If you ever think about how strong Spiderman actually is. A Spiderman that stopped pulling his punches must be terrifying.

Andrew's peter just saying "okay" when tom peter said "dont say you know what im going through," he completely understands how tom feels and respects his feelings

Andrew truly cares about the role. Even after all this time, he put 1000% of emotion into it.

In this scene Tobey was the collected-and-moved-on older brother, Andrew was the still-not-over-it-but-calm middle brother, and they both are consoling their emotionally-broken younger brother. I love this scene 3000

The fact that we got this scene is arguably one of the greatest achievements Marvel will ever have

"I wanted him dead..... I got what I wanted. It didn't make it better" I love that line so much

Andrew’s “ok” at 1:22 is SO REAL. There’s nothing about it that sounds or feels like acting. He remembers every excruciating moment in the immediate aftermath of losing Gwen and is so completely familiar with this exact level of inconsolability, this feeling that nobody could possibly understand the depth of his pain, nobody could possibly understand that it was HIS fault, that HE failed. He knows there’s no point in pushing what he wants to say to Tom when Tom says “don’t try to tell me you know what I’m going through”, so he doesn’t. He just says “ok.”

The symbolism in this scene is perfect. Maguire is represented on the right as Peter Parker, and empathises with Peter in regards to loss and facing the emotions of anger and revenge as Peter. Garfield is represented on the left as Spiderman, and helps Peter see the importance of controlling the strength and responsibility as Spiderman. While Maguire seems to have found peace more as Peter Parker and Garfield as Spiderman, Holland's Spiderman represents a good balance between the two.

"I couldn't save her, I'm never gonna be able to forgive myself for that." This part made me cry

"She was my MJ..." Gets me every time.

To this day, I'm still so glad Andrew Garfield got to be in a great Spider-Man movie

This is how you bring back legacy characters! They felt like actual characters of the movie and not just some cheap cameo for the sake of nostalgia. Everybody from the previous films played their part extremely well in this one, and it's always magnificent to see.

The people that helped Peter through the loss were in fact other Peters. So many props to Marvel for actually making this work out.

At around 3:33: "I got what I wanted...it didn't make it better." One of the greatest movie confessions ever spoken. Both Tobey Maguire and Andrew Garfield where incredible in their portrayals as Peter 2 and Peter 3. Just a great film all around.

Can we just take a moment to acknowledge and appreciate Ned? He's not just supporting Peter because he's his best friend. He's hurting too. Ned and Peter grew up together. May was probably like a second mother to him. At 0:36 you can see Ned crying not just for Peter but because he loved May too.

Man I love how they all connect with the “With Great power comes great responsibility” line. That’s when they all realize it’s a moment of destiny. A moment that transcends time space and universes. That’s the pivotal moment where the true Spider-Man is born.

I LOVE SO MUCH what they did with Andrew Garfield in this movie. They couldn't have done his character more justice.

4:22 "With great power..." "...comes great responsibility. " Hit me with all the feels when they said that iconic phrase.

3:56: "I wanna tear him apart". He didn't have to, but I LOVE how Tom keeps the Queens accent while NAILING the emotional gravity of the scene.

Spider-Man No Way Home for the most part really did a good job with Tobey & Andrew's Spider-Men. They weren't just cameos, they actually help MCU Spider-Man, not just for the final battle but also helps him emotionally after losing Aunt May. Both Spideys experienced losses of loved ones and both had the great power comes great responsibility talk. It was so beautiful seeing this scene in the theater.

Andrew Garfield is the most passionate and grateful actor to ever play Spiderman. I love all 3 but AG will always be my favorite. He genuinely loves this character.

What I love the most about this scene is how normally Peter would’ve been so excited to meet other Spider-Men. But he’s so emotionally distraught that he just wants them to leave

This scene is forever GOATed. It was like seeing the avengers team up for the first time. There’ll never be a thing like it again.

"Maybe she didn't die for nothing Peter" So badass

This was, by far, the best thing to happen to the Spider-Man movies. I loved all 3 coming together.

3:07 if Andrew was killing villains already just imagine how he would have been with the Venom suit!

4:30 I love that look the two other Peters exchange. You can hear their thoughts..."The kid is not lost yet. He's us."

I truly couldn't stop crying at this moment - seeing them together, sharing their stories of losses, brought back memories of seeing all past Spidey films in cinema. This film was a masterpiece! Childhood was made!

I love this scene, people fail to realize that the other Peters where protecting him from going through the same time as them, they didn't want him to fall in the darkness

2:36 I always start crying when Andrew is about to say he lost his MJ When I first saw the movie I nearly screamed. "No, No don't you dare say it!"

This scene really hits home for me. Back in 2020, I lost a friend to suicide. At the time, I felt so much shame and so much guilt about not being there to help him when I could have. When I first saw this movie and this scene came on, I almost burst into tears as I felt like Tobey and Andrew were comforting me in a way. This scene felt like the closure of all the guilt and shame I had felt and I was able to come to terms with it.

This is so amazing. Andrew's and Tobey's Peter aren't just cameos, they actually help Tom's Peter walk through grief and trauma. They support Peter dealing with one of the wort things he ever had to, losing aunt May - his uncle Ben of this universe. This is huge character development, one of the greatest Spidey stories I've ever seen. This movie is superb.

I love how when they all start talking, there’s no music. It makes it feel so grounded and lifelike. Makes it feel serious

I’ll never be able to get over Andrews acting in this scene. Or the film in general. My man just displays so much raw emotion in his voice. It’s hard not to tear up with him when he says “I’ll never be able to forgive myself for that” 2:30

I remember when I first watched the Andrew Garfield movie, the scene where Gwen died I was shocked. Just the way it was done visually and I didn't expect it at all. They definitely set it up like he was going to catch her. Probably one of the most shocking deaths in a movie I can think of.

"With great power comes great responsibility." It is the wisdom that binds all the Spider-Men together. Even Spider-Gwen heard those words, uttered by her father, Captain George Stacey, the night that the Green Goblin killed him. It seems to be their mutual blessing and curse.

I just realized Tobey says "maybe she didn't die for nothing" when they realized that they all heard that from their parental figure when they died, suggesting it has some cosmic importance

1:57 I know it's a serious moment, but Tom Holland missed the part where that's his problem.

0:17 Good!!! Don’t try to hide that everyone has feelings!!!! I am so damn glad that scenes with people crying (especially men crying) has become such a common thing now

This was the most impactful scene in the whole MCU. I loved that they made the other saga's canon in the MCU

This was the closure that Tobey and Andrew deserved. To appear in the MCU all together writing their wrongs.

Assuming Tobey and Andrew's Aunt Mays are still alive, it must honestly be heart breaking for them to see the youngest Spider-Man practically lose everybody but his friends

I think what Zendaya did with the, "She was my M.J." was really great acting. It's like she was mourning Gwen, while at the same time absorbing the magnitude of what her Peter feels for her, making her love him that much more. She conveyed so much without saying a word.

I will never stop praising this as perhaps the greatest Comic Book movie ever. Not just because of the three spider-men or Sinister Six, but the fact that marvel used Aunt May to be Holland Peter’s Uncle Ben, then using the other spider-men to fast track through the absorption of his grief and loss, and then making him sacrifice it all to turn Tom Holland’s Spider-Man into the comic accurate Peter Parker who struggles to pay rent and works on his own was such an intensely genius move. Literally this one movie actually makes each Peter’s set of movies complete with their journey because it’s just THAT good. The writing for this was fucking impeccable

Imagine traveling back in time 20 years to show someone this film after they just watched Spider-Man 1. Sure, they wouldn't get almost anything going on, but knowing that there have been 8 live action Spider-Man movies made in 20 years would defenitely surprise them.

2:24 “My uncle Ben was killed. It was my fault.”

0:54 the amount of chills this shot sent through so many spines

Andrew Garfield aces this performance. Seeing the pain on Tom's face hearing he lost his "MJ" kills me evertime

4:26 You can just feel the realization he has. It's like "Oh! That's something that has happened to both of us."

While Tobeys Spider-Man had a good story and the uncle Ben death scene was top tier….Andrew’s Spider-Man is really what helped make this scene. His loss is really crazy and the way he describes it was amazing

“The night Ben died I hunted down the man who I thought did it I wanted him dead I got what I wanted it didn’t make it better it took me along time to learn to get through that darkness.!” 😭😭 - Tobey M. ❤

It's incredible how great their chemistry is considering that there was never any plans to have this teamup happen when Tobey, Andrew, and Tom were each initially cast as Peter Parker/Spider-Man.

Low how instead of showing up unexpectedly during the final fight they instead showed up when Peter was at his most vulnerable.

“I lost…I lost Gwen, my…she was my MJ.” 😭

I love the other Peter’s helping in this scene but man I love the way that MJ and Ned just envelop their friend without a word. Just loving him

This scene just works. The writing, the acting, all of it. Just superb. The fact that the same studio brought us Thor Love and Thunder is crazy.

I absolutely love the way they each play this scene. Obviously Tom is a wreck because everything that's happened is still so fresh. But Andrew is barely holding it together when he talks about everything he's been through because he's still fairly young and hasn't had the years to distance himself from it, whereas Toby speaks about his experiences with the sort of peaceful seriousness that only age and wisdom and making peace with your demons comes with.

Tobey is my spider man, but during this scene spider Andrew talking about Gwen was so emotional, a terrific actor

This movie added an additional 5 movies to the MCU. Baller move.

Zendaya does a really great job acting here, being supportive and emotional at the same time.

Most powerful scene i ever experienced in a superhero movie among a packed theater audience EVER since Endgame. Andrew sharing about Gwen made me cry so loud, but Tobey completing his iconic moral: "...comes great responsability" chilled my bones and my heart froze. I grew up on these two Spideys, seeing them all together sharing a same scene was a dream finally come true. Stan would have been so proud ❤🕷

Honestly one of the best movies I've seen, I remember saying YEARS ago that they should make a film where all 3 spiderman meet and its this big awesome moment, and marvel certainly delivered, feels like a dream come true, so great seeing Tobey and Andrew get another opportunity to play possibly their biggest roles they've ever had, it must've been such a blast to be a part of, Kudos to Marvel

The look Tobey gives Andrew, and the very slight nod Andrew gives Tobey after the "With Great Power, Comes Great Responsibility" moment.

Marvel really made us fans cry. Toby and Andrew need their own movies.

1:16 I appreciate the carry over of Andrew Garfield's character being the most openly empathetic. When he confronted Max in Amazing Spider-man 2 for the first time in Times Square, he starts off by listening and then acknowledging Max's confusion, fear and that he doesn't want to hurt people and we see that return by trying to empathize with Peter but instead of forcing him to listen, when he's shot down he backs off, giving him space and listening to what he's saying. Andrew's peter knows how to approach people and I'm so happy that was something that returned in this scene.

I actually *REALLY* like Andrew’s speech about how he stopped pulling his punches. Because it’s him, pseudo acknowledging *my* biggest gripe with the way his Spidey was written.

1:03 The circling of the camera to show Andrew and Tobey as well that subtle sound of the violin. Something really special about it, amongst my top 5 scenes in the movie

This was the best Post-Endgame Marvel movie. Same sense of bringing different universes together to overcome great struggles. Awesome scene, fantastic movie 👏

This scene where Tom Hollands Peter Parker meets the other two is very touching. Andrew Garfield’s Peter Parker is at what would have been the mid point of his life, and doesn’t want Peter to give up. Toby Maguire’s Peter Parker is older and wiser, who’s experienced everything that Tom Hollands Peter Parker has gone through, but wants to help him to not make the same mistakes that he made in the past. Imagine if we met our future selves, how different our outlook on life would be.

All of the spidermen are just so respectful, even Tom stopped to listen and share how he feels

Andrew's acting when he tells the peters that gwen died is so good, he deserves a tasm 3

Imagine if Tobey and/or Andrew were able to keep their roles. I don’t think we would’ve gotten this absolute masterpiece of a Spider-Man film

How heart warming it would’ve been if the other Aunt Mays came through the portal and hugged and comforted Tom Holland’s Peter

I like Spider-Man because every rendition of Peter Parker has been flawed, troubled, and totally imperfect. It makes him feel so human.

1:20-1:24 the very fact that he is literally the one that can relate is heartbreaking

This is what makes a great Marvel Movie. Sure it's fun and goofy and flashy, but the most important ingredient is that it has a very human heart.

The way Tom's Peter flinches and tries to protect Ned and MJ when the other Peter's jump down is really sad. The poor kid's been through so much.

@3:20 Toby's right, no matter how bad you want that Person dead wouldn't be the same afterwards

The second Ned and MJ grabbed him, hugged him and all cried together, man I cried 😭 Now I’m crying again 😢 This scene was so beautiful ❤ (Also I had to add, To me, in my opinion, aunt May’s death scene was the saddest from the first two Uncle Ben’s. She was on the journey with him since civil war and we saw the mother/son dynamic between them. And it happened right in front of Tom’s peter. They made it darker on purpose for everyone to see.)

All the actors/actress in this scene absolutely knocked it out of the park. Zendaya's facial expressions in the background were incredible

This scene will always have a huge place in my heart, here are the best parts of it in my opinion: 1. When MJ and Ned go to comfort Peter, and he just breaks down crying hurt me so much. Ned also is probably mourning too because hes known May most of his life to, because he and Peter have been best friends. 2. When MJ says there are some people here, the way Peter jumps up right away to protect them, like he has a fear of his best friend and his MJ getting hurt because he has already lost so much. 3. When Peter said he lost Gwen and she was his MJ you could see the tears welling up, and us as an audience personally know how bitter he got after that and him telling Peter 1 (Tom) that he doesnt want him to end up like him is so pure and personal. 4. Also when Andrew told him that you can see MJ realizing this happened to Peters love intrest in another universe, and seeing how he never moved on and how much he loved gwen was so real, which probably made her realize how much peter really loves her and how much she loves him now, and Peters reaction to that was heartbreaking, him realizing this this other MJ died hurt him and how much he doesnt want to loose her. 5. After Tobey said he got what he wanted, the way Peter is so broken, going from "I dont wanna kill anyone" to "I wanna tear him apart" the day aunt May died was the day happy peter died 6. The way after they finished great power great responsibitity line, he breaks down into tears hurts me and also just MJ watching him say he wants to kill goblin, she saw in ffh he was ashamed and sad he killed mysterio but now he sees how broken he is 7. "maybe she didnt die for nothing" =ughh my heart so in conclusion they are the best siblings and the character developmenttttttt also i probably missed some because there was so much signifigance in one scene i could go on forever Peter I LARB you 3000!🥰😭

To have each Peter Parker talk to each other about the painful losses they have experienced in their earths not only connected all of the stories of their respective movies together in one scene but brought everything full circle. What a classy and awesome way of honoring the legacy of the Spider-Man franchise

Such a great scene! Just a big shame Stan Lee was never around to see this :(

There’s just so much to love about this scene. Finding themselves in one another and sympathising with their seperate tragedies, Peter 2 finally learnt to be free from his darkest moments, Peter 3 still struggling with his own demons and warning his younger brother to not fall in line like he did, the THREE BOYS TOGETHER makes this scene so incredibly special. Gets me in the feels every single time 🥲

God I love Tom's acting in this scene. The way he just breaks down when MJ and Ned hug him gets me every time.

I love that Tobey is faster on the draw. He’s been doing this shit the longest

After the events of Wakanda Forever, Holland's Peter and Shuri would have a lot to talk about.

It’s sad, Ned, MJ, and Happy were the only family Peter had left

3:02 for those that don't know, in the comics Spider-Man deliberately rolls with punches and pretends they hurt him, to be kind. He could literally just stand stock-still, letting thugs punch him and they would break their fists like they were punching a statue. Spider-Man always holds back. When Otto Octavius took over Peter's body to become "The Superior Spider-Man" he accidentally punches the Scorpian's Jaw clean off, because he didn't realise he had to hold back. I don't know if Andrew's Peter went that far, but that's what happens when a Spider-Man TRULY does not hold back.

I adore what they did with Andrew Garfield's Spider-Man. When we last saw him his best friend went evil, he created a new supervillain and Gwen fucking died. We never got to see him find closure, heal or even grow past any of it. So the fact that we get to see how Andrew's Spider-Man never recovered, didn't get his happy ending is just perfection. They could've just ignored all of this and had him be his regular old happy-go-lucky character and assume that offscreen he managed to forgive himself and move on but they didn't and i love it.

The soundtrack in this movie is just on point throughout. Especially after Aunt May dies, the music is a constant gut punch during Peter's mourning scenes and the scene when he finally realises what it means to have great power and responsibility, when Strange does the mindwipe spell. Absolutely love this movie

This is the most emotional marvel movie by far. That scene when mj falls & Andrew's peter catches her. That scene fuckin broke me in the cinema.

I like the subtle look MJ gives to Peter, it’s fast but it tells him “hey you need to listen.” Only a loving partner could do that.

This is when you know, this movie didn't rely on that nostalgia train and did nothing with it. Movies almost decades apart interconnected in a single scene. Culminating with the line that made peter parker "the spiderman". "With great power, comes great responsibility." Never thought a superhero can make me feel this emotional. It's hard to be spiderman but that's what made peter parker noble. He lets go of that mask and he'll have a good life. But he embraced the mask and lets go of his life, for other’s lives to be better. Spiderman is my greatest superhero.

“I got what I wanted but it didn’t make it better”-Tobey Maguire

Never thought to see all the Spider-Man interacting with each other fighting together... NWH is just amazing

Man, I will never forget the experience on opening day my mom even let me skip school that day because she knows how big of a Spider-Man fan I am and some of my friends watched it opening night and I didn’t want to get spoiled. To see these two in this movie, but my inner child out I felt like my 10-year-old self again. But they weren’t just cameos. They were there to help Tom through his grieving process and become a better Spider-Man truly inexperience I will never forget.

4:16 every time I get the chills

This is the most intense scene in the movie, all three Peters sharing their grief about their respective losses in the most emotional situation🥲

The way they brought us to the lowest of lows with May's death and then to the highest of highs right after with this scene...oh god. Perfect.