Pin your own comment, mate, it's pretty far down in the comments.

Thanks for the correction. One small detail, the F6 chord (or E6 in the correct key) is really an F#/E. The E aug chord (your ii chord) is a weird F/Ab!-kind of an incomplete b13b11. Took me a while to hear this one correctly.

I know from learning some of Stevie's other songs that he likes the black key keys.

@@toprak3479 thanks for the reminder! I thought I already had!

David Bennett Piano Okay. The ideas are the same, thanks.

Percussion is great to hide the harshness of key changes because the percussion comes to the forefront and surprises us...just like an out of key note would. Was a tasteful way to help blend the change.

I couldn't hear it myself because of that

Tweba Senoi it’s quite an easy trick to do, your ear is listening to a certain key which has its home (in example, key of c being the note c) as soon as you get distracted by something your attention goes straight to that allowing for the home to be swapped behind your back...and unless it’s been replaced with a drastically different home the small changes will go unnoticed

That snare also scared the shiz out of me

@@callumbooth6802 Personally I find it very lazy, if that was the intent. Let the change make so much harmonic sense, due to your strong voice leading, that you could strip away everything else and it would still work. If the harsh change serves a specific purpose, let that shine as well.

That evokes the same for me!!

Cool thought, you're right!

True also the fact that de piano was recorded by stroking the strings directly instead of pressing the keys (I hope I explained that well lol) helps with this.

Yes!!!

Yesss!!! Same!

Looks like those sticker things(?) on MSN Messenger that we used to send to friends so they can collect them and use them in the chat. 2000's kids will understand me 😆

LOL

yeah its always made me really weirdly unnerved

A good way to display the themes of the uncertainty of love and growing up smack dab in the beginning of the album.

I realise why ive been obsessed with the into now

It sounds like a generic Android alarm

Also the first note sung is an 'A', which fits well into both A Major and F Major.

Finally someone who had the same thought. At the end the song jumps all over the place with its keys (well done ofc).

I love to use this as an example too. It's what makes the song.

I was waiting the whole video for him to mention that song

Love that song!

It's jarring. Up and down and all around.

He does a similar trick in Bad love so I think perhaps there was more to it, than stiching two parts together and more it was a trick he liked the sound of

Badge too I think

agreed!

Yeah, I think it's mostly about the climate of the song and this kind of change is kinda "depressing" trick, making song sound more sad, which would be correct here because it's not a song about happy love.

Except I would insist that it DOESN'T modulate down to to C#m, it modulates up to E major. The first chord in the verse is C#m, yes. But the verses actually make a lot more sense if you think of them as being in E major, and then modulating back DOWN to Dm for the choruses.

Jeff Teza 😊😊😊

Thanks!

It honestly explains why the lyrics make absolutely no sense :P

@@SomeOfTheJuice They do make sense if you look for it.

John Lennon: *Laughs in walrus noises

@@SomeOfTheJuice Apparently the lyrics were about a boy who ran with a gang, killed someone and had to leave, while being pursued for it.

McCartney did the same thing numerous times.

trent reznor does this whenever he switches to major

Because the keys aren't a straight line so much as a circle, this is natural! Depending on how the notes are placed when the key changes and what chords are used, it can feel like an upward change because it could technically be described as one. (It's just going up a lot.)

And also because often the actual chord change into the key is an upward one - like in Layla it moves up from a C chord to a C#m, plus the tempo speeds up, and the vocal comes in up the top of his range...

Explanation for some of the cases: 5:47

Even the operatic section in Bohemian Rhapsody feels like there's an upward movement in terms of energy and mood of the song from the somewhat sad/emotional verse section

I like to live on the edge. Every video that doesn't get atomic-bombed by the content ID system is a victory!

@@DavidBennettPiano no joke. When you kept playing the actual music for more than one nanosecond I was biting my nails and figured this video was uploaded only 5 minutes ago.

I was trying so hard to get a stupid hair off my screen then i realized it was your avatar.

I thought that too until I saw that it moved with the screen as I scrolled, lmao

That’s the precise reason I just subscribed!

steve octave thanks!!

thank you

Henrik M thanks!

thanks!

halcyo cheers!, 👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻

No Content 🙂🙂🙂

Thanks!

QueeferSutherland that’s the genius of Paul McCartney.

It's also realy cool that Paul McCartney didn't need to know anything about music theory to do it.

True. I didn't know the key changed until I studied music theory and listening to the track one more time

@@paulnottherealmccartney8558 nice username

@@bignutsinyourmouf4606 Thanks mate. I emphasized the NOT since people were actually mistaken me for Sir Paul McCartney which we all know doesn't surf the web and youtube for some unknown reasons. Thanks anyway lad

Indeed, but the Bb section is actually more in F major than Bb major, it just starts on the IV chord.

@@althealligator1467 Depends on how you hear it. To me the melody and chord placement put the tonal center in Bb.

@@johndipinto8816 Maybe at first, but clearly the chords end up being IV-V-I in F.

@@althealligator1467 Well, no. I hear it clearly as I - II (major) - V - I in Bb. The melody sits on D for the first three chords (Bb, C, F) and resolves to Bb on the second Bb chord, which ends the phrase.

@@johndipinto8816 Yeah sure, I'm not saying Bb is the wrong analysis, but you can always hear any chord as tonic, it's subjective, plus context alters your perception. The composer only guides the listener through the way they're trying to hear it, which is where keys come into play, but I don't think they're an objective, unilateral, and infallible concept at all. Like look at Sweet Home Alabama, D-C-G-G, people always debate as to whether it's in D or G. The answer is both, because the way the composer guides you through it makes it ambiguous. Every note is diatonic to G major, but the progression starts and loops back to D major, which makes you hear both as resolved even when you're not paying attention to what sound tonic or not. Similar to our Bb-C-F-Bb chords here, where it starts on Bb but is diatonically in F. You can hear both as tonic, but I think Bb is not as obviously tonic as D is in SHA because we only loop back to it once and we don't approach it from a dominant chord. I guess it still sounds tonic though, just like F does. The melody resolves to Bb, but try this: sing an A after that Bb, over an F or Dm chord preferably. You'll see it sounds even more unambiguously resolved.

Igor Osolodko 😊😊😊

Thanks! That means alot

@@DavidBennettPiano Keep up the good work. I'm writing from Trinidad and Tobago btw

theivory1 thanks!

I'm glad I helped!

Luke Rea thank you!

Thank you!

Thank you!

I agree. The extra work in those graphics and "what if?" is much appreciated.

Thank you!

This is exactly what I'm thinking when people analyze The Strokes or Nirvana. Like, no, they just thought it sounded cool. Stop it.

Just because musicians might not be strictly aware of the theory in their work doesn't mean we shouldn't analyse it.

That is just what you hear explained at 14:09

Music theory isn’t necessarily meant to explain what the composer was thinking when they wrote it. It’s meant to provide a framework of how the music functions and compares within our pre-existing knowledge of music. Not that it matters since David has an… unorthodox understanding of how functional tonality works. Some of his reasoning is pretty arbitrary; you could argue that the shift from E to A in Penny Lane is either a modulation up or down. But that doesn’t matter within functional harmony. What matters is that the key of A is related to the key of E by one sharp and modulations between related keys like this are a common occurrence in western music. Paul McCartney might have wrote it this way not only because it sounded good, but because he’d heard it before in other music and wanted to evoke a similar feeling. Paul has said that he was influenced by Buddy Holly, Eddie Cochran, and Chuck Berry among others, who all were influenced by the jazz of the early 1900s, who were influenced by Romantic composers, and so on and so forth. This "passing down" of influences is so common in music that most music theorists, and many classical and jazz musicians for that matter, don’t bat an eye when they see it. I’m not saying that Paul McCartney didn’t write great original music. But to say that he arbitrarily picked chords and melodies out of a vacuum because they "sounded good" would be a disservice to all the music that came before his.

Exactly. Over analysing music is just as time wasting as people who try to analyse UFC fights.

Thank you!

How could you possibly know this?

Katie Quirk 👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻

Thank you !

Thanks!

might be my favourite

@@DavidBennettPiano I live here. But I cannot identify what is that above the "A". We once had a dispute as to which song would be the official song of the city. So we settled for "San Francisco" to be the official song and "I Left My Heart in San Francisco" to be the official ballad.

Thanks for watching!

great comment, great commentator.

ice la honk Great reply, great replier.

cheers!

@@DavidBennettPiano keep em coming thanks for sharing your knowledge from a humble self taught six stronger, your insight is very much appreciated!

best new wave song of all time

The verse is in Eb but the chorus is in C major/A minor. At the end of the verse they step up a half tone to E ("one half won't do...") which is a secondary dominant leading to Am / F / G / C in the bridge. The chorus is similar to the bridge: Am / Dm / G / C

Talk Talk were the masters of the key change

@@triksox You're right - I was trying to remember this song from memory, and I keep mixing up the chords in the original with the chords in the No Doubt cover version, which is a half step higher than the original version. At least I was correct that the chorus is a downward modulation.

You're welcome!

​@@DavidBennettPiano you've heard the start of Subterranean Homesick Alien? It is Dm, then Gb. I have no clue how they came up with that.

@@pablodmdp Close... it starts in D minor for 2 bars. Then it modulates to G (not Gb) via a perfect cadence. It's a very clever bit of harmony. I may have to do an analysis!

@@DavidBennettPiano Sorry, the intro is Dm, G#. Those are the first two chords of the song I'm positive, ask Warren: kzfaq.info/get/bejne/jpaRY8ahv9OVnKs.html

Thanks!

It’s because a lot of his songs are very jazz-based. Lots of minor 7 and major 7 chords and 2-5-1 progressions.

@@AaronB99999 He really likes using the "back door" change, too.

Golden Lady

Almost every song on SITKOL

That wasnt one of them

The edit in that line was a masterpiece of the Beatles. It is really hard to not unhear it.

Link?

Only SpektralZ what do you mean?

@@everberry51 if you havent noticed, it goes from take 7 to take 28 in the second chorus. In "Let me take you down cause Im *going to Strawberry Fields* ", Ringo's drumming becomes very intense and John has a devilish voice or should I say slower or deeper.

\: D @everberry51 kzfaq.info/get/bejne/bJh4f72Hu6y2p4k.html

Thanks!

Yeah like davie504 used to be good but now he just repeats the same words like "epic", "bass" and stuff like that and makes meme review kinda things honestly he is one of the worst right now

@@ukkovuorela4196 I agree. I really enjoyed watching him play bass without uttering a single words (that was his unique style) He is not really fun when you listen to him talk.

You put it perfectly, man.

@@ukkovuorela4196 I'm so tired of meme shit on KZfaq. It's not funny if you're over the age of 14.

YOU’LL NEVER GUESS WHICH SONGS USE THIS MINDBENDING TRICK!!!!!111!1ii