I literally got goosebump when watching Identity. I agree with you so much, Taemin is the kind of artist that live on by real audience. Us Shawols gave him energy and confidence, and strength to overcome everything. I have an opportunity of watching Taemin live in the flesh. And there're always a magic in Taemin with live audience. (Like the fact that everytime Taemin performed, there was rain) I'm sad that he can't feel us cheering for him, and loving him. Please keep on loving Taemin and SHINee for long time, my friends.

Taemin is an artist who feeds a lot on the energy of the public when it comes to performing, something that is difficult in an online concert without anyone but him. Lately I have been worrying that Taemin is constantly dealing with this feeling of loneliness, on more than one occasion he has said it and it seems logical that the tight life of an artist lends itself to that. Sometimes I would that SM didn't press or saturate his activities schedule so much and so he has time to live his life and although it is true that Taemin is already used to this hectic pace of life since he was a child when he joined SM, it is It makes sense that he's scared to stop. Although it pains me not to see him revolutionize the music industry as only he knows how to do, I believe that 18-month break is necessary and by then I hope that all this drama of the pandemic has ceased or diminished considerably. In addition, that time will only help him to come up with other amazing performances, songs, stages never seen, I assure you. Apart from his beauty, sensuality, charisma, passion and scenic presence, the brain of that man falls in love completely, he is a genius to devise concepts, to be unique in everything. Let's support his latest comeback in the meantime and give him lots of love pls.

TAEMIN's NEW SONG AND ALBUM "ADVICE" TO DROP ON MAY 18!!!! THERE WILL BE A NEW MV TOO!!!! The choreo will be even harder than Criminal and IDEA and is officially the fastest choreo in SM. Dancers are challanged to post their dance cover 24 hours after the music video is out! PLEASE LOOK FORWARD TO IT~!!!

I think i'm lucky to see Taemin in live 3 times. A Real Artist.

He is a true born to be performer! Taemin is stunning!

You’re right I did feel he was so lonely and it’s the reason why he put off holding a beyond live for so long Taemin is someone that feeds off the audience energy so much it must be so upsetting for him to perform without them

Oh and talking about we got married, you need to be prepare to see a manly, YES, MANLY, 21 years old Taeminnie. Damn. It's so long ago yet feels like yesterday to me.

When I went to San Diego for the super m concert I felt like I had went with everyone in the crowd. We all talked back and fourth or made comments to each other. And when taemin came out and performed danger we all had the same reaction and we all chanted together. So going to a live concert was the best for the crowd, the guys on stage and the atmosphere. I will miss taemin dearly and pray for his safe return. None of us will forget him. Hopefully we can find a way to send comfort to him while he is in the military so he won't be lonely. I was thinking about how he went 18 months without his brothers and now he is going to be away from them again for 18 months. So he will really be away from them all together for three years. This pains me so much but I guess I have to be happy knowing he got to see them for a few months before they separate again. Everyone send all your love and best wishes to a man that makes us all very happy. Thank you

7:52 he also seemed to be super tired and insecure in the beginning. After a few songs it got better imo. I also think that it just took a lot of energy from him to hold his emotions back. You could see him tearing up a few times from the very beginning on. He's someone who pushes himself to the absolute limit, but honestly he needs to stop it. At some point it will take a toll on him. He's so hard on himself and I wish we could make him understand, that it's ok to not be ok. It seems like he's seriously scared to lose his fans and I really don't understand where this huge fear is coming from. He doesn't owe us anything. And it's not his fault that he has to "leave" for some time. We won't leave him and most certainly not judge him for anything. I wish he would take a break before he enlists instead of working his ass off!

He looked really emotional that day T_T It's a relief that he could hold it and gave us amazing performances. I still have post concert depression T.T It's a pity he couldn't meet the fans irl but we, the interfans could enjoy his concert is something that should not be sad about ^_^

I love this man!! Very very much!

His performance of Soldier at his Off-Sick concert will always get to me. It never fails to make me cry, the emotion he puts into it is undeniable. And I agree with you, Taemin is someone when he is performing solo live, he needs the crowd. He needs us to be there with him, giving him that instant feedback, giving him that energy. While being able to "attend" one of his concerts even though I live thousands of kilometres away is amazing and so surreal, I could also tell that even though he had people there in person cheering him on, it wasn't the same as him being able to see thousands of people waving their light sticks for him.

The fact that he didn’t get enough time to fully prepare for this beyond concert says a lot bc he did say he felt like he made mistakes but that is okay🥺 he nailed it

I agree with everything you said Torsie. After I watched his concert, there's something inside me that wasn't happy. I love taemin so much and he holds a very special place in my heart. Whether he did well in his concert or not, my love for him will not change. You got the right word to describe the feeling - "alone". The whole stage felt lonely. He looked lonely. Oh i can just imagine how hard it was for him to perform. 😞

I think Taemin loves performing with his SHINee friends too.

To hear you pointing out how he looks lonely through out the concert, actually I thought abt how he looks.. sad. Compare to when he performed with SHINee. And I cant really pointing out what, but I think it's not just because of the offline and online aspect, it's more how he might try to prepare to say goodbye temporarily (due to enlistment) to many things he usually do and interact for 13-14 years nonstop. Because I know that must be really hard, knowing he never really rest and suddenly now he needs to do a really different routines and daily life.. well, we never know whats truly on his mind but yeah.. thats really what im thinking while im watching the concert 😊

3:26 so cool, that he performed Romeo+Juliette! And the transformation from Holy Water to Heaven is just so good! Who ever said we need to put these two songs one after another needs a raise :') and once again, him singing live is just so, so, so, so good!

One of the things I love about SHINee is the connection they have with us it feels almost intimate when they speak to us from the stage. I’ve watched Taemin on beyond live three times now and you could always see how much he didn’t like it. He feeds off our energy and the love we give him and sends it back to his audience in his performances. There is a part at the end of his TMI concert where he says something along the lines of how he has grown up on our love and kind words and he drinks it up like a plant and we made him into what he is today. That struck me as really beautiful then but it makes me sad now because he is so cut off from us. All these comebacks he has made and not once has he had that direct feed back from us. Solo, super m, or SHINee and I think that’s why it scares him so much to leave us right now. He has been in constant contact with us online but nothing face to face. Leaving was always going to be hard, he has been doing this since he was 11 that’s a huge change in his life, but leaving on this note makes everything worse.

Yes, you are absolutely true, there is this HUGE different experience between live and online concert. Last year, I have planned to attend a couple of concert but it's all crumbling down bcs of this pandemic. It's really2 upset me but what else we can't do. The world is suffering right now and i hope it gets better 😭 immediately.

Thank you so much for sharing this video and your thoughts, Tors1e. Toward the end of the Beyond Live, I was so taken with how young Taemin started looking. His eyes were brighter and he was relaxing a bit. I think the performing energized him, Onew being there probably helped him, and the Shawols on camera I'm sure did their best to cheer him on. But nothing beats a live performance, for the performer as well as the audience, as you well know. So, you're doing We Got Married. (I know Key did it also, but later.) Friends advised me not to watch it but I'm happy to go along with you for the ride on Patreon. I think this program was filmed during the heyday of both 2Min and TaeKai so that should be interesting. SHINee members were on a lot of different variety shows and series together and individually. I don't notice 3rd and 4th gen groups doing as much now. By the way, you look beautiful and well rested after your painful ordeal, so at least there's that.

pls react to taeminxbewhy pinocchio

Thank u for reactions!! I really luv ur reaction😍 can u react to taemin- into the rhythm live stage? It's soooo adorable and makes u happy ..😍 i really recommend this 💙💙 lovely baby cheese🧀🧀💙 kzfaq.info/get/bejne/j9mRoKmTy660YIk.html