The 11 Chord.What is it, how does it work

  Рет қаралды 28,586

David Burt

David Burt

11 жыл бұрын

The 11th Chord is probably the most misunderstood chord out there.
This tutorial sorts it all out for you. Enjoy!
David Burt

Пікірлер: 75
@WimVanAelst
@WimVanAelst Жыл бұрын
Very well explained David. Thanks !
@nelsonlopez4296
@nelsonlopez4296 3 жыл бұрын
Thank you for sharing your usefull knowledge on this topic.
@davidburtstudio
@davidburtstudio 3 жыл бұрын
My pleasure
@cactusowo1835
@cactusowo1835 2 жыл бұрын
I'll just use these chords, but as texture chords, without resolving, very intuitive video!
@alexjohnson9815
@alexjohnson9815 4 жыл бұрын
Amazing teaching. Not many talk about the 11th chord, but you just showed the importance.
@davidburtstudio
@davidburtstudio 4 жыл бұрын
As I mentioned in the tutorial, the 11th chord is probably the most misunderstood chord out there. I am pleased I was able to help you out.
@seanonel
@seanonel Жыл бұрын
Another Lydian sound methinks. Thank you for your explanation!
@davidburtstudio
@davidburtstudio Жыл бұрын
Yes, perhaps in the case of an augmented 11th. 😎
@HILARI333
@HILARI333 2 жыл бұрын
Wonderful ! So helpful, thank you!!! You really helped me with a music theory class assignment.
@davidburtstudio
@davidburtstudio 2 жыл бұрын
Wonderful to hear. Thank you. I hope you got a good grade on your theory assessment. 😎
@Ronno4691
@Ronno4691 3 жыл бұрын
Excellent. Fully informative with valuable insights re; the Sus 4 aspect! I hit a brick wall when I saw DbMaj#11 yesterday in one of my Jazz guitar books (I like to play piano too and the advanced, fully accomplished jazz piano in such books intrigues me) and now I know. Thank you, Mr. Burt. Liked and Subscribed. Edit: there is also the matter of Jazz pianists preferring to 'sharp' the 11th, because being a half tone away from the E in some voicings, the 11th can be very dissonant. I hope this adds to the conversation.
@davidburtstudio
@davidburtstudio 3 жыл бұрын
Welcome, and thank you for subscribing. Chord symbols can become “tricky “, especially like the one you came across. It should have been noted as Dbma9#11. I have tutorials on chord symbols, PART 1 & 2 along other many other topics which can be easily found on my website: www.davidburt.com. On the right-hand side of my home page click on the tab, TUTORIALS.
@thepalabrasuelta
@thepalabrasuelta 5 жыл бұрын
Excellent explanation! Thanks!
@davidburtstudio
@davidburtstudio 5 жыл бұрын
Yes, it is a very interesting chord with many facets. Glad it was helpful.
@DnStefano
@DnStefano 2 жыл бұрын
Amazing explanation, thank you!
@davidburtstudio
@davidburtstudio 2 жыл бұрын
Your welcome. ,,,, And now you know the rest of the story. 😎
@7guitarras326
@7guitarras326 Жыл бұрын
Thank you David, greetings from Chile
@davidburtstudio
@davidburtstudio Жыл бұрын
Welcome to my channel and all the way from Chile. Pleased you are enjoying my tutorials and music videos. In answer to your question, there are so many boogie woogie videos being circulated world wide that I doubt I could add anything new or worthwhile. I hope you find my tutorials helpful.
@fernandorizo9413
@fernandorizo9413 8 жыл бұрын
Thats what i call teaching! thank you so much! can you do a video on how to use the 11th chord and how it can be resolved in different ways?
@davidburtstudio
@davidburtstudio 8 жыл бұрын
+Fernando Rizo It is already up. You can find it through tutorials on my website: www.davidburt.com
@kristoferkristensen9021
@kristoferkristensen9021 Жыл бұрын
Checking this video out ten years later. Hope the information is still good.
@davidburtstudio
@davidburtstudio Жыл бұрын
Fortunately, music theory doesn’t change over the years. 😎
@rdwwdr3520
@rdwwdr3520 5 жыл бұрын
really excellent. thank you
@davidburtstudio
@davidburtstudio 5 жыл бұрын
My pleasure.
@casparuskruger4807
@casparuskruger4807 7 жыл бұрын
It's very refreshing to see someone post a video and actually explain what an 11th chord is in the real world of music. Kudos for the mention of always adding the 9th and omitting the 3rd on 11th chords --if no further explanation is given ( m11, #11 ). Yes, the 3rd in there "doesn't quite cut it" Over the years in pop sheet music, I have noticed the chord symbol of the plain 11th ( like C11 ) has fallen by the wayside--even when used by artists who have been playing them for years like Steely Dan/Donald Fagen, Chicago. Their books from years ago often did refer to these chords a 11th's. This cluster is normally now referred to as Bb/C , Gm7/C or C9sus4.--although m11 and 7#11 still appear.
@davidburtstudio
@davidburtstudio 7 жыл бұрын
Good day Casparus, You’re right, publishers do tend to use “/” to depict 11th chords. Strictly a marketing thing. Yes, major 3rds and 11ths do not work; however, having a minor 3rd with an 11th , or a major 3rd with a #11th is desirable. As I mentioned in my tutorial, I personally prefer them not to be played a whole-tone apart from one another. I'm sure other musicians will disagree with my personal take on that matter.
@casparuskruger4807
@casparuskruger4807 7 жыл бұрын
I think it depends a lot on the style of song and what context the chord #11appears, whether the 3rd is voiced beside the #11 or if it's even include at all. For my own purposes for instance, I'll call a C13#11 a Bbmaj7+5/C if a ninth--but not a 3rd is included--but I'm quite aware such a symbol would raise eyebrows if anyone else saw that symbol! I have noticed however the tonality of the chord seems to really defined with the inclusion of the #11 note, and rather curiously, the inclusion or exclusion of the 3rd doesn't seem to make all that much difference here either way. Unlike the 11th and m11th chord the ''7" ( or 13 )is included in the symbol ( C7#11) but as the third vanishes in the 11th chord, the 5th vanishes in the #11. Or does it? One could include it, but I guess I'm from the school where I consider playing more than 5 different tones in a chord muddles things up considerably. I've always presumed an 11th chord always included a 9th note, but I now have seen some songbooks substitute the -5 for #11, even when a ninth note doesn't appear. But like you said, it does boil down to marketing thing. And it looks like the 11th chord seems to have the most controversy surrounding it in the world of chord-symbol nomenclature. And that's even BEFORE a guitar player adds his spin on it!
@davidburtstudio
@davidburtstudio 7 жыл бұрын
Hello again Casparus, I personally believe of the importance of being accurate as possible in the notation of the chord symbols, since they do not work independently of the key signature. Slash “/” chords in these cases are better left in your imagination than being observed in the written music. Although I prefer the major 3rd on a #11 chord I have to agree with you that it can go either way. (The 11th replaces all 3rds) However, if you are looking for a ii chord in C, as in Dm11, it’s important that the minor 3rd be present. If it is omitted you’ll end up with a dominant chord being an extension of a D7, with no reference to minor.
@casparuskruger4807
@casparuskruger4807 7 жыл бұрын
Yep. Gotta have that minor 3rd in the m11. But in defence of '/' chords--Perhaps they theoretically are misnomers in the world of musical theory. I had a teacher years ago that would gulp and growl whenever he heard any reference to one, but I have used and seen them pretty well throughout my musical perusings over the years--mainly due to the type of music I have been playing during that time. Artists like Joni Mitchell, Steely Dan/Donald Fagen, Gino Vannelli, Ambrosia --even the Beatles have posted chords like these for years--very likely because that's how they think of these chord as being when they write their songs. For instance a I/IV or I/II DO actually have a sound of their own, and feature a somewhat (what I call ) a more 'airy' voicing than lets say a Maj9 or 11th chord, respectfully. I've even encountered chords notated as E/G which suggests a G13-9 --but again leaving out the 7th in this shape makes for again a more airy voicing--as well as simplicity when describing the chord. E/G is just a more compact way of describing a chord as G13-9no7. Cheers
@brbijuram3548
@brbijuram3548 2 жыл бұрын
very nice thank u
@davidburtstudio
@davidburtstudio 2 жыл бұрын
You are most welcome. 😎
@composer7325
@composer7325 9 жыл бұрын
Thank you.A very good lecture
@mrnelsonius5631
@mrnelsonius5631 3 жыл бұрын
I just wrote a song with a #11, by accident, and realized “I have no idea why this is working”. Sent me down a rabbit hole chasing the theory behind the weird move my brain made. Video was great!! Particularly pointing out the obtuse naming a lot of publications use for these chords. Very helpful 🙏
@davidburtstudio
@davidburtstudio 3 жыл бұрын
Pleased to hear you're getting useful information from my 11th tutorial. If you didn't use a major 3rd in your augmented 11th chord, you might try adding it into the chord structure., preferably not right beside the +11.
@mrnelsonius5631
@mrnelsonius5631 3 жыл бұрын
David Burt the #11 showed up in the vocal melody, and it worked because the chord under it had an add9 but no 3rd being played. Gave the melody a very Lydian sound in this one section. Creates tension but immediately resolves after so left it in even though I second guessed my choice at first! Haha
@davidburtstudio
@davidburtstudio 3 жыл бұрын
@@mrnelsonius5631 That's great. Both 11ths and #11ths should be supported by 9ths. An 11th should never have a major 3rd in the chord, anywhere,. However, a #11 will work with a major 3rd in, or out of the structure. Try adding a major 3th. If you don't like what you hear, toss it.
@vusumuzijacobdhladhla7945
@vusumuzijacobdhladhla7945 Жыл бұрын
You are my teach you make things easy
@davidburtstudio
@davidburtstudio Жыл бұрын
Glad I could help. 😎
@LApianoplace
@LApianoplace Ай бұрын
This is the deep explanation I've been searching for. I label the 11th a dominant function chord? C¹¹[CEGBbDF] How to voice the 11th. Sure it could be simpler F/G ... favorite voicing for my exploration today is the end of the 2nd phrase in a Billy Joel song "And So it Goes" and final cadence to others as well? Polychord seems to simplify the construction but not the sound or its function. The 11th Chord seems like the Holy Grail of all chords to understanding sound.
@davidburtstudio
@davidburtstudio 29 күн бұрын
Your voicing for C11 of [CEGBbDF] will not work. Remember the 11th will take the place of all 3rds. That two handed voicing should be [CGBbDF] C11. The F takes the place of the 3rd. (E). The 11 Chord is a dominant chord. However, the minor 11 chord is NOT. That chord should have a minor 3rd. as well as an 11th. [CEbGBbDF] Cm11 Just two times a 3rd is present in an 11th chord. 1 / The minor 3rd with an 11th (Cm11). 2/ A major 3rd with an aug. 11th. (C9+11) or (C9#11). 😎
@LApianoplace
@LApianoplace 29 күн бұрын
I see I wasn't very clear with my word choice. You explained the voicing so nicely around 5:11 in the video. I wouldn't play the stacked thirds all at once with two hands. How to voice the Eleventh. I meant to say I would use the voicing of the polychord you gave F/G or Bb/C or as you said E flat triad is the upper structure b7 9th & 11th of the F¹¹ dominant function chord. It seems you explain it so clearly also at 4:20 with C/D as it is easier for publisher notation purposes. You have amazing skill and knowledge on this. Thank you so much for sharing.
@davidburtstudio
@davidburtstudio 29 күн бұрын
Thanks again for your kind comments. FYI. For a C11 a publisher most likely would use Bb/C. However, if they wanted to ensure the 5th was used they might use Gm7/C SAME CHORD. 😎🎶
@artcamloz
@artcamloz 3 жыл бұрын
I posted the following question on a Facebook group: “Are F/G and G11 the same chord?” I was surprised because almost everyone said they are differnt. I was sad because that meant I had to rewrite a lot of scores. Then, I was happy to find this video. Probably I won’t redo the work.
@davidburtstudio
@davidburtstudio 3 жыл бұрын
As I mentioned in my tutorial on the 11th, it is the most misunderstood chord. Since many butting musicians don’t really understand the concept of the 11 chord, publishers have often used F/G instead of G11. The music student plays an F chord in his right hand and G in the bass and for the most part still thinks he/she is playing some form of an F chord, not realizing it is actually an 11th. I’ve even seen publishers go so far as providing the symbol Dm7/G to ensure the presents of a 5th.
@ryanmelvey8764
@ryanmelvey8764 2 жыл бұрын
i like to think about it like building a minor seven chord on a fifth up from the root. makes it quicker for me! i thought it sounded like a sus chord so it was great to get that confirmed here!
@davidburtstudio
@davidburtstudio 2 жыл бұрын
Grad I was able to hi. 😎
@adamreecepiano
@adamreecepiano 4 жыл бұрын
hi great explanation about difference between suss chord and 11th - I never looked at it that way before . Can you explain a bit about sharp 11 - when to use and any tips at all about this - thanks
@davidburtstudio
@davidburtstudio 4 жыл бұрын
11ths are often used to support a 13th. As in C13,11. (C,G,Bb,F,A) The 11th (F) replaces the major 3rd (E) or minor 3rd (Eb). But the augmented 11th (F# in C) allows the option of using, or not using the major 3rd. As in C13+11. (C,E,G,Bb,D,F#,A). The minor 11th Chord should incorporate a minor 3rd, but as I mentioned in the tutorial, never, never should you have an 11th with a major 3rd in any configuration. Finally, a 13th does not have to have an 11th as in C13. (C,Bb,D,E,A). Augmented 11ths are also used on their own. It hypes up the 9th and gives the sound of a very strong dominant chord. I hope this was helpful rather than more confusing for you.
@fernandorizo9413
@fernandorizo9413 8 жыл бұрын
i've been watching your videos and it is wonderful~ thanks for sharing. the only question... what other chords can the 11th be resolved? my equation : C (root) + Gm7 = Fmaj7 . notice that the chord resolves nicely in to a Fmaj7th chord which would be the tonic and it would be the key signature. looking at the circle of 5ths i can go around all the keys with this equation. can the minor 11th resolve in to a Maj7 chord? can that be the tonic? and what other chords i can use it to resolve it?
@davidburtstudio
@davidburtstudio 8 жыл бұрын
+Fernando Rizo The most important thing to remember: Any chord can go to any chord. Some changes work better than others. An 11th chord is an extension of a dominant V chord. V tends to go to the I chord. I.e. C11 to F or Fma7 or Fma9. However, it’s quite happy to go to the vi, iii, IV, and ii chord as well. Minor 11th chords often show up as a ii chord. They can go directly to I, or change the bass to a V, before returning to I. I.e. Gm11 to Fma9 or Gm11 Gm11/C to Fma9.
@reynoldabrahamj2815
@reynoldabrahamj2815 4 жыл бұрын
Make one full Vedio where u teach about each and every chord like 11th 9th 5th etc
@davidburtstudio
@davidburtstudio 4 жыл бұрын
I've already done that. Check out my website www.davidburt.com and click on the tab TUTORIALS . You will find it all there. Sorry for not replying to you sooner but I was one of 247 Canadians stranded on the ms Zaandam. It was the ship in the news where no country would offer help. Yesterday I flew home from Fort Lauderdale to Toronto. While on the ship had no access to my KZfaq channel. But I’m back with another video posting today.
@elliotlangford824
@elliotlangford824 6 жыл бұрын
wow thanks!! i was always a bit hazy on the difference between an 11th and a sus4!
@davidburtstudio
@davidburtstudio 6 жыл бұрын
Since a 4th and an 11th are the same note, it's not surprising that there would be confusion. I'm happy I was able to lend clarification between the two.
@elliotlangford824
@elliotlangford824 6 жыл бұрын
David Burt cheers! Do you teach in the Toronto area? I'll be there this November, might like to get a lesson from you
@davidburtstudio
@davidburtstudio 6 жыл бұрын
Yes Elliot, I live in the west end of Toronto. The area is referred to as Etobicoke, and I'm about a 4 minute walk from the Royal York Road subway station. I'd be happy to help you out.
@davidburtstudio
@davidburtstudio 11 жыл бұрын
11ths are used as an extension of a dominant 9th chord, which in turn can support the 13th. A major 7th is not usually used because although it creates some tension it is passive in nature like the 6th and.therefore, "tries to pacify a dominant situation". Interestingly, the major 7th can be used with 13ths as in Cma13. (See my tutorial on 13th chords). If you wanted to hype that chord up further, you could add a augmented 11th. (C,E,G,Bb,D,F#,A) Cma13+11. Hope this was helpful. D.
@davidburtstudio
@davidburtstudio 3 жыл бұрын
We often use notes that are not part of the scale. G7-9 in C, no Ab in key of C but there it is. Bdim7, another Ab in the key of C. These notes are “borrowed “ from other modes. 11 and #11 are both used depending on voice leading (melody). Both those can, and often do replace the 3rd. However, you can have a minor 3rd with an 11th, as in Cm11 or a major 3rd as in C9#11. But never, never (you won’t hear me say that very often) should you have a major 3rd and an 11th in the same chord.
@Phineas1626
@Phineas1626 6 жыл бұрын
Hi David. Like many others, I took a lot from the video. Yet, I’m befuddled as ever on how extended chords(save the 9th, which isn’t an issue, because, as you say, “...a ninth is a ninth is a ninth...”) are built. So I’ve got maj, min, and dom to the ninth down, and even dom 13ths like C13. But how are Cmaj11 and Cm11 and Fmaj13 and Fmin13 built? I recall being taught that major chords alternate maj and minor thirds, and minor chords alternate minor and major thirds, but now I find nothing ANYWHERE online that confirms or refutes that, as applied to 11ths and 13ths. Does that pattern break somewhere in the stacking pattern? Seems it would have to if the correct notes of the scale are to be kept intact. Any help would be appreciated, since I can’t find an answer to this anywhere. Thank you.
@davidburtstudio
@davidburtstudio 6 жыл бұрын
Well Phineas1626, let me see if I can shed some light here. An 11th is an extension of a 9th and is considered dominant. (Active) A major 7th added to a major chord makes the chord (passive) a non-dominant chord. Rarely will you find a major 7 and an 11th in the structure of harmony, because passive and active considerations do not work together. However, a composer may very well want to use both to create conflict. The alternating majors and minors you mentioned do not refer to chords. They refer to intervals. (The distance from a lower note to a higher note) Therefore an interval of a major 3rd upon inversion becomes a minor 6th and vies-versa. Let’s look at dominant structures. Root, 3rd,5th ,7th (basic) extensions 9th 13th If you prefer the 11th then you drop the major 3. Becomes Root (5th) 7th 9th 11th and a 13th is possible. Looking at passive structures. Root, 3rd,5th, 6th or major 7th (basic) can be extended to 9th no11th and if you use the major 7th, a 13 can top off the structure. It would be called a major 13. I hope I haven’t confused you more. Please consider viewing my tutorials on harmony structure starting with 6ths , 7ths , major 7, and up through 9th, 11th, and 13th.
@Phineas1626
@Phineas1626 6 жыл бұрын
David Burt David-thank you so much for the response. I really appreciate it. Unfortunately, I still can’t answer the question: “Is there such a thing as Fmaj13 or Dmin11, and if so, what are the notes for each?” I believe the answer to both is “yes,” but I couldn’t say so with any conviction. Oddly, I get much of what you’re saying, for example, about dropping the third when you use an 11th, because of tonal conflict, etc. What really makes me mad is that I took lessons for 5 years, ending not that long ago, and I thought I had a good understanding of this sort of thing. Maybe because most of the songs I played never required more than a 9th, except for the occasional dom 13th. Incidentally, what I’m really after here is to look at any chord notation on a lead sheet and automatically know what all the notes in that chord are, including the ones that don’t get played. So, for instance, if I see Fmaj13, I want to think F-A-C-E-G-Bb-D - and the sad part is I don’t even know if those are the notes in the Fmaj13 chord-if there is such a thing. In any event, thanks again. I always hold in high regard good teaching and I’m impressed with your method and how you interact with your viewers. Thanks for the suggestion to view your 6th and 7th (etc.) harmony videos - ironically, I decided last night that I was headed there next. So thanks again and take good care.
@davidburtstudio
@davidburtstudio 6 жыл бұрын
Okay, in answer to your questions. Yes, in both cases. The notes you chose for the Fmaj13 - F-A-C-E-G-Bb-D are almost right. Just remove the 11th (Bb). You don’t want a major 3rd and an 11th in any configuration. All your questions on minor 11ths are covered in my tutorial on the11th Chord. I would suggest you review it again. My discussion on the minor11th starts at 5:50 minutes into the video. Also the major 13th chord is discussed in detail in my tutorial on the 13th Chord. It starts at 9:15 minutes into the video. In both cases alternative voicing structures of these chords are also discussed. After viewing these tutorials, should you have any futher questions, I’d be happy to help you out.
@Phineas1626
@Phineas1626 6 жыл бұрын
David-you were right...a review of both your 11th chords and 13th chords videos was very helpful. And I appreciate your direct answer to the Fmaj13 chord notes, etc., questions. Given your answer, am I to understand that the 11th note would never be played employing Fmaj13; i.e. I couldn’t play F (omit A, the 3rd), C, E, G, Bb and D for Fmaj13? I ask because I have seen on some websites (8notes.com, for example) they list the notes of the Fmaj13th chord as F-C-E-G-Bb-D, leaving the 11th but dropping the 3rd. So, that’s why I ask if it’s an absolute or an either/or. And least you see where I’m getting some of my confusion! In terms of “building” chords from the root to the farthest extension (13th), for major, minor and dominant-is it accurate to say that they are built only by using the alternating notes in their respective scales (maj, min, dom), setting aside for a brief moment the issue of not playing a maj 3rd with an 11th, and similar issues? I want to thank you again for indulging my questions. I really have gotten so much from your videos and I commend their style and clarity, even for an idiot like me. And I promise to watch the harmony videos very shortly!
@davidburtstudio
@davidburtstudio 6 жыл бұрын
A major 9 means that the 9th is supported by a major 7., and not the dominant 7th. The major in the chord symbol refers strictly to the use of the major 7th. Likewise, the major 13 is supported by both the major 7 and 9. In a previous replay to you I've stated, "Rarely will you find a major 7 and an 11th in the structure of harmony, because, passive and active considerations do not work well together. However, a composer may very well want to use both to create conflict". Basically, chords are built on stacking 3rds, but not necessarily. Don't get hung up on whether the 3ths used are major or minor. There are no rules in music that say, "You can't do that". Music at best is an inexact art form. You can do anything you want. Use any harmony structure you want. Use unresolved melodic leaps. Your only criteria should be, that whatever you decide to do, you should like what you hear.
@WilliamSlaght
@WilliamSlaght 8 жыл бұрын
What's terribly wrong with notes that are meshed together, or two semitones at the top of a voicing. I feel this to be a somewhat a subjective, yet personal approach, yet I mean no offense for I do understand the dissonances that can be mad, but I ended up getting used to these dissonances even when they're not resolving. As well as F/G (or D-7/G for the matter) does not necessarily mean it's an 11th chord. It really depends on the context of the piece, what key it is in, the melody, and what the changes are, and so forth. Such as if D-7/G resolves to Eb7 then to Abmaj7, yet the D-7/G is more of a G9sus4 chord more than anything than a G11 of which that 3rd wouldn't mesh at all with these changes at all in a welcomed fashion. Furthermore, if D-7/G goes to Cmaj7, then I agree with you on that it is simply G11 dominant V to the I. If D-7/G goes to G7, then I could see it as G9sus4 resolving to G7 (or G9), but it could be also a ii chord with the pedal note being G as well. Like if I see this progression preceding it A-7/G to D-7/G to G7 (then to Cmaj7), then I would prefer to view D-7/G to G7 as a "ii V". I would prefer not to see it as G11 going to G7, but this could be possible, but then again it would be rare and it would depend on the context of the piece I would be playing. However, the chord progression of G7 to Fmaj7/G to E-7/G to D-7 to Cmaj7 would show an example of a "ii I" as it's basically V to IV to iii to ii to I with G being pedaled the whole way through until the I. So that shows that D-7/G heading to Cmaj7 isn't necessarily always could be identified as a G11. So all I have to say is that this editor's trick you've mentioned does exist, and is probably in the majority compared to these other changes I've mentioned, but how I feel about D-7/G would be that it would either be at most times a G11, then it could be a replacement for G9sus4 as well (since D-7/G is apparently easier to read), and finally it could actually be the ii chord with the G being pedaled, yet this is few when compared to the changes before. Well that's my two cents on this matter.
@davidburtstudio
@davidburtstudio 8 жыл бұрын
+LinkBulletBill Sorry for taking so long to get back to you. I try to answer all questions; unfortunately, I missed your comments. First of all there nothing wrong with dissonances. When they resolve either actively, or passively, they move the music forward. If you are playing melody at the "top" of your harmony you need at least a whole-tone below the melody and the rest of the harmony. so the the listener can clearly hear the melody. I.E. an F# directly below a G melody confuses the purity of the melody, where as a F directly below a G melody (a whole tone) should cause no problem at all. Crowding in other notes that cause tension throughout the harmony is cool. To my ear, it's better when they resolve but hey, to each their own. As to your second point. F/G does represent a G11 as in G bass with F (the 7th) A (the 9th) and C (the 11th) above the bass. Publishers tend to use that notation when going through a chord progression such as ii, V I. In other words, if there is an approach to a I chord by a dominant V11 chord, you most often will see Dm7 to F/G to C rather than Dm7 to G11 to C. Publishers like to keep things simple. Using the correct notation of "G11" in this case "scares" potential buyers of sheet music. Bad for business. The only time a publisher would use a Dm7/G is if they felt it was important that the 5th be included in the G 11th chord. I.E. --- D F A C becomes 5, 7, 9 11 over G.
@rodneymanthengamanthenga7638
@rodneymanthengamanthenga7638 2 жыл бұрын
this guy sound like Clint Eastwood
@egenestarr1986
@egenestarr1986 4 жыл бұрын
could you imagine if we had very long fingers and extra fingers, o wait thats what the digital world did for us
@davidburtstudio
@davidburtstudio 4 жыл бұрын
Yes the digital world has come a long way in many things especially music. However, all the magic of digital will be lost if first you don't understand the principals of how things work musically. Sorry for not replying to you sooner but I was one of 247 Canadians stranded on the ms Zaandam. It was the ship in the news where no country would offer help. Yesterday I flew home from Fort Lauderdale to Toronto. While on the ship had no access to my KZfaq channel. But I’m back with another video posting today.
@WARDISWARD
@WARDISWARD 5 жыл бұрын
YOu lost me 06:12 You're not playing an F maj 11 f(root)--( no third )--c ( fifth)---'e flat' which is a minor seventh ...Etc.. Unless it's a dominant ( without third ) which would make sense , since your replacing the fifth with a minor third in your example
@davidburtstudio
@davidburtstudio 5 жыл бұрын
Let's see if i can clear some of this up. I should first point out that an 11th chord is a dominant chord. Therefore, no Fmaj11 symbol would not be used. The major in your chord symbol would refer to the major 7th which would destabilize the dominant chord, so definitely no E natural. F11 would use Eb, the (minor) 7th. At the 6:00 minute mark I start to explain that a minor 11th is also available. I first show the F11 as F (root), C (5th), Eb (7th), G (9th), and Bb (11th) no 3rd since the 11th takes its place. I then explain that the Fm11 is formed by moving the (5th) C down to the minor 3rd (Ab). All the other notes remain the same. The C could be replaced in the Left-hand is you like the sound of the 5th in that location. If you still have any questions, let me know.
@WARDISWARD
@WARDISWARD 5 жыл бұрын
Yes , I understood that you went from a dominant to a minor eleventh . Thank for clearing it out cheers
@davidburtstudio
@davidburtstudio 5 жыл бұрын
You're correct. By the way when playing a minor 11th chord, it no longer is a dominant chord. Pleased we got things cleared up for you. Cheers ....
The 13th Chord
10:53
David Burt
Рет қаралды 6 М.
The ONE Chord Nobody Seems To Understand
22:40
Aimee Nolte Music
Рет қаралды 113 М.
The child was abused by the clown#Short #Officer Rabbit #angel
00:55
兔子警官
Рет қаралды 21 МЛН
ОДИН ДЕНЬ ИЗ ДЕТСТВА❤️ #shorts
00:59
BATEK_OFFICIAL
Рет қаралды 8 МЛН
She ruined my dominos! 😭 Cool train tool helps me #gadget
00:40
Go Gizmo!
Рет қаралды 63 МЛН
Extended Chords - 9ths, 11ths, and 13ths
20:04
Michael New
Рет қаралды 190 М.
Approach Chords
0:50
Open Studio
Рет қаралды 290 М.
Understanding Tritones
10:04
David Burt
Рет қаралды 35 М.
#83: How To Use Altered Extended Chords
27:59
Piano Lesson with Warren
Рет қаралды 89 М.
Jazz Piano Explained in 20 Minutes (Beginner Lesson)
19:48
Jazz Tutorial | with Julian Bradley
Рет қаралды 3,2 МЛН
Songs that use 9th, 11th and 13th chords
16:15
David Bennett Piano
Рет қаралды 200 М.
Sus Chords - Not 11th chords
0:59
Aimee Nolte Music
Рет қаралды 15 М.
17 ways to play a chord progression
23:17
David Bennett Piano
Рет қаралды 91 М.
Say Mo - LIL BIT & 1 shot 2 (Waysberg Music Remix)
2:43
Waysberg Music🇰🇿
Рет қаралды 167 М.
ҮЗДІКСІЗ КҮТКЕНІМ
2:58
Sanzhar - Topic
Рет қаралды 4,8 МЛН
Umyttyń Ba? (feat. Turar)
2:54
akimmmich - Topic
Рет қаралды 43 М.
LISA - ROCKSTAR (Official Music Video)
2:48
LLOUD Official
Рет қаралды 69 МЛН
Көктемге хат
3:08
Release - Topic
Рет қаралды 217 М.
Райымбек Нысанбек - Сүйдім аруды
3:39
Райымбек Нысанбек
Рет қаралды 110 М.
BABYMONSTER - ‘FOREVER’ M/V
3:54
BABYMONSTER
Рет қаралды 28 МЛН