Stop Hiding Traps

  Рет қаралды 94,887

Questing Beast

Questing Beast

3 жыл бұрын

Get Electric Bastionland: bit.ly/BastionlandPDF
Get Into the Odd: bit.ly/IntotheOddPDF
Get Maze Rats here: bit.ly/QBDTRPG
Get Tome of Adventure Design: bit.ly/ToADPDF
Get Crypt of the Science Wizard: bit.ly/CotSWPDF
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
My RPGs (PDF): bit.ly/QuestingBeastPDFs
My RPGs (Print): bit.ly/QuestingBeastBooks
Newsletter: bit.ly/TheGlatisant
Patreon: bit.ly/QBPatreon
Amazon recommendations: amzn.to/3RwpZzU
Questing Beast merch: bit.ly/QBMerch
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
My blog: bit.ly/QuestingBlog
Must-read blog posts: bit.ly/OSRposts
The best RPG blogs: bit.ly/OSRblogs
What is the OSR?: bit.ly/PrincipApoc
Send a review copy or advertise: bit.ly/ContactQB
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
QUESTING KNIGHT PATRONS!
fikle
The Threshold Team
SonOfSofaman
John Eternal
James Endres
Carl Flippin
Roll Stats
Minty
John Case Tompkins
Gianfranco Bux
Fil Kearney
Eric from Bloat Games
Dwayne Boothe
Darren Brum
Dan Webb
Christian Lindke
Chris Boyce
Ardashir Lea
Alex Dzuricky
Aaron Seymour
Joshua Blair
Bill Piper

Пікірлер: 346
@QuestingBeast
@QuestingBeast 3 жыл бұрын
Support the channel on Patreon to unlock voting rights, early video previews, and the secret discord: bit.ly/QBPatreon Keep up with the Old-School RPG scene with the Questing Beast newsletter: bit.ly/Glatisant Download my RPGs and adventures: bit.ly/QBDTRPG My favorite RPG-related products: amzn.to/30kfamM
@bethanytaylor554
@bethanytaylor554 3 жыл бұрын
Can you add closed captions to this, please? I am deaf and want to watch the video but it doesn't have captions. :(
@QuestingBeast
@QuestingBeast 3 жыл бұрын
@@bethanytaylor554 If you wait for a week or so Google will automatically add captions. Unfortunately I don't have enough time to do captions for my videos.
@danielrowan4716
@danielrowan4716 3 жыл бұрын
I’ve been playing DND for 35 years and this is one of the best takes on how to run tricks / traps I’ve seen. Excellent treatment
@minnion2871
@minnion2871 10 ай бұрын
Perhaps traps could be divided into the categorys of "Trick" (Where it doesn't actually harm the player but inconveniences them somehow), Hazard(Where it can harm the player, though is usually obvious enough that you'll probably see it without having to specifically looking for it as long as you aren't rushing ahead or acting recklessly...) And Ambush, where the thread of harm is still there but it's more of an attack activated by whatever enemies are attacking you... (Like a Kobold trying to swing a Bear trap into your face to lock you down while the others pepper your character with arrows and the one that swung in on the bear trap is now trying to shank you as well...)
@danielrowan4716
@danielrowan4716 10 ай бұрын
@@minnion2871 I concur with this thought. The 1e DMG Appendices G and H provides tables and guidance for Tricks and Traps, but does make a fairly clear delineation between one being a harm / hazard (traps) and the other more of a puzzle, obstacle, or weird occurrence (tricks) for the PCs to overcome or at least deal with. Not to say that a trick can’t be hazardous or harmful, but I believe the spirit of the thing is as per your point.
@TheSonicShoe
@TheSonicShoe 3 жыл бұрын
One of the best "traps" I ever made wasn't even a trap at all. It was just a (recently deceased) mad scientist's normal bedroom in his hidden lair. By the time they reached it, they had already had several things try to kill them, so when they found a normal looking door, they went full S.W.A.T. team, and tried to breach and clear the room, and whatever baddies were hiding inside. The door was actually unlocked, and the room was mostly empty with just some mundane set dressing that elaborated on the scientists tastes and interests. Their paranoia nearly got them to start a fire in an underground bunker with poor ventilation, and almost turned a totally safe room into a potentially deadly scenario. Sometimes the absence of any *actual* danger can be one of the most deadly things a party of overly paranoid adventures can encounter!
@benvoliothefirst
@benvoliothefirst 3 жыл бұрын
DIABOLICAL, hahaha
@richtigmann1
@richtigmann1 3 жыл бұрын
the trap _is_ the player!
@jaredlasseter7364
@jaredlasseter7364 2 жыл бұрын
This is genius
@xremming
@xremming 4 ай бұрын
No party I have ever played has been able to just cross a simple nondescript bridge without becoming paranoid. It must be a trap!
@segevstormlord3713
@segevstormlord3713 3 жыл бұрын
In old-school dungeon crawling, it was assumed that searching carefully for traps came at the expense of time. Traps were largely just revealed if they were going slowly and carefully, just as you suggest here, but they were well-enough hidden that characters moving quickly for any reason could and probably would blunder right into them.
@DocFleg
@DocFleg Жыл бұрын
Good point! Really great reminder as to why movement rates actually mean something.
@HeadHunterSix
@HeadHunterSix 6 ай бұрын
I agree that rushing headlong should be its own risk, and even that is an informed choice on the part of the players - so the consequences are commensurate with their choices. Aside from a warning that moving hastily might make them miss secret doors, traps etc., there's nothing else the GM has to advise. Let them lie in the bed of spikes they made.
@majorfallacy5926
@majorfallacy5926 3 жыл бұрын
My favourite way of doing concealed traps: the click rule. It's super simple and goes like this: "As you march down the hallway, you hear a faint 'click' from under your boots. What do you do?". No save or damage yet, and all the tension of standing on a live landmine. You can mix it up with traps that don't give you time to strategize around but still have a click, giving players a single action before shit hits the fan. That way they still have agency, but it's not a puzzle-like obstacle. What's important is that they're thinking about what they could have done to avoid it entirely.
@aliwahay
@aliwahay 3 жыл бұрын
love this!
@davewilson13
@davewilson13 3 жыл бұрын
Click is great, been using it 3 months and it’s great
@BigCowProductions
@BigCowProductions 2 жыл бұрын
I heard about this from Dael Kingsmill, who got it from someone else haha. But yeah I love the idea!
@thescoon1
@thescoon1 2 жыл бұрын
Yeah, this is actually sick advice! The tension is there, and the coolest thing about this as well, is your players will immediately ask for details in the room that would normally be just simple flavour. They step on a pressure plate and hear a click, so they ask 'Okay, do I notice any holes in the wall, or other markings on the floor? And you can describe that in more gritty detail, giving your players tension, but also immersion. 100/10 great advice.
@HenshinFanatic
@HenshinFanatic 2 жыл бұрын
Love this, mix in at a roughly 11 : 1 : 8 ratio with obvious hazards:standard traps:time-delayed traps with obvious signal on preparing to activate.
@Bluecho4
@Bluecho4 3 жыл бұрын
A few points. First, a while back, I watched a VOD of a group running through the Tomb of Horrors. And the DM in that game made use of a kind of two-choice method for how the players check for traps. They can either 1) roll 1d6 to detect (and be at the mercy of the die), or 2) describe how they're searching, and if their method seems logical they just _automatically_ find the trap. The former leaves it up to random chance to get through, the other to the players thinking strategically. I think you could easily apply this kind of thing to multiple aspects of traps. Detecting them, disarming them, etc. Either you use the base mechanics as normal - leave it up to the die roll to decide their fate - or the players take fate into their own hands by describing exactly what they're doing. Second, I think signposting that a trap is there can work, and indeed its importance is proportional to how deadly the trap is. If it's something that could instantly kill a PC, it should be properly foreshadowed. This serves a double purpose. One, it seems less unfair if the PC bites it, since they knew ahead of time. Two, it builds _tension._ Many people are familiar with the Alfred Hitchcock story about the bomb under the table. How it's boredom followed by shock if you didn't show the bomb under the table, and it's tension and resolution if the audience is aware of it. This can and should apply to DnD traps, where half the engagement for the players comes from the tension of interacting with a trap and trying not to set it off. Third, the Angry GM came up with an idea I always found fascinating: the "Click Rule". That is, when a trap is set off, the trigger goes off in a way that is audible or what have you (the tension and release of a tripwire, the click of a pressure plate, the grinding of gears, the flicker of fire in a flame sprayer's nozzle, etc). The moment that happens, the GM asks the player what their split-second reaction is. Depending on the answer, the resulting saving throw or attack roll (depending on the trap) may have Advantage or Disadvantage. Or even negate the hazardous effects entirely. The player might not have had a say in springing the trap, but they can have agency over their immediate reaction to it. It's also a good reason why giving clues as to the trap's nature is so important, so they have an idea about how to defend against it.
@strawberrylotlizard
@strawberrylotlizard 3 жыл бұрын
Very good thank you
@mandodelorian4668
@mandodelorian4668 3 жыл бұрын
I like this, there're players who love to RP and problem solve at the table, and those who really don't want to and feel like they should just be able to roll the dice for their character's skill to handle the problem. While the RP aspect is more immersive, it means that if a player who is not real detail-oriented or outgoing wants to play a character who is, they're going to have a bad time. Going with the "either/or" method allows for both kinds of player-character interaction at the table. Groovy 👍
@arnman2093
@arnman2093 3 жыл бұрын
Do both ways at once. A good description of the search process yields a bonus to the detection role. They role so they know if they fail.
@isaacmartinez2359
@isaacmartinez2359 3 жыл бұрын
This advice was so great, literally all I did was place a huge hole in front of my players in a narrow hallways and they seemed to be having much more fun doing that then all the traps I ever had with comparatively useless skill checks.
@Alberaan
@Alberaan 3 жыл бұрын
I think this has completely changed my mind on traps. Also, I have been playing Dungeon World, which has a particular take on traps which I didn't completely grasp. I think the way you explained it applies completely to Dungeon World, so thanks a lot!
@JohnCarr
@JohnCarr 3 жыл бұрын
I was thinking the same thing as I was watching this - old school complex traps are much more in line with Trap Expert and how it would manifest in the fiction than the 3E-plus traps that have been more the norm for the last 20 years.
@misomiso8228
@misomiso8228 3 жыл бұрын
This has a cool background / camera set up. I particularly like the map of Sigil...!
@QuestingBeast
@QuestingBeast 3 жыл бұрын
Thanks!
@bodywhey8
@bodywhey8 3 жыл бұрын
I just commented the same thing basically. I agree completely. 👍🏻👍🏻
@QuestFriend
@QuestFriend 3 жыл бұрын
Your book Labyrinth is a perfect example of this subject. Almost every encounter is clearly presented and my kids love problem solving a way out without rolling any dice.
@benvoliothefirst
@benvoliothefirst 3 жыл бұрын
Agreed! The Labyrinth game is a master class in non-combat-oriented role-playing. Great for kids and adults too!
@IVIaskerade
@IVIaskerade 3 жыл бұрын
A good D&D trap should threaten a high-level PC, but can be solved by a first level one.
@zubbworks
@zubbworks 3 жыл бұрын
Instakill landmines. Walking along, then boom, no more adventurer.
@benvoliothefirst
@benvoliothefirst 3 жыл бұрын
@@zubbworks I'm not sure you're following the spirit of the original poster, there...
@zubbworks
@zubbworks 3 жыл бұрын
@@benvoliothefirst With a spot check of like 12 or something.
@Battleguild
@Battleguild 3 жыл бұрын
@Reggie Jackman Not really. A simple achievable landmine in dnd would be creating a thin clay vessel, and placing a alchemist fire inside, then lightly bury it. While it wouldn't "boom" like a traditional landmine, but a pc's leg would burst into flames and they'd need to put it out. "Machine guns" exist in D&D in the form of Repeater Crossbows. They have a mounted case, usually 6 bolts, and can fire a bolt for each attack made with it, needing to reload when the case is empty.
@Battleguild
@Battleguild 3 жыл бұрын
@Reggie Jackman I mean, no one can force you to like D&D, and if it was one of the worst designed systems, it would've disappeared into the abyss like countless other rpgs. 5E is D&D's most successful iteration of the game, so it must be doing something right.
@WestfaliaStuff
@WestfaliaStuff 3 жыл бұрын
Yes, this is excellent, you're really spelling out a lot of my more unformed thoughts on the matter. Well done.
@sebastiang7528
@sebastiang7528 3 жыл бұрын
Great stuff! I’ve always loved the idea of traps in RPGs, but I’ve never managed to pull them of very well. I’ve only really added one trap that the players had fun with and that was a classic swinging blades trap that I just threw in there in improvised fashion, because I realized that the hallway they where going down was to empty. I didn’t plan any skill checks or anything for the trap, and the trap was obvious. I described how there where giant blades swinging from one side to the other. I thought it was going to be to simple and boring for them but they had a lot of fun looking at their inventories and their spells. Eventually they decided that they wanted to try to freeze the blades with their mage’s once per day ability “Frost nova”. So I allowed it, because it was fun, and they felt really satisfied with it. After watching this video I understand why it was fun, and why that improv trap was actually pretty good. Keep up the good work!
@duskworkerdron5901
@duskworkerdron5901 2 жыл бұрын
I had a trap in a cave that was basically just a pit leading to an underground lake. The players could see treasure glittering below the water, but the issue was the water itself would try to grab and drown anyone who touched it. They rigged a net from an extra chainmail shirt they had, tied a rope around one of the player characters, and tossed him into the lake with the mail net to fish out as much treasure as they could. The water would toss him around, but the rest of the PCs just pulled him out if he failed his roll to hold his breath. It was a lot of fun.
@Sonicracer100
@Sonicracer100 3 жыл бұрын
Nah I'll stick to my pit in front of treasure, thanks. Can't beat that!
@dougsundseth6904
@dougsundseth6904 3 жыл бұрын
I largely agree with your take on traps. If you have hidden traps that the players are likely to miss with their usual tactics (passive PER or Take 10 by the best character, for instance), the party will be harmed essentially at random. The only way to stop this random damage is to take more time and search more thoroughly. How much time would you like to spend (either at the gaming table or in world), while the players search every square before entering it. (That's what any sane character would do in that situation unless there were a _very_ strong reason not to. Hidden traps are boring: "Jason Bourne steps into the room, but unfortunately doesn't spot the laser trigger that runs close to the ground. The Claymore mine goes off and turns him into people puree." There's a reason you don't see this* in movies. What you see instead is the interaction of the character with the nefarious creation of the villain. I would modify things just a bit, though. I would set the detection threshold below that of the perception of the best character, so that when circumspectly exploring, the party will virtually always find the trap. But if they get lazy (or start frantically running for some reason, or the character with the best perception is incapacitated), they can still get hit. This gives an advantage to the character who cared enough to boost that skill. Similarly, I would require a roll for at least some of the challenges in the trap, some routine, but some quite difficult: "OK, so you're going to jam the rotating mechanism of the balance beam with a piton.... When you step onto the balance beam, I need Joe to roll his Disarm Trap skill to see how well jamming the beam actually worked.... OK, the beam turns slightly and you hear a grinding sound, it doesn't turn enough to spill Ferdinand the Black, but you see sparks start to fall toward the pool of naphtha." This is similar to what happened to Indy in the first scene in Raiders of the Lost Ark, where he knew how to disarm the trap ... in theory. ("The difference between theory and practice is that in theory there's no difference between theory and practice.") * There's an exception for establishing scenes, but those are about establishing the threat, not playing out the story.
@MonkeyJedi99
@MonkeyJedi99 3 жыл бұрын
I recall one scene in a Bourne movie where he did miss a laser tripwire that set off a silent alarm, telling enemy forces he had entered the room/house/whatever it was in that scene. So it was like a D&D trap ringing the alarm bell.
@davidpeters6743
@davidpeters6743 2 жыл бұрын
Or the party can use better tactics.
@demonzabrak
@demonzabrak Жыл бұрын
Do you remember “Taking 20”? Pepperidge Farm remembers. But yeah, taking 20 is how you can check for traps without taking ages making rolls and decisions at the table. It’s not a thing in 5e I think, so I’ll explain it even though it feels very obvious to me. Ignore that bit if you know. It’s like taking 10, but takes 2 minutes instead of 6 seconds. It represents taking time to meticulously and slowly perform the skill check. It requires you to effectively roll a 1, 2, 3… until roll 20 after 20 rounds (2 minutes) of effort. Taking 10 on the other hand is a single round. You just try for average and wind up a half point under. It requires no rolls, and the same amount of time to walk down the hall from a play time perspective. “I walk down the hall, taking 20. I find DC (whatever) traps automatically.” Ta-da. That’s all it took. It’s also why older editions had four types of “turn timers.” 6 second rounds for combat, but also 10 minute rounds for local/dungeon area exploration, hourly for overland exploration, and daily for downtime and the like. You can pick 5 squares to take 20 on per exploration round. Ten minutes deducted from your hour(s) long spells, pick another 5. Repeat until combat. Role play when appropriate. That was the gameplay loop. It took essentially no time, because it is just how searching used to work. You decided fast or slow, and use either 10 or 20.
@dougsundseth6904
@dougsundseth6904 Жыл бұрын
@@demonzabrak Somebody said, "How much time would you like to spend (either at the gaming table _or in world_)...". Perhaps somebody was thinking of taking 20. So let's examine the process from the in-universe viewpoint: 10' wide hallway that is 100' long with two rooms, each 30' square that need to be searched. Depending on how the GM works, you might also have to search either the walls and ceilings or the upper 5' cubes, since only an idiot would put all the traps at ground level. For this examination, we'll take the more charitable assumption and use the upper cubes, since it's faster. That ends up with 224 5' cubes, which will take 448 minutes to search, or just a bit under eight hours to travel 100' and search two rooms. Perhaps that makes sense in the worlds you play in or run; it makes no sense in mine. Everything in the "dungeon" would attack during that time, either in waves or as a single massed assault. And without that, two rooms per game day is boring and unbalancing, even if you subscribe to the 4-encounter model. (FWIW, I have run as many as 17 encounters in a single game day in a dungeon, because that makes sense to me. YMMV.) "Traps everywhere" is boring, especially if you're not the thief. As for "older systems", let's just say that I first played D&D more than 45 years ago. I was old-school when it was just "school". I graduated.
@bioblade
@bioblade 3 жыл бұрын
The best video on traps I have seen so far thank you
@patrickrobles1036
@patrickrobles1036 3 жыл бұрын
An additional problem to DM's that think they need to solve their own traps: they tend to think there is only one solution. That is a puzzle. Also, I disagree with the detection aspect as I think it can make certain players feel that their characters are relevant beyond combat. If the player likes to roll I'll have them roll, and I'll alter the description to suit. "Something's got you on edge," "you smell machine oil," "you wonder why your footsteps sound differently" they will almost always immediately take the cue and start role-playing, even if that isn't their strong suit. At that point they have to start giving me descriptions of hwo they're going to test the environment just to find it. Once that occurs it runs much like you say, although I still often have them roll to see the degree of success. Especially when it involves things like throwing corpses onto pressure plates and the like. There is a high degree of player involvement, and then a roll, which is how I think it should be. Isolated rolls that trigger a success are boring.
@benvoliothefirst
@benvoliothefirst 3 жыл бұрын
I can't tell you how freeing this was. I've always thought I had to anticipate every possible move my players might make as well as the branching paths that each might lead to. This is going to make DMing so much more fun for me!
@semaj262
@semaj262 3 жыл бұрын
I'm a big fan of giant pit as a low level trap! I absolutely love the traps as hazards technique, and use character choices as what their specific options are. Barbarians get that suspicious tingle, but share heaving a stone door open with fighters. Wizards puzzle out arcane wards with Rogues who get mechanisms and delicate work, and Druids notice the signs of animals or the dissonance of monsters. Player choice is key to engagement, and I find that counts charcter generation choices too! Everybody gets to show off, across the dungeon. I've had some excellent experience running traps like Portal levels, teaching a trap and solution before complicating it, and completely separately as the much maligned quantum ogre. I describe a bunch of features in an empty room, and when players notice or try things, I roll a d4 and let the result tell me which tactic they use works, the first the third whatever. I sometimes use escalating traps! I use initiative order if the game has it, and start things off with a big obvious TRAP BEGINS moment, in the style of an Indiana Jones blade hallway or snake pit, amping up the stakes each cycle.
@BobWorldBuilder
@BobWorldBuilder 3 жыл бұрын
I really like how you explained the process and benefits of making traps obvious and more like a hazard. I've almost always do that, but never really thought about why I do it! Great video, Ben :)
@meatKog
@meatKog 2 жыл бұрын
Or investigation (based on clues), like a blood trail moves into the entrance of the cave but hen stops suddenly in a clean line. What do you do? "I would like to Investigate."
@ross.metcalf
@ross.metcalf 2 жыл бұрын
I definitely agree that having obvious hazards is better than a ton of traps. Not only can hidden traps be unfun to traverse, it can also slow the game down to a crawl with the PCs checking every inch as they go. You don't have to come up with a solution to bypass the traps IF there aren't any NPCs that regularly bypass the traps. However, if- for example- the traps are protecting the big bad's treasure room, and the players know that the big bad regularly goes to their treasure room to store or retrieve treasure, then its good to have a solution for how your NPC bypasses the trap. If the NPC designed and/or built the trap, they probably have a secret way to get past it; its unlikely they'd risk their life every time they want to get past the trap.
@HeadHunterSix
@HeadHunterSix 6 ай бұрын
I love the move that the OSR paradigm has made toward increased player agency. The mindset that I see in the games you mention, as well as the 24XX line and Zotiquest games is refreshing: Advise the players of hazards, their risks and consequences... and then let them make informed decisions as to how they intend to approach and resolve the situation. In the worst case, they fail at their attempt (and this goes for anything, not just traps) but there's still involvement and agency and even failure can be interesting, exciting, or entertaining. Nobody loves to be a blind victim of _anything_ in RPGs.
@danroscigno187
@danroscigno187 2 жыл бұрын
Great advice. As a player, I don't enjoy rolling dice, I like to co-create the story. I was the thief on our last campaign, so I was disarming several traps. The DM did a great job of describing the traps (he generally skipped detection in the manner you describe). We had fun role playing the disarmament as a group.
@AdorkableDaughterofNyx
@AdorkableDaughterofNyx 2 жыл бұрын
considering thieves tools and dexterity checks to disarm traps are commonly a core and defining feature of the rogue that can apparently be passed around like candy via backgrounds. i'd remove the thieves tools from every background and make them rogue exclusive.
@frankb3347
@frankb3347 2 жыл бұрын
When thinking about how to portray traps in an action packed way I'd look to the Indiana Jones trilogy for inspiration.
@varenoftatooine2393
@varenoftatooine2393 14 күн бұрын
One idea is to show the trap but hide the trigger. Make it so that it's obvious to anyone being careful that danger is present, but maybe the trigger could require more investigation to discover.
@zavierlee695
@zavierlee695 2 жыл бұрын
You should check out Torchbearer, it's a system that really nails a gritty dungeon-crawling vibe. Keeps some life in parts of the dungeon that become stale quickly.
@PBaloo01
@PBaloo01 3 жыл бұрын
Found your channel a few days ago, and just wanted to say I love your content. I never got to play back in the day, but I enjoy reading through older edition's adventures! And while I love the modern sensibilities/style of play of 5e, I'm constantly finding ways to improve elements of the game (like dungeon crawling) with elements and perspectives from those times - Which is why I find your videos so helpful! So thanks!
@bizzy5439
@bizzy5439 3 жыл бұрын
This is great stuff! It mirrors a lot of the trap designing process I've been writing up for myself since I've always hated how traditional traps work. This method works perfectly with the aspects of roleplaying games and is, as far as I've been able to tell by playing, the best method!
@ReignOfHazards
@ReignOfHazards 3 жыл бұрын
Great video! You framed in the issue that I have with modern trap mechanics in dungeons and dragons 5E. I often make the passive perception DC to notice a trap extremely high, but if they verbalized that they are actively checking for traps, I make them very obvious. To me that’s just a matter of getting them engaged in the moment and not just running on auto pilot. I also completely agree with the notion that you should design a trap without a solution in mind. Often, if you’re thinking about how to solve it, you’re forcing the players to think exactly the way you do. It’s much more engaging and fun for them to be completely creative on their own and come up with solutions you hadn’t even considered.
@Ryomaslade45
@Ryomaslade45 3 жыл бұрын
Been trying to work out how I wanted to run traps in my Superhero game, this really helped. Allows for way more creativity
@roberticvs
@roberticvs 3 жыл бұрын
Really good essay on traps. You've changed my mind about this topic. -- Kudos for the Time Bandits map. Make sure Supreme Being gets it back.
@wardkerr2456
@wardkerr2456 11 ай бұрын
I agree. Traps are best played as puzzles. You have, by the way, made an excellent argument for diceless role playing.
@morrigansbestcrow
@morrigansbestcrow 2 жыл бұрын
I'm a big fan of well hidden mimics next to obvious mimics and a wall of fire being put out by pipes while there is also in a illusion fire going on in the exact same place so the players get real confused when their shit "doesn't work" despite there being no more heat
@trevynlane8094
@trevynlane8094 2 жыл бұрын
I like mixing visible traps with discharged and hidden traps a lot. Visible traps are a warning sign, and are meant to be seen. Discharged traps are traps that someone else has triggered or disarmed, and make for good flavor text. Hidden traps are a hazard and do give XP when disarmed or triggered.
@demonzabrak
@demonzabrak Жыл бұрын
Serious question: why XP for being discharged? It feels like giving XP for getting attacked by a monster and immediately running away.
@trevynlane8094
@trevynlane8094 Жыл бұрын
@@demonzabrak I give xp if the party triggers or disables the trap, not for already discharged traps. Traps are one shot hazards, and are usually dealt with when encountered, and discharged traps that the party finds are set dressing, like cobwebs and dirt in the dungeon. Sorry if I wasn't more clear.
@mingramh
@mingramh 2 жыл бұрын
Brilliant advice, thanks. I would just add that I like players to learn when to look for traps. There are times and conditions when they should expect them. Second note. I like to add a non-obvious solution in a previous room to take get them to think. One of the 1st edition modules in the A series had a sticky creature. In a previous room there was a barrel of alcohol that would neutralize the effects.
@irishthump73
@irishthump73 3 жыл бұрын
Great video! I've been struggling with coming up with new ideas for traps. Love the map from Time Bandits in the backround!
@aaronsomerville2124
@aaronsomerville2124 3 жыл бұрын
I partially disagree. I think that "detection" is important. If it's totally obvious, then it isn't a "trap". The essence of a trap is to take someone unawares. The key is that interaction with the trap is the result of a player choice. Why go down this hallway, when there are no tracks in the dust? Or the faint sound of hidden machinery? That being said, I prefer not to rely on rolls for searching / disarming; I would rather solve it through description and choices.
@aaronsomerville2124
@aaronsomerville2124 3 жыл бұрын
@@richmcgee434 I think you have to use common sense, and the content of your site should match the concept. Are you saying that a dungeon cannot have a room or corridor that the inhabitants know to avoid? This whole point sounds like wanting to dogmatically limit design choices because of preferences expressed in the latest hipster rule book. Do whatever you want, obviously, but the hidden trap is a trope for a reason, regardless of whether Ben finds it fun.
@torenatkinson1986
@torenatkinson1986 2 жыл бұрын
@aaron Yes, you are right. It isnt a trap, it's a hazard. Hazards are good, traps are bad. That's my takeaway from this video
@0ptikGhost
@0ptikGhost 2 жыл бұрын
I don't think hazards are good and traps are bad. I think the problem is that rolls should never be passive. All rolls should occur as a result of player action. This means it is bad DMing to present a trap without clues to its existence. A hazard is a trap that is presented as obvious. Players need reasons to take action and that only happens because the DM told them there were actions that could be taken. Some players will not enjoy needing to pay tons of attention, especially today when the average person has an attention span measured in seconds. In any case, odds of detection should depend on how obvious the trap is (hazards are 100% obvious while death traps are perhaps only 1-5% obvious and other traps somewhere in between) and what players choose to do to find them (class and circumstance could play a factor here in addition to specific actions as some archetypes will have an easier time than others at detection even if the same approach is used). For disarming, again rolls should occur as a result of player action. When a player declares they want to try to disable a trap the DM should ask how they want to do that. The player can only answer that question if the DM has already provided clues to options through description. Lack of such description indicates a bad DM. Again, circumstances, tools, player action, etc., should determine odds of success in combination with the complexity of a trap. A very complicated trap may even require multiple rolls to disarm/disable different aspects of a trap (I think of it like doing damage to a trap and the trap is no longer dangerous after it has accumulated enough "damage"). Perhaps different pieces of the trap have different difficulties and playera could choose to start by dealing with the more difficult and dangerous portion or with the least dangerous part. Give players enough information to make choices. Finally, for damage players should once again be involved via action. A good DM will have, once again, provided clues on possible strategies to avoid or minimize the bad stuff. The action attempted by the player will suggest what rolls and modifications to apply in an avoidance roll. Depending on the trap a player could avoid the trap entirely, swinging blade, or the character(s) will always receive at least partial damage, gas chamber. Perhaps a trap can be intentionally set off to make it inert and safe without any damage to characters. The key is to engage in dialog with players providing as much information as possible and reasonable so players can make choices and take action along the way. I mean, if we run combats the same way people seem to run traps, then combat would be just as boring and not engaging. Player A swings, roll dice, success, roll damage. Player B swings, roll dice, failure. Player C swings, roll dice, ... you get the point.
@0ptikGhost
@0ptikGhost 2 жыл бұрын
This video does have a lot of good advice on how to run better traps by turning them into hazards but the techniques should be used for all trap types to different degrees. This is a great video!
@Leviathan_XO
@Leviathan_XO 3 жыл бұрын
Dude you have been on a roll lately, awesome work
@dukejaywalker5858
@dukejaywalker5858 3 жыл бұрын
great advice! Another idea to solve the "detection" problem is to make sure there are signs of previous victims. i.e. smeared bloodstains, severed limbs, crushed piles of bones, etc... that tip players off.
@verlandes1
@verlandes1 7 ай бұрын
Sidenote, there is an analogy here for lovecraftian or mystery ttrpgs - instead of having players roll to find clues, hand the clues to the players directly and let the challenge be to discern information from the clue.
@jimeronimo
@jimeronimo 3 жыл бұрын
Great advice my friend. Love your philosophy on this.. points well taken.
@kimforsell8122
@kimforsell8122 3 жыл бұрын
Excellent Ben! You just solved a problem I have been nurturing a couple of months now - thanks!😊
2 жыл бұрын
There is a fourth D: "Death" Traps are designed to kill. That's also the D that makes traps not boring...
@paulgalvinauthor
@paulgalvinauthor 3 жыл бұрын
I think this is spot on. Especiall the part of basically, setting up a scenario without an predefined notion on how the players are going to solve it. Just create an envirnoment, be ready to improvise as they investigate the situation and come up with their own suggestions, etc. It's a ton of fun and as you say, players frequently come up with really crazy cool ideas you never would have thought of.
@grumpygrognard7292
@grumpygrognard7292 3 жыл бұрын
Enjoyed your commentary. I prefer using traps that cause obstacles, delay, diversions, or even separating members of the party rather than simply causing damage. I think most mechanical traps should also have bypass mechanisms that characters could find. Sort of like finding secret door mechanisms.
@jameshwren
@jameshwren Жыл бұрын
Some of my favorite traps are super simple and are super effective in Roll20: - create a complex map of a dungeon, often a sewer, a cave system, or just a maze, it works best if it has multiple levels - create multiple versions of each floor but rotate your map 90 degrees or reverse it, when you design the exit keep this in mind which direction you want to rotate it - when you players go from one map to the next you drag their tokens to that map, and when you drag them back, you drag them onto a different map, this is done if they weren't marking their path along the way. - Quickly they will find themselves doubling back, and each time you can rotate them to a different map - I have one severe system that has about 9 maps that only represent about 3 levels of the sewer but it does a great job of giving the sense that they are lost. - This trick also works great with forests, bogs, or any nature where a predator might lure them off the road into the woods only for the players to realize they are quickly running out of daylight and can't find the road again.
@Dalboni
@Dalboni 2 жыл бұрын
Awesome. Thanks!
@razorchuckles
@razorchuckles 10 ай бұрын
This is one of your best videos ever - gave me a lot to think about when designing my next dungeon!
@nicklarocco4178
@nicklarocco4178 3 жыл бұрын
I think all traps should be accompanied by monsters, so the players can't just take forever to solve it. I ran a trapped room with a pillar in the center that began to fill the room with water, and also deposited snakes into the room. So the party had to deal with snakes while trying to close the trap that was filling the room with water.
@jamesjenningsix
@jamesjenningsix 3 жыл бұрын
Excellent video. Gave me a new perspective on trap game mechanics.
@deanlol
@deanlol 3 жыл бұрын
This is brilliant! It turns traps into puzzles!
@aaronkroeger3380
@aaronkroeger3380 2 жыл бұрын
These tips are great. Immersive sessions can be harder to prep but it's worth it
@samchafin4623
@samchafin4623 3 жыл бұрын
Excellent advice! Thank you, sir for your knowledge and insights. Also, I finally broke down and signed up for your newsletter after I caught a glimpse of the conceptual magic blog articles you recommended.
@respawn4925
@respawn4925 Жыл бұрын
This is so simple, yet so elegant and clever :D Very good!
@bodywhey8
@bodywhey8 3 жыл бұрын
Ben, I’m loving your recording space. The background of your video is inspiring, to match your videos. Great channel, man. Great channel.
@QuestingBeast
@QuestingBeast 3 жыл бұрын
Thanks! It's mostly due to patrons that I could buy all that art.
@richtigmann1
@richtigmann1 3 жыл бұрын
This is a simple step but it makes so much sense and there are examples too! very good guide
@malkaviangrin9440
@malkaviangrin9440 11 ай бұрын
This is SUUUUUCH good advice!!!! I really love the idea of letting the players out-think you *on purpose*. You'll make them feel clever and draw them further into the fiction. I'm going to use these ideas, thanks Ben!
@davewilson13
@davewilson13 3 жыл бұрын
Wow I love this. I love puzzled and PCs often don’t love them, they feel contrived. This makes puzzles fun for them too.
@hungryLIKEALI0N
@hungryLIKEALI0N 2 жыл бұрын
I like this concept a lot and will definitely try employing it next time I create a trapped dungeon.
@KodeeDentares
@KodeeDentares 3 жыл бұрын
Pit trap? Oh! The dungeon owner left a ladder on the other side, just there! Maybe you could use mage hand to bring it over?
@toddpickens
@toddpickens 3 жыл бұрын
Really interesting approach. I will give this a try.
@maciejmazur2622
@maciejmazur2622 3 жыл бұрын
How could you not mention "Grimtooth's Traps" - craziest and most original traps i ever seen, and if you loved the thing with the fumes and the spark beam youll love some of the stuff the sadistic ogre comes up with :D
@HeadHunterSix
@HeadHunterSix 6 ай бұрын
The problem is, a lot of those traps are things that players couldn't reasonably detect, even if they were looking. Admittedly, it's been a very long time since I read them, but I recall the room full of methane ("odorless, colorless... the only way to detect it is to breathe it, and that's what kills you") or the crossbow in the privy. Unless the mindset changed in later volumes, Grimtooth's Traps tended to be things the party either couldn't detect or couldn't prevent even if they did. That basically goes against the mindset of player agency and informed choice.
@adrianscholl
@adrianscholl 3 жыл бұрын
Love all your videos so much! Your library in the background got me curiously trying to read all the titles. I know it would be quite different from your normal video, but it would be really awesome to get a library tour one of these days!
@christopherlee622
@christopherlee622 2 жыл бұрын
Good vid. Very helpful and inspiring
@TheDungeonMinister
@TheDungeonMinister 2 жыл бұрын
Excellent stuff!
@TheDungeonDive
@TheDungeonDive Жыл бұрын
My favorite kinds of traps for solo games are just quick little things that add a bit of spice to an encounter, usually something random just drawn from a deck or rolled up on a table. For me, traps are more about the story points they create than anything else.
@jacobgordillo2100
@jacobgordillo2100 2 жыл бұрын
Nice. I'm going to use a modified version of the flammable gas pit trap in an adventure I'll run this week and next week. Really great idea.
@cazmarius3442
@cazmarius3442 Жыл бұрын
I love to reduce the need for the detection step by narratively making the party a latecomer to the area. Adventurers before them died in the trap, so physical evidence of their perishing leave clues as to the hazard. Scorched outlines on a wall, bones on the floor with injuries consistent to the trap, and the like.
@nehukybis
@nehukybis 3 жыл бұрын
The detection part can be fun too, as long as it isn't arbitrary. As long as the traps make sense, you're rewarding intelligent play. Mechanical traps have to be maintained or they'll stop functioning after a few years. Unintelligent or disorganized monsters won't bother to maintain traps and organized, intelligent monsters won't put them in halls or rooms that are constantly in use. So your more complicated traps will only be found in key places, like the hallway that leads to the treasure hoard. Traps that are harmless because of rust or accumulated dirt or because someone else triggered them and they were never reset... these all add atmosphere and warn the players to stay on their toes. Another interesting feature is the >unintentional> trap. Old bridges collapse, ceilings fall. Flooded sections can be extremely dangerous if the PCs can't breathe water, especially if it has a strong current.
@Coyote-oy1oo
@Coyote-oy1oo 3 жыл бұрын
this is amazing, thank you. I always avoided traps, found it only worked in heroquest with those hidden things
@LaplaceDaemon
@LaplaceDaemon Жыл бұрын
Dungeon interior designers must be the most gifted salespeople in the realm. They routinely get evil wizards to spend exorbitant amounts of money on bottomless pits, crazy death machines (that need maintenance) and collections of venomous animals (that have to be fed and cared for), when just a wall with a really sturdy door and a DIY magical ward would do the trick.
@Vlakrov
@Vlakrov 2 жыл бұрын
Finally someone who said this things, thank you, amazing video. The only real trap I ever made was: in this dungeon at the enter you find a very visible string of steel going wall to wall, with holes in the wall( so you just don't have to touch it). The n, later in the dungeon you find another one, and here also you don't have to do nothing in particular. Finally before the last room of the floor you find another one, but this is different, in fact right before and after it there is ashes of something. Here the player migth say " nothing, just like the others" and go forward, but if they do this after the string there was a pressure plate that the ashes hides and so they will explode and take serious damage. Instead of they think of why there are this ashes and why here and they say they want to see the floor or even not but they just think about one solution, I will reveal the pressure plate that before they don't notice because of the ash. Obviously don't step in the string or the pressure plate doesn't need a check.
@HundredthDemon
@HundredthDemon 3 жыл бұрын
Hey, greetings from Ukraine! Haven't seen this backdrop before, this den looks awesome! :)
@kyrnsword72
@kyrnsword72 Жыл бұрын
Traps are handled real good in a game system I love called D100 Dungeon. Most game rules and the charecter sheet in D100 Dungeon are real awesome.
@bored_pyro
@bored_pyro 3 жыл бұрын
First time seeing your channel in my feed and loved your video; hitting lots of notes I think about when running my games too. Traps as a HP tax are just awful. I also enjoy running traps whose outcome is putting the party in a more dire situation (a trap that alerts the enemy of your arrival instead of just doing 1d10 bludgeoning damage). At any rate, you've got my sub! Well done.
@calebsyswerda
@calebsyswerda 3 жыл бұрын
Every time I click on one of your videos, I find a gem that I end up saving for future reference. Excellent material.
@murgel2006
@murgel2006 Жыл бұрын
Well, your description of how "it is currently done" was a revelation for me, again! I constantly ask myself, do people really play that way? And the answer is YES! They are using an RPG to emulate their computer games.
@minnion2871
@minnion2871 10 ай бұрын
Some trap Ideas that I've thoght would be fun.... The bulging door: You've seen this "trap" in cartoons before I'm sure, where an overstuffed closet spills its contents onto anyone unlucky enough to open it.... Same thing really.... You open a door and an avalanche of stuff falls out. Maybe dead bodies, maybe treasure, maybe a bunch of junk or dirt from a cavein, or perhaps a mix of all of the above.. Slides: Well the "Trap" part is what is at the bottom.... Maybe a Gelatinous cube, maybe a pile of garbage in a trash compactor, maybe a rope waiting for the Kobold who built it to swing across to safety while anyone following them down the slide goes off into the pit because the Kobold took the only rope with which to swing across said pit because they went down first... Or maybe there is a spiked door at the bottom the Kobold shut and barred to injure and slow down anyone chasing them... Another good one for Kobolds: Stuff hanging from the ceiling all the way down the hall.... Just string curtains made of Caltrops and fishhooks, soaked in oil and hanging three and a half feet above the ground. Those standing in it have a hard time seeing what is right in front of them.... And at any time the Kobolds can just set the whole thing on fire causing it to eventually drop down to cover the floor in flaming fish hooks and caltrops.... Even without the fish hooks to snag any medium creatures not crawling down that hall, just oil soaked strings could be a hinderance to vision too... and again the threat of flaming string falling down on top of you would still probably be enough to make for some interesting encounters... Though Hanging corpses close enough together to obscure the players vision could be good too.... (As well as a fun hiding place for monsters to drop down from should the players be crawling under them)
@PossumMedic
@PossumMedic Жыл бұрын
Great episode! 😃 I've watched it a few times now! Pretty much every time old modules mention annoying traps 😆 Also cool to see a copy of the old Into the Odd rules! I don't know if I'll ever find one but I'd love to get a copy someday! 🥰
@MatthewsWd0
@MatthewsWd0 3 жыл бұрын
Nice Video! My favorite trap so far has been a corridor full of four sets of dormant animated armor with a mechanical mouse and a bell. When the players enter the room, if they walk down the hallway they each make charisma saves to show no trepidation in the silent gaze of the animated armor. If they fail, the armor awakens tries to grapple the players and, initiative is rolled. Then a "combat" occurs where the armor tries to restrain the players while the mechanical mouse moves down the hallway to ring the bell. The mouse is invincible, but every time it is hit with a ranged attack it falls prone due to malfunction and must use its movement to stand up next turn. If the mouse makes it to the end of the hallway, it rings the bell, guards are summoned, and the armor begins to attack the player instead of grappling or restraining them.
@AlexGidra
@AlexGidra 3 жыл бұрын
Thank you for important video. It not so much as OSR style but pretty much modern style where is If DM knows all answers she/he should be writer. You clearly demonstrated how problem solving style of DM’ing brings more fun to game.
@TheGiantRobot
@TheGiantRobot 3 жыл бұрын
Great ideas!
@archersfriend5900
@archersfriend5900 Жыл бұрын
As a dm I absolutely love traps. They are fun and make the players think. Some are devious some are dangerous. Traps are fun. I like them as a player. Please don't take all the cool stuff.
@charleshalcomb7431
@charleshalcomb7431 Жыл бұрын
Idea: a room which is obviously a falling roof trap. Inside are two ropes - one blue, one red. One lifts a cage, granting access to the treasure chest. One drops the ceiling. Do you snip the red wire, or the blue wire?
@Keaggan
@Keaggan 2 жыл бұрын
The way I've done hidden traps is if they do step on a pressure plate it's very minor and then the rest of the trap is seen to be far more dangerous. So that initial scare is there but it's not punishing. Now the hazard is in place and I follow very similar what you described in the video.
@NoLoveSouth1st
@NoLoveSouth1st 2 жыл бұрын
Amazing job! I will definitely use a lot of these tips in my next session in a kobold temple :)
@thefallenmonk605
@thefallenmonk605 2 жыл бұрын
Favorite trap/hazard for beginners. 10x10 hole in a hall way with a rope swing. Tease them with swinging across and just a day of damage on a fail.
@cobracous2656
@cobracous2656 3 жыл бұрын
I like the idea of obstacles. I'm definitely going to add those to future dungeons. However, I don't use passive perception on traps. Passive perception is for detecting stealth or something visible, but not obvious. But I do love the obvious obstacles that players need to solve!
@StefanHayden
@StefanHayden 3 жыл бұрын
great advice!
@1420ify
@1420ify 2 жыл бұрын
Traps always need some sort of combat!
@a.spirit8408
@a.spirit8408 3 жыл бұрын
Xanathar's Guide has a great section on Complex Traps (pg 118) that are the kind of traps (environmental challenges) mentioned in this video.
@paulcoy9060
@paulcoy9060 Жыл бұрын
4:30 Remember in Knights of the Dinner Table, when Bob the Thief wasn't able to play for some time, and the rest of them are trying to take a jeweled egg (?) from in the center of a rug, and they can't walk on the rug, can't use magic, can't do a lot of things because the high-level guardians are keeping things fair for all the contestants, making sure everyone follows the rules? And when Bob comes back, his solution is so simple, the rest of the party attacks him for being right? Just describing the trap, which technically this side quest represents, I guess, and he describes what he character does.
@TheBigGummyBear
@TheBigGummyBear 3 жыл бұрын
This was great! keep it up
@halolytical9375
@halolytical9375 3 жыл бұрын
Funny. I was watching this to help with the 2nd and basement levels of my dungeon and when you described the portcullis trick, I remembered I had the same trick in my 1st level where, when the party gets to a certain room, a portcullis blocks off the entrance and a tentacled creature lurches from the corner. I even had a second door that cannot be open unless the portcullis is lifted. And if you open the door from the other side, it slams shut and pushes whatever is front of it inside. Along with the portcullis closing and the door locking.
@Try_Hard_Dad
@Try_Hard_Dad 2 жыл бұрын
Ahh Triple D, Guy would be proud of another D&D joke in his honor lmao
@terrybeal2252
@terrybeal2252 4 ай бұрын
Excellent advice. I also recommend Runehammer's Trap Theory video. Traps are awesome if they're done right. 💀
@calebchristensen900
@calebchristensen900 3 жыл бұрын
One I’ve thought of but haven’t figured out the tech. Of it is a room with an incline at one end, an open door, and a constant flow of alchemists fire coming down the incline. Maybe every now and then the floors made of flint, and it’s slippery or hard to climb.
@chrisbridges4885
@chrisbridges4885 3 жыл бұрын
Great video! Good stuff!
Make Tracking Encumbrance Fun
11:08
Questing Beast
Рет қаралды 63 М.
Traps!, Running The Game
15:44
Matthew Colville
Рет қаралды 216 М.
The day of the sea 🌊 🤣❤️ #demariki
00:22
Demariki
Рет қаралды 53 МЛН
OMG🤪 #tiktok #shorts #potapova_blog
00:50
Potapova_blog
Рет қаралды 12 МЛН
The Lost Dungeon Crawling Rules of DnD
19:04
Questing Beast
Рет қаралды 216 М.
This Dungeon Master strategy rewired my brain
13:08
Ginny Di
Рет қаралды 208 М.
Rating my subscribers' DnD hot takes
16:24
Questing Beast
Рет қаралды 37 М.
The Evolution of Darkvision
14:50
Questing Beast
Рет қаралды 30 М.
Traps that Make Sense || D&D w/ Dael Kingsmill
20:47
MonarchsFactory
Рет қаралды 175 М.
Early DnD was a open-world tabletop MMORPG
11:13
Questing Beast
Рет қаралды 99 М.
Jaquaysing the Dungeon
9:28
Map Crow
Рет қаралды 214 М.
Old-School Starting Spells are Crazy
7:30
Questing Beast
Рет қаралды 35 М.
Speeding up a game of DnD
14:20
Questing Beast
Рет қаралды 61 М.
[RU] BLAST Premier Spring Final 2024 - Day 5
4:46:21
RLG PARI RU
Рет қаралды 363 М.