I've got a tip for all ghosts trapped in games: If you're trapped in a game then don't corrupt the game enough to the point where the player shit themselves

I just realized if this was a normal game, you would get a Apple guy that has very mean “friends” who steal his keys, make him do things for them, before closing the barn door on him on purpose when he is showing clear signs of fear of the dark while he just wants to get a key for his house.

Overall Andy is mighty positive to all he sees and lives in this game, his first thought when he gets locked in a dark barn with an eldritch creature waiting for him is: Oh boy! I should find a light

Peter: "you wanna play a game of tag?" Andy: N-no I'm just looking for my keys..😅 Peter: SOUNDS GREAT, LETS PLAY!

I love how reasonable Andy is. Like he's just asking why they took his keys and who this pumpkin guy is and why he's down here. He just wants his keys back man.

I love how you could tell that Andy was subtly annoyed with his friends stealing his keys.

I get so scared from things like this, but here I am, watching a 30 min horror video. That was super informative and scary!! I love lore like this 😖 and the fact that there were "irl" pictures of the characters

I like how Andy is kinda aware and doesn't act like everything is ok. Like when his friend's stole his key and locked him in the building.

Notice how Andy said "Wait who even are you" to Peter, and since it is known that the person whos in Andy's virtual body *was the one who made the game*, implies that Thomas has never ever made Peter the Pumpkin as a character for the game in the first place but rather a creation of the entity in his head.

So, me and my dad decoded the binary that Mike wasn't able to. What we got was "Cared from what happened she couldn't even us the truth. It wasn't her fault." We're thinking that the letters obscured on the top line might mean that "cared" is actually "scarred", and there's a word missing, which would be tell. We also worked out the Ceaser Cypher, it spells out "Thomas, don't ask for hclp, nobody can save you now". The way Ceaser Cyphers work means that the c in hclp is intentional, so that's pretty interesting. The final bit of binary with Peter the Pumpkin comes out as "cared" then "ppene". We think this is just a repeated glitch from the first binary file, since ppene probably comes from ha"ppene"d. I should point out that when I say "me and my dad", I mean "I was watching the video, he saw binary, and he decided to decode it"

16:44 Damn, that audio in the background sounds like when the guy at the end of the commercial is naming all of the side effects

so basically, they died and their souls are the characters? man i love games like this with a storyline. also, andy deserves his keys back, mans been so chill the whole time.

This whole game could’ve ended if Andy went to a key smith for a new set of keys.

Andy: Ugh! I lost my keys... Hey guys have you seen my keys? His friends: And we took that personally

Some of these secrets actually made me feel like crying, not because of fear but of sadness.

I think there were nods to Isabella still being alive in the first chapter, as it's shown that those who have been killed by the evil entity have had their faces covered up by a rectangle bar... Although Isabella's face is covered up in the Christmas Photo, her face at 23:31 isn't... which would be one of the allusions to her still being alive in this game's story.

The binary translated is: “cared from what happened she couldn’t enenus the truth. It wasn’t her fault.” Just saying the eyes covered some of it up so I may have gotten some of it wrong.

This kind of horror is my favorite kind. You start out knowing nothing but as you go you find that something is off and as you dig deeper into it you can find a clear story that is horrifying as well as some really disturbing imagery. This is also why I think the Walten Files are such a great horror experience.

0:00 Intro 0:35 Menu Screen Secrets🔎 1:54 3 Secret Messages⁉️ 3:25 Game Error Audio🔊 5:52 Felix Secrets🐟🎣 7:52 Margaret Secrets🐶🍎 9:50 Melody Secrets🌜🎶 12:47 Claus Secrets🕑🪓 15:30 Out Of Bounds🛶 17:01 Barn Room Secrets👀 20:20 Peter Pumpkin Secrets🎃 23:37 Story (so far) Explained👨‍👩‍👧‍👧😈 29:36 Outro

Don't know if anyone noticed but when you click on Claus when he says "I spy something deceased" he says "yes that's right" implying that Arthur possesses Claus...the way claus says "yes that's right" when he says "I spy something deceased" sounds so funny 😂😅. Also Thomas shrugs when he sees the entity like "well this is it..." 😂

I love how more and more people are making indie games, and adding more experimental stuff into each one. Like, I love it a lot. :) it means more people are able to express their stories, and have people enjoy them too.

14:52 Andy: "Well, I finished all the minigames - let's kill some time."

11:18 you know what's a scary trait? Being addicted to screams of pain because of the sheer panic and agony in their voices even though they are just voice actors. The screams are disturbing and yet... I can't stop...

To clarify something about the missing date or rather what I understand from North Woods Law. If the person is not found alive or dead they aren’t concluded as either. A 19 year old cold case still had a possibility of the missing person as alive until they finally found his truck with remains. Since Loius was witnessed drowning he should be confirmed dead unless he disappeared out of sight before succumbing to the depths. I’m looking far too into that but it makes me wonder if him being missing means more.

Not gonna lie, the game creator really outdid themselves. It gave me the chills!!! Would love to see a sequel to this game

That game feels like a cursed game creepypasta made to scare your friends from early 2010's, relying mostly on this somewhat cheap zalgo, but done well from backstory point

i love how cheerfully he says " no im just looking for my keys"

7:45 a fckng loud ad came in right at this moment and I swear I think I just my whole life just flashed before my eyes

“…You took the keys to my house?” -Andy before everything went to hell

Theory: pumpkin is high chance the demon because during the dialogue, he said” come on! Let’s play hide and seek!” Andy then says no I’m finding me keys, but the pumpkin forces him to play anyways, just how the demon was forceful to him. Also since Andy’s friends were hiding his keys, I feel like they are trying to get revenge for him killing them.

I feel like the reason why clause’s minigame can only be played last is because it’s the most creepiest 2:14

8:30 is when you know this got scary

Can we just talk about how andy's friends ask him if he wants an apple? Like... Thats messed up dude...

I have a theory about the second saved file. It’s probably have to with Logan Eastwood, since he uploads videos about the game and finds other secrets we can’t access and he probably was a previous beta tester. Edit: I looked at his bio and I realised he’s (probably) not a beta tester. Logan is related to Thomas, (because he said he found a game on his great uncle’s computer or somethin) and it looked like he wasn’t REALLY a beta tester. Or maybe actually, WE’RE Logan. I have no idea, I just got into this game so we will find more lore when the game updates.

I loved this video, if there's anymore updates to Andy's apple farm please continue to talk about the lore!!

This is actually creepy, despite how simple it looks. Very well made.

Considering Thomas didn't want this game to fail, he made a deal with a demon, sealing his fate and many more fates who would become connected to Thomas and this game.

This Theory actually confirmed a few suspicions I had when I first saw the game. I can't wait to see what happens next.

you sound so calm while explaining lore.

Louis Eastwood was what started all of this. What a coincidence that a simple trip with a boat that Isabella and Louis were in was what started all of the craziness that happened in the story.

I feel Thomas DID bring this upon himself and his family. You don’t ask an eldritch entity for help and not expect it to go “sure now just confirm your payment, will that be in souls, blood, or credit?” It was a stupid haphazard attempt to get cash that blew up in his face.

“His date of death is 1983” Me a hardcore FNaF fan: *stares down in fear*

Just found this video after playing Rabbit Knight - thank you for this comprehensive video!

Fun little thing, if you complete one minigame, then go to the next minigame without going to the picnic table area, complete the second minigame (and presumably repeat the process of avoiding the picnic table on your way to the third minigame) then the messages will be superimposed over each other and pretty much impossible to read. I learned this accidentally while watching Markiplier play the game, and he caused this to happen by playing Margaret's game, then instead of going up to the picnic tables and then right to Melody, he went right and went around the tables before heading up towards Melody's area.

Margaeret: Kamryn Andy: Thomas Melody: Isabella Claus: Arthur Felix: Louis Peter: The demon

Anyone in an indie game: I wanna make my product to be more life-like Everyone: yup they're gonna make some deals with the devil

THAT LAST JUMPSCARE WHEN YOU FIND THE KEY ALWAYS GETS ME EVERYTIME

The fact it's October 14 but this video was a amazing explanation

okay so there are some caesar and binary codes that werent deciphered in this video: 7:30 But It Wasn’t Her Fault. We Weren’t Alone That Night. I Don’t Blame Her. 8:20 Kamryn 18:15 Arthur King. His best - friend did him in 18:30 kamryn eastwood. loving wife and mother fire [last word in morse code] 18:59 Loius Eastwood 20:05 cared from what happened she couldn't even [tell?] us the truth. it wasn't her fault. 21:04 cared | ppene | asn't [pieces from the previous binary code] 21:57 THOMAS, DON’T ASK FOR HELP. NOBODY CAN SAVE YOU NOW.

The noise, in the glitch where Andy walks away from his car, walks in snow, peeks in the house, and listens to the conversation, then when he enters, everything seems burned down, it's like the noises SuperHorrorBro is talking about. Andy is quite the strangest character.

SuperhorrorBro. I like your analysis on Andy Apple Farm.

melody goin ham with those notes

The biggest thing that sticks out to me is the contradiction over Louis' fate. The secret text after the fishing games says that he did indeed die, drowning "at the bottom of the lake", but the scene in the barn only states that he is "missing", it doesn't give him a date of death like the others. If he was indeed dead, why only state him as "missing"? That's a very deliberate and interesting choice to make, because it brings up some very big questions. 1) Did Louis actually die that day? If not, how did he survive and why did the rest of the family not know? If he did, why mark him down as only "missing"? 2) If he did indeed survive, then going off the fact that the other characters in the game represent/are possessed the dead involved in this situation...who or what is inhabiting the Felix character....?

The game being called Andy's apple farm and Andy being an apple is scary enough for me abnskfkg

I love the story thanks for telling us

Clause: I spy something growing. Me: **proceeds to click his crotch**

This is literally just The Walten Files if it was only about developing BunnyFarm. You can clearly tell that it's trying to capture the same unsettling style of horror.

17:16 "oh they are just in there" - she states casually, pointing at literally most horrific building ive ever seen. Every horror movie family in a nutshell

Love your videos

I get REALLY scared watching these but I like it!

Felix: :D Also Felix: The child sank into the water and never resurfaced, and presumably drowned.

If I had a nickel every time there was a fictional video game created around the 70's/80's/90's with chunky pixel art and cartoon cutscenes with characters that had their own individual minigames revealing their tragic death as a human and paranormal revival through cryptic messages and disturbing imagery, I'd have two nickles. Which isn't a lot, but it's weird that it happened twice. (Note that I genuinely love both AAF and The Walten Files, I just thought this would be a good funny analysis lol)

I LOVE your content:)

the running sound fx are so funny, it's like the dude doing it is super duper short or something

Mike, there's something you should know. Look up Andy's apple farm Logan Eastwood. There's extra secrets on that channel that kinda make the game into an ARG. I think you might be interested.

Fun fact: when you’re playing Margaret’s mini game and you touch her chest area she’ll leave and say that’s not a fruit 😳

Great video!👍🏻

I remember my friend always and still does watch you at 2 am

my theory is that Thomas summoned the demonic entity to make his characters more life like but was able to stretch out its influenced from the game,when the family members died the demonic entity is the one who pulled their souls into the game trapping them in there for all eternity, thats my take on the story so far love the content mane keep it up!

bro andy's voice when they took his keys "you took my keys?" "but why would you?" he sounds so scared and sad also when they said the keys were in the farm the absence of noise and andy just being confused of why his "friends" would do that

Commenting for the algorithm. Can't think of anything to say other than this is a great video!

i like How Andy/Thomas Is Just Pointing At The Entity/Peter Like He Doesn't Even Care

It makes sense that the entity becomes Peter pumpkin because Peter never gave Andy a choice to play tag or not, and the entity didn’t give Thomas a choice in killing his family and Arthur

I like how more indie games and analog horror are using child like drawings and this 2d pixel game style. The idea of developing a game or horror story can be intimidating cause not everyone can draw the best or 3d model, but whether these horror stories use “bad” drawings on purpose or not it shows you don’t need immense artistic talent to tell your story, you can tell it with whatever you have access to and it could still be amazing!

13:30 those black pixel guys in the background give me purple guy vibes

I think the message in 21:59 reads, "Thomas, don't ask for help. Nobody can save you now."

8:23 The binary here translates to “Kamryn,” revealing Margaret’s previous time as a human before completing the game and revealing her name before the recordings or barn Edit: 7:33 is a caeser shift of one and reveals massive lore. “But it wasn’t her fault. We weren’t alone that night. I don’t blame her.” This confirms the entity played a role either in knocking Louis out of the boat or keepIng Isabella from saving him and it gives her if she ever gets out closure that he does not blame her for what happened to him.

I always thought the pumpkin was meant to represent the authorities as when you get the Felix secret, they talk about "Pumpkin County Sheriffs." The minigame itself seems kinda odd too. A tag game. IDK just wanted to theorize a little too.

There are a couple of things I thought might be references; first, the date for the Apple Acres tape recording is the 13th of April, the date on which Homestuck begun and an arc number throughout the comic. While this could have just been a random date, I think it could be a reference to Homestuck. Second, when the entity takes over Thomas, the line "When did I give you a choice?" is very similar to the line in Undertale on the Genocide Route "Since when were you the one in control?" and the face he makes is very similar to Chara's face after that line. Third, the line "Oh boy, I'm gonna have to find a light. It sure is dark in here..." could be a reference to the Hotel Mario line "Gee, it sure is dark in here. Did you bring a light?".

i feel more comfortable when superhorrorguy talks because it gives me comfort that i hear a non-creepy voice

"How many Easter eggs do you want?" Andy's apple farm:YES

"Thomas met his friend Arthur in a bar." With who appears to be William Afton and someone else, possible Henry, in the next booth, throwing back a few rounds, after buying Fazbears pizza, and talking about how great their new pizza joint for kids is going to be.

This video gives me nostalgia-

this guys voice fits what he talks about, perfectly! Its such a fitting voice.

Here are my thoughts. There are two possible explanations to this. 1: The demon scene is actually out of order. Prior to any of the events shown, Thomas consulted a demon of some sort for an unknown reason (note the book, knife, and blood on the ground, indicating he took part in a ritual involving drawing his own blood), but things went horribly wrong and his family died as a result. (This explanation is less likely, seeing as every other event is entirely in order.) 2: The demon was pulling the strings all along. Maybe they were the spirit of someone who wanted revenge on Thomas, maybe just someone who wanted chaos. Whatever or whoever it was, the demon wanted to cause Thomas true pain. It pushed Louis off the boat, holding Isabella back so he would drown, later killing Isabella as well. It possessed Thomas and caused him to eventually burn down his own home, killing his wife in the process. It forced Thomas to kill his best friend, making him watch as the life left his eyes. Thomas likely tried to destroy it using a ritual (see idea 1), but it only made the demon stronger, and it provided him with an agonizing death, consuming him before using its newfound power to trap the souls of them all in a game where they would never be able to escape. To make sure of this, the demon placed himself in the game to guarantee none of them would escape. Unfortunately for the demon, it failed, and the family was able to communicate with the player once the game was beaten and the barrier that is the 4th wall was broken. Along with this, the modernized technology of the game tapped into the memories of the souls and revealed the story of their deaths; the story that we are seeing today. Edit: Found something interesting, gonna look deeper into it. If the youtuber who made this video has a discord or something, reply to this comment with it because I might have a breakthrough

Andy: “no I’m just here to find my keys” Peter: “sounds great! Let’s play”

This is my childhood I watch u at 2022 and 2021 And I'm so glad that I'm watching u again

“WE TOOK YOUR KEYS TO YOUR HOUSE ANDY!” “W-why???” 😭😭😭😭😭😭

Andy: looses his keys His friends: so you have chosen death...

I remember seeing this game when my friend was looking for games to play, we really dodged a freaking nuke.

i love how audio number 4 after first mini game sounds so much like it’s stock

Guys we gotta get superhorrorbro to 2 million

The message at 21:57 Thomas,don’t ask for help Nobody can save you now

I am very disturbed by modern horror games and this one is the most. So much I had to block it from my vision

You're good at finding games secret and my friend is a fan of yours

Looks like I'm not gonna sleep tonight without nightmares

This guy's voice is so nostalgic, especially when you've been watching him from his bendy vids years ago

Okay but poor andy, he just wanted his keys back 😭

Thank you man now its gonna give me nightmare

Is it weird this is one of the top 5 vids I go to sleep to…