Ms. Joanne Linville always exhibited not only professionalism and true class. When she left us, obviously her talents and compassion were needed elsewhere.

Saw her in twilight zone,rip

@@alexp3752 .....her talents and compassion were needed elsewhere is a great line for real life of this plane of exitstatnce or for actors overall....thanks heaps for it !!

She was soooo good, boots & all.... Yum

She was so beautiful 😊

Yes, however, when the Enterprise changed course once the cloaking device was up and running, the Captain was gentlemanly and courteous enough to assign her quarters on the ship and treat her with dignaty, quite the opposite of the way the Romulans treated him when he was on the Romulan flagship. He also assured her that she would be left off on a nearest starbase for her safty as well as her dignity. EXCELLENT EPISODE, THE ENTERPRISE INCIDENT! Loved every minute of it!

@@danbasta3677 Honor/warrior culture vs dignity/explorer culture perhaps.

@@alicetremain7366 right!

@@danbasta3677 To be fair to the Romulans, Kirk's entire ruse was to pose as a potentially violent madman. The Romulans treated him quite well, all things considered.

Don't forget how he called to Scotty General Order 24 for over his captors' communicator.😉

Well, keep in mind that they had also just dealt treacherously with her to steal the cloaking tech. Espionage is a shabby business by its very nature.

I'll drink a shot of Romulan ale to that, sir!

He's just trying to get with her, the old salty dog. That's why he gives her her own quarters.

@@nathanfitzgerald6651 I'm having some now

​​@@brianbagnall3029 2:45 Yes, and after his mouth said, "Mr Spock will have the honor of escorting you to your quarters," his goo-goo eyes (and the flirty flute music, lol) then said, "And I, will have the honor of paying you a little visit later, baby." 😂 Easily-missed subtleties like that were part of this show's greatness, lost on today's crass crowd.

Family of Larry.... ?

Her daughter is a younger spitting image of her. She was in star trek continues.

I think she was in a Columbo episode. She played the w?ife of a U.S. Senator who murdered his Campaign Advisor.

@@chrismarks4277 did a good job too

She definitely lived long and prospered.

I totally understand what you mean by that. The same thought occurred to me.

A very red pill moment. Much respect to TOS!

Oh _I_ thought it meant they’d banged off-screen as part of maintaining Spock’s cover.

@@ericericson9282 Star Trek is _very_ red-pilled, if we go with the original Matrix meaning _or_ the red of communism, rather than the hilarious misunderstanding those within the American conservative -bowel- movement seem to have of the term. It’s _also_ hella-based! _”Workers of the world unite, you have nothing to lose but your chains!”_ - Grand Nagus Rom, 2372

@@DissociatedWomenIncorporated also yes

Nothing touches the original.

Modern Trek can't even come close.

Wow! Finally a post on KZfaq that really hit it on the nail best regards from the state of Kentucky!

Beautifully directed with intelligent restraint using first class actors.

@@Bootmahoy88 Totally agree with you.

BEcause he wanted her in his bed, as usually.

@@Kontorotsui seems that she and spock had something between ?

@@Kontorotsui no he didn't, have you never actually watched star trek?

@@Kontorotsui if anything I think Spock called dibs here

I think there was chivalry there, too.

haha i thought i recognized that old rust bucket!

I think they used the top of nomad and one of the globes from "Return to tomorrow"

@@manw3bttcks Spock is such a sly devil for basically saying he had to make out with her because it was the only way to get the cloaking device! Win win !!

It's a shame they could not salvage Nomad. The knowledge it had with its merging of the Tan'Ru probe could have easily given the Federation Transwarp, AI, and massive improvements in ships and planets in the 23rd Century. I could have seen an episode where Nomad's AI matrix was the basis for Data.

How many Romulans have you seen?

To be fair, he wasn't really captured, it was just made to look like he was.

And in both, Spock is involved with Romulans

Jolan Tru...

HE WAS CAPTURED LIE MCCAIN

Dealing with the Original Series Star Trek here. The ONLY BEST STAR TREK OUT THERE. Who really cares about that bozo chrome dome picard character and his flipping his hands over his head stuff. Yes, exactly, cowboy diplomacy for the win, action, adventure, drama, at times, a little comedy, Original Star Trek Series Rules!

Haha that's awesome!

🤣

Great show!

"Take me to the brig" "You're far too hot for that. Go to your quarters."

@@richardt6 Beyond hot!

@@richardt6 Hahahahahaha... Yes, that's about right.

Young men that woman is a lady. With grace dignity as well as beauty. You don't find many women like her anymore.

Yep!

Her daughter played the same role in the "Star Trek: Continues" episodes, equally talented and beautiful.

@@backalleycqc4790 Her daughter is a clone of her mother for sure. Same face, same acting talent.

Amen. What a breathtaking and beautiful performance.

Yes and alot better than what we have today. A bunch of useless breeding snowflakes.

I admired how both commanders nodded to each other.This one scene is Star Trek in it's purest form.

Is she related to Larry Linville of M*A*S*H fame?

@@davepitts4479 Met her once at an ST con. Asked the same question. She said no. Classy lady, just like her character.

@@RSW6666 Thank you. After I wrote that, I thought to put the question to Google and got my answer.

@@davepitts4479 If you watch "Star Trek Continues", you can see her daughter, Amy Rydell play the same part in the 2 part episode "To Boldly Go"

Agree. Especially enjoyed the other good Romulan one, Balance of Terror. Another captain with some personality. Even the Klingons had character. Though my favourite was always Kruge from ST3.

Oh I don't know - TNG had some good ones: kzfaq.info/get/bejne/jad3eqiombrHdo0.html

@@fuzzblightyear145 the captain of the Romulan ship on balance of terror, i think that's the episode where where it was ship on ship, was played by Surek, Spock's father :)

@@lorcis1 , the late Mark Lenard played the Romulan Captain and later Sarek, Spock's father. You're correct!

@@albertoswald8461 And with his role as the Klingon captain in ST:TMP, he became the first actor to play the "big three" aliens.

😂

*Kirk falls through trapdoor in front of captain's chair* WRONG SWIIIIIIiiiiiitch

@@DiRF I understood that reference

aaaa Scotty gotta love em

DiRF wrong switch Kronk

I, just recently, watched that episode! I thought "Damn, she's perfect. How'd they find the spitting image of the original actress?" That was her daughter?! Bee-eautiful.

Yes, I was gobsmacked when I saw her. My immediate reaction was, "OMG, she's aged well!" I had to pause the show there and then to research the 'Continues' actress.

Amy Rydell rocked it in her mom's role in Star Trek Continues!

The Mother was far better looking

@J Spiel, you're mean spirited. Her daughter is beautiful and did a wonderful job.

Have to keep the Military Industrial complex fed somehow....

With Trump in charge, they were free for the asking. LOL!!!

It's a line that has stayed with me for nearly 50 years.

@@johnarmenta2199 right, takes a look at Biden handing over the country to Xi. *eye roll*

@@RobertWilke The entire west actually.

Very, very cool. Thanks for sharing.

Kirk, one of my childhood heroes.

MegaAdamreed Don't know why this is so freakin' funny! lol!!!!

LOL! :)

Until they ran into The Borg - they they ran like hell !

An order is an order.

To this day?..that event happened 200 years from now....will happen...🤨

"I'm on my way!"

If all the shouting is done up there, need you to report to sick bay.

Another McCoy slur, "joking" status or species bias.

I some times tire of the relentless teasing Bones gives Spock.

Just the KISSING SCENE between her and Spock was highly discussed not just among fans but als by the involved actors. Look it up in the Leonard Nemoy biographies

Mark Leonard was too,rip

DC was an alias for lady writer so there you go!

@@user-nr8vj3qf5l Her name was Dorothy IIRC, so it isn't an alias, just her initials.

Still, wouldn't have been able to get credit if she used her name.

One of the other episodes that show this is when he sees Kirk is alive and shows how happy he is. ( Course I don't need to tell you that...) Good stuff.

Good observation.

One of the few times Spock actually displayed a human trait.

Beverly Joanne Linville

Liviana Charvanek

@Comrade Stalin : ... and Susan Oliver.

@@brianhiles8164 ... and Lee Meriwether

Things I say to the escort when the hour is up.

@jaysmith3361 😅 No, love! She just needs to save enough money to be comfortable and then she's coming to me, she swears!!! 🤞

@jaysmith3361 you didn't get my joke. Never mind.

She was a very alluring yet powerful commander and left an inelible mark upon my young 10 yr old (and even today my 49 yr old mind) mind....

mybestvideos aregonewiththewind jj

omg i dont want to know that . I see her forever beautiful powerful and in complete control. I forget that when I first saw these people were in their prime.

And her daughter (Amy Rydell) reprised that role in the web series Star Trek Continues. Episodes "To Boldly Go".

On Romulus she would be 220 yrs old

Yes, this particular had a very strange and hard to explain atmosphere, very well filmed and crafted by all concerned

I'll give the video a thumbs up - not you.

Yes, really liked this one. Spock's incredible restraint when he was with the hot Romulan commander is quite commendable. 👍

Joanne Linville was so brilliant in this episode -- unforgettable!

@@rowanaforrest9792 her daughter reprised the role they look quite alike

it's not unique to TOS, it was a common style back then.

Deck 2 is below the bridge, but the turbolift trip lasts as long as the plot requires.

Yes the lighting u mentioned I see with some regularity..also the softening of the shot usually when a beautiful woman is the subject..which usually has the Flute track as well. Great stuff. Its my 8PM ritual week nights.

And that line It is our secret....

@@silkwesir1444 I love the lighting of old Hollywood. It’s especially prevalent in film noir.

In the "Star Trek Continues" series finale, Joanne Linville's real-life daughter plays the Romulan commander.

My favorite dress of all the ladies on TOS.

@@beyourself2444 Watch on you tube "Mannix, Leslie Parrish, the Girl in the Frame". Ms. Parrish is wearing her gown from Star Trek !

Well as of this summer “not anymore” after hearing about her passing on Sunday evening.

@@beyourself2444 Mine too!

True, she's even better than when Tasha Yar took a turn at being Romulan, as her daughter of course.

me too!

I was in 5th grade back then. It aired after the 10 PM news.

I'm a First Gen trekker, too. It premiered one day before my 5th birthday, on my sister's 6th birthday (that she never let me forget). Both of my parents were sci-fi fans, and the premier episode, "The Man Trap", totally floored them, so needless to say I never missed an episode, either.

@@just_kos99 Yes, "The Man Trap" was the first episode, but it wasn't the first one filmed. I think there were a few episodes filmed first. If you notice the first Kirk pilot film, they were still using the old lasers instead of phasers. They had the old baggy uniforms. In the man trap, the show was obviously out of order because Kirk and McCoy were already teasing each other as if they had been on the show for a while. What do you say?

Late Dad and I too, 66 through 68. I was 8ish, now 64.

In my opinion the stories were better also.

Yes,yes,yes! I don't particularly remember this episode BUT clearly our 60s/70's imaginations filled in the gaps- in aging retrospect, all TV culture from this era reached a very high watermark that from the 1980's onwards has, dismally failed to reach which is an increasing cycle of decline-discuss......

So with you. In NG the prosthetics were stupid and unattractive. Over the top ridiculous such as the Kardassians.

That minimal makeup was kind of necessary, but I agree. I recall reading that the set of the Enterprise D in TNG cost as much as a whole season of TOS. Whew!

Yes so why so many artificially enhanced women today? I.e. breats inplants ( which is causing cancer) botoxs, butt inplants, permanent mascara, wigs, multiple piercing, full body tats, ( research shows that by injecting ink into the skin will probably cause cancer later in life) why?

@@grayman735 You are delusional. We've had breast implants since the early 1960s. Modern cosmetic surgery since the 1920s. Tattoos for centuries.

stick to the original statement assholes--hot women on this show

Really dude!?

@@Daisyno2when i look at t' pol all i can think about is live long and prosper.

Come on now... I was a HUGE fan of TOS. But it had its share of hammy acting, bad acting, and heavy handed pathos. It just had much better writers in the writing room (at least for the first two seasons).

It had suspense. The others did not.

@@rgrossjr42 I agree that TOS was cheesy for the time, but they were on a shoe string budget, even for the time but the skill of the actors AND writers, surpasses STD.

acting in std has precisely 3 modes: screaming, crying, or 'plank of wood'

AND THAT means something. After all the classical STAR TREK had been a low budget show were you heard always through the cracking of the inexpensive stage floor if you watched the episodes in the original sound track, So top actors were rare on the show due to th minimum payments

Yes, Nomad is recycled. They had to be economically responsible you know. And conveniently every alien planet they ever landed on spoke American accented English.

Glad the 21st century has mastered the USB and Bluetooth interoperability. Such tech, as well as touchscreens, will have been lost til at least the 24th century (original timeline, not kelvin or the Enterprise series borg reverse engineering). Enjoy it before ww3.

The computer graphics on the ship for the later series was just an extension of what we have now. TOS looked futuristic at the time.

Yes to me just ORVILLE really recreated the original Roddenberry appeal

yep, ya gotta dig it!

yep and her chain mail uniform was awsome too

now they have all the women running around in pants and short hair. Might as well be men at that point.

Even the Klingon women, that episode where Kang and his crew were beamed aboard the Enterprise and later were given swords by the energy creature to fight the Enterprise crew. His mate was very hot looking in that Klingon female uniform.

Back then they also made plenty of crap stories. We just remember the good stuff. For example, I do not collect and reminisce on bad stuff, I collect and reminisce on what I think is good. Comparing the best of the past with the bad or even mediocre of the present is never a fair comparison.

esa Software, I agree. Most of the original series episodes had more complexity and subtlety. The lighting, the background sounds, the conversations rather than a stiff script. Even Spock had facial expressions. The original series allowed suspense to build. The newer series have very little of that. The newer the series the more it relies on weapons and war. Too much CGI for CGI’s sake. One of the best episodes of “Enterprise” was “Carbon Creek”. Cerebral, thoughtful science fiction.

Yup, yup...so True...

The late John McCain had that level of class.

😂😂😂

@@garyfoster3854 Did you watch Boston Legal? Were you interested in any of the cases not with Shatner or James Spader? Shatner commanded the screen when he was on.

@@howie9751 don't bother, he probably likes star trek discovery

Well put. She was awesome in season 1 of Hawaii Five-O. She played a crooked faith healer.

I think it is the same object!😊

@@danielgregory3295 that is correct

Roddenberry had nothing to do with it.

I didn't get the full meaning of their love-making scene until I was grown. Touch-telepath make-out. Something else. I am not sure I would even allow my child to watch certain episodes and this was one of them. When he touched her he knew her mind. Dangerous talent if it were applied for espionage.

@@EdiaStanfordBruce I remember, azz a child, feeling sorry 4 her. I don't remember da whole episode, BUTT I remember thinking, she dserved better.

@@EdiaStanfordBruce But wasn't it?

Strangely her character was never named (though I'm sure someone writing the EU has done so).

I find it odd she comes aboard the Starfleet vessel and changes into an Earth dress, makeup and earrings.

@howie9751 The Romulan Commander had changed out of her uniform and into a dress before she was accidently transported with Spock to the Enterprise. Therefore it had nothing to do with "Earth".

@@spuwho Either way, I don't think the Romulans had Earthlike clothes and cosmetics for their women, especially their Commander. It was a contrived part or the script to make Linville beautiful for the end of the show.

LOVED her boots!! Always wanted a pair😏

Exactly! What were they thinking? They looked like shit with the forehead crap.

DS9 ended up making similar changes to the Vulcans.

This was always an argument between the film and tv show production teams in the 80s as well. Luckily Picard rectified it and going forward romulans are much more like they were.

Romulan make over a disaster. They look totally stupid with the Moe haircut and those dumbass shoulders.

STTNG had the opposite production problem as TOS. TOS suffered from too little budget, STTNG often had too much, and used it to do things better left undone.

Turbolifts: moving at the speed of the plot

It took the scenic route.

the depth of the ship often alluded me with all the decks

They're dramatic turbolifts. They move exactly as long as it takes for the conversation to finish.

Had to match the dialouge between Mr. Spock and the Romulan Commander. So, yes, it had to be slow in order for the dialouge between the two could be completed.

The designer was names Bill Theiss. I agree he did a wonderful job.

The Romulans were portrayed as a very elegant people. I hated how ugly and spartan they were presented in TNG.

They were gearing up for war in TNG.Its 100 years later, and a very different era.

@@obsoletebutneat TNG had to make Romulans the ugly enemy, having already chosen to make allies of the (heretofore) ugly Klingons.

Welcome to the 60s. That style was straight out of 60s main stream styling. Not that, that it is a bad thing, its not. It was a time when women still dressed like women-Feminine, which was a beautiful thing.

They should've laid out a 360 degree spread or at least a few shots aft. That's what I would've done.

German U-boat does a crash dive. Every second lost by pursuing destroyer reduces a chance of a fatal hit.

He seemed to have the same type of delivery as Shatner.

very well written episode. When they do top rated episodes this one often doesnt make the list? I dont get that. She's what we now call "hot" loved her and Spock together. Clearly a worthy match!

Tal would have been executed for his failures.

Too bad we do not expect as much of our leaders.

I'm ok with firing and jailing leaders short of treason

"Sub-Commander Tal makes a perfect Romulan!" He was standing Tal. Unless, of course, it was all a Tal tale. I'll see myself out.

Thanks to Dorothy Fontana, the writer who created the Romulan Commander, played by Joanne Linville. Fontana has said the idea for the story was sparked by the Pueblo incident. She was dissatisfied with the result in terms of logic (Kirk and Spock as duplicitous spies), but agreed with Nimoy and Linville that Vulcans and Romulans had to display a non-Terran sensuality (via touch telepathy). If you like to read, you might like Kathleen Daily's fanfic novel in 2 parts, The Romulan Commander's Story (online). It picks up the threads from the close of this episode and explores, as she puts it, "the profound personal and political consequences of the events depicted in 'The Enterprise Incident'."

Sorry, but when I said this episode could only happen in the 3rd Season I meant it was thanks to the fact Dorothy Fontana wasn't there working on the series anymore. It would be much duller episode without Spock and Kirk as spies. The lines would be much worse probably, I mean Fontana wasn't a particular skilled writer. Dramatic lines like " BUT the birds and the bees are NOT Vulcans, Captain" or Leila calling Mr. Spock... well, you know "Mr. Spock" during their break-up scene are all Fontanas contribution to the series, sadly. She had some decent ideas, but was an amateur really. I'm not an old TOS fan, I discovered the series just recently "with a fresh eye" I hope. You'll probably disagree with a lot of my opinions - I think the praised 1st Season had actually more flawed episodes than Season 3, but people don't mind because "they just started".

Why sorry? Differing opinions make life interesting. TOS has a lot of clunky dialog, so singling out Fontana on that score seems a tad unfair, but perhaps I sounded adulating. I give her credit for coming up with the Romulan Commander, despite the ease with which the character was duped, which Fontana also criticized after the fact. I was disappointed, but it was 60s TV; they had less than a hour to tell a story with twists and turns, speeding it up with the blinded-by-lust trope, which, as acted, was riveting. Agree it wouldn't be the episode it is without the covert mission, but that doesn't refute Fontana's point that duplicity was actually out of character for these white-hat guys. Would have added some interesting tension if they'd been given more such missions based on the success of this one. I read somewhere that Joanne Linville was asked to reprise the Commander's role in TNG but had another commitment. Wish the script or draft were available. .

Ok, I'm non-English speaker so maybe I shouldn't critise writing skills of Dorothy Fontana or any other native speaker, for that matter ;-) My English is defenitly worse than hers as you may see... But maybe my view is an interesting one thanks to this. Beside I think that an undeserved bad reputation that Season 3 has comes partly from people like Fontana trash-talking it over the years. And she wasn't even there on this honorably sinking ship and that was my point.

Tastes change, and TOS isn't sacred. Different views are preferable to gushing enthusiasm. It's useful to be a devil's advocate for season 3. Besides The Enterprise Incident, there were some other intellectually interesting ones (I esp liked the details in Is There In Truth No Beauty, The Tholian Web, The Cloud Minders, and Turnabout Intruder), but the Enterprise Incident is the best for me. Back then, Rod Serling pointed out how uneven TOS was: "Star Trek was again a very inconsistent show which at times sparkled with true ingenuity and pure science fiction approaches. At other times it was more carnival-like, and very much more the creature of television than the creature of a legitimate literary form." (from Wikipedia). It was totally depressing when the series was put in the 10pm slot on Friday night, the budget reduced, and the show finally cancelled in 1968. You've read about it; it seems to have colored a lot of people's attitudes. For an ordinary viewer, there was no way to see it ever again (I bought all the James Blish text treatments, sold as paperbacks).

- really does not look much like a uniform.

​@agwhitaker She wasn't in uniform at the time--wasn't that when she was off-duty, hobnobbing with Spock?😊😊❤

Pantyhose and the boots made it work.

Joseph1NJ it shouldn't have been cancelled

@@jenpeterson3712 Agreed, as when the moon landing in July of 1969 gappened, the Original Star Trek series would have gone through the roof, and the sky would never been the limit. NBC was so stupid to have purposely caused the ratings to go under so they would have an excuse to cancel the show.

Or, you could just purchase the DVD collection on Amazon.

$2@2021 = $0.25@1967

Back in the 60s this was canceled after 3 seasons and the 3rd season was garbage. Now we have 4 star trek series and counting with no end in sight. Count your blessings.

Capitan Kirk is looking at her Zulu is looking at the Capitan

Spock had solid Game.