The man made Katie and Sadie into characters. That's seriously impressive.

I absoltuely love how you give character dynamics and arcs to people that didn't have any in the orginal season, like Katie, Justin, and Cody. I esspically liked how you portrayed Sierra and Cody's relationship, I honestly like it more than what they do in the actual show. Super good!

The Sierra and Cody dynamic here is the sweetest 😭💜 maybe in this world Coderra could happen without it being kinda problematic

Island what if: *exists* Courtney:

Gwen falling down 📉📉📉📉📉📉📉 EDIT: Heather and Alejandro's plan to eliminate Justin was so in-character, Congrats

Sierra would be a complete power house if she weren't so obsessed over chris n cody

"which is a nice natural setup for a future episode" **highlights phobia factor**

You're my favoutie channel who makes "What IF" scenarios for TD because you go so much more in depth about everything. Not just how different the challenges and eliminations would play out, but also the dynamics. I don't mind that you take your time to carefully lay out everything because is just THAT good.

Nothing better than a long video to keep me up at night.

Great what if. Seeing Alejandro play everyone is always a big treat and him eliminating Gwen was a great move No idea if you have written part 2 already but I think Duncan would steal Chef's boat and get back to the island once he learns that Harold rigged him out. We know that the eliminated players somehow see what happens on the island so he would learn about it quickly. He would probably get back after the 1st merge boot goes away

I love how you take characters who were kind of dead space in the og(Katie, Sadie, Justin, even Tyler, Cody,) and give them actual arcs and development that they didn’t get in the actual show. I love your videos and your rewrites are always so creative while managing to stay true to how the characters would act with their established personalities. Keep up the good work!:)

I adore what you came up with the diary plotline! Actually genius. Current predictions are that the finalists will be between Cody, Katie, Bridgette, Heather, an/or Alejandro. They just seem like they have the most going for them at the moment and feel the most important to the plot. Of course that could all change during the merge and someone else could start gaining a bunch of attention. I'm interested to see if Izzy and Eva still rejoin or if you pull a fast one on us and have someone like Gwen come back instead... Assuming that Alejandro and Sierra's presence hasn't taken away the rejoin spot anyway. Super excited for the next part!

Oh my god this was so good! I really love how most of characters were well utilized in this storyline. Even if characters like gwen got booted out early, her elimination was still very important part of your rewrite because of the investigation. It's kinda sad that Duncan and Courtney got eliminated early but seeing characters like Justin, Beth, Cody and katie and sadie having bigger role is so cool. Besides that I really like how you fixed Sierra character and made her relationship with Cody make sense but still - the Best part of it is Alejandro and Heather. I love their relationship so much and it's so interesting to see them working together instead of against each other. They are such a power evil couple and the way how they scheme against others and when they work together and destroy people's life is jest hilarious. Also I appreciate the fact that when alejandro is here, heather's plot armor is smaller and her actions are much smarter and their strategy is overall better. I kinda like this storyline better than original at this point XD

Sierra beat up a shark while she was in a wheelchair. I think she could probably handle a bear.

Probably the best rewrite of total drama I've ever seen. Seeing characters I don't really like like Justin and the twins get character development is so interesting. I'm impressied with how can you create this different dynamics and it still feels like the characters would actually act this way if this was canon story. I'm not a fan of shipping and I prefer characters who are strategist thinking how to win a game but in this story this different couples just works perfectly. People just want to date but it's often has to be stopped because their allies don't want them distracted from the game and this creates conflicts and drama. Also I like the parallels between Heather and Alejandro - both of them betraying their close allies - Beth and Justin two times in a row. Alejandro should be called the eavesdroper with how frequently he listens to someone's conversation xD But it's totally in his character to do so - he wants to have everything under control at all times. He'll definitely get farther into the game than Heather - his smooth talk and thinking ahead of the time is just better than Heather who can barely control herself from anger. This Gwen's framing storyline is just sooo good. Peak cinema. People responsible for total drama should hire you bro.

Oooh this was another interesting one! Immediately agree with the team placements of Alejandro and Sierra to even out the genders. Again I have to praise you for your world building and expansion on character dynamics! The Justin/Katie storyline was great as was the Cody trying to avenge Gwen’s early exit plot. The big Gopher alliance is also very complicated and entertaining. While I would absolutely watch one long video, I will just as readily watch two videos for parts one and two. And if a two parter is easier on you, then I support that! I’d rather get one really awesome part and have to wait than not get any awesome videos and have to wait. Going into the merge it looks set up for Alejandro to turn on Heather, but it would be neat if she found a way to turn the tables on him. Thematically the bike race episode would be good for that. Bridgette Geoff if they don’t get split up soon will probably make endgame together similar to the What If Ezekiel wasn’t sexist timeline. I imagine DJ will still get eliminated during the Horror challenge. If Katie lasts until the top five then she’d almost certainly get voted out by the playa de losers with Sadie already there.

Just when i was about to sleep Edit: Wow this is really good actually, kinda sad that Courtney and Gwen are gone earlier.

Great now I gotta stay up all night to watch this

This is probably the most interesting one you've done so far, really excited for part 2

this is f*cking awesome, can't wait for part 2

bro is so good at writing he made me actually care about Sadie and Katie existing

This is good, but I kind of wish that Noah got like, more development because I feel like him and Alejandro could have become, unlikely friends or something due to their personalities. I could imagine Noah being like “you might have everyone else fooled, but I know EXACTLY who you are.”

TDI Idea: What If Chris assigned the teams as the campers were introduced? Screaming Gophers: Beth, DJ, Gwen, Geoff, Lindsay, Heather, Duncan, Tyler, Harold, Trent, Bridgette. Killer Bass: Noah, Leshawna, Katie, Sadie, Ezekiel, Cody, Eva, Owen, Courtney, Justin, Izzy.

I LOVE the character development you gave to Sierra, specially since since she's my fave and she deserves the best

I love how the Screaming Gophers are carrying the show SO MUCH

Don’t push yourself too much! If you ever feel to overworked, always remember to take breaks despite the demands of the algorithm. Keep up the great work! 👍

I really really like this first part. It felt well developed, and I liked that you gave some of the early boots, actually story lines. My favorite has to be Justin and Katie's storyline with Justin being way nicer than in canon (though I will say it will feel kinda jarring seeing him go evil in Action). As for an idea (that doesn't lose you), I actually thought that you could possibly do some what-ifs on Disventure Camp since it's quite a similar show and I think it would be nice to see something like that. Anyways, it's a great part, and I can't wait to see how the rest of the season plays (my only worry is it didn't look like you're doing an elimination for episode 14 so I don't know how you'll get rid of people in the merge). Edit: I just realized that you're probably not bringing anybody back.

I feel as if Sierra maybe could fend off the bear because once Cody was in danger in world tour, Sierra was able to drag to whole cast on swan boats off a waterfall with her teeth and her legs (however this could be because Cody said "if we live i will let Sierra kiss me"

i’ve always hated how katie and sadie were just filler characters, so i did rewrite them more than once. i think that yours is actually way better, props for that!

I love this channel cause there’s a lot of what if td channels where they have characters compete in seasons they weren’t in and always make finals

35:02 Yeah , bears are really strong but we have to keep in mind that in the episode “ hawaiian punch “ cody got eaten by a shark and sierra literally went and grabbed the shark by the tail and started *violently throwing the shark up and down until it dropped cody .* so yes , i imagine that sierra could beat a bear in a fight

I love this so much. Somehow you’re able to convey such a convincing and interesting story with the tiniest changes and I find that really admiring. Plus your voice is really soothing so that makes it 100x better. I can’t wait for part 2!

This is better than the actual tdi ngl

Ezekiel actually got a bit far u know... for Ezekiel.

Cody is consistently interesting for once this time

I like how you made Katie and Sadie into actual characters rather than just one more and giving Justin more to do. And this version of sierra and Cody’s dynamic works

Finally another JustinxKatie truther, you see the vision 😂

oh my god, this was delicious! you wrote an incredible season, i really could not stop listening to your narration bc the plot you weaved was that amazing! incredible use of alejandro and sierra, everyone's choices are still in character and i love the new relationships and dynamics (im particularly interested to see how heather and alejandro's dynamic will play out in the end) im going straight to part 2!!!!

This is one of the most underrated TD KZfaqrs. He posts really great videos!

24 minutes in and both the original winners are out, 2 people really make a difference huh.

I enjoyed this a lot! I really hope you don't go with Izzy and Eva for the returns. There's so many other characters with more interesting plot relevance. Justin is my boy but for this story I think it would be interesting to bring back Gwen and maybe Courtney for the drama.

I just did this! Here is my elimination order: 26th: Courtney 25th: Eva 24th: Noah 23rd: Gwen 22nd: Ezekiel 21st: Cody 20th: Izzy 19th: Sierra 18th: Beth 17th: Owen 16th: Sadie 15th: Katie 14th: Duncan (rigged votes) (in mine Tyler is a main bully instead of Geoff) 13th: Harold Merge Gwen and Izzy return 12th: Lindsay (Third villain of the season) 11th: Bridgette (tricked by Alejandro instead of Trent by heather because of what happened with Gwen in episode 4) 10th: Heather (secondary villain of the season) 9th: Justin (3rd hero of the season) (used to be a villain) 8th: DJ 7th: Tyler 6th: Izzy 5th: Trent (secondary hero of the season) 4th: Gwen 3rd: Leshawna 2nd: Alejandro (Villain of the season) 1st: Geoff (Hero of the season)

'We know they arent able to collect their belongings before theyre eliminated' uh yeah they are, lindsay and bridgette have their stuff

This was really excellent and entertaining video to watch. I'm hyped for part 2.

OMG THIS IS WAY BETTER THAN THE ORIGINAL ONE!!!

Wow, I really enjoyed this! Your videos keep getting better every time

yo bro i have an idea for a what if scenario. what if Duncan didn’t quit in tdwt. i feel like him still being in the game would be really interesting seeing his interactions with Alejandro earlier on in the season, what could happen between him Gwen and Courtney with them all being on the same team, and how he’d do in earlier challenges.

THIS IS AMAZING!! hopefully one day you can do action as well based on this au that you created from the characters. Gwen and Courtney creating their romantic connections with Trent and Duncen in season 2 instead of one. And other many things. Great work

So glad I found this channel, great videos. Especially this one and the first part.

Bro just needs to make his own season

2:13 I disagree that it would be a lot more interesting, as this version here changed so much from the original. If Sierra was on the Gophers and Alejandro was on the bass, I think like, the first seven eliminations would remain unchanged and I think this version would play out a lot more similarly to the original, whereas the version where Alejandro is a gopher and Sierra is on bass changes so much and I think this is more interesting

I'm sensing a showdown between Alejandro and Cody coming in the merge! I suspect that'll be the main storyline~

I honestly LOVE this channel I can’t wait to see more of your videos!!

i love how in-depth this is

I remember when Sierra said she audition twice for the show

This was great! It always bothered me that on Island, the few episodds Katie was in she was silent for half of them. Same with Sadie who was silent until the episode she got voted off. I believe Katie should have been the one to last as she is noted for being more independent than Sadie. It also always bothered me that out of all the veterans, Katie (and then Sadie) have gone the longest without competing again. So two thumbs up for upgrading them from background characters to having an actual alliance! I was living for Justin having feelings for Katie and the heart to heart with Sadie. I will say that, I know Sierra taking on a bear is so out of the loop of reality...though when Cody is in question I feel like anything is possible for her. Eva managed to manhandle Sasquatchanakwa, and Heather beats down a Pterodactyl creature in Action for her hair. Courtney also knocked out several sharks in Action, so maybe Sierra could take down the bear to show how crazy she can be for Cody.

“justin says that sadie isn’t that pretty, and her… *frame* isn’t very attractive” *total roblox drama flashbacks*

That was awesome!! I really love how you think of the dynamics and how the characters are interacting with each other, it's top tier. Would we get an What If Al and Sierra were in Action?

You forgot that Sierra beat a shark in a wheelchair

Love part one and can’t wait for part 2. A what if suggestion for next vid after part 2 is what if Izzy accepted chefs alliance in action when he offered her one.

I loved this video!! Watched the entire way

this is so entertaining and well-written

Trent Cody and Leshawna as a trio 🥰

What if Cody didn’t get injured. What if Katie never switch teams. What if Tyler face his fear. What if Harold didn’t rigged votes

Omg i am loving this so far

This was a pretty neat watch, and I think its cool that some characrers that originally got elimated early can be fleshed out a bit more, but I will say I think Tyler should be doing more, since he's lasted way longer this time around, but hasn't really done anything to justify keeping him around. I think its a big missed opertunity to not include the jock stereotype in the Extreme Sports challenge. I think it would've been cool to have Tyler in place of Harold and either have him win the challenge for the Bass, or screw it up and lose it in his typical clums fasion. As of right now though, He hasn't really done anything of note in this hypothetical and I think he should either have some sort of importance, or get eliminated.

Bro love the videos. Just one what if scenario suggestion. What if Duncan does not quit in Walk like an Egyptian (total drama world tour)

A what if can be what if in world tour izzy and Sierra don’t swap teams (and I haven’t finished the video but can u do a part 2 with action and world tour)

My prediction for part 2: Episode 15: Since we have 12 people left, no one returns. Leshawna still wins. Alejandro could, but I feel like he’d throw it to not put a target on his back. The bass guys are all against Harold, which also brings in Lindsay and Bridgette, which brings in Katie. Alejandro tries to save Harold, but it’s unsuccessful. Harold confesses his love to Leshawna on his way out, which makes Leshawna realise something. Alejandro lied to her. She is out to get Alejandro. Episode 16: Heather noticed Tyler helping Lindsay during the challenge. She wants a plan to break them up, so like the original where she broke Gwen and Trent up, she makes a plan to get Lindsay and Tyler broken up. Alejandro, not wanting Heather to put a target on her back, again, gives a different suggestion; they trick someone to kiss Tyler in order to break up Lindsay and Tyler? Who do I think they’d trick? Since Leshawna is gunning for both of them and she’s a very strong player, I feel like she’d be their target. So Alejandro feels like he should betray Heather to get her out since he has a deal with Lindsay and Tyler, however, she knows it was his plan to frame Gwen, so he wouldn’t want her gone just yet. He assists with the breakup by pretending to apologise to Leshawna then… trips her up to make Tyler and Leshawna kiss. Heather makes sure Lindsay witnesses. Heather wins immunity like the original, and since Leshawna is a stronger player, she’d get targeted in the vote over Tyler. Leshawna knows what Alejandro did so she vites him, and Cody and Trent wouldn’t fall for the truck so easily and would also vote Alejandro. However, it’s not enough to counter Bridgette’s, Katie’s, Alejandro’s, Heather’s, Lindsay’s, Geoff’s and DJ’s votes on Leshawna, and it doesn’t matter what Tyler does. Alejandro gets the final marshmallow and Leshawna is sent home. Episode 17: No Duncan, no guy’s alliance. I feel like Alejandro would last the longest without being caught, and Heather would still find DJ, winning immunity. Tyler, trying to make things up with Lindsay, tries to convince her that he didn’t kiss Leshawna on purpose, Lindsay hears him out and believes him, she’s now out to get Heather for lying. However, she can’t vote Heather since she still has immunity for capturing DJ. Lindsay, Tyler, Cody and Trent make an alliance against Heather and Al. However, since they both have invincibility, they vote Tyler or Lindsay. I think Heather would be annoyed at Tyler, and since Bridgette, Geoff, DJ and Katie believe he cheated on Lindsay, they vote Tyler as well. Tyler is eliminated. Episode 18: Lindsay doesn’t build Heather’s bike, instead she focuses on her own. I think that Trent’s, Bridgette’s, Cody’s, Alejandro’s and Lindsay’s bikes would make it across round 1. Whoever got Heather’s one she had to make herself loses on purpose so she can’t win, but that actually keeps her safe. I think the results would be as follows: 1st - Alejandro 2nd - Lindsay 3rd - Trent 4th - Bridgette Cody wipes out Bridgette is unfairly kicked off. Episode 19: Heather still scares DJ, he still gets out. Uh I am too lazy to finish this 😅 I’ll just predict the final elimination order: 24th-Courtney 23rd-Eva 22nd-Noah 21s-Gwen 20th-Ezekiel 19th-Owen 18th-Izzy 17th-Sierra 16th-Justin 15th-Beth 14th-Sadie 13th-Duncan 12th-Harold 11th-Leshawna 10th-Tyler 9th-Bridgette 8th-DJ 7th-Lindsay 6th-Geoff 5th-Katie 4th-Alejandro 3rd-Cody Finale: Heather vs Trent

Justin X Katie was smth I never knew I wanted CANT EMWAIT FOR P2

Congratulations on 1k subscribers. You totally deserve it.

What you did with Ezekiel was funny! Pushing the girls comment till later to stall Katie and turn her into a power player! W

The butterfly effect makes katie and sadie characters

Guys does this mean the whole season Sierra wasn’t a tdi super fan because this was the first season?

Justin makes people be hypnotised by just a look at him, Alejandro had to flirt

Man just explained an hour of two people in season one and it made my life hmm how can i say this? Less destructive

It’s fine man, take as long as you need :)

A big what if that may take a bit: What if all 68 Total Drama Competitors(TDI, TDWT, ROTI, PI, and TDI2023) all competed in Island 2007

I LOVE THIS 😭❤

After this you should do one for action because this changes the whole timeline !!

The only problem I see with this thought experiment is that now the entire season revolves around Alejandro (and a little bit of Sierra), instead of him just being another camper added to the cast.

Justin X Katie was suprisngly wholesome in this

Amazing video! 😍

I don’t know why but I enjoy these Very cool :)

this is so cool !!!!!!

21:39 LOL I can see that Sierra + Chris scene playing out in my head and it’s hilarious!

I honestly hope kaite makes in far in the season part!

WHAT IF.... in the episode "I see London..." Chris Said that if Zeeke won the challange he would've been allowed back into the game, SO WHAT IF... Noah and Owen never caught Zeeke and he won the challange?

Task: Not have a super fan. (Success full)

Best what if ever! 🎉🎉🎉🎉

I love your videos, they're so creative and interesting, take your time to upload them! Maybe you could make a video about what if everyone of the first cast was on action?

PLEASE NEXT PART IT WAS AMAZING

Holy cow, how do you make these videos so quickly with this quality? Amazing job with this video, I always wondered how TDI would be if Al and Sierra were there.

Master piece

This would also effect world tour, because they wouldnt be new contestsnts....

Ideas: 1. What would have happened if the sisters had not caused the elimination of the best friends in the amazing race? 2. What Would Happen If The Reality Experts And The Sisters Never Make An Alliance? 3. What if The Sisters Came Second In Awesome Race?

Only gripe i have is some of the cartoon plot armor like dj winning the challenge pushing the boat with everyone on like they did in the original, but as soon as you eliminated courtney first i knew you were gonna make some changes with logic, i like hypotheticals like these

35:24 but in the same episode begore she fights the monkeys we know she can run FAST to keep cody safe

You know this reminds e what if Beth did not get the curse idol in bone island

I think Cody should have been the one being damaged since the curse was for the screaming gophers and Sierra was on the Killer Bass team, I actually can see both being Damaged and out of the game. I speculate Gwen and Duncan are coming back on No Pain, No Game, I don’t know what could happen with the diary but she’ll find out at some point, and for Duncan it’ll be justice and he’ll tell that Harold changed the votes so he’ll get eliminated in here, I would say all the truth about Alejandro comes out since Harold at leaving confesses to Leshawna, making her realize what’s going on with his flirting, the alliance he had with Harold, suspect about Gwen’s diary and tell the others Alejandro isn’t trustworthy maybe. I think Gwen and Duncan are important additions (like, who can get enough of Duncan?), this also means there’ll not be more non elimination episodes, on my way for part 2 lol, on search and destroy, Trent leaves like on the original, that’s why I added Gwen, I don’t see any of it changing. After that I would like this to be the elimination order: Katie (some sort of betrayal because she choses heather, it could be Geoff’s fault because of Bridgette being upset since she supported her, or simply Heather doing another slay) Tyler (also got manipulated by heather but instead of Lindsay it was him, and now Lindsay changed his mind and she still says what heather deserves on this episode) DJ Bridgette (similar to her og elimination but on this episode) Geoff Leshawna Gwen Alejandro Heather (She must be shaved, Duncan helps Lindsay) Duncan and Lindsay wins 🖤💛 (but I would also love a Lindsay vs Heather)