Video: Aaron Tveit and Jeremy Jordan who do you prefer? Me: YES.

Jeremy Jordan has a poppier vibe that almost sounds more personal and earnest sometimes, but Aaron has the very clean classical sound and they're both extremely good.

gosh they're so different. Jeremy is way more soft and tentative, while Aaron is powerful and deep. Neither could sing like the other but they're both so good

Can they just team up with Jonathan Groff and Andrew Rannells

Apples and Oranges. Jeremy has an immediate emotional connection, Aaron has a power that's visceral. Taught both of them, and they were filled with such joy when they sang it was impossible not to bring your A game.

So I need a duet with them...now. We needed it yesterday.

I find Aaron really engaging, but with Jeremy, I forget he's singing. I just get caught up in the story and emotions. I could watch him all day :)

Jeremy Jordan makes me feel emotions because of his superb acting and Aaron Tveit makes me sob because of his angelic voice. man, they’re both just perfect

Hmmm.... for me Aaron is a singer who acts; Jeremy is an actor who sings.

When Jeremy, sings, I forget that he is performing. It’s like he speaks directly to my heart.

I feel like y’all tend to forget that Aaron Tveit used to be a straight up voice major and grew up singing classical music OF COURSE HES EFFORTLESS

I'm terribly in love with both. Aaron's voice is like an Angel, and the songs that require holding that perfect note for a longer time. But Jeremy.... He pulls your heart out and wrings your emotions dry. I want both!!!

how is aaron tveit so effortless

In the immortal words of Tulio and Miguel. Both. Both is good.

Each is individually extraordinary. I do not want to compare because that would infer that one is better than the other. Their styles are so different, it's just a matter of taste because both have the ability to touch your soul and bring out such emotion that you tear up. Love them both!! I'd love to hear a duet!

Aaron has a voice that truly allows one to float to the music. But Jeremy (my love) has a voice that punches at your heart and forces you to feel the emotions that he's projecting. That's me anyway.

I LOVE Jeremy but you put Aaron vs anyone else and I will say Aaron everytime. His voice brings actual tears to my eyes.

Tveit has the clarity of classical training in an almost athletic sense. He is a gifted acrobat. Jordan is Mario Lanza. Both are precious natural resources who live their sound in different ways. Keep singling out this kind of talent and putting it out where others might find such pleasure. Thanks for your efforts

oof every time I hear Aaron Tveit's voice I swoon

While I wouldn't say one is definitely better than the other I thought it could be fun just to judge which of their voices better suits the songs they sing here. Maria: Aaron. There's something more classical about his voice that suits the abstract orchestral style of the song. Run Away With Me: Jeremy. That fucking BELT. Tonight: Aaron for the same reason as with Maria, though I appreciate Jeremy's more personal and grounded version more here. Out There: Aaron. This one was very close but that last note in Aaron's version killed me. Bring Him Home: Aaron. Not my favorite use of falsetto from Jeremy here (though I know he can use falsetto beautifully as we see later in this video). Take Me or Leave Me: Aaron. Simply an iconic performance that I listen to almost daily. Waving Through a Window: Jeremy. I like the brassiness (if that's the right word) in his voice here. to be fair to Aaron the audio quality isn't very good. Why God Why: Aaron. ARMS. I Can Go the Distance: Jeremy. He comes across more youthful and energetic here which I think is important for the song. Oh What a Beautiful Morning: Jeremy. His voice just really pulled at my heart here.

I generally prefer Aaron Tveit's vibrato and voice, though Jeremy Jordan's singing is always really soulful. They're both very good, but if I had to pick one to see, it would be Aaron.

Both are terrific, my personal preference is Aaron for clarity.

Listen... I’m in love with both of them. But for those higher belting notes I feel like Jeremy sometimes sounds like he’s straining his voice whereas Aaron seems to hit them without effort. But they are both insanely talented

I love Jeremy but Aaron has my heart!

Can we get aaron as enjolras again and jeremy as eigher grantaire or marius

Not fair to ask us to choose! Love them both, but I have been an Aaron fan forever!!

Both are very talented. I'm going with Aaron this time

I love me some Aaron Tveit, but Jeremy Jordan is the most perfect person I've ever had the pleasure of hearing.

For me it will always be Jeremy Jordan. Aaron is amazing, but he never reaches into my chest and rips my heart out. Plus Jeremy has incredible breath control. He can hold out a note FOREVER!!!

Jeremy Jordan all the way ❤

People tend to forget that Jeremy CAN sound as clean as Aaron during the more classical tunes but chooses not to in order to express the emotions of the song. It’s just a matter of choice for how he chooses to express his voice in these clips.

Technically, equal. Emotionally, we all know

I love them both, but Jeremy is the best!!

I love Aaron’s voice!!

They are both talented singers and actors, but Jeremy Jordan has always been one of my favorites. His voice is just amazing and always speaks to me.

Both Aaron Tveit and Jermey Jordan are fine, but Aaron Tveit is my Quarantine Discovery. His interpretation of "Merry Me a Little" was the best acted ever. Somebody please star Aaron Tveit in Company on Broadway!

I love both so much, but Jeremy wins for me as he pushes so much emotion and heart into his songs. They are emotional performances. They give me feelies. Aaron... a little cold. A little technical. He rarely breaks my heart the way Jeremy Jordan does almost EVERY TIME.

God, wow I love them both so much and their both so talented, if I had to pick Aarron

I love Aaron’s voice

I love the way Aaron portrays love. He just looks like he loves so deeply and fully when he sings. Jeremy sings like he’s a teenager in love and it’s brilliant. I love them

Why choose? Both are incredible and I would love for them to play opposite one another. Their voices together would be 👌🏻

Aaron Tveit's voice and interpretation are just perfect.

Both of them are great, Aaron has a cleaner and more technically correct voice, but I prefer the color in Jeremy's voice, he really touches your soul in a more intimate way.

I see Jeremy jordan aarom tveit and just click. It's lemons and limes, both citrus but significantly different

The thing that blows me away is that they've both gotten better as they've aged and they were incredible to start

I love Aaron and yes he is beautiful and the way he portrays his characters is really enjoyable Yo watch but Jeremy is literally on a whole OTHER FRICK FRACKING LEVEL OKAY-

Forever my favorite broadway boys. Can't choose. The world needs both of them. ♥️♥️

They are both so talented! They cannot and don't need to be compared!

Okay, but I just got to hear two of my crushes sing my name over and over again. I can now die happy.

Both are joy to hear and listen to. Apples and oranges is the best way to describe the two. Having seen both their work live it is nothing short of a joy to witness their talent. Dissect their differences as performers all you wish but what they each bring to the theater community is a gift we should all be grateful for.

Jeremy is great and all... but Aaron is just otherworldly. Especially in Next To Normal.

I know this is a few years old now but I love Aaron so much. His Take me or Leave me with Gavin is too amazing.

Two crazy talented men, but I´m team Aaron all the way.

Jeremy broke my heart when I saw the video of him in Newsies, and Aaron destroyed me when I saw him in Next to Normal on Broadway. Both are extraordinary

Jeremy Jordan is my favorite person, no joke, it's kinda an issue. I'm working my way thru watching every movie, tv show, play/musical, and YT vid of him available. I rly need to work on schoolwork, but I mean.....priorities

I find it wonderful that most of the comments admit to the phenomenal talents of both these wonderful stars.

I think Aaron is just technically soo on the mark and sings so effortlessly

Jeremy recently sang Bring him home at Carnegie Hall. It is glorious!!!

They are both so wonderful. We're blessed to be able to hear them and their unique qualities for free on KZfaq whenever we want!

Aaron: I’m not trying to make you a wife here Me:..............could you though??

Ive known Aaron for more time but something about Jeremy got to my heart in the fucking first note. When he sings he makes you feel so many things, gosh

Aaron is a Barcelona Chair and Jeremy is a Wingback Armchair. Depending on mood a perfect fit. Fall into them .

I love love love both of them. Had the amazing opportunity to see them both live! They are both phenomenal. Jeremy has this presence like he is absolutely having the time of his life when he sings and performs for people. Something about that just pulls you in and makes you feel like you're in the audience with him even when watching a youtube video. Not many people do that.

I don't know about the rest but no one, and I repeat NO ONE can top Aaron Tveit's performance of Take me or leave me with Gavin Creel

Jeremy Jordan should play Fiyero in the Wicked movie

I love newsies and waitress and everything Jeremy Jordans in but like Aaron tveit. He's freaking perfection.

It's amazing how evenly split the comment section seems to be!! I have to say Jeremy Jordan snags the win for me though. He never sacrifices emotion OR technique, he's perfect to me

They are both so talented ...but...Jeremy Jordan....

Stop comparing them Both are amazing vocalists Only compare in ur own mind

Jeremy's singing is truly an extension of dialogue. As it should be. He's such a good actor. His range is effortless. I love Aaron just as much for different reasons

How could I ever choose between my two loves? I've been familiar with Aaron a lot longer, so was my first love. But Jeremy grew on me. I wish both of them could be cast in the same show.

Never hear of Aaron before. He is incredible, and I can tell he is classically trained too. However, I still enjoyed Jeremy more. So my personal choice is Jeremy. But they are two incredible tenors and Aaron has incredible vocals

Love them both! So much talent!

Its super interesting because they both grsduated from the same college. Also maybe one of the reasons that Aaron sounds so clear and classical is because he first majored into vocal music but switched to musical theater

I love them both - for different reasons. They're both absolutely fantastic!

Two great singers in their own right, no need to compare.

I personally prefer Aaron but they are both brilliant actors and singers

Jeremy's tonality 🤤🤤🤤

this was in my youtube home recommendations and im not even complaining!! i love them both

You found some songs that I never knew they sang! Great job finding the songs!

I’m so glad you created this video. It’s really amazing how talented they both are. They each have their own unique gifts. I really enjoyed them both tremendously🎉

Jeremy's voice 🤯🤯

both my favorite singers... been watching their shows and performances . been a fan

I love Aaron Tveit. He has an incredible voice. But Jeremy Jordan is THE voice. It’s other-worldly.

I listen to both these lovelies daily, love them both. Jeremy just does something for my emotions though.

This was amazing! These are my top 2 favorite leading men!

You don’t compare to Jeremy. He’s his own category of incredible 👌

They’re both glorious!!!

If I had to chose I would say Aaron Tveit as Jeremy's voice is a slightly darker at times, however both of their vibratros are amazing. Jeremy also blends better with other singers. However, Aaron Tveit has a voice that just makes me say wow.

My two favorite people... nothing better than this. Instant seratonin.

Jeremy is great... but Aaron is the image of perfection

Ps...this compilation was heaven! Thank you!

Aaron has great range and he's very smooth. But, Jeremy has a way of hitting you with the emotion so it doesn't feel like a performance every time. Jeremy Jordan is my vocal preference.

I can't compare them, I love them both! (Aaron’s “Out There” and Jeremy’s “Run Away with Me” were both flawless, though!❤)

Omg both of my musical theater celebrity crushes

just... hear me out a sec...Aaron Tveit and Jeremy Jordan singing together "Agony" from Into The Woods...I'm just gonna leave it there and go slowly...

You really cant compare these two. Their vocal training is completely different. Jeremy has more of a musical theater sound, while aaron has a classical base with any style of singing on top of that. Which is why his voice is so rich, because he uses the pharynx space way more then Jeremy does. Which is why Aaron's voice can have that intense thick cry, its especially noticable during El tango de roxanne. While Jeremys cry sounds more thin because its not as well placed (but just as healthily placed) just a different style. Both fantastic singers and id do anything for either of them. Of course thats just my unprofessional opinion as a voice student who wants to be a voice teacher.

Nooooo i cant choose!!! Jeremy I feel has emotion in his voice, but Aaron does too, it's just more classical feeling. Both are amazing though, I can't choose a favorite!!!!

When I want to swoon, I listen to Aaron. When I want to cry, I listen to Jeremy.

I’ve seen Aaron perform live 9 times. He is a much better singer of any genre they perform.