Thank you!

#No_he_isnt Go cry me a river republic fanboy.

#Boss_FixerWillknos

Mostly because all those stormtroopers aren't at the same place.

Plot armour.

​@@clonecoric4140 ok thanks for telling me then

​@@clonecoric4140I really thought that the empire is the most great army that even created in the galactic history

Simple, the empire is full of lazy idiots that never bothered to train their soldiers to adapt to guerrilla tactics, focused more on flashy yet impractical weaponry (Death Star/at-at) instead of practical weaponry (tie defenders/tanks/battle droids) and never add more to said weaponry like shields or armor. Clones, saw and even smaller group are unpredictable and the empire aren’t trained for unpredictable (except Thrawn, one of the few competent imperials)

I mean to be fair this is the early empire. While they are expanding the universe, there’s still enough cracks for rebels to slip through before the more well guarded times like in andor. And yea clones would have a harder time fighting imperials compared to droids but clones are know to adapt.

@subscorpion9560 If that were the case, then they shouldn't pretend that the Empire is almighty. The Empire isn't obviously a post-war government. The Tarkin novel did a great job with its portrayal of the Empire, but in TBB, Tarkin literally appears at the start of the show with a new uniform as though the Emperor just pressed a button and everything changed. It seems that the creative team forgot that the Republic uniforms used in TCW were literally based on uniforms we saw at the end of ROTS, which occurred several weeks/months into the Empire. Instead, TBB gives us the impression that the Empire is in the position to change everything. The war is somehow definitively over, the populace is somehow already joining up en masse into the military, which thus far has been entirely comprised of stormtroopers (which thanks to Crosshair we know are somehow stationed pretty much everywhere) and the Empire is already doing tons of 'morally questionable' stuff which the Republic is said not to have done in the open. The writers want the Empire to be evil without putting any amount of effort in. The Empire bombarding Serenno is a great example of this. Why the hell did the Empire destroy the entire city? And then, in the episode with the Separatist governor, she was talking about how Dooku warned that the Republic could 'become something worse' or some other bullshit. And the worst part about it all is that people act like this is good world building, when it clearly isn't. All it does is make the 'bad guy' seem like someone that no one would work for.

I mean the elite trooper in season did say the empire gave him more than what the republic did for him, people already didn’t like the republic and thought the empire would be better and there are people who believe the empire bring order in the galaxy. I mean look at Freck who supports the empire or even Vardos. There’s also children born in the imperial era who wanted to join the empire when they believe they were the good guys like Thane or Ciera. I’m saying that while the Empire is evil, there are moments where people would be willing to join them and not out of fear but actual loyalty, safety and better pay. I mean why else would the empire be able to have millions of stormtroopers from core to unknown regions?

@@subscorpion9560 Except the sources you are citing don't come from the show aside from 1 line from 1 trooper. TBB doesn't get to ignore tons of established lore and then get to cite more nuanced stories to explain its flaws

@@tk-6967 Well i'd say it still holds up as well as any other show, you know the bad batch is just really fun to watch, it's hard for me not to just sit back and just enjoy seeing them go on adventures that aren't always fighting Plus, if being honest i was more curious seeing what happens to them after the series and to be honest Am glad to know they end up living on Pabu I feel like Certain imperials like Rampart, Bragg and Hemlock are written off as you know imperials merely trying to do their jobs right Also on comparison to Andor love how there isn't One Mention or appearance of Lord Vader at all which is great because it sorta abbreviates his over recurring roles in recent SW! I always enjoy Filler, so obviously i enjoy every episode I admit The stormtroopers could have been written a little better especially seeing how Crosshair's squad had some personality, ES-01 was a refugee likely who joined tbe empire for it's resources and food, ES-02 was likely the one that tried to remain Loyal to Crosshair until she had to run off to save her own skin and ES-04 who wishes to find some new enemies to fight since the end.of the clone wars saw the end of the Republic's enemies the separatist! But still what do you expect, The Batch for a majority are using Stun on season 1 so it really manages to beat the soldiers immediately, Season 2 they're always with some assistance that helps them beat the imperials And season 3, the Stormtroopers for a majority are ambushed by a giant creature, (the forest monster, the Zillo beast, the Rathtar)

Not really, by the time they died they were kinda escapies and had chosen the rebellion in Se's case and his own faction in Rampart's case

Since this is the early imperial period we used the republic division numbers as that would mean over 20,000 troopers were in that one hanger, which would not be feasibly possible

@@CommanderThireYT A single Battalion in the republic had 661 troopers. A division is usually 6 times a battalion. Again, you undercount the number of casualties. Are you really just an ignorant Republic fanboy, or do you really feel bad about fictional soldiers dying? You overcount the droid deaths so it must be the case.

Pretty sure 20,000 troopers weren't possibly stationed in Mount Tantiss at the time. Also, a reminder that words by characters tend to be exagerated, Scorch couldn't have specifically meant 20,000 troops. Sounds like someone's salty over the amount of seppies counted

Yeah, someone should make another video like this but with accurate numbers by someone who actually does research. Not some random who makes numbers up.

When have I over counted droid deaths? what you are saying makes no possible sense that 20,000 troopers would be in that one area. The writers get it wrong sometimes. Also a division could be very small in the GAR such as the 212th recon division and the 332nd division so I did actually do my research

They were TK trooper as seen by thier helmet and they fell from a considerable enough height that I consider them dead

@@CommanderThireYT ah ok

​@@CommanderThireYThe's talking about the Clones that Wrecker bashed together

@@richardched6085 But I didnt count them

The cockpit is destroyed enough for me to count them as dead

I didnt show the thier death clip