I can still hear Jonghyun....our bling bling...😭❤

이 무대가 음향감독님이 학생들 방송국 견학오면 mr제거로 보여준다는 무대구나 라이브 진자 잘한다

나만 방송국 음향감독 그 영상보고 넘어왔냐

샤이니를 두고 라이브인가 아닌가를 논하는 거 자체가 웃긴 일이지

Can't believe this is true... when I heard Minho voice replaced Jonghyun. It's not easy for both SHINee and us. But SHINee tries their best to fulfil the gap. We can listen to Jonghyun voice in many videos. For now, please cheer up and support each other (SHINee and Shawol). I believe that we can move on together :) 5HINee is always 5 in our hearts.

I'm so proud of them but it still hurts at the same time

샤이니의 view는 가사가 끝내주는듯ㅠㅠ

2:26 운동화 끈 묶는 태민이 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 근데 실패ㅋㅋ

I know it hurts not to see our angel Jonghyun right by their side but just as our kings have said, the best way to go through this harsh battle is working hard, living day by day as we normally would because we all know Jonghyun would’ve never wanted us to suffer. So let’s keep it up, let’s support Shinee more than ever!!

they are so strong and admirable shawol are lucky to have them

와아.. 진짜 온유 목소리가 보물이다.. 키하고 온유는 목소리에 청량이 있어.. 듣는 순간 아 샤이니다 싶음..

진짜 뭐 하나 뒤처지는게 없구나 얘네는 .. 이런 그룹 돌판에서 또 없음

5HINee💙💙

Minho doing Jonghyun’s part shows that he improves so much. So proud of him.

아미지만 샤이니가 kpop 자존심이다 진짜 ... 이런 선배가 잇어서 지금의 kpop이 있는거. 뷰는 특히나 샤이니를 잘보여주는 최고의 무대.

스타일이 진짜 어째 이렇게 매치하지. 어디서 본 적도 없는 맴버들 믹스매치 스타일이라 시간 지나서 봐도 촌스럽지가 않네. 뭘 따라한 느낌이 아니라.

SHINee and shawols let's keep going strong :) I'm so proud of them, great performances I can't wait to see the full episode

My heart doesnt feel okay

민호가 노래 잘 안 해서 몰랐는데 노래 잘 하네여...... 샤이니 당신들 도대체 부족한게 뭐지ㅜㅜ

샤이니는 천년돌 만년돌 억년돌.. 장담하는데 샤이니를 넘어설 그룹은 지금은 물론이거니와 그 후에도 없다

Guys, yes i know, we all miss Jonghyun a lot, but please... remember that 5hinee read all our comments, and you talking about "This is not the same" and "This performance feels wrong" just will make them feel disappointed and sad, please support SHINee and tell them that they're doing it amazing and that we are very proud of them.

It's okay to miss jonghyun. It's okay if you're still hurting. But please, SHINee are the ones who are hurting the most. So let's stay positive, it hurts even more seeing shawols dwells in sadness

팬은..아니지만 내가 생각하는 아이돌의정석이 샤이니 같다 중딩시절공방뛰러갈때 샤이니 누난너무예뻐로 활동하던때였는데 그때나 지금이나 변함이 없네

10 years idol is no kidding. Taemin can even tie his shoes in the middle of the song.

Clean vocals!!! 😍😍😍

I’m not crying, you are

요즘 샤이니 영상을 많이 보긴했나보다.. 알고리즘이 다 형들이야

??? : 뷰 너 언제 촌스러워질거야? 뷰 : 그거 어떻게 하는건데

They did well

Why am I crying??? :( :( :(

이거 보니까 이거 mr제거한 거 실시간으로 보고 있던 유스케 스탶들이 오오~ 하는 영상 어디 있지 ㅠㅠ 진짜 내 가수지만 너무 멋있는 그룹...

중간중간 화음 애드립까지 라이브 다하는거 진짜 발린다

I’d really hate for SHINee to see some of your comments. We all miss Jonghyun but can you at least say amazing job SHINee for continuing to be amazing.

Their vocals are just no joke, out of this world amazing.

ㅋㅋ 라이브 너무 잘해서 안그래도 그냥 음원같은데 샤월응원 안들리니까 뭔가 더 라이브안같다 ㅋㅋㅋ 샤월 목소리가 들어가야 찐라이브같은 느낌 샤! 이! 니!!!

울 샤월들 샤이니 제6멤버 맞다,, 노래 중간에 샤!이!니! 없으니까 넘 허전쓰,,,

I cannot express enough how proud I am of SHINee right now, they're doing so well, also making me feel good things with those live vocals. (And did y'all see Taemin trying to tie his shoes bless him).

CDNee, as expected😻

다 너무 좋은 사람들이고 열심히 하는 사람이라 이런사람들은 진짜 잘됐음 좋겠다

샤이니는 항상 최선을 다하지 롱런의 이유가 있음

Jonghyun's lines: 1st Verse - Minho 2nd Verse - Onew 3rd Verse - Key Adlibs - Taemin

anybody noticed taemin trying to tie his shoes (and failing)

역시 샤이니... 라이브 너무잘해

솔직히 샤이니가 무대에 올라서 라이븐가? 싶으면 그게 정답임... 애드립부터 기계음 까지 모두 라이브 하는데

They're doing an excellent job covering Jonghyun's parts No one should doubt about SHINee talent 👏👏👏

Not to kill the mood or hurt feelings or anything but, it really is inconsiderate for a lot of you guys to constantly remind others of jonghyun’s death no matter what shinee is doing. I’ve been with shinee since debut. He is my bias and I miss him more than anything. But I don’t want to be reminded of it everytime I try to enjoy a shinee video. Please just talk about the video or comeback instead of constantly bringing the mood down to the floor.

어떻게 음원보다 라이브가 더 좋냐

다 잘하지만 온유 목소리가 진짜 보물이다

There's indeed no vocal hole in SHINee! All of them sing this really well esp since it's live and all! Props to my kings💖💞

Proud of these guys🤗 they work very hard plus the adjustments they have to make. It's not easy for them as well but as a fan we have to support, give encouragement and love them more.

완벽한 아이돌..

온유 음색은 진짜 보물 그 자체다

*always 5HINee♡*

ㄹㅇ 온유형 목소리도 찰떡이다 ㅎㅎㅎ

샤이니는 다섯명 다 올라운더인듯 👍

2:25 자연스럽게 운동화 끈 묶으려고 하다가 결국 풀린 채로 무대 마무리하는 탬ㅠㅠㅠ 4명 다 끈 있는 운동화인데 탬니 혼자만 풀린 것도 어딘가 허술한 느낌이라 귀엽곸ㅋ큐ㅠㅠㅠㅠ 무대 끝까지 열정적이고 프로페셔널하고 멋지고 다하네 증말ㅠ 샤이니 넘 사랑스럽다ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ

Shinee the best!!

kibum, why are u so handsome??

0:16 fㅗㅇ듀 오진다

종현아 이렇게 예쁜 곡 써줘서 고마워💙

샤이니 더 떳으면 좋겠다ㅠㅜ_ㅠㅜ재능에 비해 안뜨는 느낌 세계진출도해서 더 대박나줘

KINGS ARE BACK! ! !

온유 목소리 진짜 매력적인거 같음

온유목소리 진짜ㅜㅜ

진짜 잘한다 역시 오래가는이유가잇다

뷰 가사 누가 쓴거죠? 누구죠?? 갓종현님 최고

1:30 여기 온유 턴 돌면서 라이브가 이러케 안정적이누...

돈콜미보고 여기까지 와버렸다

크 역시 라이브는 샤이니지

방송국 음향감독님이 들려준 엠알제거 영상 보고 오신분? 저랑 같이 기절하실분?

SHINee is known for their perfect-synchronize choreo, ear-worm song and amazing live performance. They kept those aspects for more than 10 years. They are truly legends, seriously ❤

이것이 전설의 음향감독님 보여주신,,,그 영상이군요 진심 샤이니 라이브 대박,,,,❤️

You can do it, my kings. Keep slaying those stages. Show everyone why you're leegends. Stay strong, loves.

Grande SHINee 💪

그니까 이게 음원같은데 생라이브라는거잖아 씨디를 밥대신 먹나

샤이니 노래 너무 예쁘다 가사도 멜로디도 ㅠㅠ

라이브 오진다...

Why it hurts? They did a great job...their voices are awesome...the reality bites....it stings...stay strong 5HINee, stay strong too Shawols/Shinee world....you are all blinging with strength. God bless you guy5.

아니...노래와 춤에 너무 진심이야 샤이니... 어떻게 입덕을 안해💎💎💎💎💎

아 라이브구나 ㄷㄷ 미쳤네

Srsly, I'm so happy watching this. Like, View is a song that they made when Jonghyun was alive. Jonghyun was the the main vocal and the choreography was made with the 5 members, and watching this make me so happy because they are singing and dancing even if they have 4 members! I'm so so proud. SHINee, always wish the best for you. I know it's hard, but you are doing very well. And don't forget, you have Shawols to give all the support and love you need. - a brazilian shawol 💕🇧🇷

They really, really, REALLY pulled it off! :D I'm so insanely happy. Also Taemin tying his shoe laces :P

1:24 온유 저음에서 고음 애드립으로 넘어가는 거 극락

누가 태민이한테 저 노랗고 헐렁한 티 입혔냐 진짜;;; 움직일 때마다 펄럭펏럭펄럭.... 그와중에 몸선도 개잘보이고 팔 위로 팟 뻗으면 옷도 위로 올라가면서..... 미쳤냐고 천재냐

I know we all feel the emptiness while watching this but guys!! The boys are doing their best and look at them being strong i feel so proud of them, 😭😭 let’s be positive now though its hard but we have to accept the reality now, remember that our angel bling bling won’t like it if we are having a hard time 💚💚💚💚💚 let’s support these strong and talented group ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️ remember that it’s more painful for them see shawol being hurt so they are doing their, don’t worry its okay 😊 I believe that the whole kpop is proud of SHINee and Shawol 💚💚 stay strong 😘😘😘😘😘

And lyrics was made by Genius Jonghyun❤

다들 목소리가 잘 어울리고 좋은데 그중 온유 목 아플때 쉬고 싶을때 있을거 같은데... 절대 쉴수 없을거 같아~ 가끔 그게 좀 안타까움!

이거 진짜 몇번을 봐도 오져

View without Jonghyun😭😭😭💔

? 라이브라고?ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 진짜 조온나 잘한다; 라이브 1군ㄹㅇ

그나저나 뷰는 언제 촌스러워질까? 진짜 곡 예술로 만들었네

와,,,라이브,,,,

Im crying for this one.. But at the same time I feel so proud of them as they are slaying it even in the absence of our main vocal. Our boys are really working so hard to keep SHINee alive. I will continue to support them until SHINee is stoll SHINee.

SHINee you did well !!!

대중성 예술성을 다 갖춘 그룹… 멤버 다섯 명 전부 수준급 실력을 갖춘 그룹을 동방신기 뒤로 처음 보는 것 같았음. 남들이 보면 비웃을 수도 있지만 동방신기/빅뱅 급으로 실력있는 그룹이라 생각함 잘 알려지지 않아서 그렇지. 팬이라서 감탄하는게 아니라는 걸 샤이니가 한 무대들 보면 뭔 말인지 알겁니다

This shows how hard working they are. Their vocals are amazing. Proud of you SHINee. Proud to be a Shawol

역시 1티어 아이돌이네

I am blown away. This is such an exciting performance because it feel fresh and new yet at the same time mature -- a work performed by veteran artists with nothing left to prove. SHINee is right up there with The Beatles, Michael Jackson, Prince -- artists whose work remains timeless thus whose sound still sounds new and ever innovative. Even their dancing is a marvel to behold: Onew's, Minho's, Key's and Taemin's dance moves have a quiet power and ease -- an eloquence (they don't need to shout their prowess) and elegance. I am so impressed. And on a human level -- I am in awe of the bravery of these young men. They are dealing with an unimaginable trauma and loss and yet they soldier on with dignity, always with the courage to remember and honor Jonghyun and the understandable bewilderment and grief of their fans.

02:26 태민씨 신발끈 묶는중

People should really learn from shinee...Korea look how powerful they are...please appreciate these beautiful jewels ...