The comment about most K-pop dances having too many formation changes.. I understand that things having a reason doesn't change how much you like them but.. most K-pop choreos are made for groups so the formation changes when the member singing does, taemin is a solo artist, the choreo doesn't have to draw your attention to someone else so there is fewer formation changes by nature, because he just doesn't need as many

“It was delicate but he slaps you in the face” omg yes! Lmao it’s exactly Taemin’s style

The comment about the dancers throwing off their bonds did not take into account that this was filmed during the pandemic and the dancers were required to wear masks so they couldn’t take off the bonds as they did during rehearsal

I love listening to all of your insights, but I think some of the comments are unfair. Taemin goes both harder and softer on the live performances depending on how much effort he has to do on his vocal parts. The dance always suffers in the cinematic versions, especially for a solo artist, but that Stage in particular could have been much better. The Stage for Black Rose instead is *chef kiss* (on that note, pleeeeeease react to Black Rose)

I love how everyone melted at taemin’s cuteness and heart at the end of the dance practice 😤♥️

I agree about the camera work for a lot of these Kpop videos. I’m not even a dancer but I get so frustrated when the camera is flying around and zooming and missing half of the choreo, particularly with an artist like Taemin who is not only a phenomenal dancer in his own right but also creates some spectacular shapes and textures with his wonderful backup dancers. And like you said, much of that is sacrificed so they can show off some dynamic camerawork that is usually overkill anyway… it is always a huge shame and it is why I will always prefer dance practice videos with the fixed cameras. It is only then that the true artistry of a performance and a choreo can be seen! (Let’s not even talk about the “dance practice” videos that try to “spice” it up with unnecessary camerawork! 🤦‍♀️) I really appreciated this video and all the reactions from the dancers. Thanks for showing them Taemin’s Criminal! This is definitely one of my favorite choreos from him!

Taemin is called the Kpop King of the industry and the same with his dance line, which is insane, unique and incomparable, all his choreos and performances are another level, Criminal is not just a dance, he has this concept of the syndrome stockholm, which is associated with the lyrics of the song and with how well Taem personifies that ... that's what is special about him when he dances and that choreo won the MAMA awards in his country last year. I suggest you react to "Famous" and "ADVICE" his most recent release.

I really appreciate professional dancer's and performer's opinion on artists like Taemin. I find his style refreshing and beautifully complex, but having professionals taking their time to evaluate the technical side of his performances is a perspective I think is necessary for kpop fans like me that want objective opinions on an artist, rather than just reactions to the artist himself based on a fan's opinion. I really enjoyed this, and I look forward to your perspectives on other performances!

Just to let you all know he has been dancing since he was 10 years old up to present at 28 years old but right now he is in the military.

You should have them watch his performance of this song at the 2020 KBS Song Festival. I guarantee you they won't think the dance practice was better. That performance blows all others out of the water. He adds a lot to the choreo in terms of popping and locking and there is a new intro as well. It's basically Taemin showing off and feeling his groove in a BIG WAY! Link: kzfaq.info/get/bejne/a7aRoqug27e1lI0.html

i don’t think the sm the stage was taemin’s peak performance for criminal. no offense to shindong but his directions are either a hit or miss. for example, the black rose performance on sm the stage was great but they didn’t do justice for criminal. 🤷🏻‍♀️ i don’t mind the criticism, i just wish you guys watch a better performance video for criminal.

Taemin can sing, he is the king

he makes me super proud to be a kpop fan.

Thank you for sharing your thoughts on this majestic choreography, Taemin is the greatest dancer today and has brutal control of his body for every beat and detail of the song and embodies what he wants to perform well. I hope you react to ADVICE, IDEA, WANT and in general all his dance practices and performances, by the way he has the most unique and versatile choreos in terms of movements.

wow，love it. Taemin is another level.

I just love how the dancers were completely out of breath and he was just like "what a nice workout, can we start now?"

Taemin is Art!! ❤

It was quite interesting to hear your opinions about the camera work for his performance video cause so many fans complained about the camera work when it was released. I do agree that the camera work could've been so much better to show the full potential of that amazing performance...

Taemin is unique, creative, incredible

Love your comments! (Criminal is about Stockholm Syndrome relationship.) And yeah totally Thriller vibes at times :) Hope you'll also react to Taemins's Sayonara Hitori (Goodbye) performance from/on Hit The Stage :) and his Black Rose song performance!

You should showed them [2020 Mama] Taemin_intro + Criminal+Haeven + IDEA.

the point about the cinematic choices changing the whole outlook on the choreo bc of busy camerawork is spot on. even on regular krn music shows u get dizzy watching camera/angles switching constantly. i wish theyd calm down a bit. as for them concentrating on the soloist in the performance..yeah thats a given. and as someone else pointed out, for groups some of the busy camera work is necessary to focus on each members parts in the choreo (reason being soloshots/fancams of each individual member to satisfy fans needs and ofc to show off details of the choreo). usually individual fancams and a group dance version shot gets released for musicshows alongside the version that airs on broadcast in the end - a combination of the two.

I am so waiting for this bcoz I miss our baby cheese. . .

You know.... Y'all have to react to his studio choom video, performing 'ADVICE'. bet you won't stop opening your lips in amazement😍

I wonder what would you guys say about Taemin's ADVICE?

Please react to Taemin's black rose.

Hi Emeroy, I've looked in on your channel before so recognized your face right away. Hi! The commentary was good, but I think that Taemin's actual SM Town performance video - the original release would have been a much better example for you all to be watching as it reflected the complete elements of their vision. The one you chose was OK, but that was the first time I'd actually seen that particular video. K-pop artists feed off their audience exponentially, and during the pandemic, I've heard many artists discuss that its just not the same energy for them, which makes them feel they are not giving their 100% ( they don't feel the same energy when performing ) - meaning in this instance, I think the music video would have been a much better option. (Not to mention you would have benefit of the subtitles to go along and get a true feeling for all elements of the concept.) Taemin is all about telling the story, vs fancy bells and whistles we see with other groups. One of your commentators mentioned that the transitions in the dance were considerably limited in comparisons to other groups. very true. Again he is all about the story vs the formula that others expect. consider discussing his performance here perhaps.. kzfaq.info/get/bejne/nqyBf5pzuJzQoqc.html I was glad that at least one of you are aware of the K-pop culture and I am pretty sure she was aware of Taemin's work from the past. I could tell she loved what she was seeing and was surprised at some of the comments from the others. With the exception of her, excuse my analogy, but otherwise this commentary felt much like a group of pachyderm judging the dancing concepts of a group of lemmings. (nothing wrong with this... but )There are two separate ideals in place and while one can be objective - often its difficult to understand the difference in perception between the two groups. I would also like to add, there was some discussion regarding how much popping should be seen, but sometimes the restraint of a movement tells a much bigger story. Cheers! I have subscribed and look forward to watching other review in the future. :)

Definitly react to advice and idea by taemin

The song is about the Stockholm Syndrome. But in the MV, Taemin is both the victim and the criminal, and is connected to his relationship with Fame. And I agree with Brandon, I like the rehearsal video more than the "The Stage" performance video cause I can see the full choreography with a steady camera. There's a better stage though on a year end show last year, I think KBS special. Thank you guys for this mini analysis.

Most of the comments seem a bit unfair ngl. But, appreciate the honesty. And, its not because I'm just some crazy fan girl, I genuinely welcome valid critique, but this felt unfair at times. But, yeah, maybe its a culture thing.

Please react to NCT U Make a wish and Taemin IDEA dance practice

sometimes the energy can be a bit iffy cause they have to practice over and over just so they can get the right take. they had probably rehearsed it multiple times before the actual video so i can see why they might not have tons of energy in some of their movements.

yes he is michael jackson korea I wish there was a reaction like this in Taemin's video "IDEA"

Taemin 'Advice and idea' please

This is so cool!!! Love this video!

i hope there'll be more serious reactions with them to taemin

wait, yall pro dancers, right? i seriously want yall to cover a taemin choreography of your choice and post it on YT. I would be interesting to see how yall will execute it. please please please!

Thankyou for this reaction, i really love hearing insightful comment from professional, not biased comment but from professional perspective.. i like this kind of content more actually ;)

I LOVED IT!! Thank you for showing them criminal by taemin 🤟🏽🤟🏽

Please react for Hoshi's Spider choreography and Studio Choom performance! I think that's a great example of Hoshi's skills as a choreographer, and might give some insight into how he choreographs for Seventeen.

i hope in the future you guys can react more of taemin, thankyou :)

I love listening to all the opinions. This really has become my favorite Taemin song so I just can't get enough of watching this choreo.

*TAEMIN’S IMPACT*

TAEMIN increíble .Hace ARTE único en el kPOP Plis reaccióna a IDEA .y ADVICE .💎

And I think you haven't reacted to TAEMIN new MV #Advice There is no dance practice for this but you can react /BE ORIGINAL ver Or 'Advice' @Beyond live (stage ver.) on SHINee channel.

I’m thankful that I knew Taemin before this video.

I enjoyed this reaction so much ❤

Please let them react to Taemin idea & advice

Ignore me... It's just me having to rewatch because taemin distracted me again

I understand everyone's different opinion on Kpop and I really enjoy those diverse thoughts

Tanks for react to king of kpop... Taemin Amaizing dancer.... plisss more react to Taeminni Idol of idol... Danger performance pliss

thank you so much for the insights! honestly this channel and emeroy's main channel is so underrated. yall are one of the few legit professional dance reactors who give honest insights and not just giving the viewers too comical/big reactions. i appreciate that. looking forward for more!! lots of love from the philippines :)))

I wish I remember the names of the choreographers :) need to look it up again

You guys really need to react to the Creme a la creme when it comes to amazing choreography and dancing. Move by TAEMIN. It has been described as "The Granddaddy of all hard choreos". Please!

Check out his actual Criminal mv

I’d like to see your reaction to taemin’s famous as well unless there’s already one?

my favorite performance of this was in one of the end of the year performances. i'd love more group reactions like this to taemin and shinee! as an aside, i wanted to hear more opinions of the ladies

Since the song is Criminal, he paid homage to Michael Jackson. He's a huge fan of his. Taemin started it he had one wish, it would be talk to Michael Jackson.

Not yall busting UwU’s from that last scene🙄🤚 **is currently deleting 27 screenshots of that moment from my camera roll**

please react to 7th sense by NCT U !!! it's so strong, hard and charismatic 🤲🏻

React to black rose and idea also please

Please do Taemin’s songs Advice and Idea!!!!!

I recommend his Move mv and his Idea mv both quite different

LIKE THAT!!!!!

I hope you can judge the performances on Streen Man Fighter and share your insights if the show judges made the right call coz there have been noise about the qualifications and judgment calls made by the show's judges from viewers.

If you guys could react to Ateez that’d be so cool 🥺 here are some recommendations if you can: -Hala Hala -Answer -Fireworks -Pirate King -Thanxx -Wonderland

Please react to shinee's don't call me and taemin's advice

You should do more vids like this

Now I NEED to see your reaction to "blue orangeade" or "crown" by txt. I love kpop and dancing so I usually learn the choreos that I like but istg I can’t with those two.

Please remember they are critiqued, judged, etc. as you all have been as well. A lot of these artists and dancers have been performing like you for years, 10 plus or more. I appreciate your critique but a lot of them are true professional dancers with years of training and experience as well. Please post some of your performances as individuals and groups and ask them to provide their opinions, suggestions, critique too. I am sure they would enjoy it as performers and dancers.😁

its quite refreshing to hear honest critique actually. thanks for the reviews + reactions

Pls react to more Kpop dance practices! It’s very nice seeing everyone’s reaction

React another Taemin dance video pleaseee, i want to hear dancer thought!

색다르네요. 보는 방법이 좋아요 😀^-^

A lot of fans were annoyed with the camera work in that performance video. Way too gimmicky and literally missed important moments. It took away from the performance instead of giving it the space it deserved. The comment section on that video is probably still riddled with complaints.

Just curious though..Do Choreo will based on music itself or based on Lyrics..What I see is some of Taemin dance choreo is based on how he interpret the lyrics into dance art..

React to IDEA by TAEMIN ❤❤❤❤

If this was a hit, I do recommend Hala Hala by ATEEZ. This one is arguably they’re best one performance/choreo wise. The members go really hard throughout and I think it would be a perfect reaction video. Either practice or performance version.

Pliss reacciona IDE práctica y ADVICE Studio CHOOM FAMOUS.

please react more to seventeen

Pls react to Taemin's Advice🥺🥺🥺

¿ Bailaron juntos Taemin + Jimin? Yes ,Si , THE BEST JIMIN ,ELEGANT HIPNOTICO, UN ANGEL. TAEMIN , NOOOO.

pls pls react to hoshi's spider performance

You guys should really react to TXT! I want to hear your opinions on their new performances Magic and No Rules!

Pls reaction to ( seventeen- call call call )

Please watch KAI - REASON dance practice

Yes because it's all about him only, the back up dancers here are just spice of the performance. And he is singing and just accompanied by dancing. Taemin is a singer (and a dancer) so the camera has to focus to him all the time. But if you want to see his entire crew backing on him, there are some live fancams available. It could have been better if we address Taemin as 'him' and not 'they' coz he is a singular person here. Overall I liked this kind of reaction concept and it's ok to say your honest reaction since you guys are legit performers and dancers as well so it's acceptable if there are some good or bad critic in a good way.

If you wanna see him pop more check “Famous” kzfaq.info/get/bejne/o9WhhJWGsNTDZHU.html

bro, where are more taemin reactions??? i wanna hear more critics analyzing taemin's dancing. I love to hear different opinions and perspectives on his dancing style and techniques. c'mon upload it on YT. also please reconsider on choosing the live performances. artists when they perform live, especially taemin, not just have to focus on dancing and the choreo, but the concept, story-telling, emotions, facial expressions and a whole lot of stuff. plus the costumes also affects and limits the movements. for this particular performance, i can see how he was lacking the energy that he usually receives from the live crowd. he has expressed how it's so draining to perform without the live audience. also, how can one person not love that zombie style dancing in that section? it adds flavor to the choreo and the concept imo. anyways, nice analysis! waiting for more taemin content ❤

More reactions to Taemin and BTS choreography

watching the MV of this might have been better.

Please do a reaction to NCT U - Resonance

please react to KAI Mmmh and reason !!!!!!

Can you do KAI - MMMH next please?

Please reaction to naughty by irene and seulgi

Advice is more powerful!

It’s about Stockholm Syndrome

The videos yall chose of Taemin do not give him justice. If you don't know what Taemin's best dance centered videos are of Criminal ask his fans.

It's about Stockholm syndrome

exo!!!!!!!