It was Helen Hirsch. The woman depicted as his “maid”.

Yeah probably worse trauma than the opening scene of Saving Private Ryan.

Yeah... so show it, this film is made to shock and show the horrors of the Holocaust.

​@@charakigaShow what MAGAts want to bring back. 😢

​@@AntebiosYou mean the people who wear black shirts, loot Asian markets and beat people in the streets? Oh wait, that's YOU, Fascist!

I recalled a interview with a survivor of the Killing Field for the movie and when he told the director some of the stuff they did the director said something like 'We can't put some of that stuff in the movie because the audience world thinks it not real". So I understand what he saying, that you can make things historically accurate but if you are introducing it to a audience that doesn't know the subject then if it Too Out Their then people will start to think it exagrated. I recalled their being a few movies that had real event show but it was so outrageous that the audince thought it was a joke by the director.

Montages flash like in snatch

I think we got the general idea.

What makes a person truly evil is having the capacity to do good, but choosing to be evil . The nazi. Would hug their friends, play with their kids, and pet their dogs. Then go to work and smash a baby's skull in to save a bullet.

Really? Watch Django sometime.

Perfect for frontline infantry. I bet he came from a wealthy military background. The war was an inconvenience for him

@@anthonyhassett yes to wealthy, not so much for military. According to Wikipedia his family were book publishers - including military history books.

@@Engy_Wuck I never heard of a good soldier who didn't have a good background either from the dinner table or outdoor skills. But really the SS Camp Commandants job was a HR managers job rather than a boots on the ground job.

You know someone is evil when even the Nazis are telling him to chill.

Which asylum was it?

His daughter who was around 9 during the war lol

@@Sky_Shinigaand? I was like 6 when the twin towers got hit if we are sharing random pointless information

@@The_Faceless_No_Name_Stranger Yeah? But you going around now days defending Al Qaeda saying they aren’t that bad of people?

@@Sky_Shiniga nigga read your comment again, you may as well be saying grass is green, soup is good food, or LBJ has a fat cock. You made a simple sentence with no context

Lol

I really don t know how he could play such a role. I would have been sick😢😢😢

Working an honest days work really pissed them off to the point they made museums . Working nearly killed them !

@@33cattt49 Explain, please? Who's "them"?

@@johnl4933 the people in the labor camp , they will never forgive the Germans for making them work

Yes you need the character of Goethe to offset Schindlers character. You need balance. I never bought the idea that Schindler was a saint, he was just someone with amazing people skills and a vision of how the war was actually progressing.

He was not, but he was a man who at the CRITICAL time made a right choice. If instead of Stanislav Petrov the guy who talked the soviet authorities down from launching nukes due to a computer glitch was a wife beating womanizing drunk, it still does not negate the "saved the world credit"

well... i have a different view on that. if a hollywood production wants to make a historical movie thats a portayel of an actual event: make it accurat. if you can not: staw away from that event and pick one that you can portray accurate since you dont have the moral right to butcher events like that. movie tip as proof: opening speech in the movie Patton. they censored Pattons words so it would be 'suitable' for people to hear to then go forward showing people getting killed and mangled in the movie. the speech can be found on youtube and the actual speech aswell. good comparison to get my point.

​@@boerbeunfortunately amon goths character is portrayed accurately, they can't show everything.

I dont think you can tell the story of Schindler without the character of Goeth to compare and contrast. Schindler on his own would just appear as a sex addict, bribe artist and oppertunist without Goeth to offset him. The film is all about contrast. In a time of need, war and famine look how much the jews lost and the Nazis took. It shows the moral battle that Schindler had to do business and yet not be a part of.

Sad that the survivor should suffer more so long after the Holocaust occurred.

I wouldn’t believe senile old Jewish people

Oy vey, it's happening again!

​@@patrizio205wow so edgy go back to watching that Europa the last battle garbage again while wearing your SS costume in your trailer home.

@@rc59191 I see you are a man of culture.

Perhaps not not believe, but simply, wouldnt stand all the horrors...

And instead it's consumed by hope in the face of evil, because good in the name of good, at risk of all own, in direct opposition to evil, will always shine brighter than evil for the sake of evil, no matter the magnitude of such evil.

very poetic@@exstacc1886

Such an intellectual reply

Yep. Goeth and Oskar Dirlwanger and his division made of psycos, lots of officials from the SS denounced him to Himmler, to put him, because considered the guy to much cruel. Now image what the guy did, when eaven the SS officials considered you nuts, and cruel in what he did.

Exactly.

Yes...but...still the director should have shown more for a direct perception.

@@venkatarao1658 It obviously didn't go with his idea of the movie. It's not easy to show true, unflinching horrors in an "entertainment".

​@@venkatarao1658wasn't the ENTIRE film enough for you? 🙄

@@ac1646 👍👍So sensible of you. 😊😊😊

Absolutely agree

I found him completely believable. The chilling part is the way Goethe plays off the responsibility of his actions, that it is the wars fault, otherwise he would have been a reasonable individual. No better than the child whose dog ate his homework story.

Certainly on par with the Hannibal Lecture roles by Sir Anthony Hopkins.

Indeed

@@johnpage7491 But his role in a social movement did give him "plausible deniability", at least to himself.

@@johnpage7491 I always thought that Val Kilmer got screwed over by the Academy after being stepped over for his take on Doc Holliday in Tombstone. Pretty much a given that it was fallout from him being kind of a d!ck to work with, but even assh0les are capable of greatness.

He was certified insane by several SS medical staff officials. He was also quick to anger and act out, and laughed as her performed such acts . He was the perfect embodiment of Horror.

'sone ONE'. There were many, many, many😢

@@johnmorales7057and evil

It could have been and has been done in movies about other large-scale atrocities.

@@sonofizzyyour point? Are you saying you are disappointed every atrocity was not reenactment for your viewing?

@johnpage7491 Did I say that I wanted every atrocity shown or how? Apparently, the only point that you comprehend is at the top of your head. And learn some English, if you can.

Definitely would have been a downer and that's not what the film-makers wanted to portray.

@carlosidelone8064 Maybe a bit of a downer, but could have been done without ruining the film. I any event, good day to all.

Because what he was known to do was Too Dreadful to show.

yes, a variant of "killing your darlings" as every good writer or producent of semi-documentary - or documentary - must learn to do.

L'ho rivisto qualche giorno fa.. 😢

That is basically exactly what he said ‘’I was just following orders’’🙄

The Russian film "Come and See" was very graphic and stomach turning, but still well done.

Five years

Or it may make them desensitized to it, if it wasn't handled skillfully enough.

Jones was a joke in that part. Ralph was chilling

Nope! 😂😂😂

Spielberg did have to have those light moments in tragedy. The film would have been unwatchable otherwise. Shakespeare did similar. The film is three hours long? They had to show some contrast so not everyone had the same war experience.

@@anthonyhassett I found that it made the Nazis, especially Goethe, even more chilling and evil because either they were joking and making light of their atrocious acts or they were demonstrating how far from humanity they were straying that they couldn't see the evil in their acts.

That's because Fiennes is so much more handsome than the bloated fat Goeth was in reality. I find Fiennes really 'cuddly'

@@bogusmogus9551 He certainly brought a homely, cute cuddliness to Voldemort, I agree!

Yea they threw him in a mental asylum cause they found out he was nuts

I loved Ralph Fiennes portrayal of Göth! But Liam Neeson as Schindler, he looked and sounded too Irish for the role. Just like Michael Fassbender as Magneto.

It could have been done in much less time than that, without too much blood and gore.

There is a painting of French soldiers in a firing squad opposite Spanish peasants in the Prado, Madrid, by Francisco Goya.. There is no gore, but the terror on the poor peasants faces really touched me emotionally. Often a touch of subtlety, can be more effective, than blatant destruction.

Ranulph Fiennes, you've missed out he's a great actor and been in lots of great films. He isn't his character.

Ralph Finnes was also in “The English Patient”.. GREAT movie… It had TWO VHS cassettes 😂😂😂😂.

A majority of the film would most likely be his time as kommandant of krakow-plaszow concentration camp. Showing in great and all detail of what he did, most likely an M or R rated

The audience would already know three things: 1) that some people are born with sadistic tendencies that get stronger over time, 2)that the position of concentration camp commander would attract the worst sadists, 3)and that power corrupts, that a concentration camp commander holds absolute power, and that absolute power corrupts absolutely. Knowing this would take the suspense out of the plot and make it easy to guess the ending.....

You post nonsense.

@@johnstuartsmith You apparently do not know how many people are ignorant about that side of human nature and the Holocaust. There are also plenty of Holocaust deniers and minimizers - some of whom are very organized and sophisticated- ready to spread and foster such denial and minimization. I know. I have fought these vermin on FB and youtuble.

View some documentary accounts. He was way worse than the movie character. How can you show two great Dane dogs ripping someone apart in a movie?

God will deal with him...eternally.

Hell doesn't exist & nor does God. He's just dead. Very very dead.

Definitely. My Lai for example..

Ralph is best choice for psychopathic scary villain! I mean he's done Goth, Voldemort and recently that crazy chef in the Menu. All of them so chilling and realistic!

Really? Give me your source or a link, please.

What? they put Stealberg in an asylum? You surely don't mean Hollywood?

@@sonofizzy WIKIPEDIA

​@@sonofizzyits true ok

​@@sonofizzygoeth stealing looting prisoners for personal profit

I know, the NSDAP OR Nazis is a political party not the bunch of thugs it became. they weren't even Fascists, leave that to Mussolini and Franco and a few South American regimes. They became a Totalitarian state, like communism. Hell, They even tried to kill Hitler several times until the 'Night of the long knives'

I agree. We need to be very careful not to cause the name of this evil to become so overused as to become meaningless. Nazis went to a level of evil unparralled against people not just in one nation but accross nearly all of Europe.

Nah only people that act like one. Why would you be offended?

@@oracle4722 You clearly have not experienced what Nazis actually did in real life. Disagreeing with you politically isn't Nazism.

​@oracle4722 99.9% of the times its just people they disagree with. You have no idea what a nazi is do you?

Just one of the bad things he did was force a boy to EAT HIS OWN SHIT and then murder him

no, they sent him to a mental hospital then extradited him o Poland and he was executed by hanging, too good for him really !

No he never made it to Nuremberg, he was hung in the prison camp

Russians hanged him.

❤❤❤❤❤

Are you really keeping score?? WTF!! How the F do you know how many people "Mao's red guards" killed??? The Nazis kept detailed records, FFS.

You really screwed up that last sentence, Thomas. Not a single law enforcement officer has been killed by BLM. Their "cause" is to stop police killing unarmed black men for little or no reason, which is a worthy cause.

Youre patetic

Well according to my grandmother who was in Płaszow there were many instances where he stood on the balcony of the villa spread out his arms and laughed like a maniac so probably there was a scene like that

Based

He enjoyed it

There is no greater monster than man.

​@panzerjamnik4540, Especially men backed by governments.

Horsefluff. Source, please.

​@@sonofizzydunno, but I just read was arrested in September 1944 for corruptive and overly brutal behaviour (Plastov was a labour camp, not an extermination camp). If something however hypocrite was possible..

@annedejong1040 The basis of his criticism and arrest was not brutality, but corruption. The SS were routinely cruel. You might want to look up Dr. Mengele, for example, of one truly sadistic b*stard.

@annedejong1040 The bone that the SS had to pick with him was over corruption, not cruelty. The SS were more than pleased to be cruel to Jews. One of the worst was Dr. Mengele.

You don’t know what you are talking about lol. Amon Goeth was real and so was Schindler.

@@Johan_Liebert___the people you mention are real. the fukn story is fiction. Which means its not true..... You don't have to believe me dpst look it up .... FICTION... IT WON A BEST SELLER FOR F I C T I O N!!!!!!!! I'm sure it's not the only misnomer you have about what happened over there

​@@krakrtreacysr907 because It's a movie with a plot, not a documentary dumbass. For example, most dialogues between characters are OBVIOUSLY fictional since it is clearly impossible to know every detail from events 80 years ago. Go ahead and show me a historical movie which has 0 fictional elements. good luck with that

Sure it never happened right?

@@donaldshotts4429 Yes, I was there myself. Its partially my fault since I wanted food that is more nutritious and healthier since modern food standards are full of chemicals. After I traveled there I passed on the side of the building since there was no barbwire and I took and eat all the food so I could build more muscle, some of the jews that where swimming saw me and alerted the guards and I left off running. There where many building ruined because of air raid though.

@@averagecommunisthater Swimming? At the luxurious Auschwitz 5 star hotel

@@donaldshotts4429 Nah, normal pools. Not luxurious but they also had football teams and played together with guards.

This comment made me join the communist party