've been asking for it! Desperate Cry

As much as they'd like Desperate Cry, I think they'd like Territory even more.

@@edgcrushr and Refuse Resist

BRUTAL

Definitely one of the tops

Totally agree

With you on this

Arise is one of my favourite albums

First song I ever heard from them, was instantly hooked haha

I don't get why people just keep and keep and keep and keep on requesting songs they won't like. What don't you understand. Don't get we wrong, Left Hand Path is a masterpiece for me, but they're obviously hate the shit out of it. These guys need groove. From Sepultura, give them Territory or Propaganda.

TheAskald because the whole point is to expand their musical horizons. They are still discovering a new band and just because they don’t like one song doesn’t mean they’ll dislike everything.

@@johnwebb3078 No, the whole point is to see them enjoy what we enjoy, at least for me. Seeing Ryan with a dead bored face the whole video is boring and that's not what I search personally. I've been watching this channel since september 2017 and there's clearly a pattern, especially with Ryan. He loves mid tempo groovy metal. Yet here we are with people still requesting stuff like Left Hand Path... I could make the perfect list of metal songs he would enjoy (The Conjuring from Megadeth was a really obvious one, glad the community suggested it, one of the greatest metal riffs...).

TheAskald I’ve been watching it for a long time and i understand the type of stuff they usually like, but what’s the point of doing unbiased opinions on different types of music if you’re just going to like everything? Should they just go through every Rush song?

@@johnwebb3078 You made a good point, but I think that requests must hit that sweet spot between something relatively new to do them, but at the same time still something they'll like. And for example Left Hand Path is even far more thrashy than Inner Self that was already far too much for them. Anyways

Yeah I was waiting for the offensive part of his critique.

@@RickBobO Funny thing, Gojira is hugely influenced by Sepultura. See the Rolling Stone article below, where Joe Duplantier cites Chaos AD as one of favorite metal albums, and says "Our first gig in ’96 was 70 percent Sepultura covers." www.rollingstone.com/music/music-lists/gojiras-joe-duplantier-my-10-favorite-metal-albums-201839/sepultura-chaos-a-d-1993-193622/

@@RickBobO Thats why i love about metal. There are always metal songs that appeal to different people. Everyone can relate lyrically, whether its about depression and loneliness or about togetherness and oneness.

Thomas Cosumar I agree. That album changed my Life. I don’t know if it’s my favorite trash album cause it’s difficult for me to choose between Ride The Lightning, Master of Puppets and Peace Sells but who’s buying... 🤔

1. Sepultura-Beneath the Remains 2.Exodus-Bonded by Blood 3.Megadeth-Peace sells... 4.Kreator-Pleasure to Kill 5.Artillery-By Inheritance (Ryan would love this one)

I remember listening to Chaos A.D. when I was 13, and thought it was the dirtiest thing ever. Then a friend of mine lent me a copy of Beneath the Remains. Completely different, but i can listen to both from beginning to end.

Beneath the Remains was my gateway metal album. I still have a special place in my heart for it!

I picked up this album from a used CD shop when I was in 6th grade, and it blew me away. Inner Self and Beneath the Remain are, IMO, 2 of the best thrash metal songs of all time

That's a shame. Even nowadays I don't like his accent. I'd take Derick for sure. He's got a unique voice and perfect english accent

@@thiagoklock5064 He's american, but his voice sucks when it comes to Max era songs.

@@Salomon_G true, lol.

@@thiagoklock5064 I started with max so for me he is the voice but i do understand your position.

He already knew English by this album he's just always had a heavy accent. Troops of doom was the last time he really struggled with English

Holy shit imagine seeing you here. RIP Popcorn

It really is awesome how they have evolved. I never thought I'd be so fascinated at watching people's reactions to songs. It's pretty cool how these guys have been open minded enough to give metal a chance. From metal to hip hop, country, pop... Music has no limits to how it can inspire ALL walks of life.

@@cavman250 Their reactions to some of my favorite tracks is downright touching at times. I love their new obsession with Alice in Chains.

Ryan will never be a metalhead. And that's okay.

It's such a great feeling when they connect to music we grew up with

That's terrible to be fair. More commercial than others albums and the sound is not as good

Monkeyfarm yeah that’s when they immediately went down hill.

Call it commercial, call it the beginning of the end, call it whatever you want. That song still kicks ass and I think LIV would like it too.

That song is VERY horrible..

Chaos AD is when they sold their soul and basically ended as a valuable musical band. No wonder MTV bombed us with the advertisments of that album during that year.

"Suicide Machine", "Flattening of Emotions", "Lack of Comprehension", these 3 are the holy trilogy of Human :)

This is the first death metal song I heard in my life, watching a MTV metal show in the middle of the night. It was in 2002, shortly after Chuck passed away, and it changed my life forever. Death is my favorite band to this day.

"trinity" not "trilogy" I meant, sorry I'm french :)

Anything off of Leprosy.

R.I.P. Sean Reinert, truly a legend

Well said... Me too man!

Me too but I can't listen to 90 percent of it anymore, death metal that is. All the growling and can't hear what they're saying is annoying now at 45. Ehhhh can't do it no more. Hypocrisy was the shit😎

Same to me! Cheers!

@@luisamoa2500 Yep. I can appreciate the instrumentation in some heavier stuff but let's face it, death metal isn't timeless. Gojira is probably the closest thing to being timeless in that type of genre. A big reason for that is because you can understand what they're saying, even in their heavy stuff and they also have songs with clean vocals. Just my opinion, of course.

Miss the old sepultura ... The metal they made ..

😎

Spanish in general

@@felixreyes8560 - Yeah but spanish isn't exactly Brazil's language...

I know

Actually Sepultura is a grave robber

Anything off Chaos AD would work. Territory and Slave New World are both great choices for non-metal fans.

Chaos A.D is a great gateway record for people new or inexperienced to metal. It's heavy, it's chock full of great riffs and has a great tone, but it's also fairly simplistic, not too overbearing and produced well enough/clear enough so as to not sound really raw.

Perfect example of a song that their fans and/or Patreon supporters should be requesting. Territory is groovy and would hook them easily.

This is one of my fav early Sep tracks... Yes on Territory and ChaosAd in general but I do not downplay the accessibility of that album vs their earlier work. Yes it’s not as aggressive and raw and relentless but it’s so solid from start to finish and for me one of my all time favorites. I recommend Refuse and Resist and my fav overlooked Sep. song ... Nomad.

Nomad is so good

​@@DemonaeTV It's the attractiveness to aggressive music. This tips the scales for just raw, unleashed ferocious thrash metal, or just metal really. Slayer too. For me they aren't the tightest or most creative musicians, but the extremeness... god damn...

If you want real brutal metal, play Nile or Cryptopsy.Hehhehe

@@jimmyandersson59 lashed to the slave stick

Vinicius Leão de Almeida true

I partly agree.... I believe that once they went into playing in english, they have to do it as good as a native speaker would.... For us brasilians, songs in english, even when we understand english, we care most about the rhytm more than the lyrics itself. For them native speakers, maybe the lyrics sounds raw or even childish. For sure, nowadays sepultura would work far better on this song lyrics. Id love to know what a gringo would say after listening to bestial devastation, troops of doom.... 😄

What's amazing to me is that I actually find Max easier to decipher than most English speaking growly metal singers.. you'd think the opposite would be true, but perhaps BC it's not his 1st language, he has to focus more on what he's saying.. all I know is that he's always been, and always will be awesome. Definitely one of the all-time greats of both metal growling vocals, and rhythm guitar.. big up to 🇧🇷, hope I get to visit one day!

If nothing else, this is what holds this album fresh till these days.

the vocalist for Sarcofago was Sepultura's first vocalist.

Angra!!!

Krisiun

Claustrofobia é do caraio

The Mist was founded two years after Sepultura. But Vladimir Korg, The Mist and also Chakal vocalist, had an important role at the beggining of Sepultura's carrer while working at Cogumelo Records store. He was the one who said to Pati and João from Cogumelo to take a better look at Sepultura.

One can argue that this is Death - Thrash ganre of HM.

This era was when thrash was heading toward grindcore on it's way to death metal

@@tajbaber9425 eh?

senna, fangio. pele and maradona! saludos brother

No me imagino el mundo sin el Beneath The Remains, si están bien Death, Morbid Angel, Possesed, Sodom, Kreator en esa época, pero ese disco es tan bueno.

Word on that, Death has it's melodic and wonderful progressive songs, they're missing out truly

I feel like something off of either Symbolic or The Sound of Perseverance would be best. What do you think?

@@marcusrobertson5627 Hell yeah! I think they would love Without Judgement or Lack of Comprehension.

Death/Thrash

I think Sepultura influenced death metal more than the other way around. They were at their rawest when they begin, and there were no death metal bands at the time, they were the pioneers (of something nowadays known as war metal, to be fully precise). It makes more sense to say that they were influenced by thrash, later, when Andreas Kisser entered the band and they created their death/thrash sound.

Sepultura was one of the first bands doing that, they influenced Death not the other day around. They can also be considered among the first wave of black metal as well, even the first singer from Sepultura left the band to form Sarcófago, one of the first Black Metal bands, they were the first ones doing corpse paint. These guys were WAY ahead of the curve.

@@YannickTMessiah You're right, Sepultura were influenced by thrash bands, like Metallica and Slayer, and bands that people nowadays would describe as proto-black metal or proto-death metal like Venom, Hellhammer, Celtic Frost and Possessed. Their first album "Bestial Devastation" is one of the earliest releases that can be considered pure death metal.

Great band! Not sure they would really dig them though

@@lurgoyff oh, I know for a fact they won't like them. I just want to see their reaction haha

.44 Caliber Brain Surgery!

Or anything from Darkness Descends, they would absolutely dislike any of those brutally fast songs

Real talk I'd love to see them react to Neanderthal

I feel the same with Exodus, both are underrated bands IMO.

Agreed. They only reviewed a mediocre cover from them and wrote them off! Why did they do them like that???! How about the song The New Order from the album The New Order! It´s awesome!

I liked Testament, their problem was that they were too close in sound and songwriting to Metallica (maybe it's just my opinion). And that's just throwing a huge shadow.

Testament couldn't ever keep their shit together long enough to make waves and by the time they did Thrash was at its very end.

And don't forget Slayer 🤘😎🤘

They would definitely enjoy refuse/resist!

Territory is so heavy! Manifest too!

actually their cover of Policia is very shot and sweet.

Arise is what pulled me into the metal world. That guitar riff at the beginning.

No, they didn't like this. Obviously you didn't watch the video before you commented.

I mean one of them liked it.

@@Mr.Truxton it made George's playlist!! Even Ryan said he liked it but didn't like it.

Nice. Do teachers allow to do that in classrooms?

❤️❤️❤️💪💪💪

The Cavaleras were actually from an affluent family. Their dad was a diplomat. I'm sure Paulo Jr. And Andreas Kisser were not poor by any means, either.

@@BayStatePrepper You might actually want to read up on that. The Cavaleras were going through a financial crisis after their father died when Max was like 9. So whatever wealth he had experienced definitely wasnt there in his teens. The other two were well off though.

He would like Pantera for sure.

They should give Cathedral a chance lol

I love thrash myself it's one of my favorite types of music. The groove to me is the best part of thrash. I don't mind the chaos do that too but I wouldn't like thrash if that's all it was. It absolutely needs the groove for it to be great thrash!

No this is pure deathmetal

I always found that era of Sepultura (e.g. Beneath the Remains) was more close to the hardcore punk stuff that band such as Extreme Noise Terror, Doom and the like.

Death-thrash metal. Dude

YES!

If it doesn't bring a tear you have NOT arrived yet guys

Spirituuuaalll healiiiing!

Anything off Leprosy.

Totally true! Ryan was so apologethic. If you don't like a song, you don't like a song. Enough said

@@enriqueplanas Well said.

First time I listened to Killing Is My Business I was like "what is this nonsense?" I literally didn't understand what was going on. Too raw and fast for my untrained ears lol

@@Walamonga1313 especially non remastered version hahahaha

@@Walamonga1313 Killing Is My Business is just an amazing album from Megadeth

And the funny thing for me is, I came coming back to listen to these heavy Thrash songs for some reason. There was an appeal and I think George is starting to get that

Absolutely

Oh hell yes!

Don't forget Pyroclastic Annihilation!

Can't go wrong with some DH. I'd recommend Aborticide or 44 caliber brain surgery.

Human Dissection

No!! The Band are from Belo Horizonte/MG

They are from Minas Gerais but I loved your comment anyway

Cavalera's brothers and Paulo Jr. (bass) are from Minas Gerais. Andreas Kisser (guitarrist) was raised in São Paulo. The band itself stablished and gained success playing in Sao Paulo scene...specially ABC cities

Or Leeway!

I love All out war and irate.

NYHC is the best. They should do a NYHC week

CPotter Vlog madball- set it off