I ABSOLUTELY DISAGREE WITH AAMNA. The chemistry between Emaan and Salaar is beautiful. Everything doesnt have to be hot. It can be compassionate and respectful and still depict love.

The scenes between Hiba and Sheheryar gave me goose bumps ! Sheheryar looks better than many international movie stars .Hiba in the red sari was stunning.

I love to see salar and imaan together, they look like a compassionate couple. Yes the is no spicy and hot chemistry between them because their bond is more about respect support and trust, mostly we see more spice and spark between the couple where there is some friction but here everything is going slowly calmly and they make a great pair

JAFAA: To answer Hassan's counter question of "Why not a shaadi" as a solution, the answer is shamefully simple: CONSENT. Andaleeb does not consent to a marriage to Numair. She does not want to get married to Numair and if not for her father rushing to get her married off, she would not even have considered eloping with Moiz, in the initial episodes you have seen Andaleeb telling Moiz how they will have to wait until she finishes her studies. So if now Andaleeb is acting out, to a point of SELF HARM, the sole person responsible for it is her father. She feels entirely trapped. Her relationship is at stake and yes call her immature but for her age, she loves Moiz in a way that she understands the concept of love and it consumes her. It is important to HER. On top of that her father has been suffocating since day 1. Who doesn't allow their daughter to stay over for a sleepover at her female cousin's house? and how inappropriate it is to march into your fully grown daughter's room at night as seen in episode 3? He isn't protective, he is suffocating and rebellious children are a result of such parents. However she loved him so much and he has completely turned indifferent to her feelings, and her entire life is now decided for her, tying her to a man she doesn't even like, a man who is at least A DECADE older than her. I won't blame her when she will attempt to kill herself on her wedding night. Her father did that to her. As of what is the solution to this problem: Jamal's issue started with seeing Moiz at the terrace, he can sit Andaleeb down and ask her to not repeat these things, and to focus on her studies and warn her of the consequences otherwise (ground her for sometime like normal parents or something), and let the relationship play out if he is SO SURE it will fizzle out. But seeing how his big dreams and educational aspirations for his daughter disappeared instantly at the knowledge of her dating someone, I am forced to question if his entire problem here is related to his ego and wish to control. Because Jamal said and I quote "Tumhare haath paaon baandh kar, Numair se shaadi kara dunga tumhari." And heck no, I am not praising a parent like that just because he did not beat her up. That is not the standard, goddammit we are in 2024!

If Aamna gets a "maternal" vibe from Emaan in Radd, then by that logic, shouldn't she get a "paternal" vibe from Nosherwan in Jaan Nisar? Instead she praises that chemistry and sees nothing wrong with the dynamic there. The chemistry between Salar and Emaan is mesmerizing precisely because the gender norms are essentially flipped. Emaan is the one who is stronger in all the areas we associate with masculinity such as career, finances, courage, aggression. Salaar starts off as meek and dependent, though he's coming into his own now. Emaan being his protector and motivator during this period does not make her his mother figure anymore than all the alpha male heroes becomes the father figure of the damsel heroines they save.

Radd: Emaan/ Hiba took my heart the way she comforted and encouraged her father after the chemo session. Daughters are gems, blessings. Shukar hae , Zain’s ugly beard is gone, ☺️

Just a small anecdote I want to share (with reference to jafa) A friend of mine met a guy in high school who was 3 years older than her. They met fell in love, told their parents, parents talked to each other & met family. They agreed to their relationship by saying that they are accepting this relationship but they have to keep their trust which they did. They waited for girl to complete her education, get a job, bother got stable in professionally and got married. Now mashallah they have 3 children together

I completely DISAGREE with Aamna here actually. Imaan and Salaar do not need to have fiery chemistry. They are a very healthy and great couple with so much respect❤

Usually I find myself agreeing more with Aamna, but here completely disagree. Sheheryar and Eman plus their growing relationship is the reason this drama works and is stellar. It is a story of 2 people who are very honest and share everything about each other's past. This is a breath of fresh air in our dramas. It is beautiful and this episode was a very well shot romantic gorgeous love story without "sansani ". We are being brainwashed into believing that deep and pure love is also full of drama but that is not necessary nor possible in 2 broken people or people suffering from trauma or burden of responsibilities. This is very appropriate.

The female lead in Teri Chaon Mein lacks screen presence. She’s way too bland and can’t seem to emote properly. Her couple with Danish is a complete mismatch.

I think Aamna is referring to the LUST aspect that was superbly evident in TB ‘s leads which was the main premise of that story. Radd is not about lustful display of love but a more mature and rounded relationship.

Jafaa: agree with amna. Andaleeb’s father is understandable but not absolutely right at all. Girls should not be forced into a marriage even if the guy is a farishta. Human beings are complex, it’s not easy to fall in love every now and then.

Oooooh you kidding? There is definite chemistry between Emaan and Salaar.. First, she is aware that he loves her completely and that in itself would wear down the defenses. Then she saw his nobility, and that started melting her. Tender moments where her gaze is searching his face and the glances asking "are you real?" And now having seen him at his most vulnerable and with the strength to confront problems, the cracked shell has crumbled away. Of COURSE we see it all. It's one of the most beautiful romances I've seen in years, because it feels so real and it's been subtle but palpable. He effortlessly drew her in with devotion, vulnerability, nobility, strength of character and she can't help herself fall in love because she responds to character, being a woman of integrity herself.

Amna is right.. If u think that chemistry can only be created through intimate scenes then u r wrong. we have also seen chemistry between shehreyar and sajal in a subtle drama kuch ankahi which was not a tere bin. Yumhaj doesn't need intimate scenes for chemistry their eyes r enough for showing their chemistry.

I love the chemistry between Imaan & Salar.This was fire🎉.Why we always have to compare with Tere Bin??

I totally disagree with Amna ,,,,radd become a great drama just bcz of the chemistry between shehrayar and hiba ,,,,,lols,she finds no chemistry and on the other hand people are loving this couple by heart ,,,,sorry we don't understand u Amna 🙏

Absolutely loved the fiery chemistry between Hiba and Sheheryar. I completely disagree with Aamna but glad to hear Hassan as he believes that Hiba and Sheheryar have such an amazing chemistry and bond as an on-screen couple. So I completely in love with Radd's couple 😍🥰

Radd: I agree with hassan here. Shehryar and hiba do have a spark... chemistry is very much there now. Aamna, whatever u r saying was more suitable for Bilal abbas and durre in "ishq murshid". I felt exactly the same for them in that drama. I found no chemistry at all between bilal and durre. Durre is a complete misfit for Bilal. She looked good with Omer Shahzad, Danish taimoor, but not with Bilal. Individually, they both are beautiful though. But Bilal looks good with delicate and young girls like Azekah denial, Yumna or madiha imam. And you were all I praise for that misfit pair

i completely disagree with you aamna, that whole scene btw hiba and shehryar was so good, especially that hug was so intimate, what a couple.

Jaffa: Andaleeb’s dad turned put to be a typical Pak drama father forcing his daughter into a marriage immediately on finding out that she was interested in a boy. Even if he didn’t want Andaleeb to marry the boy , he could have waited, given her time to see how serious she remained with her class fellow. Moreover, he completely ignored the fact that Dr. Umair was not just way older than his daughter and completely different personality wise, but had a big psychological fear due to which he didn’t want kids. That is not normal , but the father paid no attention to it.

day by day, hassan is getting more mature and sensible in his views 👍

Most pakistani men change so much after marriage that it's literally mind-boggling. I even got married to a man with whom i had all those conversations, but after our marriage, he changed completely. Mostly, it's the man's parent's influence that ruins marriages. They teach their son stuff about how to control their wives, which is why our men never see wives as partners. Rather, they see them as their property. People use religion as a weapon to make their kids obey them even if they are adults with families of their own. Which is why divorce is increasing. Girls and women understand their rights as a wife and partners, but mostly, parents are living in the past.

Disagree with amna here, Emaan and Salaar have sizzling chemistry. That morning scene between them, their eyes conveyed everything that is to be understood ... hiba n sheheryar making it so palpable to watch their characters individually and together.

I agree with aamina totally...like scenes of salaar n eeman are good but but something is missing dont knw what but something is missing...u dont feel butterflies at all...

If amna is not finding chemistry between hiba & shehryaar then she need to learn what really a chemistry IS

Jafa: Andaleebs dad is still acting weird, why can’t he let her study wait it out. It’s not uski umar nikli ja rahe hai

I agree with amna and Hassan both to a certain extent . They look good together cuz they have come a long way and developed this relationship but yeah something is missing and Emaan’s emotions sometimes feel forced or faked

There is a lot of chemistry in radd between emaan and salaar yaar

I also did not enjoy those scenes between hiba and shahryar. I feel like Salaar shows much respect to her and more respect than romance.

Mrs. & Mr. Shameem: I wish to point out to Aamna that the point of this track was to give them "Hope". They ran away to wait for their death but in a clean and serene place there, they didn't get as sick and stayed alive. Something they didn't expect. Due lack of information they didn't realize that all HIV patients don't die early, some even live long and good lives with properly medication. Due to the accidental pregnancy, they educate themselves and due to the miscarriage they realize that better healthcare could have avoided many things for them, which is why they decide to go back to help other such people. PS, the scene where their house help comes back, seemingly to help them, but instead robs them and leaves a helpless Umi to die, and then informs the villagers who arrive in the morning and throw their stuff out is such a difficult track to watch. While Abdullah's acceptance of his mistake is a positive portrayal, the house help's betrayal depresses you all over again.

I agree with Aamna...there is no chemistry b/w emaan n salaar..it is more like friends who hv bonded over mutual affection...for me it was her combing his hair..reminded me a bit of mom getting beta ready for school...difficult to see spark after tht😊

Disagree with amna the chemistry between emaan and salaar is sizzling 🥵 the sexual tension between them is just enough to give someone chills.. especially the scene where she wake him up

Hasan Bahi: in Jaffa, the issue with marriage between Nomair and Andaleep is that it is being rushed. There is no breathing room or space for the emotions to settle down. How does marriage provide Andaleep the time she needs? Rushing into a commitment that is generally considered lifelong will lead to challenges.

There is no less chemistry in radd .. don’t know what you r looking for !!

I agree with Amna. There's no chemistry.

I agree with Amna. I haven't yet found chemistry between Salaar and Emaan. The morning bed scene was very good, but still, it lacked something. They come across as very good friends. For some reason, the chemistry did not convey well for me. They both are excellent as individuals, but something hasn't yet clicked for me. Also, that red saree was a complete disservice to Hiba. I'm not a Zain fan, but I think they had more chemistry than these two. But I'm really hoping to see them grow. ❤

How can someone not see the chemistry yaar 😫

Amna rocked at that point "mardon k zehn mein bad touch hota hi nahi hai" 😂😂

I agree with Amna !! even though the acting was spot on I don’t see chemistry (spark) as well and I think it is something to do with the writing , it might be because both the characters are close to perfect , and we didn’t see Emaan recovering from her previous relationship and felt like she immediately fell in love with Salaar

I agree with Amna. There was no spark at all in the private scene in Radd

Really like the chemistry between Shehryaar & Hiba 😍. Totally disagree with Aamna

In jafaa deebu is literally in college, she’s not 22 23 they literally wear uniform guys, she’s hardly 18 19 it’s fsc not bsc

agree with Amna .. no sparks or chemistry between 2 in radd.. the scenes between them were bit boring or dialogues were boring .. something was missing or was wrong

Agree with amna hiba had better chemistry with arslan idk why there is very big sister brother relation between salaar and eman

I am from Punjab(India ) i msg for the first time on ur platform..in RADD AMANA SAYING RIGHT.

Sheheryar and Hiba look absolutely amazing together... I really enjoy Radd...

I loved the scene in radd i literally clapped when he told her his feelings. Dont agree with amna. Every show wont be a tere bin amna sounds a bit obsessed with it. Go hassan for arguing back on it.

Agree with Amna on the lack of chemistry

Iam really disappointed after watching this😭.. I was really waiting to hear what amna has to say about the chemistry btw salaar and emaan🥲..

I can feel Amna when she says Hiba is more suited with a different generation of men.❤️

So Amna doesn’t find chemistry between Hiba and Sheharyar but finds it between Danish and Laiba? Hassans opinion is correct on this, as danish and labia has no sparks and the whole drama is bland. On the other hand Hiba and Sheharyar show a much better chemistry.

I agree with Amna I also dont find any chemistry between Eman & Salar despite all the romantic scenes given Shehryar looks so good even Hiba individually but toghether nooo if it was meerub murtasim in this scene they would have nailed or mahira fawad or even iqra farhan..shehryar with other actress would give more impact like Sajal but not with Hiba

Since Tere Bin, the lovey dovey scenes are far too many in most dramas. Unfortunately, most fall flat. Many dramas have come since then with couples in love and couples showcasing their love, but the chemistry that was in Tere Bin is missing. It’s like the drama makers are shoving romance down our throats in an effort to create the organic chemistry that was shown between Murtasim and Meerab.

I love the chemistry and spark between salaar and emaan ...modern love

Agreed with Amna I c no chemistry between Hiba and salaar

I agree with Aamna. Hiba and Shehriyar are very good actors. But the magic was not there, beautiful setting and the decor but there were no sparks. Or was it the saree?

I just in love with the chemistry between Imaan and Salar ❤❤❤❤

Please come out of TB. Undoubtedly, Yumhaj had great chemistry but stop bringing them and comparing them with every other couple. Sorry to say but Imaan and Salaar are way more mature couple to do pillow fights. But chemistry is definitely there and their relationship growth has been amazing.

I think I am the only one jisko Sehar ki performance achi nahi lagi, I don’t feel anything for that character. She failed to create a connection with me, I have felt for much poorly written characters only because of the performance. Here I was just waiting the scenes & waiting for it to end.

I agree with aamna, i dont see a romantic chemistry btw emaan and salaar, its just a relationship of trust and respect!

Jafaa: I agree with Aamna and with @ihaveissuespls. No matter how 'suitable' a match the oncologist is. Andaleeb DOES NOT WANT to marry him. Her decision to elope is entirely her father's fault.

🔥🔥🔥Emaan salaar chemistry just electryfiine 🔥🔥🔥

I agree with Amna ! There is no chemistry at all ..Emaan looks older than Salaar and more motherly in attitude than that romantic love of his life !!! The red saree was awful!! Sorry. Why is a 40 something year old boring oncologist a good option for a 21/23 year old college girl who doesn't like him or doesn't even want to marry him in Jaffa ??? Pls don't ignore the age of the hero in Jaffa .....Hassan !!!!

Loving Radd. Excited to see what Arsalan Naseer's character does now that he is back in Pakistan.

Jafaa - Aanma doesn't it seem a bit unrealistic that a 23-year-old Andaleeb would be so eager to just run away from home (Jumping) without any real hesitation or sadness about it, even if the situation isn't great. (and you calling it naive? really?) These days, even younger folks tend to have a bit more awareness and complexity of thought when it comes to big life decisions like that. Sehar's acting also seems a bit off. Nothing great . I get that you're a fan of the actors, but it's important to still be able to critique the writing and character development & actor. Just because we enjoy certain performers doesn't mean we must defend them blindly. you unnecessarily point out things that aren't even actually bad about the other dramas and actors.. Please be fair in your reviews.

Please check age of hiba and shehereyar. Hiba is younger than Shehreyar. Right? Why always saying same thing?

For radd: I agree with hassan sir's POV of emaan and salaar's relationship. They took their time and confessed their true feelings like a lover and not "friends". They have still a lot to talk about i agree but at the same time I'm disagreeing with Aamna ma'm. I thouroughly enjoyed their chemistry in these 2 eps and LOVED IT!!

I partially agree with Aamna. The thing is between hiba and sheheryar there exists a softer camaraderie, not the fiery interaction that was there between yumna and wahaj. The former is driven by affection, and the latter was driven by passion. And that is why in scenes where there is supposed to be a display of passion, they do fall somewhat short. It comes across as a little bleh compared to other scenes where affection was the central point, like where imaan was combing salaar's hair when he was injured. Having said that, as Hassan said, not everything can be compared to TB because wahaj and yumna share that comfort and understanding off screen as well, that translated to their on-screen respective persona as well, making it at least a bit easier for them. Hiba and sheheryar, I don't know if they share the same camaraderie off screen. P.S- between Danish-Hiba and Sheheryar-Hiba, I'd go for the second duo though.

Eman & Salar have beautiful chemistry together.

Love the chemistry between Salar and Eman❤️‍🔥

I completely agree with Amna about the lack of chemistry b/w sherayar and Hiba because I also didn't feel that as a moving scene!

No, I don't see any spark between hiba and sheheryar, even though the direction trued his upmost to create one ! The choice of the cheap red sari made it worse. Actually Hiba is beautifull, but doesn't give a youthful look, whereas Sheheryar looks younger than his age

Yumna and wahaj are gorgeous couple but that doesnt mean we need to compare all the couples with them they are good in their place and imaan salaar are good at their place. Why we have to compare

Disagree with aamna! Really amazing chemistry between hiba and shehryar!!

I can totally get what Amna said about Shehryaar and Hiba. I have exactly the same opinion about Radd. Agreed 💯

I only watched some clips of drama bayhadh and that too because of your review aka roast.... I noticed Affan is looking kinda different in this drama maybe because of lighting camera angle poor makeup or whatever it is. He doesn't look as good as he is in this drama

Hiba has more chemistry with Arsalan Agreed with Amna in jaffa

chemistry between hiba and shahryar is 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥

Radd is best and eman and salar chemistry is 🔥

Bang on Aamna..totally agree on the chemistry bit

lol Aamna you are looking for fireworks in all relationships!!! Sort of agree that Hiba has better chemistry with Danish! In this drama though you needed an actress who comes across as strong and independent and Hiba is perfect in this role. Also Sherry is perfect in his character. She seemed to have better chemistry with Zain. Maybe we need more time to see Hiba and Sherry and see their love develop ❤

In JAFAA I think hassans mother is not dead instead locked up in a room that’s the reason whenever she’s discussed it’s always weirded out and even the mystery of her room being locked up

Unpopular opinion hiba had better chemistry with Arsalan than Sheryar...

Hiba and shehriyar don't have any chemistry🙂it's true

Radd: I agree with Amna but I also don’t think there’s a real spark in Jaan Nisar either. I feel like Hiba can’t portray that kind of love in her expressions. She seems like she’s a great daughter, a great sister, a great coworker, a great friend but I don’t feel that kind of love coming from her to her ‘husband’ on either drama. (I’ve only see these 2 dramas of hers so I’m only judging these.) In Radd and in Jaan Nisar I can feel and sense the love from her ‘husband’ to her but not from her to her husband. (If that makes any sense 😢)

Amna ab her drama me Yumna wahaj or fawad mahira nae la sakty chemistry k liye😅 So ap Hiba shehriyar ko b moqa dein feel kia krain😂😊

Agreed with amna , no chemistry at all ... sart sy eman g eman g kr kr k ,,aesy dabba dabba milta raha hy with zeero confidence,,alag alg pyary but not together ...

i agree with aamna, Radds stroyline is amazing but couldnt find sparks or chemistry between salar and eman

Non popular opinion but I think Eman and Zain have more chemistry because may be they both were equally providing for the needs of relationship

Emmam and salar beautiful chemistry ❤❤❤❤

Jafaa : he’s a beeping oncologist, must be in his 30s, yet he’s made out to be a bumbling immature boy who can’t stand up for himself, is being arm-wrestled into marriage, his whole track is unbelievable for me.

I have felt this that there is no chemistry or the casting is really off from the promo of this drama. Shehryar looks good with people like syra shehroze and sanam saeed. Arsalan had more chemistry with hiba than shehryar

i agree bcz i also didnt feel any sparks between hiba and sheharyar in radd and for some reason their chemistry was not really appealing to me..

Very “respectfully” I want to give my point of view. I can see the spark between Emaan and Saalar and it has been shown very gradually which is believable. Ofcourse we can see the friendship between them and slowly and steadily the spark has come in. Sorry Aamna, I love you but have to disagree with you 💕

@amna I'm highly disappointed with your review today. Hiba and Sheryar have awesome chemistry. It's the only drama I look forward to

Love the scene of Radd between Emaan and Salaar❤ ❤

As characters, I like the chemistry between Emaan and Salaar but I agree that Shehriyar would look better with someone like Sajal, Maya or maybe Ayeza and Hania.. overall Radd is good for many other reasons and individually performances are so good that it’s not dependent on lead’s chemistry..

I totally agree with Amna. I too, felt no chemistry between Emaan and Saalar. Agreed that whole scene was flat.

Radd: Completely agree with Aamna no damn chemistry between hiba and sheheryar, their dynamic comes across as very hesitant, come on Hiba is married she will have her reservation, and we all know that she filled in for Syra Yousuf, who was the first choice of makers, their pairing would have done wonders like their photoshoot

Radd : I am with Aamna. Hiba works wonders with senior ,matured men. I love Hiba and Syed Jibran's chemistry. On a character level, when a woman "babies " her husband, acts like a mom to handle his emotions and trauma, it's hard to imagine "chemistry including sexual tension ". Shehyar's character seeing a mother in Hiba's character is absolutely messy!!!! Why do our men feel pride in finding a bride like their mother?!🙈🙄🤦‍♀️