不应该是Esther Yu吗？Esther Xu是谁？

是Esther Yu好吗, 可以换吗

Pls make subtitel for XIN team Miss U 3000

I won't skip adv for esther video only and watch it again and again

It should be Esther Yu not Xu. Please edit the title

She suits her hair down so bad normally it's in them pony tails

abissispoppinn 247 she has really beautiful hair, I’m jealous

I was shocked by her vocals the most!

AGAIN DANGGGG

very true!

Love your Profile Picture.

Lol I was cleaning my screen crazily 😂 Nice DP

@@arhoziinyuthe3263 i thought it was a hair

Yeah. I play it again and again

@@thuyduonghoangthi1716 I thought too🤣

Hey this is popular

Not really unpopular, everyone knows that. She first auditioned as a vocalist, later became the rookie rapper.

I love her so much omg

Fr

🍌🍌🍌🍌

Please vote for Shaking ❤

P T I’ll vote for Esther

I know right I feel this song become meaningful when they performed this song

It’s Jiayou lol

Jiayou!!!!😂

*accepted

@@feedmemilo thank you

phet Kkc i think Esther don’t fit center position

Luna Vermillion She obviously improved and did well as a center in this. She has the stage presence and is eye catching even though she isnt the best out of the 109 girls. Everyone is always commenting how she is unsuitable or not as good as others. Stop being so salty,. Give her a break...

@@lunav.8363 ohh please she is PERFECT ok... i guess your eyes js filled with dirt clean it up and watch the vid again babe😉🙄. U'll know she is the vest

Shaking my queen she's an all-rounder ❤️❤️❤️

She's originally a vocalist

Swear😘😘

True that's why she is part of my top 9: Esther(visual/entertainer/always the one who will answer every interview hehe), shaking(the all rounder), babymonster ann(main dancer), fhramm (noona rapper), xiaotang (cool dancer), xin lui (vocal/handsome unnie), kiki(vocal/sexy unnie) (2 slots is still open for me can't decide who'll it be)

I like her best♡

Trương Khánh breathing and a little more of support, but yes she is quite good

Nope, take a look at their final performance "Hunt". This time there is no sound editor to help them.

Pars its just the song that doesnt fit her voice and there is a lot of dancing so shes out of breath most of the time. like the comment said she just need more training

@@chuuchuutrain5646 Indeed. Unfortunately, this weakness was amplified by her being the center which led to the undermining of the entire team :/

Can't agree more!

she's a well established actress after all.

They won?

Shaking is a vocalist before she turn to rap....

@@user-cg5pb2mo5f No they don't won

I agree, she's one of my top picks!

@@nurulnadzri490 really? Her vocals and her tone particularly it's beautiful

She's originally a vocalist before she tried rapping about 2 years ago

Her original goal is to be a vocalist but her trainer advised her to try with rapping. Just like Moonbyul from Mamamoo.

Shaking's voice is killin' me too :) very soft

@@silverbullet4438 yess

Her singing style is like G.E.M

She made it to the top 20, so she was not underrated. Unlike other survival shows, top vocalists were not guaranteed a final spot in YWY2. In fact, all the best vocalists were eliminated.

she kinda reminds me of a younger version of Ella

Perfect Students I think she is underrated by the international viewers

@@perfectstudents8361 true... but yuyan was not

Hope u get over your hate at roada being underrated cause roada will go on a kpop show girls planet 999 and she might debut in kpop...let's support this talent beauty again

I like her very much but they didn't win :(

She was a vocalist before becoming a rapper

Unique love the tone of her voice

@@carryingyourheart Yes her voice is unique and catchy as well!

@@minhhuongngo755 Yes! That's why I'm glad that she proved herself to the audience who don't know about her vocal.

Shaking voice is so good..it is more emotional.. and I want her cover this song

Shaking voice suit this song so well

I'm obssesed with Shaking voice and her emotion when she sings this song

face it, you like it cause of Esther Yu, nothing else.

Shaking's voice is so hauntingly beautiful. I'd love to see her perform more as a lead vocalist in the next performances :)

But Boo is vert cute 😍😍😍

💕💕

BooBooBear4U2 vote for her then at iqiyi app

Ekkkk i want too

Lmao saw your comment on another video with the exact same thing 😂😂

I agree, but I want more Serious Esther than the Funny one. I think it's cringe to see her childish type. It's just my opinion :)

I really thought she was talentless but she proved me wrong during this performance. I'm glad cause she's definitely debuting and I didn't want her to be dead weight on the team. My worries have been put to rest 👍

Does she really in this group?? Because what I remember is Lin Xiu sing this song..and Esther in how can i look so good team right?

@@yeonieee1 if she's always serious , how is she gonna cheer people up? 😐

she can sing but she's not stable ...

Me me, ester and zhao Xiaotang plus snow kong doing rap. Woww, is that a telepathy?

+1

Same! I know Esther is an actress and has a big following already unlike the other trainees so it wasn't a surprise that she got a lot of votes. But this 2nd round, Esther is showing how worthy she is of those votes and that she too is talented and passionate. I love seeing the growth her growth and seeing the other girls challenging themselves.

@@caryljannielazo4988 No, Esther hasn't a big following before... There are many trainees are popular than her. She is no1 not by her famous before this show.

Tabi Nani she is an actress plus shes one of the richest people in china so she is definitely recognized and well known even before going to this show

Me too🥺🥺

same

Love her❤️❤️

yeah it's pretty cool

Yesssss❤️❤️

Omaigash,look at the first part,the eyes are actress

Esther is an actress tho

She is amazing , she want to be a idol, and have acting experience , she combined those two o__o she is smart ... she need to debut omg

Yes she is amazing she also sing 2 ost for her drama "Since I Meet you" for ive fallen for you and "Love Exercise" for amazing boufriend 2

I like how she dance,so nice

same girl.. i always voted Esther in iQIYI.

Same Esther is the best!!!!!!

me too 😍😘

Lol ...I voted too n she won hahaha

Yess and also she deserves it after all the unnecessary hate she received. 🥺🥺🥺

yesss i love heeerrr

Ikr! Easther Yu is good and all but can't they spare a minute to appreciate Roada Xu's vocal? Even Lu K can sing Easther Yu's part but Roada Xu's part was so hard to cover 😤😤

@@dreamcatcher5526 i think it's mostly because we know that Roada Xu can sing very well so it's not surpriing that she can do the difficult part but since alot of people said that Esther Yu had bad vocals and no dance skills its surprising to see her vocals being good and her dancing improving

she’s not underrated at all everyone knows that her vocals are outstanding

yes i agree becos she's so different here

She sang a song as OST of a drama, and cover some Korean songs, you need to listen 😁

Phuong Truc Le to be honest, I’ve heard the Korean songs she covered and didn’t believe it was her because the voice is totally different, but after listening this, I believe it

同意 哭慘了😢

This performance really changed the way I think of Esther Yu, very well done by her

People giving her a hard time when she can pull herself just fine... she knows she isn't that good, but she continuosly strives to be better and we can see the results... Esther Yu is like Sohye (in produce101) an actress who doesn't have basic dancing and singing skills but always shows unexpected charms (and they get eventually become decent singers and dancers - okay for an idol group) But ugh, this is unrelated but one of the Rocket Girls (PD101 china debut group) even after a year of debut, is still very bad in basic skills...

Well, she's sung an ost before..

@@delacruzjuan6972 yes yes i agree with you..ppl can't see esther's charms cuz they thought she can only act but they dont know that esther can really sing and dance.

Esther is good...

Twice stole My wig maybe because these videos are auto tuned, I watched her in the live version and she really isn’t the best

@@JayZinger This videos are not auto tuned. It's their real voice.

ikr, her voice is unique aswell

Soo "very good" to an extent where even the mentor can indefinitely point out her instability and elaborated how her being the centre has severely brought down the team, unlike the other team's centre. Update- It seems like you fans are too immersed and gloated in the pleasure of these rare praises of your idol to realize what Ella said at the end of her performance. The key factor as to why the opposing team won over her team was the fact of how well their lead vocal sang in an effort of harmonizing her and her members which overall enhanced the entirety of the performance. To give a bit of context as to why Esther Yu's team underperformed despite having just as great or even greater of a vocal girl on their team, it was due to the instability of Esther Yu in the effort of attempting her first simultaneous task of dancing and singing as the center which she so eagerly seeks for, the vocal girl couldn't showcase her vocal as it would disrupt the flow and tone of the song. Now, the weakness of Esther Yu that led to the nullification of the strength of her member now became the greater supporting case of the victory of the opposing team. Am I right of that claim?

@@jaydenjee427 everyone knows Esther doesn't have a very good vocal but you should see her improvements and hard works . She is way more better now

Please vote for Shaking ❤. She is so talented. She is beautiful and good dance rap sing

Lol you must be missed xin liu ver. That much better than this one

@@flipflop2628 your name reminds me with my assignment :"

Me tooo. Lov shaking

Yo can't believe they lose

Yass!!

such a turn on dkaslmdklas

Please vote for Shaking ❤. She is so talented. She is beautiful and good dance rap sing

Although her voice is suitable for rapping, I would love to see more DEEP SEXY voices like hers in girl groups. I really miss the days of SNSD and 2NE1 when girl groups have so many different voices blending together and creating a unique and powerful mix.

She's totally talented. I pick her👌🏻

I watched her performance,, and I really like it !!

Same!!!

Yes,She,Jenny zhen,yanyu come from same show,that time she vocal.That time shaking eliminates early.The show top2:yanyu top5:Jenny zhen

the improved ones were Hana Lin and Joey Chua because they tried something spiced and they even went out on their shells but on the previous contest of youth with you s2, Esther always goes to sweet/attractive/lovely songs. I also appreciate Shaking, An Qi and Xin Liu for choosing other songs and went out on their shell to try different type. Esther improved but if she keeps on doing the same routine in choosing songs, I bet she can't make it to top 9. She was only chosen as Top 1 just because of the votes. But. if we talk about performance and will be ask if who are the Top 9 most outstanding trainees of youth with you Season 2, Esther is not on my list.

@@sweetsellelasapin7816 No matter who will make it to the top nine later, they must be the best people with their abilities ... I only start off those who try really hard, And Esther Yu did it ... Of course the others also did very well, and I wish them all the success

Sweetselle Lasapin the top 9 is chosen by votes, it’s not esthers fault that she is loved. she knows what makes her look good. she may not be on ur list but she’s definitely on others’

@@sweetsellelasapin7816 ha dude who hurt you? Just vote for your girl and being useful to your girl, esther will be on top 9, just show this ability and become 1st trending topic weibo, she is powerful atractive and talented

@@sweetsellelasapin7816 LOL. Keep that Joey comparison to yourself. Joey always make obvious mistakes in the performance. She just gets lucky that Yu Yan is her teammate. Hana Lin, Naho & Esther have all made very significant improvements in their singing & dancing. Whereas Joey's singing & dancing are still weak & she can't even emote well in Ambush On All Sides & R&B All Night

Nice

Same!!

Same

Yesss

Same!

Unique voice,, i agree with u She's multi talented !!

Yes she is hope she can make it to rank 9 cause she really deserve to debut. she's my bias❤️

No. She's THE best

I wish they won too. But all the trainers picked the other team

Girlgroup and Boygroup Lover Not all actually . Jony J chose them.

For me i feel that Team B is better in terms of vocal and their teamwork, sorry thats my personal opinion, tho i must say i really love Roada voice. Overall both groups sang really beautiful for a beautiful song

B is much better bruh

Although Team already did a good job, I can feel their vocal ability is not as good as the other team (on average). Even Shaking and Esther need to improve their control of breaths. The other team did much better in controlling their voice.

Same, i cant get out of my head that presentation, but this was another thing

If you watch her performance don't ask (first performance of her) eventhough she only get little part but her expression really on point too

PP Lalin yeah, if I were to compare I liked Esther yu, shaking the best while on the other group I liked xiaotang, meddhi. But because the song required lots of vocals and team B overall vocal performances was better they won.

Shaking's vocals was good but unfortunately its too shaky even too my liking, no pun intended.

@@geri911 shaking is shaking 😂🤣💕

@@thanawatjaisut3573 hahaha, it does have a beautiful tone she just needs more control and then its perfection! I like Shaking a lot too, but yeah that's the honest review. ;)

@@thanawatjaisut3573 Sorry I have no emoji in my keyboard to show you how hard I'm laughing now.

These days they don't show his reaction, especially to her performance.

I think iqiyi know that some people ship kun and esther, so these days they didn't show kun reaction about esther team

A powerful duo of Shaking Chloe and Lu Keran. Esther Yu shouldn't be classified as any threat.

@@jaydenjee427 what was the point that youre saying this LOL i mean, even jony j said she is the only one who stand out in her group

Lu zhang and mheddi from team B had great voice and combination, I almost cried but i cant cause theres someone in my room. TEAM B IS MORE EMOTIONAL. as you can see there are some trainees who cried and compliment them more, the coaches also compliment them more than TEAM A thats why they LOSEE

@@jaydenjee427 ohhh im right i saw youre comments a lot about hating esther hahaha😂😏

Lisa and other mentors chose Team B, so i dont believe that you are a great judge for this show, you are out. Lol but really tho Team B did better that team A, yes of couse team A is pretty good but team B's voice outshines them.

if you focused on her, you'll see shes a very kind person to her teammates and really supportive of them, most people don't notice bcs iqiyi only show scenes of her being funny

Best comment ever! 😭😭😭😭

Yasss

2008 JYP √ 2011 SM √ 2013 CUBE √

she has so much potential and i think shes one of the best vocalists on the show

@@lovezone6768 Agree

That was a big sad. Because this time when her mother actually agreed to her dream, it's complicated for her to survive this show because of the weirdness of votes. Talented ones are more likely to be underrated in this show.

What is weibo??

Weibo is basically the Chinese version of Twitter