Roof korean: No loot - No shoot

There's just something about a tan gun

8:39 some brass does magic on the left side of the table 🙅🤯

The Glock 19X that was submitted for military trials did have an external safety, also I was really surprised that Glock did not have an MOS slide for this.

You absolutely changed my mind about the m17 and I think I’m going with this one.

The Glock submitted to the military had a manual safety!

My dad is looking to buy his first "combat ready" or "fight gun" type of pistol and I've been recommending both of these to him. This video is perfect timing to be able to show him why either is a great choice, and just before fathers day. Going to the range this weekend to try them out.

Instantly knew what that T-Shirt was.

the 19x was originally submitted with a saftey

I bought the M17 a couple weeks ago and I couldn’t be happier. Great performance and amazing reliability. I’m planning on buying a smaller slide and barrel so I can customize it for range and conceal carry.

😅When you started shooting at 3:20 my initial reaction was, oh crap is Chad behind the camera?!

@7:40 "That's ok, I got a big mag for that." The way to solve all of life's problems.

When it comes down to two guns that are both reliable and accurate it always comes down to which feels better to you and which one you shoot better.

I appreciate your views on firearms, y’all are always one of the videos I watch for whichever firearm I’m interested in. Thank you keep up the good work

I'm adding this comment before I watch the video. I was issued a Glock 19 when I was deployed to Afghanistan and Iraq. It worked every time I pulled the trigger and when it came to putting rounds on target accurately weather it was paper or a bad guy I hit where I aimed. The Glock is battle tested and you'll never change my mind. But I still like to see the comparison. I now have a 19x and would much rather have it over the Sig any day. Oh and my Glock never broke.

7:28 and you don’t have to use 19x specific mags only gen 5’s don’t fit the 19x but gen 4’s and earlier do fit the 19x

Love my 19x. Next will be the g45. Love a gun I can shoot all day with no problems. Works every time for me. Worth every dollar

almost bought a M17 at youngest daughters work, noticed the rear sights are blacked out, but right next to the M17 they had an M18, so, went with the M18.

These videos are a taste of sanity in this crazy world.

"I prefer the Sig...but I actually keep the Glock on the nightstand." 🤔🤔🤔

The 19-X is the only Glock i will own, metal sights, great trigger, adaptable grip three mags and shoots very accurate, though pricey in comparison the Sig M17 is preferable in handling and just feels better in the hand. owning both may be redundant but fun.

The side by side shooting was very cool! Do more of that.

The m17 is the better gun, the p320 series is amazing i have 4 i freaking love them. I like the 19x, but i dont like glocks. But the 19x is a nice pistol.

Sig won based on price. Sig and Glock met requirements, but price decided the winner, great job with the video.

LOVE the straight on camera angle, looks great.

The M17 is like a garage queen supercar, while the 19X is like the sportscar that one would love to drive daily

The Military has reported multiple miss firing by the M17 & P320, even when holstered. I would not trust my life to this gun. The problem was supposed to be fixed and the new M17 has the same issues... Will you now carry it ?

Full auto 19x meltdown would be awesome

Very fair review Eric. Love all the points you are addressing. I haven’t really delved much into why the sig was chosen. This explains it fairly.

I couldn't decide which one was better so I got both of them :-)

The glock that was submitted had that manual safety. My only complaint is that the 19x finish isn't as robust as I had hoped. Wore it out into the woods one day while cutting shooting lanes and scratched it down the right hand side from either a branch or a ladder.

The Honda Civic or... Ford pickup truck? I'm not sure these are in the same class of reliability haha.

The 19X trials gun had an ambi safety and optics cut, those were requirements for the trails, if it didn’t have it, it would have been sent back and not even been in the trials. And you don’t need 19X specific mags, you just can’t use the gen 5 base pad. The 19X isn’t using special mags, just colored gen 1-4 mags

8:39 bullet casing on the left does some strange stuff wtf?

The Sig P320 is by far my favorite handgun, but the short slide/long grip combo of the g19x gets my respect.

The military Glock 19x had a manual safety

It's been mentioned, but for reinforcement.. the Glock that was submitted to the trials did have a manual safety.

The government choosing the Sig had little to do with the functionality, or the platform......it mostly had to do with the fact that Glock was more expensive whenever it came to spare magazines and spare parts..... The government usually will settle for the lowest bidder on just about everything.

3:24 I almost shit myself thinking there was a cameraman.

I flinched when you shot toward the camera. I thought someone was standing back there.

Glock fan boys: Does it take Glock Mags? 19x: sort of

Sig actually did what the army wanted. Glock tried to make what they had work

Looks like the military might have some issues with their new Sig's. Just read up on some of the problems with the m17 which include: accidental discharge, failure to feed, failure to eject, and consistent stoppages when firing FMJ rounds. That's a lot of problems for one gun to have. Guess that's why i carry a Glock 19. Before all the Glock haters start trashing me about this comment, I just want to put out there that i have nothing against this specific gun. I actually thought it was pretty cool and the price wasn't crazy high like a lot of the Sig's i see usually. But the accidental discharge that some of the Sig's have and the overall high price of some of their guns has been the main reason why i avoid Sig's most of the time.

The Sig FCU was such a genius idea.

Damn. I thought Chad was behind the camera when you started shooting lol. - Duck Chad!!

I’ve been waiting for someone to do this

7:15 gen 4 magazines work perfectly only gen 5 mags have a problem.

While the other “commentary “ videos are important, it’s a breath of fresh air to see a firearm shooting video again!

When the videos drop like that im coming HERE EVERY TIME!!

Gen 4 and older Glock 17 mags will work in the 19x. The gen 5 G17 mags are the only mags that have the baseplates that extend forward.

My buddy bought the 19x, but I wanted the G17 gen 5. We shoot them both a lot, but I’m still glad I got the G17 over the 19x.

Please watch small arms solutions video on the m17 program

Thinking as a (former) Soldier: Of the Glock, the sights would've been my biggest complaint. But, they addressed that with the night sights. Also, in spite of my personal, *slight* aversion to the design (ergos and stock sights), Glock *IS* an excellent, robust design with a great track record. Even so, the Sig is better over all, imo-- sights, ergos, modularity, etc. (Although, I do prefer the shorter Sig the Marines went with for ease of use and weight). Also, you have to bear in mind-- a good portion of military people, upon joining, have had little to no firearms experience. And that's where the Sig's controls shine-- ambi safety and hammer, especially. Because, for an experienced shooter, those things might be minor annoyances, but really aren't deal breakers where actual use of the pistol is concerned. Whereas, for a "new" shooter, they really are better to learn on (more forgiving of mistakes) than a striker pistol is... One thing that worries me, though, is that I sincerely hope Sig's reputation doesn't take a hit, the way Beretta's did, because of the anemic qualities of the 9mm ball cartridge... But, that's probably never gonna change until we tell NATO to suck it... Fwiw

I bought both. After an even number of rounds up to roughly 1000 through each, I started to bring the Glock to the range and leave the M17 at home. Im not sure why. I like the ergonomic of the Sig more, but I just slowly began gravitating toward the Glock. Everybody should try them both and put a few hundred rounds through each. I know that's usually not feasible, but you just never know what works for you until you know the weapons.

The casing that came out @8:38 rolled and stood up by itself. Magnet on table?

3:25 My Brain: I guess things are going to end early Guy: Shoots at the camera

Needing to use 19x mags in Glock seems a big negative, though maybe not for the Army. Having the ability to swap grips and slides with the Sig modularity IS fantastic. Didn't know how much I'd like that, but putting a Sig P365XL frame on my P365 was a great upgrade for my uses.

If you could ever get your hands on a Savage 1907 in .45, I'd love to see it go against a 1911 and see why exactly they chose that.

Picking up a g45 today

Sig low balled the $. Case closed

I am more leaning towards a sig more so than I would be with the glock. Great job discussing the difference between the 2👊

When I heard about this military trial I searched online for the guns they were testing. That was the nearly the same time I decided to buy my first gun and after careful review I bought the Smith and Wesson M&P M2.0 5" and put just shy of four thousand rounds through it without a single malfunction. I still use and carry it everyday.

The 19x takes gen 1-4 mags just not gen 5 mags. It’s wild how misinformed all these people were when this gun first released. The 19x is amazing

Sig P365 or XL --against-- Glock 43 or 43x ...an that should be next!! DUTY guns was great but CCW guns vs next is the way to go .....like the idea of showing the 2 best in there "class" this way, i suspect it would be hard to pick if you roll out the 15rd "glock" mag for the 43x but in all serious i would love to see your thought on these head to head -thanks Eric like the camera angles

Finally, back to the good stuff. Great video, Eric.

My Glock 17 Gen 3 mags work just fine in my 19x. As well as my Pmags.

The 19x had a manual safety on the test just not on the civilian model

They fked up going with the grenade

Absolutely love my Glock 19x

Best secondary in warzone review

OK couple things here.... the G19x that was put in for testing did have a manual safety ALSO no one said the chassis had to be "modular" AND there as no request for a optics mount.... the only reason it won was because of price...

Would be interesting to see a m17 meltdown, and a torture test, e.g. mud, sand, etc, comparison between m17 and g19

Ruger-57 vs FN Five-seven !!!! Please

19x all day, every day

I thought the video was as always. But i want to mention that you do not have to use specific Glock 19x magazines. The standard Glock 17 magazine used in this video was a Gen 5 magazine that has the oversized base plate for the Gen 5 Glocks that have the half moon cut in the frame. If you use a Gen 5 magazine and replace the base plate with something for example a Gen 4 base plate it will function just fine along with all previous Generations.

It’s understood that Glock wasn’t going to give the warranty service that Sig was ,that’s the why they (Government )went with Sig .Young solders are hard on any gun !

Love glocks. Never shot a SIG, gonna have to cop definitely.

Mr. Miyagi say: Strobe on. Strobe off.

As a satisfied G19x owner, the main thing I got from this video is that I definitely need to get me some of those roof korean t shirts.

The Chassis system in the Sig, is great for changing frames, "BUT" forget about an easy complete disassembly of the internal Chassis parts. Where as the Glock cannot change frame sizes but the SIMPLICITY is in its engineered design for complete disassembly of parts!

Would love to see you compare the G19x and the P320 M18, I think it would be more of a even comparison, the two pistols are more alike

Good head to head review. The fact that the 19X won't take regular glock 17 mags would be a deal breaker for me. One of the big selling points to me with Glock is magazine interchangeability. I've never been a Sig fan, but between the two, I believe I'd go for the M17 if I were considering a handgun purchase.

They wanted a "modular" system. Glocks are not modular. The Sig is truly modular. When they specifically ask for something and a company doesn't give that and the other does...... kinda win by default.

Kinda feels like a Hickok 45 video review without the dad jokes and more real information

I'd like to see a comparison between the other pistols involved in the Competition. I'm personally a fan of the Beretta APX, Especially considering how low it's price is right now. With the APX you get the form and function of the Glock 19x, but the modularity of the SigM17, with the unique design with the slide serrations (I personally like them)

Reasons why the Sig p320 won: > $200 per unit.

The P320 handgun has a habit of firing without its trigger being pulled, an occurrence that has been reported again and again. Stunningly, in spite of both empirical testing and many incidents, Sig Sauer has refused to issue a recall or even acknowledge that the P320 is dangerous to its hundreds of thousands of users.

You're correct. The gen5 mags won't work on 19x, but gen1,2,3,4 glock mags will work.

Glock is an automatic NOPE from me. I'm definitely liking the Sig M17.

That shirt is pretty great 😂👏🏻

Eric is exactly correct. Either is a great choice. The point is, the Sig is my preference but maybe not yours. Either choice has my respect!

Every time i see a new episode from eric n chad i say to myself yea buddy

I would like to see a reliability test on the M17 and the 19X.

The sig p250 started all of this

Only Gen 5 mags have that issue of hitting the lip. Previous generations mags will fit the 19x.

Man you really mailed this video in. Both guns come come with 17 rnd and extended mags. The G19X had a safety when it was submitted.

The Sig is the prettier date for the dance, but for the street fight Glock19x she’s going to give you the piece of mind. Plus how many soldiers will be shot by a fellow soldier dropping his sig by accident.

On Glock I Think You Have A Higher Grip To The Bore, Than The Sig

Bro, what did that glock do to you? You are slapping the shit outta that thing.