With the whole Jess not being in her underwear thing, there are actually 3 different scenarios that can happen depending on how good Mike is to Jess up until that point. If you’re really good to her and essentially do everything right she’ll just undress immediately and they don’t get that conversation about her being insecure and the shutters aren’t closed. If you’re not 100% perfect to her (Jack scared her and got her wet) she has that conversation with Mike and makes him close the shutters and only gets partially undressed. If you’re really consistently bad to her and weaken their relationship enough she makes mike do the shutters and get her a blanket and doesn’t undress at all. Neat little nuance that doesn’t change the story at all but still makes the seemingly superfluous choices that affect nothing have an impact. Part of why I love this game.

"You can befriend a wolf???" Yes, Jack. If you dont kick it like you did last time 😭

Ashley never would have died in the Saw scenario. Josh had the whole thing rigged so that it ALWAYS goes for him regardless of what Chris picks; Josh never actually wanted to *hurt* anybody, he just wanted to scare them. Game Theory actually did an AMAZING video on Josh about how he's pretty much completely innocent in this entire game, as he was victim of a medical system that failed him by misdiagnosing him for 9 years straight and giving him the wrong treatments despite him CONSTANTLY telling people that the meds they were giving him weren't working, that and his friends are mostly all horrible people, so there's not much comfort to find in them either adgfshdjfkgkhlj (Except Sam and Chris, they always seemed quite supportive of Josh, but he sadly kept pushing them away)

just realised now that since jessica was knocked out when mike found her in the mines, that means it was the wendigo mimicking her screams! wild asf

“it was just a prank, han!” is the old new “what doesn’t kill you will make you stronger!”

From an in-game perspective, Josh picking himself as the most hated character is. Probably pretty accurate. And pretty sad. It’s hard to forgive him but it’s pretty hard to just hate him, too. Mans was on the wrong medication, was suffering from severe schizophrenia, and had been ostensibly abandoned by his friends after his sisters died. I might become a sadistic villain of immeasurable proportions too tbh

I love mike tho, he starts the game as the asshole jock and then gets the shit kicked out of him, befriends a wolf, and becomes a badass

Pro tip: When your running from the 'psycho' as sam in the towel, hide as much as possible. Eventually you will get to an old elevator shaft and you'll have to hide in there. When you do, Sam finds and old storage room with Josh's phone, plus some more hidden and secret stuff.

100:20 No matter which way you pull the switch it will always “kill” Josh. Which points out two important things. 1. Josh never actually put any of them in real danger, these were just sadistic games for entertainment. 2. The sad part about this is Josh has convinced himself that Chris, his best friend, would never choose to save him over Ashley. This shows that Josh believes his friends don’t care about him.

I do like how well they manage to portray the symptoms of Josh's schizophrenia, though. Not only are you experiencing his psychosis between chapters as his mind breaks down progressively, but his friends talk about him being difficult to reach and having withdrawn from their social circle. Struggling with energy and motivation on both a personal and social level are some of the symptoms. You also see him jumping from one idea to another almost chaotically, like he can't seem to keep track of his own thoughts, both in the video he uses to invite them down, and when he's talking with Chris early on. Not only is he interacting in awkward ways, but in inappropriate ones with his incessant prattle about sex. One of those things I only noticed after watching/playing more than once. Rami Malek absolutely killed it.

I always like how this moment of Jess getting attacked plays perfectly into the true identity of the Wendigo. Remember who was Hannah interested in and what did Jess just loudly proclaimed she's gonna do? Yeah, next time better not proudly scream about how you're gonna enjoy yourself with someone elses crush, especially when said 'someone' is a legit monster.

Chris, looking for Ashley: Ash? Sean: It’s snow, but good try Made me laugh harder than it should’ve

“two girls: dead. one guy: rami malek. other guy: mike” that was way too funny

Jack imitating Dr. Hill's facial expressions at the beginning is fairly accurate. Props to his efforts 👏

The wendigo mimicking Jess in the mines was pretty scary. It became so obvious it was mimicry when "Jess" just kept on repeating the same cries for help. Scary.

Hey Jack! Forensic science major here to talk about that bloodstain pattern at 54:26. Dunno if you read this but if you do I hope you find it interesting. So first off I love that you call it "spatter" and not the commonly misused "splatter"; the correct forensic term is "bloodspatter" after all but is something most people say incorrectly. About that blood, the stain consists of a lot more blood than is commonly seen in most typical patterns, which is a first hint that something is fishy. Secondly, while it is possible for compound patterns (patterns of multiple kinds) to appear in a single area, there are too many patterns and noise happening on that wall which is a second red flag for me at least indicating that the pattern may not be entirely genuine (which knowing everything about Josh and his schemes, that's entirely accurate). But let's say HYPOTHETICALLY they were legit in some way. The large oval shapes in the pattern indicate medium-velocity spatter, specifically I they mostly appear to be what are known as cast-off stains. Cast-off stains are the result of hitting someone with an object, and the repeated swinging of said object flings blood from that object onto other surfaces. The tails of those large spots indicate the directionality of the motion: most of the tails of these spots tell us that someone was repeatedly swinging and hitting an object from a combined upward and rightward angle, indicating the assailant was likely right-handed. The fact that there is blood dripping down (due to gravity) in a lot of places, it could indicate an extremely bloody encounter due to the unusually high frequency of the spots. Not only that but blood is quite thick and on something like an uneven wall would take time to drip down a wall that much (real or not it could be a good indicator of (generally) how long Chris has been unconscious since the stain wasn't there before). The shine of the blood under the flashlight was a bit of a neat detail, as dried blood does not necessarily reflect light to that extent so it could also be a subtle indicator that the blood is fairly fresh (some of the smaller drops seemed to reflect the flashlight's, well, light). For reference, it might take approximately 60 minutes for small blood droplets to dry on a wall like that, with variances in times for larger stains that could take upwards of 8 hours. The mist-like pattern points towards high-velocity bloodspatter of some kind, which is not easy to "achieve" by any means. High-velocity spatter is commonly associated with things like gunshot wounds. However there is another bloodstain pattern known as expirated spatter in which an injury to the lungs causes blood to be coughed or expelled through the nose or mouth, which creates an unusual and semi-fine mist. The best way to tell if it's expirated is if there are small air bubbles in the droplets on the wall, but obviously we cannot see this kind of detail. The directionality of some of the misting makes sense towards the top and right, but less sense nearer the center of the overall stain. There is also a strange "pooling" of blood in the center of the stain that looks to me like a passive stain. Wipe or swipe patterns are common on walls and other objects, but I don't see a lot of evidence of either of these leaving me to conclude that the large pooling is a transfer stain, where an object considered to be the source of blood (like a severely-injured human being) simply made contact with the wall and transferred some of their blood onto the wall which allowed a lot of it to drip towards the ground because of the higher volume of blood. Some of the drip patterns are unusual, specifically the ones that curve, as if we are assuming this a typical 90-degree vertical wall then all the extra blood should pull straight downwards with gravity. Blood can have some magnetic properties and any that drips down a wall may have some attraction to other streams of blood dripping down hence why some of the trails curve as blood falls down. However, there are still a few trails I notice where even this property of blood doesn't make a lot of sense with the stain. Another possibility is that some of the stains are what are called arterial spurts; if you nick or puncture a major artery, the blood will spurt out through the wound in a repetitive, arc-like pattern that coincides with the person's heartbeat, with a new stain being produced every time the person's heart beats. Arterial spurts can occasionally be mistaken for other patterns. What strikes me as interesting is the combination of bloodspatter patterns in this single stain: medium-velocity in the form of the large droplets with the tails that suggests cast-off, high-velocity in the form of the mist-like patterns that could be an expirated pattern, the arc-like stains which could be arterial spurts, and low velocity which is what I believe to be the large and simple transfer stain. There is some unusual clumping of some of the drops/pools of blood, and not just in one place on the wall, and the way that some of the blood trails down the wall is slightly odd and inconsistent. All of this combined.....well, it isn't exactly impossible, but there's enough going on that makes me question the validity of the bloodstain pattern. And while I don't think someone would be dead if they lost this much blood, it might be enough to render somebody unconscious, however they were injured to create this pattern. And there you have it. Probably a lot of useless info to me, but you asked!!

Here’s my take on why Chris was punished so much: it was Chris’s idea to drink that night. It was his idea to get black out drunk and Josh blames him for him being passed out and not able to save his sisters.

Jessica: *Is fucking dying* Séan: "Well, well, well, what's all this then? I can befriend a wolf? Anyway this place is very linear"

I think you remember the character of Josh wrongly. After his sisters died he went to the Doctor a has hallucinations of him throughout the game. He doesn't want to hurt anyone physically (except maybe slapping someone or when knocked out chris, but never anything serious) For example no matter who you choose between Josh and Ashley, Josh will always 'die'. He wants them to feel terrifyed and punish them for what happened to his sisters. I dont think he hates the other people just wants to scare them and say it's just a prank guys, that's why he records the whole thing and wants to publish it on the internet

I know this video may not be doing the best compared to some of his other ones, but I REALLY hope he continues this series. I loved it the first time he played this game and I am really enjoying seeing him do it again all these years later

“It was just a prank Han” may be even better than “it’s morbin time”

“Man these QTE’s are a bit too tough” Proceeds to pick the “fast but difficult” route each time

I personally think that the Wendigo that took Jess is Hannah. In the beginning of the game, it's perfectly obvious that she *Really* likes Mike and the Wendigos can obviously keep atleast most of their memory, and Mike might be one of the things she still remembers. now... she sees him about to get with Jess, so before she can see it happen, she takes Jess away, but doesn't necessarily kill her, which means that possibly specifically for the reason she doesn't want them to be together, which is likely why it's also Jess that's the first victim of the Wendigo. Also, what Jess and Mike were about to do is likely what triggered it, considering out in the woods is probably a better place to attack than breaking through a window.

Another thing: The drop that Jessica sustained would've caused trauma to her body. What was that? Three? Maybe, _four_ stories? When the elevator hit the bottom of the shaft, the sudden stop would've ruptured various internal organs. Even though she might've gotten up later on in the game and "walked it off", she's bleeding internally and in _severe_ pain. Death is _inevitable_ as she would collapse due to he injuries and/or get taken down again before she is _ever_ saved. R.I.P., Jessica.

Chris: Worried about Ash Mike: Worried about Jess Jack: TOTEMS!!!

I always thought that it was interesting that if you choose Josh over Ashley in the trap Josh will actually be nicer to Chris later in the game when Chris and Mike are tying him up in the shed, whereas if you choose Ashley over Josh, Josh will make fun of Chris for it. Just goes to show the level of detail that the creators put into this game.

Please Sean finish this series! Even tho this video didn’t get the views that you and us were expecting we who did watch and WILL watch love that you’re doing this again! I personally am getting a lot if laughs and giggles 💚

Jack: Scare the pants off her! *Does the one thing that prevents her from taking her pants off*

I remember watching "Josh dying" for the first time and it was incredibly shocking because of the gore and everything. Great game

The fact that Josh isn't just some psycho villain really makes me love him as an 'antagonist' he's just pulling awful pranks on everyone, not trying to actually kill them as revenge for what they did to his sisters and the way Doctor Hill acts in his subconscious makes me wonder about how he acrually treats him.

Man I may be really dumb but I only just realized that Hannah was the wendigo that followed Mike and Jess to the cabin and grabbed Jess. Even as a wendigo she was still angry that Mike was with another girl.

Maybe you're just taking a little break before returning, but please do another episode :D this series is like a trip down memory lane and so many of us are loving it.

1:00:39 This scene was what changed this game for me. I remember the first time you had to decide Josh or Ashley's fate and how shitty it made you feel for picking any option here. It was also painful for any first-time players who wanted to keep all of them alive and it made you feel like you failed your mission to do that exact task. This game will forever make me consider my actions in any other video game because it's just that good at making you feel like a monster...

i love how "it's just a prank, Han!" and "What doesn't kill you, will make you stronger. BUT WHAT IF-" are the main taglines sean has brought out for until dawn and the quarry, respectively 😂

What really leaves me wondering about this game is what Josh had planned for Mike and Jessica. Like Matt and Emma wandering off, well, they could come back later and be part of things. But he specifically sent Mike and Jess off to the cabin. Were there more automated surprises there they never triggered because Jess got taken so quickly?

If he doesn’t finish this playthrough I’m going to cry

There are three scenarios with Mike and Jess. 1. They don’t remove any clothing. 2. They only remove outerwear. 3. Jess strips to her underwear. You got number 2, probably because you chose to scare Jess rather than just show her the mask. It also depends on how long you take to get to the cabin, how long it takes to turn the fire on, etc. The dialogue is also different depending on which scenario you get. Edit: Also in the situation where Jess is taken away and falls into the mines, she can die or she lives but is heavily injured. Once again, it depends on how long you take to reach her. Jess is the hardest one to keep alive because the two times you have to save her (chapter four and chapter ten), it depends on how long you take to reach her (chapter four), and making sure you don’t move the controller and doing the fast QTE to make sure Matt catches her from falling (chapter ten). The only way Jess can die is by having her jaw ripped off.

It’s so hard for me to be mad with josh- yeah what he did back to them was awful putting them in harms way but he didn’t know about the wendigos and based on the doctors notes we find later on it’s clear that he lost his mind after his sisters died. Also he’s the only one you can’t really save in this play through he either dies or is turning into a wendigo as the game ends, sad overall

PLEASE MORE UNTIL DAWN IM DYING ON THE WAIT OVER HERE

personally i like josh better than ashley, because josh cant actually kill anyone and never actually wanted too hurt anyone. Ashley can lock chris out of the house and watch as the wendigo rips his head off. :(

"Weird wall nipple" is the best description of a button I've ever heard

The whole point of Sean playing this again is to just repeat "It's just a prank, Han!" over and over again. But I'm here for it.

im more interested in him finishing the replay of this series than i was with Stray ahah, take your time Jack but i do hope you come back to this game!

It clicked in my head that the wendigo stalking Jess and mike in the cabin is Hannah, and shes really jealous after hearing Jess scream that they’re gonna fuck 🤣

Bears in these games are the most powerful beings in existence. I swear they could fight the Sun and win.

As someone named Josh, I accept your apology

I never knew I needed to hear the word “Wendiboner” come out of Jacks mouth until he said it. 😂 Almost spit out my TOTM coffee!

"Just use the cabin." It's only a 5 miles hike out in the snowing woods full of large deer, wolves, bears, and legendary native folk beasts who eat human flesh, the power doesn't work and you have to warm the old dusty place with matches.

“I’m sorry Josh!” *proceeds to viciously slice him*

I'm glad Jack found the wolf totem this time around...hopefully he won't kick it like last time and have the wolf friend later on....

Loved seeing this the 2nd time around, all the little things Josh set up like the mask popping up in the car, the "cheap jumpscares" that suddenly makes sense because Josh has been putting this all up for god knows how long. He staged the whole seance so that he could run off and set everything up while his friends are following clues he left there.

Sean: _chooses to scare Jess_ also Sean: _gasp_ MICHAEL!

WOW that's ironic "watch out for that josh he's a schemer" if she only knew how right she was.

Fun fact about until dawn: This game was originally going to be on the ps3 and there are many videos showing some of the unfinished chapters that were going to be in the game. There are also builds of the game which show it was going to be in first person at one point. The story is almost exactly the same apart from the ending.

my personal thoughts: at the end of The Quarry and the credits were playing and the paranormal playlist was playing they should have given us an until dawn easter egg or sumn, just like showing that these are in the same universe. like when they were talking about random shit on the podcast they could just like mentioned something about what happened up on mount washington and everything like just small easter eggs like that

I really hope we're getting a part 3 after stray is finished

The QTEs in this game are so much better than in their later ones. They're quicker and hold more heft to it. All the QTEs in The Quarry are in slo-mo making the moment feel dragged out and so sluggish. In this, it's Mike jumping bing bang boom all over the place, either you nail the QTEs or you're fucked. Like in Quarry, you having to catch a phone in slow-motion is just so blah compared to this, the stakes are so low, it's boring.

Emma after Hannah gets upset over her favorite board breaking: it was just a plank, Han!

Let's just say this was _reality..._ From a clinical perspective, those cuts on Jessica's chest are _pretty deep._ In reality, the claws would've sliced through all _seven_ layers of skin and _even_ the subcutaneous fat. As you said, Seán, infection _is inevitable_ if she doesn't get medical treatment _immediately!_ (especially since there's a chance the wendigo's claws have come in contact with infected blood)

Hoping Sean continues the game. Not just for us who still want to see the rerun- but for his own sake. He seems to be really enjoying this, he mentioned when getting to the quarry that he'd like to replay and compare the two and between those two things- I think it would be lovely for him to continue. Do a little something for himself you know? Despite the views or not he should be allowed to take time and do something he'd honestly enjoy doing now and then. Not always have to push all the time for what others will want. So If I have this right and he truly is enjoying the second play- and the comparison is still something he would have enjoyed doing- then I sincerely hope he continues to play.

The fact that any of the characters don’t die of hypothermia is amazing!

I think one of the charms of this game is that each character feels like they belong in the story. Even if the character is unlikable (Emily and Josh) they still have a place in the story and the story would be completely different without them. One of my problems with The Quarry is that some of the characters didn't feel like they lived up to their potential while everybody in the game has at least one stand-out scene. Can't wait until we see the scenes with Emily in the tower and mines since those are probably my favorite scenes in the games!

We're being Until Dawn blueballed

Chris and Ashley are like "OH MY GOD I killed him, there were guts everywhere" During so, Sean has a revelation, "Ohhh, it was Mike that got his fingers cut off!" , Kind of like me or all of us just background thinking... But what if they cut your pinkie finger off!

54:30 to answer your question Jack, I don’t think it is Ashley’s blood. Josh probably put fake blood on the wall to set the scary atmosphere. Josh used his dad’s movie props and stuff, so it’s likely he used fake blood too.

I really like that after you pick the things that "unsettle you" he ends up putting it in his office?? Love thattt

the thing i find weird is that the people josh's prank thing mostly victimised were sam, chris and ashley. pretty sure out of those three only ashley was involved in the prank while chris was passed out drunk and sam tried to find hannah. you'd think he'd want to focus on emily, mike, jess and matt more than chris and sam

I've been checking your channel every day for this playthrough :/ I've literally gone through and watched your old playthrough and marks old playthrough waiting for the continuation :/

Jack FYI if you don’t attack the wolf you keep him as a pet that happens when Michael sees a wolf Don’t touch anything when you see the wolf just stay still then give him the bone 🦴

"OOF, FUCK NUGGETS" That was my favorite line in the game and I don't know why it made me laugh again 😆

What I am completely surprised about is Josh faking his death. The important decision there is vocally telling them what you’re going to do. The whole moving lever thing, that’s rigged. It’s always going to change to Josh’s track because he NEEDS to die to continue to be the psycho without anyone suspecting that he’s behind it. Even though his behaviour makes the player suspect him instantly. If you choose to save Josh, then I think Ash won’t know that Chris was going to kill her. He just says no problem when they’re in the lodge looking for Sam

I can never get over how much older Mike looks than everyone else. It's like the down on his luck uncle is hanging out with a bunch of teens

Mike: "You can't just jump out at somebody! I'm in the middle of the woods, it's scary!" Is that not what he did to Matt and Emily? 💙💙💙

Jack hears a Australian accent: “Thats such a terrible attempt at an English accent.”

Was so excited to see this series and them just been sitting here waiting day after day for another episode

How much Sean love the "it's just a prank, Han!" line is how much I love Jess's "Mike and I are going to FUCK. That's right, we are going to have SEX. and it's gonna be hot so enjoy it!" lmao it's such an iconic little monologue lol

We know Sam is the most intelligent and sensible person right from the start. How you may ask ? !!! Because she is the only one wearing a winter hat!, in winter!, while it's snowing!, up a fricken mountain !!!

The totems are showing a situation in relation to the character that found it. The death totem found at around 57:07 shows a potential death for chris. If it were a loss totem it would show a potential death for another character that can be caused/prevented by chris.

Nobody is talking about the fact that jack just messed up names and has made two mentions back to Detroit, for some reason it makes me very happy

Jack saying "It's just a prank, han!" every damn second is now part of his vocabulary

Can't believe that Sean saying : "My name is Connor" made me SO nostalgic. It's been so many years. 31:28

I can't tell if the recap really included "It was just a prank, Han." or Jack's really just enjoying it that much.

I hope he comes back to this series! It was his in 2015 that got me into this game, so seeing it pop up again after The Quarry was such a treat. And with the extra Matt & Emily scene as well!

“Jess are you here!? One sexual innuendo for yes, two sexual innnuendos for no”😂😂fair play

i forgot how brutal this game can ACTUALLY get, once you start to get further into the game.

This may be an unpopular opinion, but Emily has become one of my favorite characters in the game after all these years. Her solo sequence later on shows that she´s very badass.

After you beat the game, it’s obvious that Josh is playing them during the Ouija scene. Hannah lived. Beth died.

Where are the new episodes :,(

"These QTEs are MUCH harder than in the newer games" Someone doesn't remember getting Conrad shot

Jess: gets pulled through door Mike: looking for Jess Chris: gets punched by josh Ashley: gets punched by josh Sam: just chillin in the bath for like half of the game don't worry

please finish this im loving the revisit and would love to see the rest

JACK YOU NEED TO FINISH THIS PLEASE

I just wanted to say, thank you for uploading this series again, Jack. I have been going through a rough time lately and this is really helping me get through. Appreciate you, Sean. Thanks for being you 💕

Okay Michael, while warming up using mutual body heat can work in a survival situation you would ideally want to be under a cover like a blanket or tarp or the like. Getting out of wet clothes is also important even outside of a snowy environment. Fire is more or less key next to shelter and drinking water when it comes to survival safety (granted you're not an idiot who burns themself trying to tend or start one).

It's been a week already =( The cat is really cute and I know this is a game most people have seen plenty of, but I seriously want him to finish this re-play.

Y'all I hate to say it, but I don't think we're getting a part 3. This only got 600K views in 4 days compared to his most recent videos or even the first part. From that perspective, it doesn't seem like enough people are gonna watch it to justify uploading the rest

If I had a dollar everytime Jack says the word “prank”, I’m gonna be rich

So, after multiple play thru's of my own, watching Jack play it the first time, and now watching this play thru, I have come to the conclusion that it was indeed just a prank, Han.

Totem prophecy: "The possible DEATH *of the person who finds it.*" Jack: "Who is that?!"

I studied blood spatter, Forensic Investigation major here! I'm no expert so please feel free to correct me. Just briefly looking at the blood spatter you asked about, it honestly looks random to me. Like there were different things that caused it, one that was just sprayed on, then another that was flicked on by something bigger. It looks like someone playing with a paintbrush. Which is probably what Josh did. Anyone could have told you that, but unlike some blood spatter designs I see in movies or video games, this one doesn't have as much of a clear message. Other than maybe the message of "hmm, how can I make this look scary?" The direction of the up and down M looking blood trail could indicate the direction the victim was being dragged in, but it's not smeared enough in my opinion. So it could just indicate Josh's movement as he's "painting" so to speak. A quick spray up and down, then a flick down for those big droplets. So you're right in looking at the direction. In other games and movies you can tell things like "Oh, these droplets look like they came off of a bat/knife/ect." Mostly based on the diameter of the droplets. Or "this one looks like the spray that occurs when someone is shot in a specific spot." Blood sprays not only off of people, but off of the weapon as well. Voids in the blood spatter can tell you a lot, as well as where the blood is concentrated. You also have to consider the height and figure out the distance. That's a whole other slew of things for investigation that can help figure out what happened with spatter. Sorry, I don't know if that makes sense. But usually I can tell what is going on with most spatter. And I might be biased because I know how things go, but you're right, this spatter doesn't make sense. But I could be totally wrong, once again. That's just my two cents!