They have no depth?

@@Itsant33 I'm adding "more" comments to this thread. Because I'm adding "more" comments, does that mean there were "no" comments before?

Amy is probably the best character, and person. Scary thing to me is that I honestly think Howard might be the best human in the show, excluding early seasons lol. Sheldon is oblivious, Raj is pathetic, Leonard is an insecure asshat, Penny is a narcissist, and Bernadette is entitled and arrogant. Howard starts out like a horny teen, which makes sense because he hadn't had a girl since puberty lol, but he actually grows as a person as the show goes on. Sure, Penny changes her career and whatever, but she's still Penny.

Same, I love Amy. The nerd girl I relate.

Amy is surprisingly as manipulative as Bernadette, you just don't notice it as much since she doesn't show it as much as Berny does.

I personally like to believe that all of them are true (with the exclusion of Sheldon, of course). One letter on an 18th birthday could definitely include all of them. There's no real reason to believe that's what they chose to do, but it's a headcanon that makes me happy.

@@KaiLucasZachary I think it was likely Amy's, from Sheldon's reaction - but you could be right! Or it might be Raj's - or Bernadette's... Long, but profitable odds, on Sheldon's...!

@@chrissonofpear1384 Well, based on a reveal in a later episode, Penny's actually may have had some truth to it...

@@chrissonofpear1384 As I said, I personally like to believe that all of them are true in some way (with the exception of Sheldon).

I think we can agree that Homer Simpson is a better parent than Leonard's mom.

​@DanSolo0119 so is Randy Marsh, Cotton Hill, Peter Griffin and even Linda Stotch who tried to murder her son

Sometimes, when you watch a TV show long enough, you know the characters well enough to predict what they'll do or say. Plus, I think Eric took a class on creative writing.

@@ZukoHalliwell Also, Big Bang Theory is very predictably written in terms of its characters. lol Nobody is going to call it the most masterful screen-writing of the century. I'm just enhancing your point, that you learn to know what each character will obviously say in a given situation. So long as you can still laugh at it with the way the actor delivers it, then there's nothing technically wrong with an obvious comedy. It's **supposed** to be a comedy, no matter how predictable.

Sheldon wasn't in the right though for saying "Well, now don't you feel silly?" Yeah, communication would have been good from the outset, but he doesn't have to be a jerk about someone attempting to do something nice specifically for him.

@@KaiLucasZachary He wasn't being a jerk. He was stating an objective statement. Feelings don't fucking matter in regards to truth.

@@ItApproaches I agree in the sense that Bernadette should have told him in advance. What I'm disagreeing with is the way Sheldon responded to it. Sure, it was Bernadette's "fault"... but even if someone is at fault, there's a way to say, "I really appreciate the effort, but I brought my own food, so maybe we could share my food and also try some of yours." Yeah, she should have told him that she intended to cook specially for him, but he didn't need to be a jackass about it with the condescending comment he made.

@@KaiLucasZachary Why does he need to say ""I really appreciate the effort, but I brought my own food, so maybe we could share my food and also try some of yours" tat's pandering to a persons feelings. Saying specific words doesn't change or effect the situation in anyway. A persons emotions and feelings are 100% their own damn business, nobody else's.

@@ItApproaches It wasn’t the specific wording. He could have just said, “Thanks, but I brought my own.” It’s the acknowledgment that’s missing. There was absolutely no need for the condescending tone of voice, regardless of emotions. Even an autistic person knows they should say “thank you” when someone does something for them.

Yes..... because that isn't allowed on mainstream television.

I'm still afraid to watch Young Sheldon. I feel like it's going to destroy a character that I love the way that so many "prequels" do. I've heard reviews saying that the kid actor is fantastic but that it's pretty much a completely different character than the "Sheldon" in this original series.

Actually, I read somewhere a good explanation that clues were put in that Amy's story was the correct one, but I can't recall why or where I read it, so I might be wrong there. But Bernadette's story seems more to me like her saying what she thinks her husband would most have wanted to hear, therefore I tend to disregard her story as well as Raj's, which is too simple, and Sheldon's or Penny's, which are both too obviously fictional (So to me it's between Amy and Leonard, but Amy seems to be the one most uncomfortable retelling the story, so I would lean more towards her than Leonard)

@@daniellanctot6548 really? The wife doesn't get right one?

I've read somewhere that maybe all the answers, except Sheldon's, are correct.

@@michaelcharlesleyson7388 one of them is*

@@yudhazacharias9377 I mean, they could have just said that. Would be a good way to tell him the entire letter while having him think that only 1 is correct

I'll give her slight credit in that maybe she assumed he was going to find out at the party since everyone already knew, so she wanted to somewhat prepare him. But, yeah, she shouldn't have done it in the first place.