Get access to all of my videos WEEKS before they come out on KZfaq. www.patreon.com/onceuponanislandchannel

I always knew that Colby lost this season at the FTC due to not apologising or feeling remorse for Jerri, since she was the swing vote. But now I realised how BADLY he treated the entire tribal council, not even saying any closing speech. Wow it is underratedly awful.

You overlooked that Colby is the first person in Survivor history to straddle two alliances simultaneously (Tina/Keith on one hand and Jerri/Amber/Mitchell on the other)

Idk, I kinda felt bad for Jerrie. She just seems liked a chill person, yeah arguing here and there with people, but she never went against the alliance and never backstabbed people. I have no idea how Colby was seen as the "Hero" when he talked shit constantly, acted emotionally after a loss and backstabbed a lot. Like what?

At reunion, Kolby is celebrating Tina's win, more than Tina herself....

The best new survivor channel on KZfaq by far. BY FAR

Am I stupid or did Jerri never actually do anything villain like

Great series idea. Enjoying the content so far

Other than Season 40, this one is my favorite. Colby will forever be my favorite. He was filming a TV show near me and I saw him pumping gas. I secretly geeked.

Your point about his bungling questions at the FTC is a valid one, but the narrative that the show even tries to push by saying his decision was cursed in Ghost Island and things like "he made one of the dumbest moves ever" is just flat out false. Time has been kind to Richard Hatch's win, but in the moment the end of Borneo was universally hated. The only one of the Tagi 4 considered likable was Rudy, and even Burnett and Probst were worried about what this would do for the show, especially given how psychiatrists and even preachers broke down how ugly it got out there. So all people applying for The Australian Outback knew they were walking into this buzzsaw in the public eye, and it is why so many conversations were about who deserves to move forward, morality and so on. And virtually all of the contestants agreed off camera that no matter what it had to be a "good person" winning. Colby did make a pact with Tina early on that they would go to the end if possible and he did want to honor that, but he also knew that if he went with Keith, he was probably winning in a landslide. Good for his bank account, but if he came across as two faced and went back on his word, it would end there, and for the show they wouldn't have their first true protagonist until Ethan, and for many it may have been too late by then. He took Tina to the end because he did think he had a chance at winning, but he was also comfortable losing to her if it came to that. And he was also playing the long game, because he knew that if he was the man of character who stuck to his word, he would make up the money he lost via all his career opportunities that would come about from being the good Southern gentleman who is also very good looking, and that happened. From the razor blade endorsements to being in movies to hosting two or three TV series, he is worth more then Richard and Tina combined. So he may not be the sole survivor of The Australian Outback, but he knew his decision would set up his opportunities for the rest of his life, and it has ten times over. Over 2,000 babies born in the year 2001 were named Colby solely because of his popularity as well.

So glad you keep posting these!

I watched your Richard Hatch one a couple of days ago and it was amazing so I can't wait to watch this one! You can just tell how much effort you put into your videos, thank you!

Man, it's damn good video, thanks for that! It makes things more clear for me. I didn't realized how badly Colby did in FTC. I totally agree with you that he played very good for 40 days and very bad last 2 days. The decision he made... that was dumb but 40 days with this people.. I just think it's hard to switch off emotions in that circumstances, especially when you're young. I hoped that he's gonna win but after all maybe it was better that Tina won. Still it was his season, he was the star and for me Colby is great character.

26:26 and as a bonus, Elisabeth and Rodger voted for Amber. Amber couldn’t flip because contestants can’t vote for themselves. Even if she voted with Nick, she’d still be out

I've never understood why Jerri was considered a villain and Colby a hero. Jerri was outspoken, always speaking her mind, sexualy open and a strong woman, never talking bad about Colby and never betraied their alliance. Colby on the other hand always talked trash about Jerri behind her back and backstabed her in end

Colby is my favorite on Australia but man did he screw up final tribal... wow As far as the varner vote he was trying to be a Villain to bait votes his way Also I have always wondered about the Amber vote and the only thing I can find is that he promised her he wouldn't vote for her

Colby is my favorite survivor player of all time. hope he comes back and wins one day

You should make a video on Keith, he’s pretty underrated

Gosh, even from the first time I watched Australian outback, Jerri is gorgeous. Her outfit at FTC was smokin, poor young woman got psychology messed up from the hate america gave after airing.

I literally love this channel 💜ugh thank you so much for your time and skills. Grade A content that I have been looking for on KZfaq about survivor!!!

Watching these clips gives me such feelings of nostalgia

They should post pandemic make Survivor: Queen vs. King where Tony and Sandra are the captains

One thing to say about remorse for Jerri. Some people are saying that by not showing any he came off as more genuine which was important. But in truth Colby had lied several times up until that point so not lying here or not saying something like what Denise said to Abi-maria just means you were willing to lie to get ahead but cared so little for someone's vote and opinions you weren't willing to lie to get it. That will indefinitely lose you at least 1 vote.

“If it’s and buts we’re candy or nuts we’d have a merry xmas

Colby is the all-time survivor. He cared about the adventure, not the money or the voting game.

YAY YOU POSTED

Hey. Great channel. I love it. Can I ask request you do a video of Rob C from the Amazon?

I'm repeating myself here, but these are some damn great analyses you make. Colby indeed lost his game at FTC, but that doesn't mean he's stupid (like a lot of people are saying). It's all about that big picture...

Wouldve been a better idea to stay Ogakor strong till final 6 when the numbers are 5-1 and THEN try to flip on Jerri and Amber, or just just merely remind amber they were blindsiding Jerri a lot more than what they did on the show lol.

Great video! Season 2 has always been my favorite season and Colby my favorite survivor from that season. I've always been baffled by his performance in the final tribal council. It's probably all speculation but do you think he really didn't want to win for some reason? He came across as being very disinterested and unmotivated in that moment. Although the same can be said of his performance several times during Heroes vs. Villains. It seems like when things are not going well or he doesn't want to be doing something, he checks out mentally. I wonder if something unseen in the final edit helped bring that same demeanor into the final tribal council? Guess we'll never know but you're obviously a Survivor super fan so I'd love to hear your thoughts!

So few views. This is weird. These kind of videos would be mass hits just 5 years ago on KZfaq. The competition today is just amazing.

Colby is a gem

Honestly.... Colby was more of a villain in my eyes. Okay now hear me out, I kind of did a video on this too, but all throughout the season you see him belittling and insulting players he doesn’t deem as worthy such as Keith and Jerri and immediately they’re deemed as the bad guys even though we can’t pinpoint anything Jerri or Keith actually physically did to be labeled as villains besides Colby just deciding to not like them. Of course, this was aired way back in the early 2000’s which was a way different time than now, if australian outback aired today I think peoples views on Jerri and Colby would be vastly different with Colby being an arrogant douche and Jerri being a strong confident player. I do think that maybe you were a little blinded by the edit seeing as you gave colby hero points for just smiling while Maralyn compliments him and not entirely stating it was a dick move for him to throw water at jerri in a fit of rage (even though Amber lost the challenge for them) or when he said Keith’s proposal was just a fake with ulterior motives. No disrespect to you, but i’m just saying how Colby was so favored back then because of the “good ol country boy” edit while being young and attractive even though behind the scenes he was a huge dick who wasn’t really nice to anyone but the cameras, like a wolf in sheep’s clothing kinda deal. We see this come more to light in all stars when Shii Anne becomes the swing vote for either Jerri or Colby and votes Colby solely because he was disrespectful to her in the episode prior and thus is voted out for awful social game. In regards to him fumbling at final tribal, I believe he did state at some point that he just went on the show to try to boost his acting/hollywood career so he cared more about looking honorable and loved than actually winning. Jeff Probst has even pointed this out too, and I guess it’s worked since Colby has now hosted a couple reality tv shows including “The Butcher” right now. But anyways that was just my two cents on everything, love your channel and looking forward to what videos are to come!

Colby is such a nice guy people called there sons colby after thus show it went up in the census

While I like Colby better overall, I’m glad Tina won over him.

As an Australian, not respecting the Great Barrier Reef by taking parts of it back to camp, is a big deal. I think that’s what Colby meant at FTC.

Ladies and gentlemen, Survivor's poster child for the light.

Some of us haven't seen the show, so I wish you wouldn't spoil the ending in the first minute. I like watching your videos not knowing what's going to happen

It's good to know what will happen in All-Stars and Heroes vs Villains.

I recall that season. Colby spoke during it less words than those spoken of him by this video narrator. Colby Iced everything he could, and was silent hero. He was the best in surviving. And just like real life those kind of people get eaten alive by the ones that are best at playing other people.

If Colby choose Keith to the final he would win and i would be happy but at least Tina is a good winner

I remember watching this with my mom and she was completely smitten with Colby, but I was always bother by the way he treated Jerri. So when he lost to Tina I was overjoyed.

0:09 Hey the main reason why I hate EoE

this feels like he threw the game in purpose for tina so she could win the money for her kids. is that just me?

Colby🐐

Yesss

im 26 yr named Colby from Canadian Texas

For some reason I never liked him, the way he treated the whole tribe then specially Jerry was beyond forgivable , in All stars he did nothing and in HvV well everyone knew how awful he got that he got carried out by everyone coz they all knew he was weak and easy to beat. I am happy at least Jerry redeemed herself in HvV, and fans actually got to see her as person.

nice

1:46- Colby's sunglasses were not considered to be his luxury item?

His eyes omg

37:30 "Richard Hatch won the game with this strategy..." Ah, but it was not Richard's choice to make. He was BROUGHT to the final 2 by Kelly.

I was tryna find Wes Nale

Colby is the hottest survivor ever. Had such a big crush on him as a teenager 🤭

It kind of seems like Colby didn’t even want to win. In the last episode it looked like he wasn’t even trying.

I think he's the biggest donkey in survivor history. He could've won if he took Keith to the final. He played himself. Plus he got bullied by the dragon master.

i hope the jerri video will have what was supposed to be perceived back then vs how it is right now... eg heroic moments presented back the 27 villainous 10 heroic... but watching them as of now, knowing al of survivor including outback would lead t eg 19 villanous 18 heroic

Colby could won if he picked Keith to the finals

I’m sorry but Colby was closer to his mom then we were lead to believe. Very weird

Colby did not lose in a 5-4 vote since there was only 7 members on the jury.. Also I disagree with it being dumb in showing remorse for Jerri as it's possible it would have come across as disingenuous and might not have meant anything to them or Jerri. Also I disagree that it was dumb to talk about how he wishes he appreciated the land.. I think that you could really only truly appreciate that comment if you were someone on that island, in that game, at that time to truly be like, "you know what, that's really good observation." They all agreed in the reunion that they agreed with Colby basically calling the land the "17th player" and I think it showed a human side saying that he wishes he had more appreciation which again could really only be experienced by the players themselves. I don't think that lost his vote from Alicia, I think Tina's answers throughout the night of owning her game and probably other stuff that showed she was clearly a mastermind at this game that I'm pretty sure the show didn't show nearly enough of was why Alicia picked Tina.

This is so far the only time in Survivor an older woman won over a younger man in the FTC.

"inevitably gets torch snuffed or wins the season" ehh... except the subject of this video lol :'D No but I do love these videos

Why isn't he a villian? He was horrible to Jerri. I had a strong feeling that he considerd himself "better" than the others. Like he was for some reason so entitelt to win because he thinks of himself as a hero. I really don't get why people like him at all.

Colby kinda seems Machiavellian but that's not necessarily villain behaviour so much as dissonance between the editing and what's happening. I think a good cardinal rule is don't listen to what people say what what they do cause a lot of the time I've found that if you do that you can track somebodies trajectory p easy.

The gifts Colby brought back to the tribe is ILLEGAL. You're not allowed to snap coral off from the Great Barrier Reef. Moment equals VILLAIN for Colby.

cute video, but I thing he was just playign the game casually XD

Colby and Tina were the real villains of S2

Should have taken Keith over Tina and was only 2 immunity wins to win HvsV.

looked 35 hot dilf though

I rewatched s2 just tody and realized Colby was always so...boring.

Bruh. He choked harder than 28-3.

Anybody watching this because ur too lazy to watch Survivor???

If IfS aNd BuTs WeRe CaNdY aNd NuTs WeD aLl HaVe A mErRy ChRiStMaS

HIS MUM HELLO ?? 😃😃

Who would of voted for Colby if he chosen Keith instead?

There's NOTHING bad or villainous about Jerri and Amber joking about chocolate and sex. The men in Amazon say way worse but some how that's ok?

I can't stand Colby. He is a villain 100%. I like Jerry. Colby is arrogant, selfish, and weak willed. Idk how Colby was an the heros tribe season 20.

His FTC was underrated for how awful it was.

Colby is a VILLAIN. Not because he is the first person in Survivor history to straddle two alliances simultaneously (that's fine), but his mistreatment of Jerri on a personal level is awful. Strategucally unnecessary things like throwing that water on her. But audiences let him get away with it because he's got a hot body. Sexy women don't seem to have that help them get away with things but men do and it's irritating.

Just in case anyone thinks he's a conceited jock...