I love how very different the rankings are for most people, just shows how amazing each of these games are and whatever aspects grasps us the most ends up being our favorite. The grotesque horror narrative of Bloodborne as well as it's gothic setting is something I absolutely adore thus it being my number 1!

That moaning in dark souls 1 always gets me😂

Another day another soulsborne ranking that starts with demon’s souls and DS2 rip

Finally someone who rates the game as it is and not trying so hard to be unique. Its very hard to rank the top5, still you balanced the ranking quite well. Nice video man.

I am on PC so i am using a 'Next GEN Fake RTX Reshade' Mod for DS3. This reshade respects the Artstyle of original and tones down the greyish look of the game and add colous. Many reshades for games are trash but this one is surprisingly superb. And no performance loss

My personal ranking: 7. Demons Souls 6. Dark Souls 2 5. Dark Souls 1 4. Dark Souls 3 3. Elden Ring 2. Sekiro 1. Bloodborne True ranking 7. Dark Souls 2 6. Demons Souls 5. Dark Souls 1 4. Dark Souls 3 3. Sekrio 2. Bloodborne 1. Elden Ring Great video

My personal list is 7. Dark Souls 1 (great levels but game is ruined after O&S, it's very bad after that ngl) 6. Demon's Souls (simplistic start of the genre but there are many mechanics that need fixing) 5. Dark Souls 2 (creative ideas but clunky and bad execution, could be a great game) 4. Bloodborne (Great weapons and fun but most bosses suck and it's a bit too unforgiving) 3. Dark Souls 3 (amazing bosses but the level design is really bland, they could do better) 2. Sekiro (best video game combat but there are some bad-annoying bosses, good overall) 1. Elden Ring (astonishing variety and crazy exploration but it is too big and empty of a world with repetative encounters on the way)

Finally someome acknowledges bloodbornes poor base game line up of bosses. Ds3s bad levels. Personally i feel the artstyle and graphics in ds1 is the best in the dark souls trilogy, ds1 isnt even my first

I don’t think bloodborne needs a remake we need a blood-borne 2 bc the base game bosses are so effy but if they take what they learned from the dlc and makes that an actual game it would be too 3 for sure

I like the gimmicky bosses in Demon’s Souls. The bosses usually come after gruelling levels with very few checkpoints. The game had a roguelite element to it, where the challenge was getting through the whole level, while acquiring the knowledge to beat the bosses. In the later games, the bosses mostly became roll spamming encounters.

No way smb actually talks about bloodbornes base game and it’s negatives good job 👍🏾 I think DS3 should be higher tho!! Good list

1. Elden ring 2. Sekiro 3. Ds3 4. Ds1 5. Ds2 6. Do not have a playstation and what I have seen for Blood Bourne the fans craze over it I swear ever since I bought elden ring for christmas in 2023 I have been addicted to game and boss ranking and when bloodbourne is not in the top three their is savages in the comments posting whole essays about how it is literally the second coming of jesus christ and even if i had a Playstation i would prob put those two at bottom anyways because of the exlustivity

Same top 3 but in a different order. For me it’s like 1a.Dark souls 1(give it the edge because it has the most complete lore) 1b.Elden ring 2.Sekiro(would probably be my favorite if the games development was given more love. Really the only fromsoft game I want a sequel from) I truly believe these 3 games offer the best qualities of any fromsoft game.

1.Elden Ring 2.Dark Souls 3 3.Bloodborne 4.Sekiro 5.Dark Souls 1 6.Dark Souls 2 7.Demons Souls

For me it’s elden at top, second I can’t choose between blood and sekiro, the story in Bloodborne is so dark, and I love it

love the respect on ds1 :)

It’s weird I like in sekiro you get one weapon and use it for the whole game but when I played bloodborne I didn’t enjoy having very little variety of weapons.Everygame has one or two things that are in the other games that would make it perfect.

From what I’ve played 5. Elden ring 4. DS3 3. DS1 2. Bloodborne 1. Sekiro I like Elden ring (haven’t played dlc yet) but I think it has a lot of issues

Demon’s Souls is not worse than the Gank nightmare that is Dark Souls 2 or the unfinished mess that is Dark Souls 1.

1:12 if you ever run out of healing items in Demon's souls.. that is the biggest skill issue I have ever heard. 4:00 Mimics are pretty fun to fight for me.

Personally I think for me, it’s: 1.Elden Ring 2.Bloodborne 3. DS3 4. Sekiro 5. DS1 6. Demon Souls 7. DS2

Never understanded why elden ring is so popular. It has bad boss design with heavily inflated difficulty due to animation reading, a dlc thats not worth it considering the fact that its 40 dollars, decent lore (if you watch 3 hours of lore videos) and an open world thats just.. boring by fromsoft standards, seriously compare crossing all of limgrave vs central yharmam, in yharnam in yharnam you are facing CONSTANT traps and ambushes, raving madmen in the streets that actually speak to you saying some of the best voicelines in gaming like “AWAY AWAY” people inside their homes that you can save, talk to, get told to f off, multiple really good npcs that have some sick questlines, 2 very decent bosses that teach you the basic mechanics of the game and just to lead directly to odean chappel and cathedral ward, a very important area you constantly come back too. Now compare that to limgrave.. basic dragon fight thats reused 20 times, npc quests 99% of people are gonna miss dungeons and catacombs filled with basic enemies that are given a boss health bar, evergaols that do the same thing, a sea that you fall right trough(cause fromsoft still has no swimming mechanics in 2022/2024 despite the game taking place on an island) a tree sentinel boss thats also reused 80 god damn times, a caravan and mausoleum that are also reused 90 times troughout the game, kale an actually decent npc to talk to that had his questline cut, all leading to stormveil that houses margit, a boss thats reused as a common ass enemy in leyndell, and godrick(one of the fucking demigod shardbearers) thats reused in an evergaol also in leyndell… (limgrave is one of the best areas in the game btw) what mental gymnastics do you have to go trough to put that on number one and bloodborne at 4? The only thing you have against bloodborne is the other main game bosses are just kind of decent and the game is carried by the dlc but.. the game of the year edition for bloodborne is 25 dollars my dude… its so utterly ridiculous to fault a 15 dollar game for having its best content in a 10-5 dollar dlc meanwhile you are glazing elden ring, a 70 dollar game that reuses half of its content and has a 40 dollar dlc.. elden ring is decent, its the thing it got me into the souls series to begin with but its by far the worst edition to it tied with ds2. I understand you are doing it to not anger the elden ring fanboys who have not even played the other games but come on my dude. (Also i love how you said chalice dungeons are “worthless and add nothing to the game” despite them being crucial to the lore + having a couple pretty fun bosses and locations and then you went ahead and said nothing about elden rings caves and catacombs that are legit smaller, more copy and pasted versions of the chalice dungeons that are not only completley irrelevant to the lore but also have no unique enemies and bosses in them unlike the chalice dungeons)

W ranking bloodborne is piss poor when it comes to base game bosses. The dlc carries that part of the game immensley. Also ds3 having uninteresting levels is smth i also agree with. If it had better levels itd be my #2 ovr

Ah! Some DS1 respect. I also believe DS1 has my favorite lore, even though ER has my favorite characters and questlines. I think you needed to point out some flaws with Sekiro since it sounded like a flawless game (although I don't believe it is part of Soulsborne). And yeah, great list overall and I can understand your arguments.

Imma be honest i think ds1 is extremely overrated crosses the line between difficulty and just a chore

The disrspect to cookbooks 💀 8:55

Sekiro DS3 Bloodborne Elden Ring DS1 Demon Souls I have immense respect for DS1 but I was late to the souls train so I don’t have a personal affinity to it as much as others. Also Elden Ring would be higher on the list if it was scaled down and got rid of all the cookie cutter content (repeating bosses, samey catacombs, etc.)

My top: 1.DS3 (Lorewise and bosswise i love this game so much, proly fav oat. I love the color work on this one, as its the ending of the whole story and it means to be dark themed and shi) 2.Elden ring( dont have to say more, greatest open world game + martin was making lore so couldnt expect less) 3.Sekiro(best fighting system no diff, Japanese setting which feels so cool in comparison to dark fantasy themed setting in othe fromsoft games) 4.DS2(gonna be thrown tomatoes but i really dont dislike the game at all. The versatility this game gives you is immaculate. I love the dlcs sm and ofc, DA DRIP😈) 5.DS1 (atmosphere is just on another level. The world building is crazy. Buuut, the mid and endgame feels kinda junky imo. Could have easily competed in top 3 but the tomb of giants, bed of chaos and seath feel just so off.) 6. BB(i cant say i dislike the game, i just dont like it as much as any other games on list, boss quality in main game is...well...u get it. Only liked like gherman, nurse and maybe amelia. But dlc slaps) Looking forward to play demon souls but still no ps5((( Ps. I love every single game in its own way, theres none i dislike/hatr

Valid list, sekiro is so good man

If you switch ds3 and ds1 you would have my exact list. Everything you said is valid, but I think it was just that I prefer faster gameplay over slower gameplay and it’s my first souls game so I might just be bias. Otherwise I agree with your list.

1. Bloodborne 2. Dark Souls 3 3. Dark Souls 1 4. Sekiro 5. Elden Ring 6. Dark Souls 2 7. Demon’s Souls

Mine (top 3 are interchangeable) 1. Dark Souls 2. Bloodborne 3. Sekiro 4. Elden ring (used to be lower but the dlc really bumped it up) 5. Demons souls 6. DS3 7. DS2

I always felt that dark souls was better than dark souls 3, solely because of the horrendous, boring areas that are after Vordt of the Boreal Valley, to the Abyss Watchers. This is literally enough to turn me away from replaying the game over dark souls

Never play demon souls My ranking 1. Elden Ring 2.Dark Souls 1 3.Dark Souls 3 4.Blood Borne 5.Sekiro .. .. 6.Dark Souls 2 (Difficulty in this game doesn’t make me feel any challenged, but it make me annoyed)

Fantastic list. This is exactly mine with the exception of swapping Demon's Souls and DS2. Almost all areas in DS2 are below average with rather boring bosses imo. As linear as they are I at least enjoy most of the ones DeS. Also, finally someone else out there puts DS3 where it belongs. It's a great game but pretty overrated imo. The levels are boring but the bosses were some of the best, at one point in time. They have since been eclipsed by both Sekiro and ER and I find them kind of simplistic now lol

Ds3, bloodborne or Elden ring as my number 1 can’t pick

1. Bloodborne 2. DS3 3. DS1 4. Elden Ring 5. Demon’s souls I havent played ds2 or sekiro yet 😔

Funny how bloodborne gets critism about main game bosses yet there’s dark souls 1 in top 3 which has a terrible second half of the game. Horrible bosses, terrible level design, shit areas and annoying enemies. Funny

Elden Ring will always be number 1, then Sekiro at number 2, Bloodborne 3rd for me.

Demon's Souls is very overlooked by the community smh

W list but I personally love bloodborne the most

Stop hating on Elden ring bruh it’s not a big deal… plus it’s his opinion and who cares if it’s “open world” and not souls like. Elden ring is a perfect game so shut y’all bullcrap..

I liked the bloodborne chalice dungeons, even though they were repetitive (I'm excluding the nightmarish cursed and defiled chalice dungeon)

ER is worst ssouls game. Im playing dlc right now and I hate open world with a passion. Legacy dungeons are good tho, still I miss DS times without open world crap. My ranking: BB>DS2>DeS>DS1>DS3>ER

In my opinion elden ring is the best first playthrough but the worst one to replay. But I think these games should be graded based on their first playthroughs

i think sekiro is a really good game but after playing i don't know what it is but there's just something about it strongly dislike also felt like very tidias imo and being honest i really didn't enjoy it, i didn't think to myself after i beat the game how much of a great game it was, i thought to myself that im glad its finally over and don't have to play it again

First time I agree 100% with the list lol. Weeeell....maybe switch ds3 and bb. But that's a big maybe.

DS2 is Way better than ds1 and demon souls but people just follow the trends 😐

We have the same "worst" and best in our list but all the rest is totally different lol Here's mine: 1: Elden Ring 2: DS3 3: Sekiro 4: DS2 5: Bloodborne 6: DS1 7: DeS

My top 3 would be: 1) Bloodborne 2) Dark souls 3 3) Sekiro Also i don't really agree with the critiques to Bloodborne that much. The bosses in the base game were just normal for the most of it, as the hunter couldn't costantly face super duper hunters and had also to focus on Kins and failed experiments. The only really bad ones in my opinion are Micolash due to him being just a strong npc and the witches of Hemwick for just their poor design. The chalice dungeons varied in beauty and hatred, as some were fabulous with good bosses while others were straight up hard mode things or farming material, you either hate it or love it, they are not useless nor unplayable, they just.. it depends on wether or not you're trying to get a platinum. I cannot understand unfortunately your love for Elden Ring, i finished it 3-4 times by now with even another character but.. i despise it, i seriously despise most bosses to the point the black bell hunter is my favourite. I don't like to explore that much, i think fighting is much more important in a game than just get into many good areas. And this is the same reason why i don't like by *that* much dark souls 1, good exploration but most of the times boring or bad bosses (some demons + BOC + Seath), and i were not used to blocking as neither DS3 or Bloodborne told me that as my first games.

Ironically I put Bloodborne, sekiro And Bloodborne at S rank Bloodborne was my first souls game so it’s special for me Ds1 and ds3 at A tier Ds2, DS at B tier Maybe demon souls at C tier but still liked it

7. Demons Souls 6. DS2 The quality gets way better from here: 5. Sekiro ( Best Bosses in the genre and great fighting mechanics. But zero weapon variety and the level design and exploration are the weakest in the entire series) 4. DS3 ( Great Bosses and overall a very solid game with few negatives. However the world and levels are not interconnected well like the other games, and not alot of originality) 3. DS1 ( Best semi open world ever made, the world design and interconnection between levels is second to none. Sadly the bosses in the base game are not good) 2. BB ( Like DS1 the world design is great and art direction is superb, the bosses even though still not comparable to the newer games were a big improvement over DS1 and DS2. The big negative for me is the build variety and weapons, you can literally play the whole game without feeling the need to change weapon and there is very little build variety. Compare that to the many build options you can try out in Elden Ring its insane) 1. Elden Ring ( Greatest open world ever made. Its one of the very few games out there that makes you live out your fantasy dream. The world building and biome variety are excellent. And unlike other games if you are stuck with a boss you can explore and come back stronger than ever. Build variety is insane with so many cool build options you can try out. The legacy dungeons, medium dungeons, small dungeons the open world all make very unique experiences when meshed together. Only negative for me is the repeat bosses but I dont really hate them)

Oh god where do I start with this list. Well firstly, I think bloodborne is better than Elden ring. Bloodborne has unmatched aesthetic and combat, and also contains my favorite boss of all time. Elden ring’s open world does nothing but put artificial distance between you and the content, forcing you to look up how to get to secret main bosses. Having DS1 in the top 3 is disgraceful and in bad taste, especially being above bloodborne. Dark souls 1 is clunky and garbage in comparison to fromsoft’s other games. I don’t care how good the world building is, the game has to be fun to PLAY. I’m sure it was good in 2011 or whatever, but catch up to the current generation will you? Also the second half is straight garbage. Dark souls 3 is an improvement on dark souls 1 and 2 in every possible way, yet it’s somehow lower than 1? Interesting. Nostalgia must carry DS1’s ranking. Sekiro is overrated, that’s for sure. The combat was built for 1v1 encounters yet only like 10% of the game is actually that. They stuff every mini boss arena full of enemies and it’s stupid difficulty that’s not even fun. The bosses are good, so I wish they made up more of the game. So personally: DS1 < DeS =< DS2

Bloodborne bosses truly are horrible, I'm playing through it for the first time and I'm surprised no one has ever said it. 99% of bosses are the same monster but with slight variations

Only correct list 7.ds2 as ive not finished it 6.demons souls due to the death mechanic 5.elden ring 3-4.ds3 or ds1 interchangeable depending on my mood 2.sekiro 1.bloodborne

My list: 1-Elden ring 2-Dark souls 1 3-Sekiro 4-Dark souls 3 5-Bloodborne Still no play Demon souls or Dark souls 2

Cough cough Lies Of P

Never let bro cook again..

ds1 is ranked too high the game has too many flaws and ds3 is too low it has some of the best bosses in souls series

Bloodborne 4 😂😂

yea ds3 is way better than bloodborne lmao

Personally, BB and ER are tie as number 1 DS1 number 2 DS3 and Sekiro tie as number 3 DS2 number 4 Demons souls number 5

I don’t know why people refuse to acknowledge the levels of ds3 being boring

bloodborne too high

I don’t really agree with the bloodborne criticism tbh. Blood vials become inoffensive after around halfway into the game and they feel good to use too, and chalice dungeons are entirely optional so I’ve never understood criticizing them to make the whole game look worse. Removing chalice dungeons wouldn’t make the game better in any way, and it’d even lose cool weapons like the chikage which is a more mechanically complex weapon than anything in DS1 or ER. The base game boss lineup is also very contradictory because ds1 has a similair issue to an even bigger extent because that game literally has like only 1 truly great fight in the base game being orenstein and smough. Elden ring suffers from the same issue and even its best bosses in the base game have heavy issues. The only boss in ER base game that id say is truly S tier is mohg because he actually has a nice flow to his fight and isn’t inconsistent with his attack timings.

Ds1 is not better than ds3 and bloodborne

1. Bloodborne 2. Dark souls 3. Dark souls 3 4. Sekiro 5. Elden ring 6. Dark souls 2 I haven't played demon souls

fact that you are calling demon's souls bosses gimmicky because of ankle breaking whilst fire giant in elden ring 14 years later uses the same mechanism- goes to show how dumb and subjective your rankings are. Limited healing? dude its the upside of having unlimited healing with all the grass you can farm similar to how you farm souls in between bosses. Your list is a derivative lip service to all videos in your echo chamber. demons souls is the og and deserves to be goated for all the inspiration. And for the love of god you dont even have bloodborne in top 3 😂

Bloodborne nice and all, but ds2 was the peak of gaming

I can’t believe u out ds1 above ds3, in my opinion ds3 rivals Bloodborne

Elden Ring number one? Another cringe normie tier list. Elden Ring can't be in the frist place by any means cuz souls formula don't work in openworld. I don't say elden ring is bad but it can't be on first place that's it. It's litterally dark souls 3 without any fresh experiance for players who played thousands of hours in ds3.

Guy puts elden ring on 1st place HAHAHAHAH, dark souls 3/bb/sekiro are all superior game to elden ring, prolly he liked it cause he can use summons