5 members... even if one of them is not on earth anymore, SHINee will always be 5. Read the lyrics when you can, the meaning of this music is even more deep

"Sea of Hope" is the best program to hear Onew's sweet angelic voice. I'm in heaven.

Rainy Blue an Onew solo will bring tears to your eyes... especially when you hear the backstory of why he sang this song.

SHINee is awesome, Onew, Jonghyun, Key, Minho and Taemin all are awesome and Shawols are awesome too. I love them all. Paul please react to each member live video. They are incredible singers. You won't be dissapointed.

I totally agree, this performance is beautiful beyond words. All five members are incredibly talented. All their discography is worth the while to react to, but I highly recommend Hold you, Orgel and Romeo and Juliett for a start.

onew really original personn. beautiful voice, beautiful face n beautiful soul. ❤️

If you haven't already, you should watch the animated official lyric video for "Way" that SM came out with before this live performance. (Which is one of the videos you see recommended at the end of this video.) Onew wrote the lyrics for this song and the lyrics make it even more beautiful. "One Star (Way)" is a pre-release single that Onew released especially for fans to tide us over until the release of his second solo album sometime in the first part of next year. His album was supposed to be released in September, but things have been delayed. The song is about a couple who are longing to be reunited with each other. As the song goes along, the two realize their love is bound by fate. As the lyrics of the chorus say, “At a slightly different time / In the invisible world / One star in the same room / You and I have one name and one face.” Knowing that Onew wrote the lyrics for this song makes it that much more meaningful and emotional. I can really feel him putting his whole heart into this song and performance. This is such a perfect song for this time of year. Full of the warm and fuzzy feelings for the holidays. I think this song is destined to become a new Kpop holiday classic. It's definitely going on my holiday playlist, and it will be one I recommend anytime someone asks me for holiday song recommendations. The chills I get listening to this song seem to only grow everytime I hear it, I'm not sure I will ever become numb to the beauty of their voices and the feeling this song creates. This song really highlights what an amazing vocalists Onew is and it showcases how hard he has been working lately with his vocal training. He has always been an amazing singer, but this just shows how he is continuously pushing himself to become even better. Onew has recently said he has been focusing on his vocal training, experimenting with new ways of singing in order to showcase his full vocal range. He is now feeling more responsibility as one of SHINee's main vocalist to make sure he is able to maintain the same vocal quality that he is known for, as he ages. However, Onew is known in the industry as the male vocalist with the most consistent vocals. He has been one of SHINee's main vocalists since debut and he is recognized as one of the top vocalists in Kpop since even before debut. Onew was only one of two people ever personally cast by Lee SooMan, the founder of SM, and he was chosen at age 16 for his outstanding vocal ability. Onew's vocals are so good that as a rookie he was even a vocal coach and mentor to a lot of SM's trainees. Punch's and Onew's voices are perfect together, and I couldn't imagine a better pairing for this song. But truthfully, who doesn't sound amazing singing with Onew? He is one of the most coveted male vocalists in the industry that all singers dream of getting the chance to sing with. And if you have ever seen him on programs such as Sea of Hope, you have seen how he can be paired with almost anyone and somehow his voice is able to highlight the other singers' voices, and take the song to a whole new level, no matter their vocal style. He has such impressive vocal talent and understanding of how to use his voice that he has the ability to compliment the vocal timbre and style of anyone he is singing with.

This arrangement is indeed rich and elegant from the string section, percussion and to the choir or maybe backup vocals are really on point. Pulling this kind of song is really amazing, going through high and low notes, executing vocal riffs with finesse is such a gift to my ear. Thanks for reacting.

SHINee is always five) Onew's voice is pure magic 🥰🥰🥰

Good comments, beautiful song by two talented singers. Love 😘 Onew vocal for many years.

SO glad you are into ballads and vocally foward songs. You came to the right group. SHINee is that vocal group with the most beautiful ballads you will ever hear. I recommend Selene 6.23, Sleepless Nights, Romantic, Life, Quasimodo, Moon River Waltz, Once Upon a Star, Beautiful Life, Melody, Sweet Surprise, 1000 years by Your Side, Sunny Side, From Now On, Our Page, You and I, Password, etc.....

Onew's voice made my day 💎

i have had this on repeat on spotify since release. it is such a beautiful ear worm.

Thank you this reaction. It brought me to tears. Such a beautiful song.

Love all ur reaction videos to SHINee :) Lets walk the shiny path together with our SHINee boys. Forever 5HINee 💎💎💎💎💎

In reality they are 5 member forever 5 You haven't heard much from Jonghyun, the main vocalist of the group, even though he's no longer with us, he has left a lot of good music. There are several SHINee songs that were written by him. One of my favorites is “Selene 6.23” I recommend this one and also a solo of Jonghyun “Y si fuera ella”

I can just sit all day and listen to Onew singing live 🥰🥰🥰. They both sing beautifully ^~^

Yes we will support u . And thank u for d nice reactions.

Onew and Punch did such a great job with this performance! Onew and Kim Eana wrote the lyrics. Please, react to some more music of SHINee, I assure you you won't regret it!

Punch is a well-known OST singer for Kdramas, including Goblin and At a Distance Spring is Green. Onew, of course, is the leader of SHINee and one of the most beautiful and distinct voices in the industry. He also co-wrote this song - the Korean title is Byeol Hana (One Star)

SHINee has 5 members - Jonghyun passed 4 years ago. I recommend watching Jonghyun's Y Si Fuera Ella (live), Shinin', and Crazy (live). If you think Onew has an amazing voice...

This is song is so beatiful! It feels so cozy and warm. Onew and Punch voices are precious! Punch is a goddess of soundtracks, I admit I didn't know how she looked, she is super cute. Any kdrama fan probably loves at least one of her songs.

Shinee will always be forever 5...💎💎💎💎💎

Love it. Perfect for my daily Christmas vibe. I want to remember all good things this December.

5 Members

ikr!!!still waiting for the romantic live song reaction ^^

Thank you so much for making this reaction. Really appreciate it. And of course thank you for the support for Onew.

SHINee have 5 members, Age wise ⏬ Onew (eldest n leader) Jonghyun (our forever angel) Key Minho Taemin (youngest)

Ooo. This is a nice surprise! Thank you.

Don't forget that SHINee is always 5, for us and the members, no matter if it's a SHINee project or their solo work, they always include Jonghyun in everything they do, and Onew said in their first concert without Jonghyun * The 5 of us will work even harder forward to earn your Love* and Taemin said very recently * We are like 5 men from outer space * Minho posts in Inst * We are SHINee 5 * just like Key always posts photos with the 5 and when they received one of the awards for their last comeback Onew said he wanted to say I love you to the members and he said 3 times looking each member at his side then looked up and said again I love you, as you see For us and for them SHINee was, is and always will be 5, Like they said With your eyes You see 4 members with Your Heart You will see 5 Onew vocals are insane being the reason I have never been able to choose between Onew and Jonghyun, for me they are like the Sun and Moon one warms me during the day and the other at night and I cannot live without One of them

Thank you for your reaction!🥰 I had subscribed to your channel because of SHINee. I love this song it is so beautiful! I could listen to Onew and SHINee all day!❤ There is an animated lyric video that has subtitles for this. Onew/Jinki helped write the lyrics to this song, which makes it even more special!🥰 You got all the members' names right and the fifth member's name is Jonghyun.💖 SHINee forever five!🥰❤

You must not that SHINee consists of 5 members namely Onew, Jonghyun, Key, Minho and Taemin As a fan of SHINee (Shawol) I want to tell you that SHINee forever 5 members or 5HINee Also thank you for your reaction and yes it's so beautiful 😻❤️ Please react to SHINee Jonghyun Y Si Fuera Ella live performance kzfaq.info/get/bejne/eKqSY5Wa2Laqk2Q.html

They really made the right choice when they chose to collab Onew with Punch. Their voices are just angelic!!!

You love this❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️

Beautiful 😘😘😘😘😘🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩

Their voices are so beautiful

Indeed… the song is so amazing. I love it! . Thank you for your cool reaction. Pls continue to react to SHINee’s videos.

Thanks for reacting to shinee

5HINee members forever💖💖💖💖💖

Onew's voice is a gift

Hi, thank you so much for reacting to Onew and shinee!, it’s really interesting to hear your opinion and analysis

5 members is fine to say Jonghyun will always be SHINee and SHINee will always be Jonghyun Thanks for checking Way, it is his new song after like 3 years, we are all excited. There is a lyrics video too, better subs too

thank you for this. SHINee is always 5. please react to selene

Please react "An Ode To You - SHINee (SWC4 in Seoul)"

Perfection 💎 💎💎💎💎 Forever 5👑

Thanks for your reaction , I really enjoyed it so much and the smile was on my face throughout the whole video, You made my day so thanks again🥺🙏🏻 I loved the song so much with everything in it.. Onew's singing style has evolved a lot since SHINee's last comeback so I'm so proud of him.. His voice is so relaxing and fresh and also, because the lyrics are so warm and sweet, I became obsessed with it. Punch is also a great singer, I always listen to her voice in The OSTs in the kdrama and I'm in love with almost all of them.. Their voice is really a great combination, it's a great collab! they did well!!💙💎 Also the number of SHINee members is five, even though one of them is not among us now but his place will always be there. I guess you haven't listened to his voice much yet but SHINee's 5th member Jonghyun is the main vocal in the group and he's a great singer, artist, writer and producer! He is really good at everything.. and of course if you watch more songs you will get to know him more .💙

I had the same reaction like yours

FYI: Before turning on the CC subs, pay attention to whether it says English (auto-generated) or just English. If it says auto generated and you aren't watching something that is all in English, the subs won't be right. Auto generated subs are designed to only be used with English content as a way for hearing impaired people to understand what is being said. The computer takes what it is hearing and creates captions for the video. That is why the subs on this video were all messed up. The computer was trying to come up with English words that sound like the Korean words it was hearing. It wasn't translating the song into English. The only way a video that is in another language has English subs is if someone actually takes the time to translate the words into English and adds the subs to the video, whether that's by the company that produced the video or by a fan.

There are 5 members in 5HINee and will forever be 5. Although he is no longer with us all here, but we can forever appreciate his talents, his arts, there are so many wonderful works of arts that Jonghyun left us and hopefully you'll do the introduction to SHINee and will see how these 5 wonderful talented boys growth in industry~ Since you've said that you wanna know SHINee bit deeper, especially the members, here are 2 version of SHINee's introduction. 1) WHO IS SHINee? A Member Introduction To The Princes Of KPOP (2021) - Recommended, and Updated :) Link: kzfaq.info/get/bejne/atV_h5CZ2ZvYio0.html 2) A very SHINee Guide! (this is not really updated but still good and relevant) Link: kzfaq.info/get/bejne/mdp5o5mJrKmvZ3k.html *** There are also introduction to the members individually too..

Thanks for your reaction. I don't even bother with subtitles if they're auto generated. They do have a lyric video version of this song and there are English subtitles on that one. Idk why they didn't bother to put the subtitles on this one too. Also FYI, it's FIVE members. Even though Jonghyun isn't physically here anymore, he is still an eternal member. Even the SHINee members still consider themselves a five-piece. SHINee will always and forever be 5. Just something to keep in mind as you continue on your SHINee journey.

plz don't forget JongHyun they're also known as 5HINee!

The woman's name is Punch. She is a very good solo singer, known particularly well for songs for kdramas. You pronounce Taemin's name a bit wrong :) The first syllable is like "ten" without "n".

💚💚💚

SHINee is 5!..Please remember that although Jonghyun is not with us now SHINee is always 5 members.

ONEW. PUNCH.MARAVILLOSAS VOCES .UNA COMBINACIÓN HERMOSÍSIMA .Plis reacciona a SHINee SELENA .ROMEO y JULLIETA.GUASIMODO . TAEMIN RISE. SOLDIER concierto Sirios Arena tour HAVEN . MONOLOGUE 💎💕💕💕

React to Marcelito Pomoy sings the Prayer in the wish bus live performance 🇵🇭🇵🇭🇵🇭

5HINee is amazing, I recommend you excuse me miss, stranger and everybody in SHINee world IV, odd eye, prism and hold you in SHINee world V, spoiler, hitchhiking and evil in SHINee world III. SHINee is 5 forever. Say SHINee, say SHINee, say Onew say Minho, say Taemin, say Jonghyun, say Key, key... ...Make some noise

Thank you for reacting to ONEW's collab with Punch! I love this song so much, it is incredibly beautiful! ONEW's voice is my favorite voice. Just a tiny hint: though SHINee only has 4 active members now, with Jonghyun sadly no longer physically with us, for Shawols and for SHINee - SHINee is and will always be 5 (and never 4). ❤️ Recommending songs is difficult as they have so many incredible ones and I could post links here for a loooooong time 😄 I will limit it to these 2 for now: SHINee - Romeo & Juliet (live) kzfaq.info/get/bejne/f5l6pdmXkrWap2g.html ONEW - Blue kzfaq.info/get/bejne/bJdlY9Z91dHXeIk.html Thank you again for reacting to SHINee, I have subscribed to your channel, everyone who loves SHINee gets my support 😊

SHINee is 5..

Woahh Thank you so much for reacting to this, such a beautiful song! I'm new to this channel and really love your reaction. Would you like to react to SHINee - Orgel kzfaq.info/get/bejne/r7mTZ7yqyZ-ldKM.html , I'm really curious of what you think of it bcuz it gives me goosebump