The sucker punch is a good weapon for everyone besides Roland as he does not get any melee boosts. As a gun, it’s ok but as a melee weapon, it’s good if you can handle how clunky bladed pistols work. Personally I prefer bladed shotguns for melee as they hit fast and hard. Not as hard as a melee pistol mind but at least they feel good to use and not awkward. There’s like a weird delay with bladed pistols and it feels often inconsistent. It’s weird and I don’t like it but the high damage might make up for that especially on mordecai when lethal strike procs.