Now this is a raw and pure vocals that new generation of kpop is lacking. Will always root for you our Leader Yong and Mamamoo!

Her live vocals are always amazing her low and high notes are stronger in the live than recorded version. She is a precious gift that keeps giving. I also love the retro feeling with the clips in between, remind me of Solarsido

Solar has really outdone herself with this one. I completely forgot my surroundings while listening to her, without any other thoughts in my mind. Beautiful beyond what I can describe in words🤍

Solar sings so we'll, her emotion😢😢😢

this is even better than the studio version i love you so much kim yongsun please never stop singing ❤

I'm in tears. How come the live version is even better than the recording??? Solar never fails to amaze me every single time with her performance 😭👏👏👏👏

I became emotional after the chorus part. Yongsun is really good at interpreting the song. This live version is even better than the studio one.

To me, this is perfect. I didnt even think it possible for the emotions to be even more potent than they are in the studio version. The soft breaths and the vibrato(?) and the fullness of the sound in an intimate space make it feel more exquisite, more sublime. I often think this, but it feels particularly true here - listening to Solar-nim sing live is a holy experience.

She's not only singing but she tells a story with her voice...Solar voice sounds like a friend, a friend who will comfort you in whatever way🥰

2:06 that slight voice crack tells so much about the song, it added more emotion than perfection ever could.

Crispy smooth vocals as expected of the only main vocalist

If there were a place in this world (besides my house) that played her music all day, I'd be there all the time

Love Yongsun's voice, she is an amazing singer. She needs more recognition as artist

Every time I feel like I cannot be more thankful to Solar-nim than I already am, she does something to fulfill a dear, secret wish. I'm emotional from the performance and from the experience of being her fan. Thank you so much for being such a thoughtful, considerate, and loving artist, my singer.

How is her live vocals better than the studio version. I am in complete awe of her every time. Solar, please continue singing ❤

100% vocal queen … solar vocal more powerful after doing musical … please sing more songs … 🙏

HOW CAN SOLAR SINGS SO GOOD GOSH, THIS IS SO UNFAIR

이 맛에 누나를 사랑하지 대단한 내가수 자랑스럽다

Live vocals is insane, as expected from our bestest main vocalist. Beauty is also insane.

How could sit there and sing those high notes in live? She is one of the precious singer in the world

HOWWWWW HOW HOW HOW DOES SHE SING LIKE THIS, YONGSUN YOU'RE SO AMAZING 😭😭😭❤️❤️❤️

Her voice is insane

노래 듣기전에 미모가 너무 훅 들어와서 감탄하다 노래에 또 감탄하고 미모에 감탄하고 노래에 감탄 아이구야❤❤❤

I'm willing to attend a solar solo concert with her just sitting/standing there and singing. God-tier vocals 💯💯

It is like she took emotions that were already 200% and amplified it to 1000%

Been listening to this masterpiece since it's released like few days ago in repeat and my reaction will always goes like this 😮 everytime I listened to it, she's just great no more words for this woman just pure admiration on how excellent she is and her talent!!

Yongsun-ah... my gorgeous singer.. so proud of your consistent growth... our pride, we love you sm ...

Solar. My 💘 my life

Ms. Kim Yongsun you're amazing 😭🤍✨ you just keep on getting better and better in your craft

MAMAMOO was the first Kpop girl group i ever listened to and i have been watching them for 6 years they are truly amazing, Solar is one of those singers that you will never find again she is so beautiful and her voice is a gift from heaven❤‍🔥💙💓💘💕💞

Gosh...I get goosebumps everytime I listen to this. Her low registers are so stable. Her voice is so soft yet belting is so strong. I just love how her vocals are so clear & pleasing to my ears🥰

I've always said this, Solar's voice carries emotions beautifully

노래 좋은건 당연한건데 솔라의 계절은 겨울이구나...요새 왜이렇게 예쁜거야ㅠㅠ 겨울노래 겨울 스타일링 너무 잘어울려 예쁘다🤍🤍

I don’t think I will ever get over this version, she’s amazing

i am so greatful that Solar Gamsung is back!!! thank you miss Kim Solar

The Diva's is Solar 👑💚

Mamamoo known for their powerful vocal...also their amazing live performances. And...solar did it again ❤❤ Dont know why, but their (mmm) live performances always 10x better than recording ver. Love from Sabah, Borneo (Malaysia) Moomoo's ❤❤❤

Solar voice is Soo calming 🩵🩵🩵🩵

The real vocal queen and the only one

솔라 노래 다 들어봄 다 다르게 불렀다는것을 알수있다 어떤것은 쓸쓸하게 어떤것은 감성돋게 어떤것은 섹시 (?) 하면서도 코믹(?) 한 암튼 표헌이 안되지만 탑급 가수임은 분명

Dear future self, I'm going through hard time atm. I hope you never give up and keep on fighting your way through life. Take care ❤️

wow..... i am speechless. Solar's vocals really are better every time I hear them, she is never stopping her improvement and definitely queen of vocals!

Falling over her vocal…LOVE U YONG

Her live vocals are amazing. She eats CDs for breakfast. I am in love ❤❤❤

Her voice is the prettiest thing i've ever heard

One of the greatest vocalists of her generation 👏 👸🎤👍

How every member of Mamamoo can make live version better than recording version. 🥺🥺 Solar stable, solid voice never fails to amaze me. ❤ You’re the best! Girl.

Solar's solo work is seriously underrated & underpromoted. You deserve so many more views❤

Her voice is so beautiful, amazing, melodious, comforting, magnificent, soothing, strong, angelic, I'm gonna cry 😭

I wish to hear her sing live at least once in my life 🥺🥺

Solar vocalist Is so powerful

Solar is one of the best vocalists in kpop right now. Not an opinion, just fact.

Such a beautiful voice, it reminded me of Selena the Mexican singer the tone is very similar so I think Solar will do a great cover

I really really love this song ❤❤ never thought that it was only a cover 😳😳 Solar unnie sang from her soul, like it's her own, where you can really feel the emotions of the song ❤❤ really love Solar unnie and her voice ❤❤

왜 라이브가 음원보다 더 좋은 것 같지..? 진짜 노래 너무 잘부른다❤️‍🔥 표정이랑 제스처만 봐도 노래가 이해될 정도로 표현을 너무 잘한다💕

I fell deeply in love for this woman 😍😍😍 Solar Unnie is the best ❤ The voice and the expression were crazily beautiful and showed the the pain of love that I want to hug her so much 😭 Yongsun ah you did well🥹

the way her singing live sounds just like the studio version 💕

시도가 남기는 말. 노래 감성 죽임.애인이 도망갈려다 못 도망가겠음. 이 노래듣고 있으면 넘~~~ 좋음. 약간은 브라이언 아담스 반주곡 같은 느낌. 고맙게 듣겠습니다. 화이팅 솔라 !!!

Solar's vocals shine with a beautiful blend of power and emotion. ❤

Thank you Kim Yongsun, you gave me back the desire to live. I love u forever💗

Her emotions when singing... WOW

I really want to see you with long curly red hair pls ❤❤❤❤

I have no words... I just cried watching this again

Looking forward to live version in the future, thank you Solar, for healing the world with your singing…

원래도 잘한다고 생각했지만 이번 솔라감성 사랑했지만은 진심들을때마다 놀랄정도에요 너무좋아요

I am obsessed with this song. I haven't stopped playing it on Spotify. Even though it is a sad song but I love all the emotion in Solar's voice 😭

하... 라이브라는 생각을 못하고 그냥 넋을 놓고 보다가... 라이브구나! 깨닫는 순간, 10년동안 느껴지만 정말 정말 정말 노래,감정표현,미모까지 다 잘하는구나..

When I thought I couldn't love her voice more...

I'm so glad they released a live clip because you can clearly hear the details she adds in her voice even more than the studio version. Ahh, Yongsun, thank you for sharing your art with us.

Truly beautiful, how can this be it sounds even better than the studio version, She’s amazing. ❤❤

라이브가 음원보다 더 좋다니ㅠㅠ 넓은 공연장에서 꼭 라이브로 듣고 싶다. 나는 솔라감성 콘서트에 목마르다.

Solar is an amazing singer👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻

صوت سولار في ليفل تاني حرفيا 🩵🩵🩵🩵

좋겠다 이렇게 노래 잘해서.. 아니 어케 더 잘해?... 실력이 더 더 늘어ㅠㅠ 소름..😭

Solar is the best singer for me. A very powerful voice that tugs your heartstrings and changes your life. From your No. 1 fan from the Philippines. 🌺🌺🌺🌷🌷💕😘

Yes, please let Solar sing in indoors. It's so cold outside XD Her voice is just so mmmmmm

I’m in love with this performance. Solar is a top tier vocalist and performance.

Amazing.... I had been looking for this kind of song in Solar first solo album. This song is perfect for her warm angelic voice, with wide range from low to high notes to show how fabouluos her voice. Simply amaxing. Please do more singing like this

역시 마마무의 정체성은 좋은 노래와 출중한 노래실력이지

Solar's exceptional voice captivates listeners with its power and versatility. His extended vocal range allows him to navigate high and low notes with ease, creating a rich and captivating listening experience. Solar knows how to balance the emotion in his voice, adding a unique depth to each performance. Whether in moving ballads or more dynamic pieces, her remarkable voice leaves an undeniable mark on the world of music.💙

This song shows the love that Solar has for what she does💚

She’s incredible… 😭😭😭 how can ppl don’t love her… 🥰 Yong~~ love you soooo much ❤️

Solar will never fail to amaze me.❤

Her voice!!! It's just making me cry all over again

I love solar singing live😍

Solar is still trying so hard to put Mamamoo back together... love you Solar

깊고 파워풀한 라이브 감성 너무 좋다! 표정이랑 제스처에서 오롯이 전해지는 감정들이 노래랑 어우러져서 더 좋아💙

God those vocals. I wish when she's hitting those powerful vocals we could see her face from the front to fully see her emotions when singing those. Just amazing. WOW!

They should have just released this. She is beautiful in the white dress in the snow, but I think her sitting alone in this room delivers the emotion of the song better. It also sounds better. I will do my best to support both versions.

아니.....그냥... 그냥도 아니고..ㅠㅠ 어떤말로도 표현이 안되는 감동이 와요.. 눈물이 날것같고.. 몽글몽글하면서 느낌표가 오고 하여튼 너무 .. 노래 너무 잘하고 아니.. 하.. 뭐랄까 정말 표현할수있는 단어가 부족하네요... 감사해요 .. 이런감정 느낄수 있게 해주셔서 감사해요 정말!

이 아름다운 노래를 들으며 첫사랑이 떠올랐고, 그가 떠났을 때 아팠고, 그렇게 많은 고통을 견디지 못할 거라 생각했지만 최고의 약 중 하나는 부재라는 것, 그를 알기 위해서는 그를 내 인생에서 꺼내야 했습니다 나는 정직한 사람이고 나 자신만으로도 행복합니다.😀😀

Solar vocals are the best! 💚💚

we've been listening her voice for years and she still manages to impress us. i'm so proud of you, solar ssi ❤

아 김용선 덕질 행복해ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ

Her voice is so beautiful ❤

Con cualquier miembro de Mamamoo, la versión en vivo siempre es mejor!

So much better than the studio version 😍

Woah! I could really feel the emotions most specially in this live clip! Woah!

Ok now I need a Solarsido acapella version, I’m obsessed

Solar's singing is really good.